Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:32

How much tax do you think someone earning £100k ought to pay? What’s a fair amount?

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:31

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:29

Totally agree OP. The predictable responses are out in force which could be cut and pasted from any thread which discusses an issue for higher earners. Because they're not allowed to complain. MN is such a race to the bottom it's unbelievable.

You have absolutely no idea of my earnings or the earnings of any other person on this thread. I simply said that I found the post to be tone deaf. Check yourself before you post.

SauronsArsehole · 20/11/2023 16:30

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:15

Again, you have managed to entirely miss the point.

In the scenario I am better off earning £99k, vs earning any other sum up to £148.

Earn £130k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

Earn £140k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

This incentivises higher earners to earn less money, making it a crap piece of policy.

So you’re bitching that you’ll have to pay full fees for 3 years?

you’re angry that you’ll be earning 150k a year and 50k will go to nursery fees etc

you’re angry that once your kids reach school age you’ll be significantly better off. That suddenly you’ll get a decent chunk of disposable income Whereas a worker on £22k who gets 30 free hours and won’t get a sudden increase in disposable income when their kid reaches school age.

oh love.

AluckyEllie · 20/11/2023 16:29

It’s annoying that it’s not a combined income. My husband earns 120k and I earn 30k as an nhs nurse (part time-0.6) so 150k total. We could both earn 95k and be in such a better position. I don’t have the capacity at the moment to earn much more so he has to keep trying to increase his income and we get penalised at every turn it seems.

We have one child in nursery and another coming, live in a high price area of the country but can’t move due to caring for elderly parents as well. We are happy to pay high tax as we both have the health and education to work full time in good jobs but it does feel like there isn’t much reward for pushing further.

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:29

Totally agree OP. The predictable responses are out in force which could be cut and pasted from any thread which discusses an issue for higher earners. Because they're not allowed to complain. MN is such a race to the bottom it's unbelievable.

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:28

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:23

@SiousieSoo

"It is about 'beliefs' insofar as it amounts to someone selectively demonstrating their perceived slight at this one element of 'inequality' in contrast to the wide ranging and devastating impact that some policies have on very vulnerable members of society though. "

Where have I commented on this issues importance vs other policies impacting other groups?

No need for the attitude. It's an issue many posters are impacted by, as you can see by those agreeing with me. It's a forum, people discuss things on it. Yes it is a current issue for me deciding if I can cope with the number of hours and sacrifices required to make a larger salary, if I will not receive any financial benefit from it.

If it does not interest you, I advise you just avoid the topic and focus on one of the many, many threads on different subjects.

I am just finding your outrage about this to be quite tone deaf to be honest.

Night409 · 20/11/2023 16:28

If I had this ‘problem’ I’d simply drop my hours.

High income + more free time = perfect life.

TheCompactPussycat · 20/11/2023 16:27

But it doesn't make financial sense for the government, they should be incentivising me to work more and pay more tax.

This is nonsensical.

If higher earners (over £100K) want the government to subsidise their childcare so they are not paying what is effectively a 100% tax, then the government will be getting less money, not more because their increased taxes will be outweighed by the increased subsidies.

MigGirl · 20/11/2023 16:26

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:15

Again, you have managed to entirely miss the point.

In the scenario I am better off earning £99k, vs earning any other sum up to £148.

Earn £130k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

Earn £140k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

This incentivises higher earners to earn less money, making it a crap piece of policy.

OP but this reduction in income is only for a short period of time, when you need less or no childcare you will have earned more (put more in your pension). You will be way better off, just like those women who are effectively not earning good anything while paying for early years childcare.

There always has to be a cut off somewhere. The government can't afford to.pay for everyone and doing it a a straight cutoff makes it cheaper to administer.

EatYourVegetables · 20/11/2023 16:23

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:18

The nuances of tax policy and what ought to be done to maximise tax take for this country seems to be beyond the understanding of most of the people commenting here, who cannot see beyond their jealousy. Sad.

Oh spare me. One word sentences like “Sad.” make you sound like Donald Trump.

You want nuance? Here: how about everyone earning over £80K starts voluntarily paying progressively more tax (or giving to charity), so that once they hit the £100K it’s not a cliff edge. Fairer? Definitely. Fixes the OP’s problem? 100%. Will she be happy? Absolutely fucking not.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:23

@SiousieSoo

"It is about 'beliefs' insofar as it amounts to someone selectively demonstrating their perceived slight at this one element of 'inequality' in contrast to the wide ranging and devastating impact that some policies have on very vulnerable members of society though. "

Where have I commented on this issues importance vs other policies impacting other groups?

No need for the attitude. It's an issue many posters are impacted by, as you can see by those agreeing with me. It's a forum, people discuss things on it. Yes it is a current issue for me deciding if I can cope with the number of hours and sacrifices required to make a larger salary, if I will not receive any financial benefit from it.

If it does not interest you, I advise you just avoid the topic and focus on one of the many, many threads on different subjects.

OP posts:
Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:23

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/11/2023 16:21

That's for those individuals to decide.

I want my taxes to go to the most vulnerable not the top earners given the state we are in.

But if you let the top earners wear more they will pay more tax that will go to the poorest in society, instead of it being squirrelled away in their pensions.

casuarinatree · 20/11/2023 16:23

So many people on this thread not getting the point.

zendeveloper · 20/11/2023 16:22

This thread is quite a sad read. Such a dog eat dog, or rather bitch eat bitch atmosphere.

I am actually pretty sure if a problem like that was a "male" (for the lack of a better word) problem, and was discussed on one of forums close to "manosphere", with all the toxicity that exists there on many other topics, the unfairness of the situation would have been understood and acknowledged. And the general consensus would be "fair play to you bro, yes that sucks and completely illogical, needs to be fixed".

But here, just wow. A woman DARES to have a high paying career and young children. Who does she think she is! Does she think she's better than a nursery worker! Is she above wiping bums?! Did she think of giving all her extra money to the poor! Why did not she plan her children better! My eyes bleed.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/11/2023 16:21

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:46

@Willyoujustbequiet what's the point in earning the extra £48k if you end up with £0 benefit though?

You need high earners to earn money to fund all these services. If they are taxed at 100% they're just going to stop bothering, as proven by @WutheringTights example above, cutting hours and so on because there's no incentive.

That's for those individuals to decide.

I want my taxes to go to the most vulnerable not the top earners given the state we are in.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/11/2023 16:20

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:46

@Willyoujustbequiet what's the point in earning the extra £48k if you end up with £0 benefit though?

You need high earners to earn money to fund all these services. If they are taxed at 100% they're just going to stop bothering, as proven by @WutheringTights example above, cutting hours and so on because there's no incentive.

That's for those individuals to decide.

I want my taxes to go to the most vulnerable not the top earners given the state we are in.

mindandsensespurified · 20/11/2023 16:20

I agree with you OP, it's absolutely barmy. I think a lot of PPs are missing the point - you're not asking for sympathy for those earning over £100k, you're pointing out that high earners are likely to reduce their hours/increase pension contributions to avoid this ridiculous cliff edge - and that this is bad for the economy, given that those high earners will then pay less tax. People saying that they should just suck it up...why would they? Who wants to work for free?

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:18

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:15

Again, you have managed to entirely miss the point.

In the scenario I am better off earning £99k, vs earning any other sum up to £148.

Earn £130k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

Earn £140k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

This incentivises higher earners to earn less money, making it a crap piece of policy.

The nuances of tax policy and what ought to be done to maximise tax take for this country seems to be beyond the understanding of most of the people commenting here, who cannot see beyond their jealousy. Sad.

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:18

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:13

It's not a 'difference in basic beliefs'.

It's a challenge to the 'cliff edge' created by loss of free hours and tax free childcare at £100k.

If you earned £130k, you would have less money in your pocket per month vs earning £90k.

It's not about 'beliefs', it's about maths.

It is about 'beliefs' insofar as it amounts to someone selectively demonstrating their perceived slight at this one element of 'inequality' in contrast to the wide ranging and devastating impact that some policies have on very vulnerable members of society though.

How many threads are you going to create on this subject? Do you actually care about anything else? Morevoer why do you appear to expect everyone else to be as up in arms about it as you are?

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:15

waitholdup · 20/11/2023 16:09

You are not being taxed at 100%+ you are no longer recieving something cheaper - you are not forced to have children, or put them in childcare - this is a consequence of your life.

For two children therefore:
Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm
This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

This is you paying for your own children

Can I have a tax discount on my mortgage? I need somewhere to live.

Again, you have managed to entirely miss the point.

In the scenario I am better off earning £99k, vs earning any other sum up to £148.

Earn £130k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

Earn £140k? Less in my pocket than if I earn £99k.

This incentivises higher earners to earn less money, making it a crap piece of policy.

OP posts:
SauronsArsehole · 20/11/2023 16:15

ruby1957 · 20/11/2023 15:36

I think the 100% tax rate is being overplayed. The extra costs are not a tax - they are a removal of benefits. Childless workers do not get this 'tax' as they do not benefit from the 'benefit' of 'free' hours etc.
Childcare costs are for a finite time - they drop when the child is in school and eventually disappear.
Given that only 4% of workers earn over £100k pa (govt figures) there seems to be an inordinate number on MN

I am not jealous !

Edited

Quite! A minority of very privileged people having to tighten their budgets just like those earning 30k a year after choosing to have children.

And agreed it’s not a tax! It’s a cost that comes with having children for just a couple of years.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:13

Petercrouchslegs · 20/11/2023 16:09

It's a difference in basic beliefs. I think if I earn 4 times the average wage I'll pay for my own childcare. You don't. No point in arguing back and forth. There can never be a conclusion. It's a difference in attitude and values.

It's not a 'difference in basic beliefs'.

It's a challenge to the 'cliff edge' created by loss of free hours and tax free childcare at £100k.

If you earned £130k, you would have less money in your pocket per month vs earning £90k.

It's not about 'beliefs', it's about maths.

OP posts:
crispcreambun · 20/11/2023 16:13

Spare me. It's not a fucking 100% tax rate. Stop trying to frame it that way when it isn't. You are simply being expected to pay for the choice YOU made instead of having the rest of us subsidise your wealthy lifestyle.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 16:13

There's a hell of a lot more whinging by rich people who have 'obscene' childcare costs and 'massive' mortgages than there is by poorer people who can barely afford to put food on the table for their families.

I'm a childminder, I'm not subsidising your childcare bills each month when you earn £100k and I earn nothing like that.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:11

EatYourVegetables · 20/11/2023 16:07

£148K salary is obscene. Don’t try to tell
me you work 10 times as hard as the nursery lady who wipes your child’s bum.

And don’t talk to me about how hard you had to work to get there and how educated you are, I have a PhD.

If you’re earning £148 and chose to procreate, you should not expect to cover your procreation costs by from taxpayer’s money that your nursery nurse, your cleaner, your gardener and I have contributed to.

I have said above that I don't think higher earners work harder than anyone else. Their high salaries are typically because they have in-demand skills, or are good at generating income for the companies they work for.

You are missing the point anyway - the point is that you need to earn £148k to offset the loss of childcare support at £100k. It's a 100% effective tax rate - surely this is unfair, we do not apply a tax rate of this sort anywhere else in our tax system.

I haven't said anything about my personal income.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread