Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too wonder why people shop on temu Shein etc

558 replies

HappySunday1 · 20/11/2023 17:32

When we know how bad the environment is how much plastic and stuff ends up in land fill how poor the workers conditions are why are we supporting them. I see so many people doing big hauls of stuff. I know it’s cheap and maybe it’s all people can afford by you buy cheap you buy twice.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
XenoBitch · 21/11/2023 21:47

I know a few people who shop on Temu, and they are addicted. They are buying tat that they would not normally get... the appeal is that it is cheap.

bemusedmoose · 21/11/2023 21:45

Because they sell the stuff you pay a lot for in shops at pretty much cost price!

Dd wanted hair claws in Claires - wasnt paying £10 for 1 hair claw. Found the same one in shop next door for £5. Bargain i thought. Only to find i could get 12 in different colours on shein for £8!

Same with temu - it's pretty much cost price stuff you get in the high street for 3 times the price if not more.

All shops use the same factories and the same sweat shops makes the stuff whether it's nike or next. So unless you only buy locally made, organic, plastic free everything then you are going to be buying plastics and items from places with poor labour laws. Avoiding temu just means you are paying more for the same crap.

To be fair to temu - i have bought from them and it was good quality and cheap. Only one thing turned up that wasnt exactly what they advertised (cute plushie cushion looking big and plump in photos, turned up small and flat and no amount of fluffing will ever make it look like the photo. Is cute though).

I also really cant afford store prices and being savvy i can definitely make the money go further with temu if im careful and dont buy tat.

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 21:35

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 21:08

@Oliotya what's wrong with wanting clothes that are pretty? Isn't that a normal thing to want?
The thing with "affordable" though. Obviously everyone likes a bargain but I don't buy stuff thinking "yay I can buy this nice top for less than a fiver" I buy because I need clothes and I like how it looks. But if it was available in a UK shop for £30 I would buy it from them. But nice clothes that fit just don't exist. I can't buy what doesn't exist.

There's nothing wrong with wanting clothes that are pretty. But you don't "need" to buy that particular item. You're choosing pretty over ethical. I personally choose to forgo items that I know are unethically produced and likely full of untested chemicals.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 21:24

Z1hun · 21/11/2023 21:20

Erm OK... you're quite angry. are you OK sweetheart. Did you break a plate.
🙂

Oh do bore off, you just can't admit that I have caught you out with your superior "I refuse to shop knowingly made in China goods" attitude!

PurpleWisteria1 · 21/11/2023 21:20

busymomtoone · 21/11/2023 17:59

I can only assume that the holier than thou OP has never shopped in supermarkets ( mass purchasing drove many a fishmonger, butcher and grocery out of business) ; never purchased on Amazon ( no explanation needed), never buys out if season or overseas produce and checks the label of origin of all her foods and clothing ( even shock horror if it comes from the High Street). I assume she’s also aware that high end ( “ buy once and it lasts seasons”) designer clothing and handbags can also be made in exact same sweat shops she so despises - but presumably having such ginormous concern for the environment she fully researches all this before making any purchase whatsoever. For the mere mortals among us , many people are driven by cost. A £1 umbrella will surely not last even one winter - but if £30 is a weekly budget then it’s not being spent on a sturdy umbrella!! For those saying it’s laziness and check out eBay ( also clothes and products often of unknown origin , and not helping local businesses) or charity shops - please recognise you are in a position of privilege to live near decent charity shops/ have time to browse them. Also they are no longer “ cheap” - my local Oxfam has on several occasions had a price tag above the original sale tag cost!! It’s indisputable that Temu and the like will have an effect on British businesses AND the environment , just as supermarkets and Amazon have had; but presumably the OP also researches and boycotts all the products, places and services currently funded/ supported and run by overseas countries such as China - good luck with that ! The horse has well and truly bolted - UK car industries, steelworks etc have all been decimated, and even many of our food products are now shipped from overseas. Of course it’s not ecologically or environmentally friendly- and if you can make a stand that’s marvellous- but many people are simply too busy in survival mode.

It’s clear from your post that you cannot separate ‘goods made from China’ generally. And Tumu. No one is perfect I’m sure with spinning their own yarn from Uk sheep and making clothes. That’s not what many of us are saying. Temu is a different level altogether. Like trying to compare an the damage of a few soldiers to that of a missile. Do not compare Uk supermarkets and the like with Temu.

Z1hun · 21/11/2023 21:20

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 20:23

You are the one who keeps banging on about my dinner set. It is from a UK company btw - however now made in China, which is the point I was trying to get across. You might believe that Made in England is the best - but how much is actually still made there?

You also said "I have no intention of moving from the UK to China". Which is why I stated I don't live there.

