Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too wonder why people shop on temu Shein etc

558 replies

HappySunday1 · 20/11/2023 17:32

When we know how bad the environment is how much plastic and stuff ends up in land fill how poor the workers conditions are why are we supporting them. I see so many people doing big hauls of stuff. I know it’s cheap and maybe it’s all people can afford by you buy cheap you buy twice.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 22/11/2023 11:42

Some people just want your cash

No shit

Here I was thinking shops wanted my friendship and nuggets of wisdom. Heartbroken I am

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:42

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 11:36

It's not the same thing.

The high streets aren't literally using the same photos of products with the same brand names and trying to claim it's actually an expensive branded product. Temu/Aliexpress et al are.

It's especially problematic when it comes to things like dodgy electrical goods which often have entirely fake safety marks on them. Happy with one of those next to your bed charging your phone?

It's not the same thing but only because you lost the argument so shifted it to talking about unsafe electric products.

When it comes to ripping off the IP of smaller designers, which you talked about earlier, it is exactly the same thing when the big stores do it. In fact it's probably even worse because they have a veil of respectability.

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 11:40

User79785435 · 22/11/2023 11:29

Who cares about unethical labour practices, about the environmental cost, about legitimate designers having their IP ripped off or that these places happily sell your data on when you can get 100 colouring pencils 20p cheaper than you can in home bargains.

But it's not 20p. It's often £10-50 which really adds up if you're buying loads of everyday household stuff that you need to buy anyway (hair clips, hair bands, socks, duvet protectors, hats, gloves, storage containers, stationery etc). Again, people's shopping habits are different but I only use Temu for boring household necessities that I have to buy anyway. I don't care which brands these are, they just need to be functional.

Regarding ethical labour practices, read my post above. Chinese factories do not employ child labour because they are all open to visitations from Western contractors and in close competition with each other. They would have to secretly maintain a child labour room whilst having an open showroom for visitors, which is ludicrous. If one factory is rumoured to be using child labour, or other illegal practices, they would be tipped off instantly by their competitors who want their contracts. It's an egocentric and racist POV to state that all factories in China use child labour when it doesn't make any economic sense on a basic business level.

A similar logic works with the claim that they steal your bank details. If you bought from Temu once and had money stolen from your bank, then you would never use it again. Like any business, they want returning customers so it's in their best interest to get you shopping repeatedly and spend more money than what they could possibly "steal" in a single transaction. Temu is a marketplace similar to Amazon and the money goes to individual sellers. It's not outside the realm of possibility that a few bad players do misuse payment data or are simply unlucky and get hacked. But on the whole, they do not take cash from your bank account as a lasting business model.

Designers have their IP stolen at all levels. There were several high profile cases of Topshop and Zara stealing designs, usually created by third party agencies. Aliexpress has been offering stolen IP work for 10+ years, and it's been around much longer than Temu & Shein. Counterfeit and IP theft is a huge problem but it's been around longer than the app and will pop up elsewhere even if Temu gets banned. AI also steals artists work. It's possible to prompt AI to create work "in the style of" any artist and the resulting image will technically be entirely copyright free. So in a few years, companies who want free imagery will all do that instead of outright reprinting existing work.

Edited

Have a dig into the ethical practices of these companies. You are being incredibly naive and assuming things like "they want your returning business" and that claims of child labour are "racist".

Nope. Some people just want your cash and your data.

Nobody is claiming that all such companies operate in the same way, but many are deeply, deeply problematic and it's naive in the extreme to think otherwise in order to save a couple of quid on the kind of essentials you can likely get from home bargains and the like for similar prices.

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 11:36

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:30

The big mainstream High Street chains also rip off loads of designs.

https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/our-designer-fear-small-firms-alarm-at-impact-of-high-street-copy-cats/

It's not the same thing.

The high streets aren't literally using the same photos of products with the same brand names and trying to claim it's actually an expensive branded product. Temu/Aliexpress et al are.

It's especially problematic when it comes to things like dodgy electrical goods which often have entirely fake safety marks on them. Happy with one of those next to your bed charging your phone?

Tamrastarr · 22/11/2023 11:31

I recently saw a Facebook post from, an American contact, warning everyone not to buy from Temu or Shein as apparently Temu and Shein, who they note are Chinese companies, are making a huge loss on every sale, clogging up search engines and trying to force out all competition. Therefore forcing out many small US businesses and having an adverse effect on the US economy!! The post ends by urging everyone to support their local made in the US businesses! I assume they mean Amazon and the like!! LOL! So it looks like they have the Americans scared!

