Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are some kids really just easier

106 replies

NewEms · 20/11/2023 17:54

I recently found out that I’m pregnant, I don’t have much experience with kids, only child so no siblings/nieces/nephews. The only kids in my life are those of my two closest friends.
Friend A has a daughter, I lived with her for 6 months when her daughter was 2 and her daughter seemed … easy. She liked lots of different foods, potty trained super easy (I was there), wasn’t a screamer, didn’t really run away. I don’t remember friend A ever really complaining, I remember her being exhausted from sleepless nights but her daughter was sleeping through by about 5/6 months. I know she had her husband, great maternity package at work, a cleaner etc, but really she never seemed stressed by parenting. Her daughter is 4 now, settled into school well, sleeps through all that.
Friend B has a son, he’s never been an easy kid, didn’t sleep through until over a year, always always screamed, was a runner as a toddler, very picky eater, tantrums a lot. Never lived with them but in the short time I spend with them he’s chaos. He’s 5 now and in school and friend was mentioning that he doesn’t listen well, used to bite other kids etc. She also has a cleaner, supportive husband and the such but has never seemed like she enjoys parenting. Friend A doesn’t have family near by but both she and her husband both seem to still have good social life’s (babysitters).

Now I’m 8 weeks pregnant, not planned. My partner is supportive and we have good jobs, when I think about “could I handle a kid” I think I could handle friend As kid, the good times seem to outweigh the bad and she seems to enjoy parenting. I’m not sure I could handle friend Bs she never seems happy anymore, and while I know she loves her son I don’t know she puts up with parenting as he seems like a lot of work. She also hasn’t really come out much since having her son, doesn’t trust non-related babysitters so has to be family. (Side question - should you trust non related babysitters? Or only family?)

Is it really just luck if you have an easy or difficult kid or is it more parenting related? AIBU to feel tempted to terminate this pregnancy just because I’m not sure I could handle a more difficult child or a child with additional needs (not that I wouldn’t love them, I would I just don’t know if I’d have the patience/temperament)?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Emi199 · 21/11/2023 18:32

Storynanny1 · 21/11/2023 17:17

“Some upbringing the older they get: My friend has older children who are totally fine with being told no because she started from young - and meant it. “
yes to this - I once overheard a friend say to one of my sons when they were playing upstairs “ go and ask your mum again” ( can’t remember what it was) and my son replied “ when she says no she won’t change her mind”
I was very impressed - and told him so when the friend had gone home. I wasn’t rigid about much stuff though just what I thought was important at the time.

Ooh, I hope mine say that one day. Good work!

It’s so important. I was so jealous of my cousin growing up who was never told no. If she was, it didn’t take too much coaxing - or rather a big tantrum which she had even when quite old for me to remember one or two. Unfortunately she’s grown up to get into a lot of trouble with credit cards. Of course they may not be related but she never experienced the feeling of wanting something and not having it growing up.

lljkk · 21/11/2023 18:01

if your kid is difficult at baseline, you can definitely make them worse with bad parenting. Some kids are difficult at baseline, though, no matter how good the parenting, and some kids are incredibly nice despite terrible parenting. A lot of what happens is hard-wired.

i don't believe anyone is born evil, but some are more easily made that way.

babybythesea · 21/11/2023 17:51

If my second had come first she’d have been an only! I couldn’t have done her twice!
DD1 was pretty easy as a baby. She was (is) a stubborn little soul but quietly so. No big tantrums, just a quiet refusal - once she’d realised that if I said something I
meant it and it was happening then she got easier. I also learnt to pick my battles so as she became school age we rarely clashed. I didn’t insist on something unless it was important and she did it because she knew I wouldn’t back down.
DD2 fussed a lot as a baby. I even phoned support lines in desperation because she didn’t seem to stop crying. As a toddler she was a nightmare. Things in the toilet, drew on everything, emptied drawers - she was the one who ended up in A&E because she climbed up shelves tp reach calpol and then got the top off and drank it. I was getting dressed…
She was always very upset and sorry but it never stopped her doing it again! She has got gradually better and better as we head towards being a teenager. But even at 11 she doesn’t sleep well. And I have had to develop different consequences etc as she doesn’t respond the same way as her sister.

WeeSleekitCowrinTimrousBeastie · 21/11/2023 17:41

I had one easy and one challenge and they've stayed that way as they've grown. Totally different personalities and temperaments.

megletthesecond · 21/11/2023 17:39

Yes. All different. You can make a difference with good / bad parenting but IME nature counts for quite a lot.
DS was hard work as a baby but after that was the most chilled out child and teen.
DD was an easy baby but hasn't been able to cope with secondary school for the last six months as her mental health is all over the place.

LittleGlowingOblong · 21/11/2023 17:31

I think you’re maybe over thinking this…. I did too. Looking back it was massive pre-natal anxiety (I too considered a termination). Counselling would be really helpful for you just now. Looking back my anxieties were really about other stuff entirely.

Whiterose23 · 21/11/2023 17:29

Yes pretty much luck. I had one easy and one not so easy child.
one was very fussy with food, one would eat anything, likewise with sleep and tantrums
Now both are at secondary school and are pretty easy but one is definitely more prone to emotional outbursts than the other. However both have always been pretty amazing in my eyes 🤩

NeedToChangeName · 21/11/2023 17:26

I'd say it's a mix of nature and nurture

My DS has always been really easy. I'm sure part of that is down to his / our personalities, and part down to DH and my jobs (both involving welfare of children)

Storynanny1 · 21/11/2023 17:17

“Some upbringing the older they get: My friend has older children who are totally fine with being told no because she started from young - and meant it. “
yes to this - I once overheard a friend say to one of my sons when they were playing upstairs “ go and ask your mum again” ( can’t remember what it was) and my son replied “ when she says no she won’t change her mind”
I was very impressed - and told him so when the friend had gone home. I wasn’t rigid about much stuff though just what I thought was important at the time.

Emi199 · 20/11/2023 23:22

Actually, what am I talking about? It’s a lot to do with upbringing the older they get. I need to get off mumsnet and go to sleep…

Emi199 · 20/11/2023 23:21

Luck but some genetics. Some upbringing the older they get but kids will be kids despite this too.

Luck: One slept like a dream.

Genetics: I am sure one had my fiery, impatient nature from a very young age! I was so conscious to never become too impassioned (in a bad way) in front of them and always talked about patience - again from very young. Some would say it was environmental and my behaviour somehow rubbed off on them. They’re probably right. One is also very laidback like dad. Two really different kids, exactly the same upbringing.

Some upbringing the older they get: My friend has older children who are totally fine with being told no because she started from young - and meant it.

Oh and routine! Which falls under environmental/upbringing. Routine can definitely help with having a good sleeper - but some kids just don’t get the memo!

BertieBotts · 20/11/2023 23:00

There is definitely research showing that temperament is a real thing. But I do think that very difficult children like Child B in your example are a minority.

Most children are somewhere in the middle of the two.

Tarantella6 · 20/11/2023 22:53

Definitely a big chunk of luck. But if you have a more difficult child you'll find ways to cope, you'll know that situation xyz results in a tantrum so you'll ensure you don't end up in that situation if at all possible. You might decide to pick your battles.

Hopefully you get a child similar to yourself - if you're a routine person, and you get a baby that likes routine chances are life will be chilled out. But if you try and force a routine on a baby that's just not up for it then it might all be a bit more of a battle.

ThorsMistress · 20/11/2023 22:47

I have 2 DS’s and they’re completely different! DS1 can be really hard work and the temper he has is awful at times.

DS2 has autism and is the complete opposite of DS1. His manners are impeccable and he’s extremely well behaved.

Both raised exactly the same

fuckssaaaaake · 20/11/2023 22:41

madeleine85 · 20/11/2023 19:41

Also, routine routine routine from literally day 1, and sleep training from the weight/age guideline saved my sanity. The book bringing up bebe was fascinating and helped me and my style of parenting. Not for everone, but as a working mum without a support network, they were huge helps.

I'm not trying to argue here but i just want to say that routines don't work for everyone. So if Op tried a routine and it doesn't work they might think they're doing something wrong but some babies just cannot adapt to routine just because the parent tries to implement one, so that's not necessarily accurate advice

Pipa42 · 20/11/2023 21:54

XelaM · 20/11/2023 20:02

I agree with posters who say try to make your life as easy as possible and forget trying to do everything perfectly (I'm about as far from perfection as anyone could get - ask my daughter 😂) yet my daughter is now a really lovely teen - super hard-working, polite, popular and aspiring to become a professional athlete. Just do what you can to make your own life easier.

Edited

Couldn’t agree more with this, if you’re stressed, tired, zooming about everywhere it will affect your parenting. There are little things you will miss or not handle as well as you should have. You don’t know what your parenting journey will involve but not being a martyr and drawing on support along the way will help so much. Yes of course there are times when you will just have to get on with it however tough. I specifically waited to have last baby at the same time as the older one was starting school to make things easier and then along came lockdown 🤦🏻‍♀️🤣 you couldn’t have made it up but we survived!!

OurfriendsintheNE · 20/11/2023 20:55

I think you have to be prepared to take whatever kind of child you get, as to large extent it’s out of your control.

But it’s also important to remember that good parents are made, not born. You care enough to want to do the best for your child, so you learn different strategies, you figure out how you can best support them. Yes, you get overwhelmed sometimes but nothing worthwhile in life is easy, and that relationship with your child can be the most meaningful one you’ll ever have with another human being.

lollipoprainbow · 20/11/2023 20:45

Pure luck of the draw my dd is autistic I hadn't planned for that.

Echobelly · 20/11/2023 20:31

Yeah, it is luck really. I have a friend who is a total supermum and was so supportive when I was having difficulty breastfeeding. She's always been a much more disciplined parent than me. Her oldest and youngest have been lovey and easy as far as I can tell - her middle one much more challenging (behaviour difficulties, toileting difficulties) but great in their own way as well. And as others have said, it varies by stage with the individual child.

Babyboomtastic · 20/11/2023 20:29

Think about it this way, you are currently growing a human. When it is born it will be a baby, but also a human. 2 years later it will be a turkey, but also a human. 15 years after birth you've got a teenager - but also a human.

The humans you know and see, and work with, are friends with, they ones that hold doors open and smile, the ones that frustratingly pull out in front of you at junctions. Again, all humans in thier full glorious range.

You don't need to know what small children are like when you can see the range in the rest of humanity. And yes, you can influence and nudge, but ultimately they are all different.

What you haven't taken account of though is how love helps you through the tricky times. It doesn't make it easy, but it does help a LOT.

Sometimeswinning · 20/11/2023 20:27

Storynanny1 · 20/11/2023 18:50

Haha that’s so like mine although in a different order!

My friend and I had the same chat about how our kids would act based on the film BirdBox. Dd would not look. Ds would have to peek and youngest dd would most definitely remove the blindfold!

Parenting wise they are all respectful and nice kids. I’d like to think me and dh had some hand in that!

SleepingStandingUp · 20/11/2023 20:18

JustAMinutePleass · 20/11/2023 18:12

My opinion isn’t going to be popular - but in my opinion and experience parents tend to create children in their own image. Babies pick up on things like anxiety and this can seriously impact behaviour in the early years. Also as they get older, kids who with parents they don’t like may become quieter at home & start socialising out of the house more. Imo a child who is comfortable enough to express their emotions - positive and negative - with their parent has had a good childhood - and that is what you should aim for. Do this by being a responsive parent and teaching independance

But op also doesn't want to risk having a child with additional needs. Even if you assert that it's possible to raise a perfect baby who sleeps through the night, eats what they're given, never tantrums, never had a difficult age, that wouldn't change the fact I spent the first 18 months in and out of hospital with DC1 and DC2 split into two and became DCs2+3. Eldest has non inherited wonky chromosomes and asd. Dtwins may well. Any cold could have an illness or accident that changes your life for the harder.

Op if you only want a perfect child or nothing, have the abortion and get iron clad contraception.

But in my experience, you just learn to cope. Yes of course some parents are genuinely shit and abusive bit that isn't the kids fault. The ready of us get by. We cry. W make mistakes. We thrive. We strive. The key is love and backup.

Holdyournoseandthinkofchocolate · 20/11/2023 20:15

‘Easy/good’ is also different depending on different situations.

I know a child who you would probably think is a dream to parent. Never shouts, never runs away, happy to sit and colour or read a book, kind to other children.

And yet the bit you don’t see is she is massively clingy and does not want to participate in group activities. School can be tricky. She doesn’t want to do anything where she is ‘dropped off’.

And parenting those emotions can be really hard. And in an older child even harder.

TolkiensFallow · 20/11/2023 20:12

It’s luck.

Before I had children I’d have argued the case for nurture but it’s mainly nature.

Prioritise a good sleep routine, if they sleep, you sleep and then parenting is easier