Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take my son into the female changing room?

941 replies

JustKeepSwimmingAlong · 20/11/2023 18:36

I’ve taken my kids swimming tonight, both have separate swimming lessons and I swam with one while the other had theirs. Eldest is male, 9 and has multiple additional needs including ADHD, ASD and some physical disabilities which means he struggles to change himself. Youngest is in nursery so can dress herself but does need supervision. We got out the pool and realised all the changing rooms were full. There were 8 classes on over multiple pools, as well as general swim on at the same time. There’s only two family/accessible changing rooms and the others are all individual. There were literal queues for the large changing rooms.
I then noticed people going out of the group change. I’ve not used it before, but there was a male and a female changing room, so we went in the females. There was no one in it so started laying out the kids clothes and getting them to shower. Got them out the showers and started to get them dressed and people started coming in. There were a couple of mums with young girls and boys, and then a teenager looking girl came in by herself. She immediately came over to tell me that we were in the female room. I explained my son needed help getting changed and the changing rooms were full, but this room had been empty so we’d used it rather than standing wet and cold waiting for a changing room.
We were nearly Finished and my son was fully dressed when she arrived. He sat next to me, facing the wall and we left within a few minutes. During this time, she did get changed, so we didn’t delay her. Now I’m wondering if I was unreasonable?
I don’t want to make anyone uncomfortable, but I really don’t know what else I could have done in the situation? There’s too many classes and too few changing rooms, and we need a larger/accessible one, but they’re the only ones with baby change so they’re really
Popular. The lessons are every week so now I’m wondering what I can do next week? Would I be unreasonable to keep using the group change if there are no other options available?

OP posts:
Newsenmum · 22/11/2023 09:35

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 08:07

So females are always less important than males?

They’re not more important than children. People on here would rather a child was in danger because some adult women might be ridiculous enough to think a pre pubescent child is a pervert.

DoktorPeppa · 22/11/2023 09:34

Sirzy · 22/11/2023 08:59

If anything ds understands the passage of time too well which creates its own issues at times!

sweeping generalisations don’t help anyone. As ds reception teacher said to me “when you have met one person with autism you have met one person with autism”

sterotypes and generalisations lead to one size fits all support which helps very few.

Yes, my DD is keenly aware of time. She's very anxious and has to forward plan everything to the minute to feel more in control of the unpredictable world around her. Going swimming would involve lots of questions from her days in advance about timings and a lot of anxiety on the day about being ready on time.

The unexpected is what causes her stress and can trigger a meltdown. Boys in female changing areas for instance would be a good example.

Loubelle70 · 22/11/2023 09:33

If theres mixed changing rooms id have waited. But. My DGS age 12 has adhd autism etc. he couldn't change alone. He is similar mental age to a 7 year old. I take him in womens changing area but find a cubicle. Hes too at risk being younger than his years, he would just stand there forever. Was there cubicles in women's changing area?

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 09:33

Robinni · 22/11/2023 09:25

I was not referring to you specifically @sollenwir

I was pointing out that while men and women are very outspoken regarding their own space and need for it, they do not make space for disabled people nor advocate for them - despite them being 25% of the population.

If there was advocacy by able bodied on behalf of disabled people this would lead to stronger preservation of rights for all, but mostly there is complacency.

You tagged me, why do that if you weren't referring to me?

itsdark · 22/11/2023 09:28

Robinni · 22/11/2023 09:25

I was not referring to you specifically @sollenwir

I was pointing out that while men and women are very outspoken regarding their own space and need for it, they do not make space for disabled people nor advocate for them - despite them being 25% of the population.

If there was advocacy by able bodied on behalf of disabled people this would lead to stronger preservation of rights for all, but mostly there is complacency.

People tend to advocate for issues that they have a connection with. I advocate for disabled people all the time because I know disabled people. If disabled people are 25% of the population, that's a lot of aware people who can advocate for them.

I mean, I never advocate for people with MS because I don't know anyone with MS and aren't vested in that cause. Hopefully it stays that way. Yet plenty of people do and give their time to advocate for that.

Robinni · 22/11/2023 09:27

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 09:20

Leisure centre is at fault. Not the OP.

Both are at fault.
Also, has OP ever asked the leisure centre to give her more support?

@sollenwir

She hasn’t needed to previously because facilities were available.

Following this experience at a busier time point (which was unexpected), I am sure she will seek support to prevent the same scenario happening again.

Heresapickle · 22/11/2023 09:27

gotomomo · 21/11/2023 22:55

@Robinni

My daughter is autistic and I would never dream of jumping queues etc. she is as capable of queuing as anyone else. From the day she was diagnosed I've never let autism be an excuse, she's an adult now due to graduate university this summer. Autism does vary so there are some with more severe/comorbidities but for people like my dd, queuing is part of life, they learn

Needing and using reasonable adjustments isn’t ‘letting autism be an excuse’ ffs. No more than my using a wheelchair is letting not being able to walk’ be an excuse.

TomeTome · 22/11/2023 09:27

@sollenwir I think you are being bullish and tone deaf. This child may never have the capacity to do the things described, kindness is not what I was talking about. Honestly it’s excruciating reading the righteous drilling down on a mother of a disabled child who asked for help thinking about a situation she wanted to manage better. Grim. Carers are predominantly women. Untrained, unemployed and unappreciated women who do not choose their lives. You are not helping.

Robinni · 22/11/2023 09:25

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 08:04

Hidden under the placard of assumptions you're holding up in front of me, maybe?
You have NO idea what I do with my time.

I was not referring to you specifically @sollenwir

I was pointing out that while men and women are very outspoken regarding their own space and need for it, they do not make space for disabled people nor advocate for them - despite them being 25% of the population.

If there was advocacy by able bodied on behalf of disabled people this would lead to stronger preservation of rights for all, but mostly there is complacency.

itsdark · 22/11/2023 09:25

Heresapickle · 22/11/2023 09:19

To be honest, your ‘fannying about under a towel’ phrase wasn’t a lot better than @Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy saying getting your baps out.

My wife has emotional trauma and HS- what looks to you like ‘fannying around’ is actually her going through an enormous amount of stress, anxiety and pain in order to take her kids swimming (she has to wear a bra and a tshirt and shorts to swim so there is a lot of ‘fannying around’ getting it all on and off!)

I feel for your wife. This is why access to family rooms is important too, so your wife can feel comfortable getting fully undressed in private.

I used to take six kids from infant upwards swimming and took them into the family rooms. We could all just get changed and I knew they were all contained and couldn't run out of the changing rooms. If a family room wasn't available, we stayed in the water waiting for an opening. It made it so much easier to have a private and contained space.

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 09:20

Leisure centre is at fault. Not the OP.

Both are at fault.
Also, has OP ever asked the leisure centre to give her more support?

Heresapickle · 22/11/2023 09:19

Thedm · 21/11/2023 22:17

@Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy

Thats also a really derogatory way to speak to a woman who is undressed in a completely acceptable location. “Get your baps out”. Jesus. I was hit by a car when I was 17 and took permanent damage, and have limited mobility in my shoulder and back. I physically cannot get changed with a towel wrapped around me or over me. I can’t do it. Getting a bra on is enough of a challenge. So my being undressed, with “my baps out” in a female only changing room is something you’re going to mock! Really? Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting way to speak to another woman.

To be honest, your ‘fannying about under a towel’ phrase wasn’t a lot better than @Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy saying getting your baps out.

My wife has emotional trauma and HS- what looks to you like ‘fannying around’ is actually her going through an enormous amount of stress, anxiety and pain in order to take her kids swimming (she has to wear a bra and a tshirt and shorts to swim so there is a lot of ‘fannying around’ getting it all on and off!)

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 09:19

TomeTome · 22/11/2023 09:12

To be honest @LolaSmiles while I understand your concern the sort of child that needs help to this level is really unlikely to develop into the sort of man you describe.

I think sometimes it’s worth remembering who and what situation you are talking about.

He's still a male in a female space, it doesn't matter if he's the kindest male on the planet. We're still sending the message that males can enter female spaces. They can't.

Robinni · 22/11/2023 09:17

LolaSmiles · 22/11/2023 06:45

@LolaSmiles

Look the reason women’s spaces are the go to in these sorts of emergency situations is that

a) Mainly it is mothers taking care of the children or bringing them to swimming

b) Women are much less likely to be rapists, paedophiles, violent and so forth

Therefore women’s spaces are deemed to be safe for children.

OP’s son is 2 months older than this 8yo cut off point for boys. She didn’t bring a 24yo disabled man in there, I think some of the reactions on this thread are out of their tree bonkers

The situation in the OP wasn't an emergency, but I do agree that in emergencies those things apply.