Allfur · 22/11/2023 11:31

Do you really need to buy loads every day?!

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:30

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 10:56

What they are mostly doing is ripping off other designs with no consideration for IP, usually along with stealing photos of the legitimate item to make you think that it's the real thing.

And then taking advantage of the fact that a large number of people won't notice or will notice but of the sake of a couple of quid won't bother returning.

The big mainstream High Street chains also rip off loads of designs.

https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/our-designer-fear-small-firms-alarm-at-impact-of-high-street-copy-cats/

Our designer fear: Small firms’ alarm at impact of high street copy-cats

Independent designers and artists are increasingly having their work ripped-off by big brands and stores, according to a leading campaigning organisation.

https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/our-designer-fear-small-firms-alarm-at-impact-of-high-street-copy-cats

User79785435 · 22/11/2023 11:29

Who cares about unethical labour practices, about the environmental cost, about legitimate designers having their IP ripped off or that these places happily sell your data on when you can get 100 colouring pencils 20p cheaper than you can in home bargains.

But it's not 20p. It's often £10-50 which really adds up if you're buying loads of everyday household stuff that you need to buy anyway (hair clips, hair bands, socks, duvet protectors, hats, gloves, storage containers, stationery etc). Again, people's shopping habits are different but I only use Temu for boring household necessities that I have to buy anyway. I don't care which brands these are, they just need to be functional.

Regarding ethical labour practices, read my post above. Chinese factories do not employ child labour because they are all open to visitations from Western contractors and in close competition with each other. They would have to secretly maintain a child labour room whilst having an open showroom for visitors, which is ludicrous. If one factory is rumoured to be using child labour, or other illegal practices, they would be tipped off instantly by their competitors who want their contracts. It's an egocentric and racist POV to state that all factories in China use child labour when it doesn't make any economic sense on a basic business level.

A similar logic works with the claim that they steal your bank details. If you bought from Temu once and had money stolen from your bank, then you would never use it again. Like any business, they want returning customers so it's in their best interest to get you shopping repeatedly and spend more money than what they could possibly "steal" in a single transaction. Temu is a marketplace similar to Amazon and the money goes to individual sellers. It's not outside the realm of possibility that a few bad players do misuse payment data or are simply unlucky and get hacked. But on the whole, they do not take cash from your bank account as a lasting business model.

Designers have their IP stolen at all levels. There were several high profile cases of Topshop and Zara stealing designs, usually created by third party agencies. Aliexpress has been offering stolen IP work for 10+ years, and it's been around much longer than Temu & Shein. Counterfeit and IP theft is a huge problem but it's been around longer than the app and will pop up elsewhere even if Temu gets banned. AI also steals artists work. It's possible to prompt AI to create work "in the style of" any artist and the resulting image will technically be entirely copyright free. So in a few years, companies who want free imagery will all do that instead of outright reprinting existing work.

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 10:56

Boysnana · 22/11/2023 10:19

You may well find that temu shein and wish are selling straight to you without the labels.
You can wait until they hit our shops and have the labels sewn in and pay more if you like.

Whether we like it or not these items are coming into the UK... branded or not...

What they are mostly doing is ripping off other designs with no consideration for IP, usually along with stealing photos of the legitimate item to make you think that it's the real thing.

And then taking advantage of the fact that a large number of people won't notice or will notice but of the sake of a couple of quid won't bother returning.

Needmorelego · 22/11/2023 10:23

@Frabbits I do admit I am baffled by people that buy things like colouring pencils online because they are something that is easy to get cheap from many High Street retailers.
But then again I know of people who rarely actually go to physical shops and just order everything they buy online (not just Temu etc type places - but mainstream retailers too). I have spoken to people who seem completely unaware what some retailers sell. When I helped out at the primary school PTA and we would get crafty bits for events - there was always at least one parent who was shocked you could buy colouring pens and crayons at Poundland because "I didn't know they sold that sort of thing" !
(baffled to think what they thought Poundland sells 🤔)

Boysnana · 22/11/2023 10:21

Some of amazon and eBay are drop shipped to you from temu etc anyway

Boysnana · 22/11/2023 10:19

You may well find that temu shein and wish are selling straight to you without the labels.
You can wait until they hit our shops and have the labels sewn in and pay more if you like.

Whether we like it or not these items are coming into the UK... branded or not...

