Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:49

@Curiosity101 It is strange that the biggest contributors to their pension annually includes this chunk of parents of preschoolers - who have high costs, big mortgages etc...

... but the only rational choice for those years is... huge pension saving?

OP posts:
Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 15:49

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:42

’not great for the economy’ vs what is best for the baby 🤔

Scandinavian countries are widely thought to be the happiest in the world. Childcare is about £150 a month per child and you are thought of as a bit odd if you don’t use it in full, but then again they see the benefit of keeping all women in employment- esp those high earning taxpayers.

Shudacudawuda · 20/11/2023 15:48

The point is that once your kids hit school age you'll get the benefit of your high salary back. They're only in nursery for a short while, especially two at once unless they're twins.
I chose to leave a 4 year gap between my two because I couldn't afford two in nursery at once, we all have to make these kinds of decisions.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:48

But you aren’t being taxed- you are just not getting as much subsidised childcare.
There will still be plenty of high earners. Same argument as ‘if they cut bankers bonuses they will all leave the uk’- utter nonsense.

justasking111 · 20/11/2023 15:48

EasternStandard · 20/11/2023 15:45

That is very high. What does a nanny cost?

5k a month is 60k a year. Does a nanny cost more than this?

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 15:47

It does incentivise dropping hours, upping pensions contributions and generally not anything that's beneficial for society as a whole. Both me and DH are in that situation - we could be paying more income tax but we don't gain anything from our wage going up. Instead we're dropping down on hours and upping pensions contributions.

Why would I work more hours of I'm not going to get paid for it. The system effectively causes me to artificially stagnate how much tax I pay. I will then up my hours back to full time and drop my pensions contributions back to a normal rate once both my kids are out of full time childcare. When that happens I will be better off financially and I'll be paying more into the tax pot, it's a win win. Just daft that we're in this weird middle ground right now which encourages capping earnings.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:46

@Willyoujustbequiet what's the point in earning the extra £48k if you end up with £0 benefit though?

You need high earners to earn money to fund all these services. If they are taxed at 100% they're just going to stop bothering, as proven by @WutheringTights example above, cutting hours and so on because there's no incentive.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 20/11/2023 15:45

Wrongpostcode · 20/11/2023 15:35

OP, I'm totally with you here. Inevitably you've got the jealous people responding who think this is fine when it's lose/lose for everyone! My nursery bill for 2 under 3 is £5k a month. Going up by £350 pcm in Jan! The system is broken at every level

That is very high. What does a nanny cost?

arethereanyleftatall · 20/11/2023 15:45

I guess it would only probably be for a year or so?
So the decisions you have to make are the same as the people who pay to go to work because of their low salary vs childcare plus commute etc but decide it's worthwhile to not give up their career/keep up with their pension payments. They decide it's only for a short while whilst the children are small.
The system isn't perfect, but I think the government would get more back lash if they were subbing childcare for folk on £100k+. Tapering does make sense yes.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/11/2023 15:44

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 15:33

jeez, what a …!

free childcare ought to be universal. Up the higher rate income tax rate to cover this. We are trying to be a civilised society afterall.

No. There is no endless pot of money.

Measures to help must be targeted to those most in need. Those more able to pay should.

AgaMM · 20/11/2023 15:44

It’s always been implied that the additional hours from 9 months will only be for those who are entitled to the 30 hours at 3 plus.

Are you also saying that the universal 15 hours at 3 plus, regardless of how much the parents earn, is being removed?

newusername2009 · 20/11/2023 15:44

Don’t forget that over £100k you also lose your tax free allowance so the loss is greater than you have calculated

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:43

Wrongpostcode · 20/11/2023 15:35

OP, I'm totally with you here. Inevitably you've got the jealous people responding who think this is fine when it's lose/lose for everyone! My nursery bill for 2 under 3 is £5k a month. Going up by £350 pcm in Jan! The system is broken at every level

Indeed.

£5k for two is awful - I think my current 'worst case' is £4,400 for two. Crazy sums.

Let's hope they at least keep the 15 hours at age 3.

