Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
waitholdup · 20/11/2023 16:10

whatsappdoc · 20/11/2023 16:09

I don't understand why it's women's careers that are being put on hold etc. In a two parent family it should be equal

Because women put up with it, I didn't - my DH was the househusband, but even if he didnt want to be the SAHP, we would have got childcare (and we did when they were younger)

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 16:10

@MigGirl Thing is I've probably got 2 choices.

If I receive a promo or pay rise taking me above £100k

  1. I can either accept it (and actually genuinely have less money that I had before)
  2. Put a flexible working request in to drop to 9/10 of my working hours and up my pensions contributions.

That way rather than getting a promotion/pay rise and paying more tax. I effectively keep my wage the same, increase my pension pot and take 1 day off per fortnight. My pay rise/promotion is still in place, I've just artificially temporarily capped my earnings cause I'd rather have 1 day off per fortnight and a better pension pot than genuinely literally take home less money than when I was earning below £100k

Once the kids are out of full time childcare you go back up to full time and drop pensions contributions. So you haven't hampered career progression but you have been able to benefit from that progression rather than being penalised for it.

I think we worked out we needed to earn £124k in our particular situation before we'd break even. Anything from £100k-£124k actually means less money than if we were earning £99.9k. Which is fine, I'll enjoy my extra day off every fortnight and (hopefully) a better pension. But it doesn't make financial sense for the government, they should be incentivising me to work more and pay more tax.

waitholdup · 20/11/2023 16:09

You are not being taxed at 100%+ you are no longer recieving something cheaper - you are not forced to have children, or put them in childcare - this is a consequence of your life.

For two children therefore:
Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm
This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

This is you paying for your own children

Can I have a tax discount on my mortgage? I need somewhere to live.

whatsappdoc · 20/11/2023 16:09

I don't understand why it's women's careers that are being put on hold etc. In a two parent family it should be equal

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:09

on the flip side of this argument- if it is acceptable for women earning over 100k to get childcare subsidised, is it ok for the poorest women to have multiple babies funded by the welfare state? On the basis that their children ‘need’ a sibling or they simply want one?

Petercrouchslegs · 20/11/2023 16:09

It's a difference in basic beliefs. I think if I earn 4 times the average wage I'll pay for my own childcare. You don't. No point in arguing back and forth. There can never be a conclusion. It's a difference in attitude and values.

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:08

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:07

@Robinnuts Not only can women in the 5th largest economy in the world not afford to have babies, but women earning in the top 5% are expected to 'cut their cloth' and not have two in a 5 year period as its an extravagant lifestyle choice.

Simultaneously however, they are insanely wealthy and shouldn't need any kind of help funding their childcare.

That these two statements conflict is... fine, apparently.

My kids are well out of nursery but I atill think the state of childcare in this country is medieval

EatYourVegetables · 20/11/2023 16:07

£148K salary is obscene. Don’t try to tell
me you work 10 times as hard as the nursery lady who wipes your child’s bum.

And don’t talk to me about how hard you had to work to get there and how educated you are, I have a PhD.

If you’re earning £148 and chose to procreate, you should not expect to cover your procreation costs by from taxpayer’s money that your nursery nurse, your cleaner, your gardener and I have contributed to.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:07

As I said above telling women they can have it all is a lie. You can’t. Something has to give.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:07

@Robinnuts Not only can women in the 5th largest economy in the world not afford to have babies, but women earning in the top 5% are expected to 'cut their cloth' and not have two in a 5 year period as its an extravagant lifestyle choice.

Simultaneously however, they are insanely wealthy and shouldn't need any kind of help funding their childcare.

That these two statements conflict is... fine, apparently.

OP posts:
whatsappdoc · 20/11/2023 16:05

We have too low a starting rate of tax to sustain all these benefits. I started work in the 70s when lowest tax was 30% and the highest I believe was an eye-watering 110%. A better system might be a childcare loan along the same rules as a student loan. You pay back 9% when earning over a threshold. Each child gets a max of eg 10k pa up until statutory school starting age.

Pointlessuser · 20/11/2023 16:05

It’s a quirk in the system but it’s only for 2 years, why would anyone be so shortsighted to not accept a promotion that would pay more into a pension, have a better long term financial position for the sake of 2 years hardship is beyond me, you can also manipulate the figures by paying more into a pension, again benefitting you.

zendeveloper · 20/11/2023 16:03

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:34

Why should it be universal? Having two children so close together is a lifestyle choice. There are many many things that income tax could be used on. Endless free childcare isn’t one of them- especially for high earners.

Well, in many cases it is a balancing act between the career and children. Many professional women delay having children until they are well established (and earning that £100K+), and then have no other biological option but to have the children close together.
If you are becoming a consultant with some resemblance of a work-life balance only at 35, for example, it is unrealistic to expect to have children with a 10 year gap after that.
A lifestyle choice, yes. But you can argue that education and employment are also "lifestyle choices" for women.

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:03

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:01

Yes- and it is a lifestyle choice to be in this position. As some else said- many of us have had to either make career choices to accommodate having children close together, delay having a second, or not having any more babies at all as can’t afford it. There isn’t an infinite amount of money available to fund the childcare costs of high earners so they can keep all of their 5k a month.

Don’t you think it’s appalling that people ‘can’t afford’ to have babies in this - the 5th largest economy in the world? Don’t you think that ought to change? Don’t you think that it would be nice for children to have siblings of a similar age they can play with?

YireosDodeAver · 20/11/2023 16:02

I think you may be massively overestimating the number of parents of 2 preschoolers who earn at that level.

I get that if you live in london and mainly associate with other wealthy mums of preschoolers then it may feel like a big problem.

The vast majority of people with preschool kids earn less than £30k. All the benefits are for them

The only reason people are getting these benefits at all with incomes higher than £30k ish is because there's a huge problem with any means-tested benefits going unclaimed by the poorest and most vulnerable, and if you make them means tested kids will die, so you make them universal but they can be clawed back through idenfying the wealthiest via the tax system so that's a good thing. It's right that there should be a cut off. It's right that it should be quite high. If you think it is too low you have absolutely no idea how privileged you are.

I suggest you structure your work life balance by adjusting your hours, or bump up your pension contributions, to keep your income under £100k for a couple of years, and count your blessings.

DappledOliveGroves · 20/11/2023 16:02

123sunshine · 20/11/2023 15:55

You can play the system and make extra pension contributions to bring your net pay down to below the £100k figure. As you also start to loose you personal allowance anyway after £100k of earnings thats another reason to make a larger pension contribution.

You can absolutely play the system and I'm almost at the threshold of having to get concerned, but then I'm in a position where I salary sacrifice 14% of my salary for my pension. But this doesn't benefit society (just means perhaps I can take more holidays when I'm retired).

It's a ridiculous system, where I'm concerned to work harder, to advance my career, because of the very real financial penalties I'd suffer if I went too far above the threshold. Surely we want to live in a society that incentives people to go up the career ladder, rather than stay at a particular rung.

Further, the idea that someone with a £100k salary is somehow living a life of riley is laughable. We live in a 3-bed mid-terrace with a £1200 per month mortgage. Childcare is £1300 per month. We shop at Aldi and I buy clothes from the charity shop. Yes, we're lucky that we can put some savings into our daughter's account each month and we have a cleaner. But the idea that we live in luxury is laughable.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:01

Yes- and it is a lifestyle choice to be in this position. As some else said- many of us have had to either make career choices to accommodate having children close together, delay having a second, or not having any more babies at all as can’t afford it. There isn’t an infinite amount of money available to fund the childcare costs of high earners so they can keep all of their 5k a month.

nutbrownhare15 · 20/11/2023 16:00

As someone earning considerably less I just can't care about this. I don't see why childcare should be subsidised at that level of earnings. You can put money into your pension to offset it. It won't be forever.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:58

@MigGirl

"I'm not saying that childcare shouldn't be more affordable. But should higher earns really have it? And weather if feels like it or not £100k is a higher earner"

Sure, it is a good salary - but childcare costs are obscene and eat up a lot of it.

A poster above says they are paying £5k for two under 3s (presumably in London). This is 100% of a £100k income's take home pay, if they have a student loan.

And - no one is asking for you 'to feel sorry for them' - I'm pointing out that ludicrous cliff edge in the tax system which means people are taxed at crazy rates. You shouldn't have had to quit your job because you couldn't afford childcare, but nor should a high earner be cutting hours or being taxed at 100% for the simple reason they require childcare.

OP posts:
MigGirl · 20/11/2023 15:58

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:46

@Willyoujustbequiet what's the point in earning the extra £48k if you end up with £0 benefit though?

You need high earners to earn money to fund all these services. If they are taxed at 100% they're just going to stop bothering, as proven by @WutheringTights example above, cutting hours and so on because there's no incentive.

The point of earning the extra £48k would be that once your child/children are in school and your not paying so much childcare then you will be earning more and your salary is more likely to go up more over the long term.

I'm sorry I find it hard to feel sorry for higher earns like you when people like me either gave up work as wouldn't have been able to afford child care or women are effectively working for nothing at all as it costs them so much, but are doing it to stay on the career ladder.

123sunshine · 20/11/2023 15:55

You can play the system and make extra pension contributions to bring your net pay down to below the £100k figure. As you also start to loose you personal allowance anyway after £100k of earnings thats another reason to make a larger pension contribution.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:55

Sweden gives 480 paid leave when you have a baby. The mother is at home much longer. They also pay a lot more tax in Sweden to fund this.

bombastix · 20/11/2023 15:51

Yes it is stupid in the extreme

arethereanyleftatall · 20/11/2023 15:51

'It's 100% tax on £48,000 of earnings. No one in their right mind is going to accept that without complaint, it's obscene.'

Another way of looking at it, is that a salary of £148k is obscene. No one should be getting paid 10x more than a carer or nursery worker of any of those other hard hard jobs that are paid peanuts. My exhusband, for all his faults, always felt his salary was ridiculous for doing a job he loved. Don't think of it as a salary of £150k for which you end up with £75k of but rather think of it as a salary of £75k. Or whatever the numbers are. Just reframe it. You haven't 'lost' £75k.

MigGirl · 20/11/2023 15:51

But many parents with slight older children never got this benefit anyway. Mine are both high school now and you only got free 15hours at 3 years.

I'm not saying that childcare shouldn't be more affordable. But should higher earns really have it? And weather if feels like it or not £100k is a higher earner. Not very many people on are such a high salary.

And I know it feels unfair when a household can earn more then a single parent. But there has to be a cut off somewhere. To be honest I felt similar when I wasn't earning yet we couldn't use my tax free allowance, (I know they changed that but.only after I went back to work). The problem with making systems to complicated to admister is they then end up.costing more to run.