Erm OK... you're quite angry. are you OK sweetheart. Did you break a plate.
🙂

Sennelier1 · 21/11/2023 21:19

I don't believe the reasoning "some people can only afford the cheap shops", because I see that those buying at shein etc. buy a lót at the same time, like several tops and leggings etc. in one go. It gives the impression of being cheaper, but for that money you could buy one or two good pieces that with good care could last you several seasons. I guess people have their reasons. Personally I'm not after having a zillion of Tshirts, I prefer a few of good quality that fit well, wash well, go with other clothes I have. But if [you] prefer to have a lot of clothes in all colours etc., fine. What makes us happy is different for each of us! Also, I have children and grandchildren and prefer my clothes to be produced childlabour-free. My third reason not to buy at Shein etc. is the fact I don't even remotely like the plastic crap and "novelties" they sell. My house is fine (for me) as it is and I don't feel the need to replace carefully chosen items with stuff I consider tatty. Anyway, I prefer to only replace what's broken ánd unrepairable.

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 21:08

@Oliotya what's wrong with wanting clothes that are pretty? Isn't that a normal thing to want?
The thing with "affordable" though. Obviously everyone likes a bargain but I don't buy stuff thinking "yay I can buy this nice top for less than a fiver" I buy because I need clothes and I like how it looks. But if it was available in a UK shop for £30 I would buy it from them. But nice clothes that fit just don't exist. I can't buy what doesn't exist.

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 21:02

@Oliotya I am not saying "designers" owe me anything but obviously every item of clothing sold is designed by somebody. The bland M+S stuff doesn't just appear by magic.
So why aren't the struggling UK retailers using the talent that clearly exists? Get these independent designers working for them - use their talent.
@SurprisedWithAHorse it's definitely not on when a small business designer (or even the big name ones) has their designs stolen. That's wrong and shouldn't happen.
But the UK retailers aren't helping themselves by only selling dull bland clothes - people are naturally going to start looking elsewhere for nice clothes and are unlikely to know if a design is stolen or not.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 21/11/2023 20:59

bippityboppity87 · 21/11/2023 20:44

I have a few bits from Hobbs, Reiss and White Company that haven't lasted anywhere near as much as the stuff I bought off Shien

It's a very irritating fact that Shein often does "last" basically because it's plastic and wouldn't break down if you buried it for 500 years. But that doesn't mean it's good quality.

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 20:48

SD1978 · 21/11/2023 20:47

Because I can't afford £200 for a nice ethically sourced jumper.......

Pop down to oxfam and get one for £2 then.

SD1978 · 21/11/2023 20:47

Because I can't afford £200 for a nice ethically sourced jumper.......

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 20:46

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 20:34

The thing I don't understand about stolen designs and fakes with the clothes - I don't see clothes that look like the nice pretty stuff my daughter likes from Shein in physical shops. If it's stolen designs from "designer names" then I wouldn't be able to afford to buy it. Most of the clothes in the regular high street retailers (M+S, Primark, H+M, the supermarkets etc) is just mostly bland dull clothes. Why aren't they selling the pretty stuff? Why aren't they collaborating with these designers to make affordable versions of their clothes to be sold in actual shops that exist on the UK high street?
If they want to stop fakes and copies then they need to make their products affordable and available.

Designers don't owe you affordable fashion. If you're buying it just because it's pretty, you don't need it at any price. It's really that simple.

bippityboppity87 · 21/11/2023 20:44

I have a few bits from Hobbs, Reiss and White Company that haven't lasted anywhere near as much as the stuff I bought off Shien

CornishGem1975 · 21/11/2023 20:43

I hear you @Needmorelego Shein etc feature a lot of styles of dresses and tops I like that I just can't find in the UK stores.

ToffeeMamma · 21/11/2023 20:43

Personally I shop for a number of reasons. COL is one. Many of the things I get on temu are things I would have previously bought elsewhere so it's got nothing to do with buying excess plastic. I do buy some toys but again they are things I'd buy my son regardless but on temu it's cheaper. They are good enough quality and I've not thrown a toy away in year. If something breaks we usually find a use for it somewhere else. Like toy cars he has now grown out of I've attached to a desk lamp and shelf edge and sprayed them. He's into cars still just not toys so they are Greta for his room. Clothing wise as a family of people on the autistic spectrum we find t very hard to find clothes that any of us find comfortable that are cost effective. Temu is all of that. Their clothes are stretchy, comfy and good sizes and hard wearing. I've just ordered him a coat that is waxy on outside, waterproof and warm but it's comfy and stretchy enough not to feel to stiff for him and he loves it. I would never stop ordering from temu. Because why should we if people have issues with all the plastic rubbish address that as a family. I always reuse the plastic packaging when I sell items on vinted, or eBay and I use the zip lock bags for storage too. I do t find it.unsafe for the environment at all. Order what you need and dispose of them reasonably. You can still use places like temu without damaging the environment.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 21/11/2023 20:42

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 20:34

The thing I don't understand about stolen designs and fakes with the clothes - I don't see clothes that look like the nice pretty stuff my daughter likes from Shein in physical shops. If it's stolen designs from "designer names" then I wouldn't be able to afford to buy it. Most of the clothes in the regular high street retailers (M+S, Primark, H+M, the supermarkets etc) is just mostly bland dull clothes. Why aren't they selling the pretty stuff? Why aren't they collaborating with these designers to make affordable versions of their clothes to be sold in actual shops that exist on the UK high street?
If they want to stop fakes and copies then they need to make their products affordable and available.

It isn't all stolen from major fashion houses. A lot of it is stolen from small businesses and sole traders. Shein is now such a behemoth that it can pump out stolen rip offs much, much faster than the original business can make them, and of course it's only going to charge a fraction of the price. And it's doing this constantly, so it's covering every style and taste you can think of.

"Affordable", well, when you operate completely unethically, nobody can compete with you on price. Consumers need to prioritise something other than cheapness. Ethical companies simply can't undercut Shein because it costs money to source responsibly, pay workers and create quality.

I posted a link upthread. Take a look, it's informative.

Needmorelego · 21/11/2023 20:34

The thing I don't understand about stolen designs and fakes with the clothes - I don't see clothes that look like the nice pretty stuff my daughter likes from Shein in physical shops. If it's stolen designs from "designer names" then I wouldn't be able to afford to buy it. Most of the clothes in the regular high street retailers (M+S, Primark, H+M, the supermarkets etc) is just mostly bland dull clothes. Why aren't they selling the pretty stuff? Why aren't they collaborating with these designers to make affordable versions of their clothes to be sold in actual shops that exist on the UK high street?
If they want to stop fakes and copies then they need to make their products affordable and available.

Thefsm · 21/11/2023 20:30

Am I aware of the ethical issues? Yes. But I shop on SHEIN because I don’t trust the places I would shop from elsewhere to be more ethical, they all use sweatshops etc. I do a lot of my clothes shopping in thrift stores but as a plus size woman SHEIN has clothes that fit me well and last brilliantly. Some of my favourite clothing is from them - and the stitching is strong and fabric higher quality than in stores like torrid I would usually go to. t isn’t throw away clothing if you shop carefully and read reviews on each item, plus people share their weight ands height info and reap photos so I have a far better idea what I am getting than with other online retailers.

I do boycot some things. Chick fil a, hobby lobby, nestle although I probably miss some of the smaller subsidiary products as they own so much. But I don’t see why my carbon footprint of purchases matters much in the grand scheme of things where the top 1% has a bigger carbon footprint that the bottom 60% altogether.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 20:23

Z1hun · 21/11/2023 19:42

I think you need to re read my message. I quite clearly never implied you live in China but you said 'not to move to this part of the world' which is very vague and I asked where it is that this part of the world you refer to is.

Also I really can't comment on your dinner set but you clearly like it so again good for you on your 'lovely' dinner set. I don't really get why you are focusing on it but ok. 🙃

You are the one who keeps banging on about my dinner set. It is from a UK company btw - however now made in China, which is the point I was trying to get across. You might believe that Made in England is the best - but how much is actually still made there?

You also said "I have no intention of moving from the UK to China". Which is why I stated I don't live there.

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 20:19

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 20:13

There is really no getting through to you is there. Yes, everyone bought from shops, there was no other option, but a lot of people didn't buy very much at all because they couldn't afford to - why can you not grasp that? Should people with no money only ever buy the absolute necessities of life, while those with money buy luxuries? Is that the sort of world you aspire to?

That argument doesn't really fly when there's already an abundance of cheap (supermarket/poundland/primark etc) and landfills overflowing with second hand. "People with no money" don't need this seasons polyester dress or fucking plastic toothpaste squeezers as was on the first page. In fact, to some "people with money" might have nicer things because they save up and invest, or buy used rather than waste it on disposable tat for the dopamine hit.

sarahd29 · 21/11/2023 20:18

Hysterical you're all naming temu primark etc but retailers like Hobbs buy in from China..that £189 cost you think is great quality...made in China..google it. Albeit better quality still made there and marked up here.

I was in the Isle of Harris this summer and was desperate to buy some Harris Tweed to sew some curtains with. £40 per metre, is it worth it..hand made on Harris..beautiful but I would need 4 metres..or I could go to John Lewis and buy non Harris tweed (from China) ready made for £90..reality is we need to buy British and prices will eventually come down if we do but we need a shock like "China is infiltrating everything you do". Have to say am complete hypocrite as I buy moulds for hobbies of temu..never used SHEIN but like the designs.

..but am going to make a more consistent effort to consider what I'm buying.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 20:16

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 21/11/2023 20:02

As much as I agree about the environmental aspect, I'm not pig ignorant so I understand that not everybody has bags of cash available to spend so price is the main driver of probably most purchases by most people.

Are you really that stupid that you don't see that people buy what they can afford?

There really are a lot of people on MN who live in their own little bubble and cannot imagine how life is for those not so fortunate. Apparenty if you aren't reasonably well off you just have to put up with it and never have anything nice or fun in your life.

I find it more disturbing than people shopping on Temu/Shein to be honest.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 20:13

Diamonde · 21/11/2023 19:29

Everyone bought from shops.

There is really no getting through to you is there. Yes, everyone bought from shops, there was no other option, but a lot of people didn't buy very much at all because they couldn't afford to - why can you not grasp that? Should people with no money only ever buy the absolute necessities of life, while those with money buy luxuries? Is that the sort of world you aspire to?

Diamonde · 21/11/2023 20:11

What's the acceptable clothing size for women to be now?

Swipe left for the next trending thread