OP posts:
Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:42

’not great for the economy’ vs what is best for the baby 🤔

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:40

Nor am I- I also was once a high earner with no family support who had to pay for childcare. That’s the reality of having children. I got 15 free hours and then had to part time. It’s a relatively short period of time and shoving babies and toddlers into full time daycare is not something that should either be encouraged or paid for by the tax payer.
I am sorry if that seems brutal but I think more honest conversations need to be had rather than telling women they can have it all. They can’t.

WutheringTights · 20/11/2023 15:40

It’s worse than 100% tax. Someone earning, say, £130k will be worse off (have less take home pay) than someone earning £99k.

I stayed part time (and salary sacrificed into my pension) for years to avoid this. I’m only going full time now that I don’t need much childcare because my kids are a bit older and I’m 100% remote, so can pop out and do the school run most days.

For me it’s been 5 years of being under employed to avoid working more hours for less money. Yeah, world’s smallest violin and all that, but it’s not great for the economy if parents make perfectly sensible decisions to work less because it means that they’ll actually earn more that way.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:40

The 100% rate isn't being overplayed.

The comparison is between people with nursery aged children, not people with nursery aged children vs. someone with no kids.

A worker earning £99k and a worker earning £148k have the same take home pay, due to the loss of childcare support.

Calling it a loss of benefits or a tax is neither here nor there - the issue is that you can earn the best part of £50k more than someone else and be not better off due to the governments ill-thought out childcare policies.

OP posts:
ruby1957 · 20/11/2023 15:36

aswarmofmidges · 20/11/2023 15:15

So essentially means testing rather than handing out freebies - sounds reasonable

I think the 100% tax rate is being overplayed. The extra costs are not a tax - they are a removal of benefits. Childless workers do not get this 'tax' as they do not benefit from the 'benefit' of 'free' hours etc.
Childcare costs are for a finite time - they drop when the child is in school and eventually disappear.
Given that only 4% of workers earn over £100k pa (govt figures) there seems to be an inordinate number on MN

I am not jealous !

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:35

It’s not 100% tax. You just aren’t getting a tax relief to pay your child care. If you didn’t have childcare costs you would still have the earnings 🤔

Wrongpostcode · 20/11/2023 15:35

OP, I'm totally with you here. Inevitably you've got the jealous people responding who think this is fine when it's lose/lose for everyone! My nursery bill for 2 under 3 is £5k a month. Going up by £350 pcm in Jan! The system is broken at every level

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:34

Why should it be universal? Having two children so close together is a lifestyle choice. There are many many things that income tax could be used on. Endless free childcare isn’t one of them- especially for high earners.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:34

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:30

so it is only the 30 hours cut. When I had my children no one got this. Suck it up. You are still getting 15 free hours.

'Suck it up'.

It's 100% tax on £48,000 of earnings. No one in their right mind is going to accept that without complaint, it's obscene.

And no, those earning >£100k will not be eligible for any free hours for under 3s.

OP posts:
ilovepuppies2019 · 20/11/2023 15:33

GlassboatSailor · 20/11/2023 15:19

I don't think it's about the means testing, it's the cliff-edge nature of it.

Further the fact that two parents each earning £99k would be eligible for an incredibly huge amount more free childcare (and tax free) then one single parent earning £100k, even though that one parent would be taking home less in the first place as well.

Fully agree. It blows my mind that everything is assessed on an individual basis rather than a household income. It penalised single parents and sends a message that every kid should really come from a two parent home so those families 'doing it right' are rewarded. It's ridiculous that a single parent earning 101 could receive vastly less free hours and tax advantages than a couple earning 199. I believe that the child benefit is assessed similarly. Single parents already face big obstacles and limited childcare help, let's support them!

PuttingDownRoots · 20/11/2023 15:33

Unless you have twins etc, having two children in nursery at a time is a choice. I would agree with you that fir one child (or multiples) at a time it should be universal. But not choosing to have two close together

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 15:33

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:30

so it is only the 30 hours cut. When I had my children no one got this. Suck it up. You are still getting 15 free hours.

jeez, what a …!

free childcare ought to be universal. Up the higher rate income tax rate to cover this. We are trying to be a civilised society afterall.