Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are some kids really just easier

106 replies

NewEms · 20/11/2023 17:54

I recently found out that I’m pregnant, I don’t have much experience with kids, only child so no siblings/nieces/nephews. The only kids in my life are those of my two closest friends.
Friend A has a daughter, I lived with her for 6 months when her daughter was 2 and her daughter seemed … easy. She liked lots of different foods, potty trained super easy (I was there), wasn’t a screamer, didn’t really run away. I don’t remember friend A ever really complaining, I remember her being exhausted from sleepless nights but her daughter was sleeping through by about 5/6 months. I know she had her husband, great maternity package at work, a cleaner etc, but really she never seemed stressed by parenting. Her daughter is 4 now, settled into school well, sleeps through all that.
Friend B has a son, he’s never been an easy kid, didn’t sleep through until over a year, always always screamed, was a runner as a toddler, very picky eater, tantrums a lot. Never lived with them but in the short time I spend with them he’s chaos. He’s 5 now and in school and friend was mentioning that he doesn’t listen well, used to bite other kids etc. She also has a cleaner, supportive husband and the such but has never seemed like she enjoys parenting. Friend A doesn’t have family near by but both she and her husband both seem to still have good social life’s (babysitters).

Now I’m 8 weeks pregnant, not planned. My partner is supportive and we have good jobs, when I think about “could I handle a kid” I think I could handle friend As kid, the good times seem to outweigh the bad and she seems to enjoy parenting. I’m not sure I could handle friend Bs she never seems happy anymore, and while I know she loves her son I don’t know she puts up with parenting as he seems like a lot of work. She also hasn’t really come out much since having her son, doesn’t trust non-related babysitters so has to be family. (Side question - should you trust non related babysitters? Or only family?)

Is it really just luck if you have an easy or difficult kid or is it more parenting related? AIBU to feel tempted to terminate this pregnancy just because I’m not sure I could handle a more difficult child or a child with additional needs (not that I wouldn’t love them, I would I just don’t know if I’d have the patience/temperament)?

OP posts:
myotherkidisacassowary · 20/11/2023 18:20

My son was a very difficult baby (reflux, never ever ever slept, couldn’t be put down). First year was so difficult, every day.

He is now the world’s easiest three year old. Has literally never thrown a tantrum in his life, is calm and cheerful, polite, funny, clever. Plays on his own for ages, loves to cuddle up and be read to, does what he’s told, expresses himself brilliantly, eats everything, sleeps through, plays nicely with other kids.

I think I’m a good parent and I do all the ‘right’ things - enforce consistent boundaries while respecting his feelings and following the principles of gentle parenting - but mostly I think I just got lucky with his nature. His personality just makes him wonderful and easy to get along with.

Bad parenting can clearly lead to children who struggle with discipline and behaviour, but temperament has a lot to do with it too - even the best parents can have a highly sensitive child who struggles with conventional good behaviour.

Wisenotboring · 20/11/2023 18:20

They are all different and definitely some are easier than others. Of course there are some parenting strategies that can make things easier or harder, but I always try not to judge as I do think having a more difficult child can make effective parenting more difficult! Plus some kids will be hard work however good the parents are.

twistyizzy · 20/11/2023 18:20

It is part parenting and part luck. I was a very unhappy baby/child/teenager and have got anxiety, depression and probably ADHD although no formal diagnosis. My parents were brilliant but I was very challenging.
DD was an angel baby, was a bit challenging as a toddler but overall delightful. Her default setting is to be happy and although I do give myself some credit I know in reality that it is mainly her nature.
However I have really tried to always be present in her life, set very strong boundaries for what is acceptable/unacceptable and there are consequences for poor behaviour. I make time to talk about her interests, friends etc and so far we have a very close relationship but it is a mother/daughter relationship not a best friend relationship as I'm not here to be her best friend.
The caveat to all this is that she is now 12 so it may all go to hell in a handcraft any day now!

Pipa42 · 20/11/2023 18:20

NewEms · 20/11/2023 18:05

I didn’t expect all kids to be the same, more just are some intrinsically ‘good’ and others ‘naughty’ - in a way that parenting can’t balance. I’m finding it all quite overwhelming, I don’t know If I would be a good parent to a child who was very picky, screamed a lot, didn’t sleep through etc, ran away when out, generally defiant and the such, not that I wouldn’t love them just I’d get overwhelmed, lose patience. Maybe I’m just not cut out to be a mum!!

I think as a first time parent get as much support as you need, the behaviour of my first drove me up the wall, the tantrums, meltdowns etc, by number 5 it was so much easier as my expectations were so much more realistic and obviously a whole took kit of strategies and a lot more efficient in what I spend my energy on (e.g no elaborate meals or messy play but things that actually affect my child’s happiness’s and wellbeing are top priority so I will drag us out to the park of a weekend) no guilt about booking on extra childcare so I can get a break and recharge my batteries. The result happy mum and happier child

VisionsOfSplendour · 20/11/2023 18:15

Anyone who has more than one child knows that of course they are all different

Obviously parenting plays a role but it doesn't change fundamental personality. Do you have siblings?

fizzyred · 20/11/2023 18:14

Definitely all swings and roundabouts really...
My DDs were easy and happy... but as teenager girls really hard work.
DS was loving, cute but a real runner and absolutely into everything as a toddler. But now he's one of those teenagers that you actually want ti hang out with because he's just so nice!

As for sleep and food... all totally different.

They've all managed to be kind and teachers say lovely things about them.

mandydandy · 20/11/2023 18:14

Yes but they change at different ages and stages. My clingy needy screaming baby became a headstrong shouty toddler, then a goodie two shoes in primary.
Now in her teens she is so easy to get on with and never makes a drama, makes good choices and doesn't just follow the crowd. The teens have been the easiest with her.
Her sister is following the opposite track. Just now is challenging but I keep repeating it is just a phase.

JustAMinutePleass · 20/11/2023 18:12

My opinion isn’t going to be popular - but in my opinion and experience parents tend to create children in their own image. Babies pick up on things like anxiety and this can seriously impact behaviour in the early years. Also as they get older, kids who with parents they don’t like may become quieter at home & start socialising out of the house more. Imo a child who is comfortable enough to express their emotions - positive and negative - with their parent has had a good childhood - and that is what you should aim for. Do this by being a responsive parent and teaching independance

Changington · 20/11/2023 18:12

Yeah, I had easy chilled first boy who has high emotional intelligence and just wants to please. Though as he gets older is questioning more and pushing boundaries.
Then I have a second boy who has been full of rage from the day he was born, stubborn and prone to full-blown meltdowns for seemingly tiny reasons. He gets a little easier every day as he is learning to regulate since starting school.

Both parented the same, just inherently different natures. Both sweet and kind and funny, high energy and smart. Light of my life, both of them. 😊

ManateeFair · 20/11/2023 18:09

I think it's probably a bit of both - parenting is part of it, but also some kids are much easier than others. Much like some adults are easier than others.

Also, an easy baby doesn't mean they'll always be easy. My sister was a positively angelic baby/toddler, but a very, very difficult teenager. She's also a difficult adult, to be honest.

Xmaspenguin · 20/11/2023 18:09

NewEms · 20/11/2023 18:05

I didn’t expect all kids to be the same, more just are some intrinsically ‘good’ and others ‘naughty’ - in a way that parenting can’t balance. I’m finding it all quite overwhelming, I don’t know If I would be a good parent to a child who was very picky, screamed a lot, didn’t sleep through etc, ran away when out, generally defiant and the such, not that I wouldn’t love them just I’d get overwhelmed, lose patience. Maybe I’m just not cut out to be a mum!!

You learn to become more patient because you don't want to fuck your kids up TBH. I have tapped into hidden layers of patience I didn't know I was capable of after having kids.

But I do also treat them differently because they are my own. I still internally lose my shit at other people's kids all the time.

Pipa42 · 20/11/2023 18:08

Aww bless, I’ve got 5 and yes some were easier than others, absolutely. Yes parenting makes a difference and not sure I could have coped with my last 2 without the experience I had gained along the way. Support helps a lot too. What helps the most is the overwhelming love you feel for you DC, it’s not something I can really describe but it carries you through an awful lot. At the end of it all they all have things you love about them along with the challenges

TrashedSofa · 20/11/2023 18:08

KatBurglar · 20/11/2023 18:02

It's luck, plus a bit of genetics. Parenting can make things better or worse, but personality happens and there's bugger all you can do about it.

Pretty much sums it up.

Cedar13 · 20/11/2023 18:08

I think its mostly luck of the draw but obviously parenting does play a part. My sister in law had 2 very different children. Parented the same mostly although she was obviously more experienced second time.

chocomoccalocca · 20/11/2023 18:06

Complete luck and no rhyme or reason. My 'easy baby' has struggles at school and we are now looking into some formal testing for ADHD/ autism. That being said for us it's not awful but at school a challenge. My youngest much more challenging baby but easier toddler and already can sit better/ focus than older sibling. It's just luck and not always clear what you are going to have. I love both mine though and wouldn't change them and enjoy parenting them both and would have more of DH was up for it!!

SallyWD · 20/11/2023 18:06

Of course. One of my children has always been much easier than the other. Identical upbringing. It's just their natures.

GodDammitCecil · 20/11/2023 18:05

I mean, it’s not like parenting plays zero role. Confused

Kids with good, loving boundaries and high expectations for behaviour, whose positive (as opposed to negative/naughty) behaviour is rewarded with attention will clearly be more enjoyable to be around than kids left to run feral. Nurture 100% comes into it.

But yes, like adults, children very much have their own personalities - nature plays a hugely significant role as well.

Some children are risk takers. Other children don’t like to get into trouble and are compliant.

Obviously some children are easier to parent than others.

That doesn’t necessarily mean the other sort of children aren’t rewarding in other ways.

But of course it’s a risk - and many parents, being honest, will say that life is much harder and less enjoyable with a harder to parent child. Add high needs into it, and it can be soul destroying.

Anycrispsleft · 20/11/2023 18:05

I basically had kid A and kid b as you describe, as twins. If you parent a kid B type kid sensitively and try to see the world from their point of view they can end up being very loving and rewarding. That's been my experience anyway. Your relationship with them comes out of the struggling together.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/11/2023 18:05

I also have five. First one - easy baby, sweet child, dreadful teenager, now a really lovely adult. Second one - truly awful baby, difficult child, lovely teenager, great if somewhat distant adult. Third - lovely baby, from thereon until University an absolute nightmare, now a very high achieving adult. Fourth - difficult baby and child, terrific teenager, wonderful adult. Fifth - to be honest I don't remember but she's nice now...

NewEms · 20/11/2023 18:05

I didn’t expect all kids to be the same, more just are some intrinsically ‘good’ and others ‘naughty’ - in a way that parenting can’t balance. I’m finding it all quite overwhelming, I don’t know If I would be a good parent to a child who was very picky, screamed a lot, didn’t sleep through etc, ran away when out, generally defiant and the such, not that I wouldn’t love them just I’d get overwhelmed, lose patience. Maybe I’m just not cut out to be a mum!!

OP posts:
Xmaspenguin · 20/11/2023 18:05

It's luck. I have two with two very different personalities. They also change as they age.

Child 1 was Satan's screaming baby from hell. Child 2 was the calmest baby known to man. Child 1 was chilled toddler. Child 2 was typical tantruming toddler. Child 1 really struggled when first at school (is now confirmed autistic). Child 2 has always loved school. Child 1 prefers reading and more artistic types of hobbies. Child 2 wants to be a You tuber when he grows up and film himself going down Snowdon in a shopping trolley.

You get what you're given and make do with what you've got.

EC22 · 20/11/2023 18:05

Yes.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2023 18:04

Some of it is nature and a child's disposition.

Some of it is parents finding what works for their baby so they have an easier time than a parent who is set on doing it Parent's Way even if what baby needs is something else (eg Baby is one that really needs a schedule but Parent is determined to be free flowing, or Baby really needs contact but Parent insists that they're not babywearing or contact napping) Neither baby in that example is "easier" or "harder" but the parents who respond to their child as a unique human probably find it easier overall than the ones who stubbornly try to score points against their baby.

Some of it is nurture, parenting and environment. (Eg the parents who put themselves as children's entertainer from day 1 & never support their younger children to play independently shouldn't be surprised if they have a 6 year old who is bored easily and won't play / the parents who hand their child a device every time the child is bored or they're out and about shouldn't be surprised that the child doesn't develop skills for sitting in public)

StarShipControl · 20/11/2023 18:04

Sleep has a lot to do with it! If you get enough sleep, you cope better.
Then there are things like reflux and dairy intolerance which many babies suffer with for ages before it gets picked up.

Personality of baby and mother plays a huge part and the support mother gets too.

KatBurglar · 20/11/2023 18:02

It's luck, plus a bit of genetics. Parenting can make things better or worse, but personality happens and there's bugger all you can do about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread