Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too wonder why people shop on temu Shein etc

558 replies

HappySunday1 · 20/11/2023 17:32

When we know how bad the environment is how much plastic and stuff ends up in land fill how poor the workers conditions are why are we supporting them. I see so many people doing big hauls of stuff. I know it’s cheap and maybe it’s all people can afford by you buy cheap you buy twice.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 21/11/2023 18:53

Asiatoyork · 21/11/2023 08:02

None of us are "entitled" to probably most of our purchases, but I still defend the right of people to spend their money how, and where, they wish without being judged by those who perceive themselves to hold the moral high ground

It’s come to something when questioning the use of slaves to facilitate cheap window stickers and stocking fillers is seen only as the ‘perceived’ moral high ground

My post about the perceived moral high ground was actually to point out that I imagine most people who take this high ground don't really do much research into the purchases they make and who makes them. It's all very well to look down on those who buy from the likes of Temu/Shein and feel superior to them - but do you really know the working conditions of those who made your oh so much better higher end purchase?. It has already been pointed out numerous times on this thread that a lot of high priced goods are made under the same conditions - just because you pay more for something does not mean it has been made by someone working in excellent conditions for a good wage.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 21/11/2023 18:47

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/11/2023 18:21

And as defenders of charity shop pricing often point out, they're there to make as much profit as possible, not provide cheap clothing for people. Hence the phenomenon of Primark, Amazon, Shein and presumably now Temu clothing in them being sold for the same price as new, if not more.

That's true, they are there to raise money for charity. But they're still a worthwhile option for inexpensive clothes for children who are going to outgrow them quickly, with less of an environmental impact.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/11/2023 18:41

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 18:25

Baby clothes in particular aren't difficult to find for free even. I'd seriously avoid dressing a baby in untested temu chemicals.

I know it was a long time ago, but I very much doubt somebody in the position I was in years ago is going to be given bin bags of the 2023 financial/fashion equivalent of Osh Kosh B'Gosh dungarees, pure new wool coats/cardigans and immaculate organic cotton t-shirts by other women in the baby and toddler group as I was. And not everybody wants secondhand - I've been caught out by clothes moths in the past and there's apparently a massive increase in bedbug infestations these days, even before the aspect of never knowing until it's received whether something being sold BNWT/Smoke free/Animal free house is actually any of those.

Lustra666 · 21/11/2023 18:37

Do you eat meat? choose you own battles, not other peoples!

Notreallyhappy · 21/11/2023 18:29

My £3 quilt bags won't end in land fill they're in the attic with summer quilts in them..

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 18:25

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/11/2023 18:21

And as defenders of charity shop pricing often point out, they're there to make as much profit as possible, not provide cheap clothing for people. Hence the phenomenon of Primark, Amazon, Shein and presumably now Temu clothing in them being sold for the same price as new, if not more.

Baby clothes in particular aren't difficult to find for free even. I'd seriously avoid dressing a baby in untested temu chemicals.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/11/2023 18:21

Mademetoxic · 20/11/2023 22:31

Charity shops have loads of children's/baby clothes.

And as defenders of charity shop pricing often point out, they're there to make as much profit as possible, not provide cheap clothing for people. Hence the phenomenon of Primark, Amazon, Shein and presumably now Temu clothing in them being sold for the same price as new, if not more.

sarahd29 · 21/11/2023 18:17

I knew someone once who worked in a food factory, on a production line of jam they they had a very well known supermarket luxury brand going to the left..to the right the exact same jam was going in to a supermarket own pot. It's all about branding and marketing.

You can choose to be the plastic tat and clothes police but be aware that the shops buy this stuff from China. Temu and SHEIN are cutting out the middle man. It's not made in the UK...

Oliotya · 21/11/2023 18:13

busymomtoone · 21/11/2023 17:59

I can only assume that the holier than thou OP has never shopped in supermarkets ( mass purchasing drove many a fishmonger, butcher and grocery out of business) ; never purchased on Amazon ( no explanation needed), never buys out if season or overseas produce and checks the label of origin of all her foods and clothing ( even shock horror if it comes from the High Street). I assume she’s also aware that high end ( “ buy once and it lasts seasons”) designer clothing and handbags can also be made in exact same sweat shops she so despises - but presumably having such ginormous concern for the environment she fully researches all this before making any purchase whatsoever. For the mere mortals among us , many people are driven by cost. A £1 umbrella will surely not last even one winter - but if £30 is a weekly budget then it’s not being spent on a sturdy umbrella!! For those saying it’s laziness and check out eBay ( also clothes and products often of unknown origin , and not helping local businesses) or charity shops - please recognise you are in a position of privilege to live near decent charity shops/ have time to browse them. Also they are no longer “ cheap” - my local Oxfam has on several occasions had a price tag above the original sale tag cost!! It’s indisputable that Temu and the like will have an effect on British businesses AND the environment , just as supermarkets and Amazon have had; but presumably the OP also researches and boycotts all the products, places and services currently funded/ supported and run by overseas countries such as China - good luck with that ! The horse has well and truly bolted - UK car industries, steelworks etc have all been decimated, and even many of our food products are now shipped from overseas. Of course it’s not ecologically or environmentally friendly- and if you can make a stand that’s marvellous- but many people are simply too busy in survival mode.

You don't have to perfect to oppose the mindless consumerism that temu/shein promote. Untested chemicals, provenance entirely unknown, unnecessary airlines, unethical production etc. A £1 umbrella is going to keep you dry for approximately half a shower = it is absolute junk that nobody needs to be buying.
Start by differentiating between want and need. Everyone needs food, nobody needs various trinkets and lots of new plastic clothing.

Cottagewitch · 21/11/2023 17:59

If people want to shop with them, fair enough, but this is what happened to me. I have a small shop. I stock tarot cards. They aren’t cheap to source. Temu sells the ‘same’ decks for pennies. Curios I ordered a pack. Of course they were a cheap rip off with no regards to the copyright therefore the artist who published them gets nothing. Quality was awful compared to the real ones. But the worse bit was some random person coming on my shops page and sharing a link to the cheap temu cards and calling me ridiculous for charging what I do when you can get them for less on temu. Items that aren’t ripping off someone’s published work I don’t mind, but it doesn’t stop at that. It’s really hurting artists and designers.

busymomtoone · 21/11/2023 17:59

I can only assume that the holier than thou OP has never shopped in supermarkets ( mass purchasing drove many a fishmonger, butcher and grocery out of business) ; never purchased on Amazon ( no explanation needed), never buys out if season or overseas produce and checks the label of origin of all her foods and clothing ( even shock horror if it comes from the High Street). I assume she’s also aware that high end ( “ buy once and it lasts seasons”) designer clothing and handbags can also be made in exact same sweat shops she so despises - but presumably having such ginormous concern for the environment she fully researches all this before making any purchase whatsoever. For the mere mortals among us , many people are driven by cost. A £1 umbrella will surely not last even one winter - but if £30 is a weekly budget then it’s not being spent on a sturdy umbrella!! For those saying it’s laziness and check out eBay ( also clothes and products often of unknown origin , and not helping local businesses) or charity shops - please recognise you are in a position of privilege to live near decent charity shops/ have time to browse them. Also they are no longer “ cheap” - my local Oxfam has on several occasions had a price tag above the original sale tag cost!! It’s indisputable that Temu and the like will have an effect on British businesses AND the environment , just as supermarkets and Amazon have had; but presumably the OP also researches and boycotts all the products, places and services currently funded/ supported and run by overseas countries such as China - good luck with that ! The horse has well and truly bolted - UK car industries, steelworks etc have all been decimated, and even many of our food products are now shipped from overseas. Of course it’s not ecologically or environmentally friendly- and if you can make a stand that’s marvellous- but many people are simply too busy in survival mode.

Mountainhowl · 21/11/2023 14:10

Boomboom22 · 21/11/2023 14:00

There was no specific war after 9/11, USA used the term war on terror and sort of linked later the Iraq war and later Libya but 9/11 is not specifically linked to a declared war. It has a legal meaning.

That's interesting, so were the US already in the middle east before then? Or do you mean the aftermath of 9/11 wasn't technically called a war? That was sort of my first taste of world politics I guess, and mostly I just remember bush shouting about WOMD and us drawing no war protests on our schoolbooks like it would make a difference 🙄 ahh the naïvety of 11-13 year olds

Going to go and brush up on my recent history while I get some work done I think, I know far more about ww2 than I do about world politics in my own lifetime

Boomboom22 · 21/11/2023 14:00

There was no specific war after 9/11, USA used the term war on terror and sort of linked later the Iraq war and later Libya but 9/11 is not specifically linked to a declared war. It has a legal meaning.

Mountainhowl · 21/11/2023 13:50

Boomboom22 · 21/11/2023 13:45

There will not be ww3 over Taiwan. Yes its an ally but its not part of nato and USA would help but ultimately so they can remain the major superpower and stop China eventually overtaking them.
We did nothing about Hong Kong despite Blair promising when they signed it back to China from the UK colonies that it would remain independent. We made some noises and said hk British can come live here, no war at all.

That's good to know! I hear a lot of what I guess is scaremongering, second hand from FIL (he's more concerned about Russia but China does get a mention). I didn't know that regarding Blair and Hong Kong, I was just in high school when 9/11 happened and from then all the political talk was about that war

Boomboom22 · 21/11/2023 13:45

There will not be ww3 over Taiwan. Yes its an ally but its not part of nato and USA would help but ultimately so they can remain the major superpower and stop China eventually overtaking them.
We did nothing about Hong Kong despite Blair promising when they signed it back to China from the UK colonies that it would remain independent. We made some noises and said hk British can come live here, no war at all.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 21/11/2023 13:45

Frabbits · 21/11/2023 13:20

Utter nonsense.

Why?

Ponoka7 · 21/11/2023 13:41

Begsthequestion · 20/11/2023 19:27

The Uyghur Muslims who are in camps in China are making stuff for Temu while suffering genocide. So it's not only about child labour.

Those goods include food, particularly containing tomato and peppers. There's more engaged with agriculture than manufacturing. We all don't give a shit about Africa. If we cared about starving children and displacement because of climate, we'd all eat plant based. These threads are about snobbery and look down on people.

CornishGem1975 · 21/11/2023 13:35

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 21/11/2023 12:21

Because life is fucking expensive and the stuff is fairly decent. It’s on policymakers and leaders to make better conditions for everyone, including skint people, not on consumers

This.

I don't shop on them because when I have tried them it's been really low-quality, and while I don't mind cheap, they were pretty ill-fitting clothes and I can afford slightly better, but if I couldn't, I'd definitely shop there still. Needs must.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 21/11/2023 13:31

HomeschoolMum88 · 21/11/2023 12:40

I wear dresses from Shein because they fit, are actually very nice (if you know how to choose well) and I actually get quite a few compliments.

I can believe that you do, but it may be because the designs are stolen from smaller firms that can't do anything about it.

I don't want to lecture anyone. I know my own purchasing habits aren't perfect, I love clothes too and unlike OP, it's not beyond my wit to figure out why people like Shein. And it definitely isn't alone in its failings. But it really is one of the more egregious fast-fashion-from-China operations, in part because it's so ubiquitous and enormous, and even by the standards of that industry it is particularly bad. Have a read here https://ethically-dressed.com/6-reasons-you-should-never-shop-at-shein/

I know Vinted etc isn't perfect either, but if you're ("you" as in, anyone reading this) only paying a few quid anyway, please consider second hand purchasing if you're on a budget or buying for children. Or if you can spend high street prices, maybe even consider finding a local dressmaker and getting stuff made? It is very often not as expensive as you might expect and it will be unique and tailored to fit you, rather than mass produced.

6 Reasons You Should Never Shop At Shein - Ethically Dressed

With the extremely low prices and bad quality clothes, Shein is one of the most harmful brands I've ever come across. The fashion industry is the second largest polluter in the world, and Shein is currently the biggest fast fashion retailer. They contr...

https://ethically-dressed.com/6-reasons-you-should-never-shop-at-shein

Mountainhowl · 21/11/2023 13:23

DogInATent · 21/11/2023 13:04

Society is more at risk from people that don't pay any attention to the news than it is to anyone buying tat from Chinese online retailers.

I try to keep up with UK news, enough to make an informed decision when the elections come around. But I generally don't get too involved in world politics because there's often a lot of history involved which I'm not fully aware of (like the situation in Gaza) so I read it if it comes up on my various feeds but I don't search it out or spend hours looking into it. I just thought it was an interesting point but perhaps it's not relevant that they (supposedly, I'm not privy to Chinese government plans) intend to take control of Taiwan (sure that's been spoken about for years at this point with some posturing on both sides) which is supported by one of our allies

Frabbits · 21/11/2023 13:20

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 21/11/2023 12:21

Because life is fucking expensive and the stuff is fairly decent. It’s on policymakers and leaders to make better conditions for everyone, including skint people, not on consumers

Utter nonsense.

DogInATent · 21/11/2023 13:04

Mountainhowl · 21/11/2023 12:13

He can't stand trump 😂 we're both somewhat left leaning, but I'm not sure what news sites he reads it's just the ones that pop up on his phone we don't watch news on the TV or anything (we only have netflix and Amazon)

Isn't China's president now president for life? I read that on a Google search but only in the little blurb I didn't go too far into it. But surely that's far more than just industrial communism?

Society is more at risk from people that don't pay any attention to the news than it is to anyone buying tat from Chinese online retailers.

HomeschoolMum88 · 21/11/2023 12:40

I wear dresses from Shein because they fit, are actually very nice (if you know how to choose well) and I actually get quite a few compliments.

LaurieStrode · 21/11/2023 12:36

Frabbits · 21/11/2023 08:47

Obviously, because people value cheap shite over the massive ethical and environmental problems these sites present.

Most of the time people are buying stuff they don't need, so the argument that they have no choice but to use these sites is totally bogus.

Exactly.

So many people unable these days to distinguish between want and need.

tiredmama23 · 21/11/2023 12:23

Because I like the clothes on Shein and they're affordable 🤷‍♀️