My question was why the default response to any issues with facilities is to just use the women's:

The pertinent question at the root of it is why some people's default reaction to facilities not being as they want is to tell women and girls to fix it or budge up and accept a mixed sex space, rather than either parents choosing somewhere that has changing facilities that meet their needs or advocating for better management of facilities to meet their requirements. It feels awfully like telling women and girls to budge up, accept boundaries being eroded and be kind.

There are places I won't take an older boy because the changing isn't appropriate. I wouldn't send him to the men's, for the reasons you outline, but I'd also not expect his female peers to lose their single sex space. This means that we need to either choose places to swim with a family changing village or somewhere that has appropriate family changing in addition to single sex communal changing.

I don't think the fact women take children swimming more means that by the women's space becomes unisex by default because people don't want to choose a different venue/the venue doesn't see the need to provide appropriate changing facilities to preserve the privacy and dignity of everyone.

@LolaSmiles

From my point of view I would have considered this situation an emergency.

This is to say going out with my DS is like going out with an unexploded bomb that is ticking.

You know he is liable to blow up - in a positive or negative way - depending on environmental stimuli, and you try to keep everything on an even keel to avoid either major hyperactivity and excitement or extreme distress.

The change in OP’s son’s routine in terms of not being able to access his normal changing space + the sensory issues with being dripping wet + sensory/stress issues with queuing all equals to me 💥💥💥

So I would have been doing the same as OP looking for the quietest available space to get the kids washed quickly and out of there.

Again, I am not saying it is acceptable for all boys under the age of 18 to be in women’s changing rooms. Not at all.

What I’ve said consistently, is that this is still a young child - not an adolescent, 2 months beyond the cut off point for him to be in a women’s changing room. And it was a situation brought about by the leisure centre bunging baby changes in disabled space. And not taking into account the huge number of classes going on and the pressure this would place on changing facilities.

To be clear, OP had picked a suitable leisure centre with facilities and used them before, but not at the time when so many classes were on - she didn’t anticipate her son’s space being taken away.

Mothers and fathers with babies are not disabled. They can perfectly well change their babies in the single sex space - provided the baby changers are moved to there.

If these people had not been cluttering up disabled space in the first place then OP and her son would not have been displaced.

Leisure centre is at fault. Not the OP.

TomeTome · 22/11/2023 09:12

To be honest @LolaSmiles while I understand your concern the sort of child that needs help to this level is really unlikely to develop into the sort of man you describe.

I think sometimes it’s worth remembering who and what situation you are talking about.

LolaSmiles · 22/11/2023 09:06

Then we wonder why some men struggle with consent issues while the parents say they just don't know what happened for them to be that way.
I agree with this.
Speaking generally, many people seem surprised that so many men ignore boundaries, have issues with consent, feel entitled to take over spaces or dominate spaces, feel entitled to tell women to get over their feelings of being uncomfortable.

But then they don't seem to connect the dots between the behaviour, conduct and standards they set for their boys e.g. it's fine for boys to 'tease' girls, it's fine for boys to dominate play, it's fine for boys to physically take over more space and claim more space in play spaces, it's fine for boys to be in female single sex spaces beyond their younger years and their female pre-teen peers should accept it, it's the role of female peers to turn away or modify their changing if they're not happy about a male peer in their space etc.

The male pattern behaviours many people rightly have an issue with (including the behaviour patterns that lead to issues in male single sex spaces) don't suddenly appear at 18.

We do our boys a disservice if we expect them to learn one set of values about respect, consent, privacy and dignity if our actions and words aren't modelling this.

Sirzy · 22/11/2023 08:59

If anything ds understands the passage of time too well which creates its own issues at times!

sweeping generalisations don’t help anyone. As ds reception teacher said to me “when you have met one person with autism you have met one person with autism”

sterotypes and generalisations lead to one size fits all support which helps very few.

TomeTome · 22/11/2023 08:56

The child in question though is described by the OP as

9 and has multiple additional needs including ADHD, ASD and some physical disabilities which means he struggles to change himself.

And isn’t “quite capable of queuing”. Generalising doesn’t help really whichever way you spin it. The majority of autistic people aren’t able to do a lot of things that able verbal autistics can they aren’t very visible. Some of that is because nobody prioritises their access to the world.

DoktorPeppa · 22/11/2023 08:47

Robinni · 21/11/2023 22:35

@Thedm

IT IS UNREASONABLE TO ASK AN AUTISTIC PERSON TO QUEUE.

THEY CANNOT DO IT WITHOUT IT CAUSING THEM HARM.

  1. They cannot comprehend the passage of time or put bounds on it.
  2. It puts untold distress upon them because they can’t understand nor quell their anxiety
  3. It causes sensory overload because of the proximity to other people - smells, noise, visual stimuli, proprioception.
  4. The after effects are days long

https://best-practice.middletownautism.com/teachingcoreskills/waiting/#:~:text=Time%20is%20an%20abstract%20concept,1%20minute%20or%20several%20hours.

Please don't make sweeping statements about autistic people like they're all the same.

My autistic DD is quite capable of queuing and does so by herself on a daily basis - to get on the bus, to get lunch, at checkouts.

And what on earth are you talking about, autistic people can't comprehend the passage of time?!

InvisibleDuck · 22/11/2023 08:41

PuttingDownRoots · 21/11/2023 23:10

@Robinni jumping a queue, even if allowed, would upset my DD more than waiting. Rules are there for a reason, and she "can't" break them.

I know plenty of other people with autism that are similar.

Yes. I was one of them as a child.

I remember being out with my dad aged about 5 and refusing to go in the men's toilets with him because 'I'm not a man, I'm not allowed to.' On the verge of meltdown about it because I really needed to go.

He didn't drag me into the men's despite my distress. He also didn't go into the women's. He asked a woman going in there with her own daughter if she'd mind keeping an eye out for me.

(For the avoidance of any doubt, I'm not trying to claim this is analogous to OP's situation - I didn't need any assistance with toileting, for a start. I'm reflecting on autistic children and rule-following re: spaces.)

Lifelessordinary1 · 22/11/2023 08:27

Speak to the pool managers - there will be lots of other people in similar situations.

backtowinter · 22/11/2023 08:20

Somewhereoverthersinbowweighapie · 22/11/2023 05:36

@itsdark I would use a family room if available. Challenging me won’t make a difference, I wouldn’t acknowledge someone asking me to put my kid at risk, except maybe to blow them a kiss once we are done and on my way out. Busy change rooms at swimming are less of a risk, he goes into the men’s. But side of road toilets or beach change rooms not a chance. He already cracks it if I take him into the women’s. My 6 year old will be accompanying me for years to come. 💋

Blow them a kiss? Deliberately provocative to other pool users then.

Why not just accompany your DS into the men's changing room?

itsdark · 22/11/2023 08:19

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 08:13

Agreed, the 6 year old isn't really an issue, it's the assertion of 'years to come' - other females can and will complain, and if the frontline facility staff do nothing they'll take it higher until something happens. Don't be that selfish person who cannot follow simple rules, and who gives lots of other people extra work.

Not to mention the message it sends the son that who cares about other people, it's all about what I want. And the message that who cares about women's privacy and comfort if it doesn't suit me. Then we wonder why some men struggle with consent issues while the parents say they just don't know what happened for them to be that way.

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 08:13

itsdark · 22/11/2023 05:45

No-one is going to worry about a six year old. Your six year old is going to have his own opinion and won't be following you for years to come. He will develop his own feelings and be horribly embarrassed being taken into the womens for too much longer. You'll see. I'll give it a couple of years before he kicks up a fuss and feels the shame.

If you ignore me saying something I will turn to your son and ask him, aren't you too old to be in the womens? That will be the end of him willingly following you.

I've seen a woman banned from a pool for bringing in her twelve year old sons. Good for the pool.

Edited

Agreed, the 6 year old isn't really an issue, it's the assertion of 'years to come' - other females can and will complain, and if the frontline facility staff do nothing they'll take it higher until something happens. Don't be that selfish person who cannot follow simple rules, and who gives lots of other people extra work.

sollenwir · 22/11/2023 08:07

Somewhereoverthersinbowweighapie · 22/11/2023 02:35

If the amount of passion that went into this thread was put into changing the law on having more spaces available for parents with kids it would be sorted very quickly. Until it is changed, I will continue to occasionally bring my boys into female spaces on occasions when it’s necessary. Because assaults happen. Toilets and change rooms have a lot of incidents. If others want to put their kids at risk that’s fine. But I’m not.

So females are always less important than males?