Bluelightbaby · 22/11/2023 10:17

I buy from SHEIN (also Vinted but even then that works out more with all the individual p&p) I buy because it’s all I can afford. Some of the clothes I’ve had for years. I do sometimes look in charity shops but I’m yet to find anything remotely fashionable.

ive also bought other bits for my house on shein too.

mrlistersgelfbride · 22/11/2023 10:11

I try to go for ethical brands if I can but honestly Shein is fantastic for childrens clothes.
I do feel bad shopping there and try to limit it but have just bought DD some lovely dresses for her birthday/christmas- the quality is surprisingly good.

Temu annoys me with it's mass spamming but my friend swears by it. She does a Temu 'haul' and the stuff seems decent quality.

People buy from them as they have a wide range of products and are cheap.

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 10:10

sabbii · 22/11/2023 10:02

Wow, very judgemental from OP!! Short answer people will buy from wherever without being dictated to. I buy from them all and Temu/Shein is no different from eBay or Amazon. For most people ethical concerns are ignored. The stuf I have from Temu have been great quality (original Lenovo and various clothing and accessories)

"For most people ethical concerns are ignored."

This is basically it, and how fucking depressing is that. Who cares about unethical labour practices, about the environmental cost, about legitimate designers having their IP ripped off or that these places happily sell your data on when you can get 100 colouring pencils 20p cheaper than you can in home bargains.

Needmorelego · 22/11/2023 10:05

@Oliotya the pillows have already been washed many times and doubled up.
I doubt the filling is very hygienic by now - years worth of sweat and dribble.
It's time they went.
I live in a London borough in a block of flats. We have large communal bins. One for for "recycling" , one for everyday rubbish.
Unfortunately by being communal the recycling bins frequently get contaminated with incorrect rubbish. Either by people that simply don't realise they are doing it wrong (the recycling should be loose and not in any form of a bag), they put something they think the council will recycle but don't (ie a dead pillow) or they simply don't care.
As a result much of what is in the recycling bin ends up in the landfill dustcart.
There is a local "tip" (aka recycling centre). You can't drop off by walking in - you have to be in a car. That rules out a massive amount of Londoners because many don't have cars.
I am lucky I am in walking distance of a charity shop that accepts un saleable clothes for rag recycling but not everyone can do that.
My borough is a nightmare for fly tipping. There's broken furniture, mattresses, broken electric items....in fact just about anything and everything dumped everywhere. Why? Because some people are selfish and lazy - but also some people just don't know what to "do" with stuff that's reached the end of it's life.
As a country we need better when it comes to recycling and disposal of products that simply can't be recycled. It's all so half arsed.
There are a lot of community based projects that are making things better (like the school uniform exchanges) but it's still pretty crap.

Bbq1 · 22/11/2023 10:05

RudsyFarmer · 20/11/2023 17:41

I’ve never shopped in either of these places but i’m now considering it!

Edited

I've downloaded the app due to this thread! Same stuff as Amazon but pounds cheaper.

sabbii · 22/11/2023 10:02

Wow, very judgemental from OP!! Short answer people will buy from wherever without being dictated to. I buy from them all and Temu/Shein is no different from eBay or Amazon. For most people ethical concerns are ignored. The stuf I have from Temu have been great quality (original Lenovo and various clothing and accessories)

Diamonde · 22/11/2023 10:01

Needmorelego · 22/11/2023 08:39

@Oliotya about recycling....
A big thing last summer was many towns having school uniform exchanges. There were loads all over the country.
The one in my parents town was literally you could pick what you needed for free. Others were "pay if you can" or 50p an item.
These exchanges were all run by volunteers.
This is the type of thing that should become standard in a society. This is one thing I meant by recycling more. Facilities need to be made easier for people to be able to do this. With school uniform it's easy to do because you can drop the clothes off at your child's school as the pick up point.

Definitely agree with this. It's easy to move clothes along with kids (harder with adult sizes and tastes)

pastypirate · 22/11/2023 10:01

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 22/11/2023 09:37

Anyway, why are people even buying clothes? What do you need them for? I just tip up bits of my carrot every 9 months and string it all together to make a carpet tracksuit. What are you all buying so many clothes for when you can just fashion it out of what you have in your home?

This....

User79785435 · 22/11/2023 10:00

They do mine data and evidence is mounting that they do place code on phones to monitor activity and change setting etc in other apps.

Yes, my point was mainly about the pricing and I can't prove anything regarding data mining. However Facebook and Instagram and the vast majority of apps all track user activity on the same level. The easiest way companies profit illegally from their data is to sell email lists of active users. Everyone gets spam from mailing lists they never signed up for and this is because your email was sold or stolen as leads. It's impossible to prove who did this unless you use separate emails for every single account you create.

It's also common sense by now to use encrypted payment methods like Paypal instead of entering our credit card details into any website or app. Even secure servers from reputable providers can be hacked. So in that respect, I feel Temu has the baseline risk of any other website or app. To me it's comparable to the risk of getting mugged while on holiday. The chances of it happening might be slightly higher in some countries and you take precautions, but you can never 100% protect yourself from crime. You can't just sit home and refuse to go anywhere or do anything because you don't want to be a victim of crime.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 22/11/2023 09:58

Has anyone got any actual evidence that Temu sell data to criminals?

Frabbits · 22/11/2023 09:57

Temu absolutely do mine and sell data including to criminals who then use it for phishing scams, identity theft and so on.

As do a lot of these cheapo places. Yet another reason to avold these places like the plague.

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/11/2023 09:48

User79785435 · 22/11/2023 09:41

Not true. That is actually exactly how much it costs for factories to produce those products AND make a profit on top. Anyone with experience sourcing from China knows that the wholesale cost of most lifestyle items are between £0.10-£5. You can go on Alibaba and get quotes for yourself if you don't believe it. None of the Temu products are custom-made or branded which means they can be created in an absolutely massive MOQ (minimum order quantity), the price gets pushed even lower. The factory pricing is nothing new and has been this way for the past 20-30 years. The only difference is that Temu/Shein/Aliexpress has giving everyday consumers access to small units of those products for the first time.

You are being taken for a mug if you believe that paying £10 for the same product from ASDA or Amazon is making a difference. By all means do so if you can afford it. But bear in mind that extra £9 you decide to spend out of moral righteousness is simply a markup that a company CEO decided on so he can pay for his Mercedes. You are funding those fat cats who are making arbitrary profits in the UK and driving the COL even higher. Those are the people who aren't affected by price increases and thus the government or other retailers have less incentive to do anything about it. If they start losing their business due to people switching to Temu then there might actually be changes in pricing close to home.

I worked in UK retail (sourcing and production) for a while and it was a true eye opener. The vast majority of companies and trendy brands get their products made in China. The quality was amazing in some cases, it all depends on which factory you choose. Some factories are sloppy and produce the typical crappy plastic tat that break after a few uses. Other manufacturers have great attention to detail and project managers who speak perfect english.

Incidentally, there are lots of people here who want to believe that Chinese factories are full of children to justify their own moral high-ground tinged with racism. Sorry to disappoint you but that's not the case. All the places in Shenzhen are absolutely normal production facilities with staff who choose to be there. Doing business with western companies is the backbone of their business model and they are open all year round for visitations (we went as well). Going by MN logic, they will have to maintain hidden warehouses with little kids making the products, along with a fake showroom of the same machinery and products to show inspectors and western contractors. This is laughable and unfeasible on so many levels. Similarly, if word got out that one factory is using child labour, you can bet your arse that they will immediately get reported to the authorities or media by a competitor who wants their contracts. Chinese factories are not in some conspiracy collusion to hide child labour from the West...they are in direct competition with each other and would love the chance to snitch one of their own if it meant a business advantage.

The pay and working conditions for factory workers are obviously not amazing, but neither is that of minimum wage jobs all over the world. However since China doesn't suffer from the COL crisis, the quality of life in relation to salary for many factory workers are arguably better than someone on a very lowly paid job in the UK. The factory to consumer business model is hugely popular within China as well. Temu is based on the app Taobao which is massive in Asia. So each factory has their own creative teams creating content and marketing the products over social media. It's really less shocking and scandalous than many people in the West want to believe.

Edited

I agree with much of what you have written but please please do some more research on Temu in particular.
They do mine data and evidence is mounting that they do place code on phones to monitor activity and change setting etc in other apps.
This goes beyond Asda. It’s a new ball game. Yes Asda and the like are bad enough and source from China and make a mark up etc, but at least some is going back into the Uk economy. Asda have to follow a certain set of rules in order to trade in the Uk. No terribly high standards but something at least. Asda arnt stealing product pictures and ideas from Uk sellers. Asda arnt using criminals in prisons to make products for free. Asda arnt bombarding google with billions in advertising knocking every other uk business out of the results. There are fair trading laws in the UK for a start. No such thing exists when you start talking about Temu / shein

SurprisedWithAHorse · 22/11/2023 09:47

bippityboppity87 · 22/11/2023 09:40

Clothes not plastic tat. It was a typo Hmm

I don't know what the disapproving emoji is for. I didn't know what you were saying and I didn't know why I was tagged. I still don't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread