Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get 3 year old own tablet?

139 replies

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 17:59

We have a long car journey next week and wondering about whether to take advantage or Black Friday deals? Just don’t want him asking for it all the time. Do your kids have their own tablets?

OP posts:
Bloopadoop · 20/11/2023 22:04

I wouldn’t. It’s audiobooks, music, quizzes and eye spy type games in our car. And some good old fashioned being bored staring out the window.

Mustardoo · 20/11/2023 22:03

At 3, I would want them to play with toys over iPads.

Allfur · 20/11/2023 22:02

Wokbun, it's not a binary choice of kid with tablet or kid wandering around

Mustardoo · 20/11/2023 22:01

We have always had a family iPad. My 10 and 15 year olds borrows that if they need to. (15 year old does have a phone)

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:55

Well that’s true too @wokbun , really none of us should be judging as it’s no one else’s business. But I’m just pointing out (as there’s been a fair amount of judging of me and a decision I haven’t made yet!) that ds is not one of those children.

OP posts:
Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:53

I don’t think he’d ask for it at home but never say never. And I know the danger can be that when you’ve got something that keeps them quiet it’s tempting to use them to get a moments peace on hectic days!

I’ll have a think. Amazon do next day delivery , I could order one and tell him it only appears on long car journeys or some such rubbish!

OP posts:
wokbun · 20/11/2023 21:52

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:34

It is a bit baffling. We used to have long car journeys as a child and I don’t necessarily have fond memories of them. I just used to be sick all the time though - ds doesn’t get motion sickness thankfully!

I do see kids in prams and in cafes looking at phones and tablets which isn’t ideal although I know sometimes you just have to do what you can, but this is very much a one off. Some may not think five hours is ‘that bad’ but irrespective of what anyone thinks it’s a long time for an active three year old to have to sit. He’ll almost certainly be fine for the first two to three hours but we will have to stop and then getting him back in the car seat may prove difficult. That’s where a novelty tablet may come in handy and unfortunately I don’t think ‘oh wow, we can listen to an audiobook!’ will have the desired effect!

You see kids in prams in cafes on them because other people in cafes judge so much if a kid is a kid and goes wandering or exploring their environment

Wotchaz · 20/11/2023 21:51

My eldest got an Amazon kids tablet for her 3rd birthday. It’s worth it’s weight in gold for long car journeys or if she has to sit through the occasional meeting, but she doesn’t really ask for it at home - definite win in our house.

Rachaelrachael · 20/11/2023 21:50

My kids have tablets and to be honest I massively regret getting them. I do limit their screen time but now have to deal with tantrums and pestering to use them on a daily basis. And when they do use them I can see a clear change in their behaviour. Think I'll be getting rid of ours.

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:47

Because we don’t have a family iPad. I am saying buy ds a tablet and I suppose what I mean is, it would be bought just to be used by him for this journey. I have to admit I haven’t thought beyond that particularly, it could well come in useful if we have to make other similar long journeys.

Napody - I’ve noted your view thanks 👍🏻 I’m asking what others think, I appreciate your answers.

OP posts:
arlequin · 20/11/2023 21:39

Why can't he just use a family iPad? What does he need his own one for?

FutureMandosWife · 20/11/2023 21:38

My child got his at 4 it has parental control on, his profile is only active between 9-6 and is timed to 3 hours for the day.

He prefers toys to the tablet so not on everyday.

napody · 20/11/2023 21:38

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:34

It is a bit baffling. We used to have long car journeys as a child and I don’t necessarily have fond memories of them. I just used to be sick all the time though - ds doesn’t get motion sickness thankfully!

I do see kids in prams and in cafes looking at phones and tablets which isn’t ideal although I know sometimes you just have to do what you can, but this is very much a one off. Some may not think five hours is ‘that bad’ but irrespective of what anyone thinks it’s a long time for an active three year old to have to sit. He’ll almost certainly be fine for the first two to three hours but we will have to stop and then getting him back in the car seat may prove difficult. That’s where a novelty tablet may come in handy and unfortunately I don’t think ‘oh wow, we can listen to an audiobook!’ will have the desired effect!

You're clearly worried about the journey. You're the parent- it's up to you whether you get one!
I'm not being holier-than-thou... I'd happily use a sweet snack to get them back in the car seat if necessary!

Hobbitfeet32 · 20/11/2023 21:38

Not necessary to have an iPad. Mine have never had them for the car. And we’ve done lots of long journeys. They’ve either played word games, I spy, sang songs, listened to the radio or audio stories, looked out of the window or <whispers> been bored for a little bit. In my opinion being a little bit bored for a short period of time such as a car journey will do them less harm than staring at a screen. Also mine used to get travel sick so screens wouldn’t have been a good idea.

CremeEggSupremacy · 20/11/2023 21:37

Getting a 3 year old their own tablet is obviously going to result in habitual use. Suggesting otherwise is daft, they are far too expensive not to use regularly, and if you need one for a one off car trip then you are probably not a parent who ‘is able to say no’. Increased use will creep in, it’s only natural.

InTheRainOnATrain · 20/11/2023 21:36

Ibizabar · 20/11/2023 21:32

As ever on MN. Full of parents who did 20 hour car journeys with children who only had a stick to play with.

Or doped up on medised with sleeping bags in the boot of the estate, no seatbelts of course with Dad pulling an all nighter to get to the South of France in one. No screens needed!

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:35

@VestaTilley i really don’t want to sound rude but have you read the thread?

OP posts:
SwedishSchnauzer · 20/11/2023 21:35

Get him some headphones and audible instead. I’d avoid screens for as long as possible and then be restricted

Ponoka7 · 20/11/2023 21:35

My GC have had tablets from two. We don't watch television, so the tablet occasionally worked for us. The now eight year old is very into art, they both do choir, both did gymnastics, it's just getting a balance. I don't believe all of the research because parents don't admit how poor their parenting has been and how little other enrichments were provided. The younger one, now six, still plays with toys, she loves play dough. She'd rather be out and about than in the house. I don't see the battles that are talked about on here. Gaming is good for hand/eye coordination. There's plenty of teaching games. My youngest has mild LD's and is autistic. She watched wildlife programmes non stop. She gained more knowledge than she would have doing something else. Screens aren't all bad. Some children are more easily pleased than others.

napody · 20/11/2023 21:35

Ibizabar · 20/11/2023 21:32

As ever on MN. Full of parents who did 20 hour car journeys with children who only had a stick to play with.

I don't think saying what worked for your children when the OP is asking for views in a very open minded way is at all unpleasant.

The 'thick' comment, yes. But that was one comment.

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:34

It is a bit baffling. We used to have long car journeys as a child and I don’t necessarily have fond memories of them. I just used to be sick all the time though - ds doesn’t get motion sickness thankfully!

I do see kids in prams and in cafes looking at phones and tablets which isn’t ideal although I know sometimes you just have to do what you can, but this is very much a one off. Some may not think five hours is ‘that bad’ but irrespective of what anyone thinks it’s a long time for an active three year old to have to sit. He’ll almost certainly be fine for the first two to three hours but we will have to stop and then getting him back in the car seat may prove difficult. That’s where a novelty tablet may come in handy and unfortunately I don’t think ‘oh wow, we can listen to an audiobook!’ will have the desired effect!

OP posts:
napody · 20/11/2023 21:33

Ibizabar · 20/11/2023 21:22

You think it makes children 'thick' if they use a tablet?

Just to clarify, I don't think this, and I don't think the research says this either!

To me it's like the learning advantage of your child learning to play a musical instrument or another language many times over. That extra shared attention and conversation at the absolute crucial time for their developing brain. The fact there's nothing else to do but talk and listen on a long journey is precisely why it's such a valuable chunk of time!

OP, get one if you want one: most parents do!

VestaTilley · 20/11/2023 21:33

YABVU. Those devices should be nowhere near children. Fine for a car journey but not all the time, they don’t need their own. Can’t you take books and read to DC some of the way of someone else is driving?

My DS is 4.5. He doesn’t have one and never goes on ours.

Ibizabar · 20/11/2023 21:32

Twilightinnovember · 20/11/2023 21:29

some of these posts are going out of their way to be as unpleasant and offensive as possible.

As ever on MN. Full of parents who did 20 hour car journeys with children who only had a stick to play with.

Tistheseasontobejollytrala · 20/11/2023 21:31

The last time I read any research on children and screen time, it said the usual sensible things: children left to their own devices fare less well than children who have an involved parent/adult to talk to about what they are watching.
I bought tablets during the sale for the grandchildren , 5and 6, before they had a trip to the States and daughter said it was a life saver on the plane and subsequent long drives.
The tablets now come out for half an hour while mum (drinks wine) gets supper on. The children seem quite their normal boisterous selves when they visit at the weekend, neither are particularly ahead or behind in their milestones or communication skills.

Swipe left for the next trending thread