Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
Doublerainbow23 · 20/11/2023 16:54

These threads always result in a lot of jealousy from those who think any higher earners are overpaid/don't deserve it/shouldn't ever complain about anything.

OP you're pointing out a very justified criticism of a badly set up and unfair system (and I'm neither a higher earner or someone with childcare costs).

GasDrivenNun · 20/11/2023 16:54

YireosDodeAver · 20/11/2023 16:02

I think you may be massively overestimating the number of parents of 2 preschoolers who earn at that level.

I get that if you live in london and mainly associate with other wealthy mums of preschoolers then it may feel like a big problem.

The vast majority of people with preschool kids earn less than £30k. All the benefits are for them

The only reason people are getting these benefits at all with incomes higher than £30k ish is because there's a huge problem with any means-tested benefits going unclaimed by the poorest and most vulnerable, and if you make them means tested kids will die, so you make them universal but they can be clawed back through idenfying the wealthiest via the tax system so that's a good thing. It's right that there should be a cut off. It's right that it should be quite high. If you think it is too low you have absolutely no idea how privileged you are.

I suggest you structure your work life balance by adjusting your hours, or bump up your pension contributions, to keep your income under £100k for a couple of years, and count your blessings.

This ^^^

Herecomestreble1 · 20/11/2023 16:53

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:30

so it is only the 30 hours cut. When I had my children no one got this. Suck it up. You are still getting 15 free hours.

Guys, this person didn't get any help, therefore we don't deserve any either. I hope that's cleared things up for everyone.

HermioneWeasley · 20/11/2023 16:53

randomsabreuse · 20/11/2023 16:48

The problem isn't so much the individuals who will artificially cap their earning as the societal impacts of potentially high earning, hard working people needing to work less to keep their effective take home the same.

The classic example in this tax bracket is hospital consultants, who already showed that they would prefer not to take overtime shifts for a negative take home pay... Not great for society really...

Yes, also GPs and dentists cutting their hours because of the impact of the removal of personal allowance over £100k

they’re not pleading poverty, they’re saying it not worth time away from their family to earn (something like) 30p in each £1. And that’s fair enough

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:52

Charlie2121 · 20/11/2023 16:42

There are some very predictable responses on this thread.

I found myself in this position. The point that most appear to be missing is that the solution is nearly always to work less for a period of time and thereby pay less tax. That helps nobody.

I timed my return to work and my child starting at nursery such that I only earnt £99k in the first tax year after maternity leave as I didn't work a full year. That meant the Treasury missed out on significant additional tax from me that I would normally have paid.

It is not about whether higher earners need supporting with childcare costs it is whether the system disincentivises them to work more. If I had my child when I was younger and earning far less I would never have been in a position to turn down any work. As it was I took longer off because I could afford to but that results in less tax being paid to help support others.

My average tax bill is 80k + NI. I think I more than pay my fair share.

We get it.. We just dont share the incredulity: there are so many inequalities in life that this one is understandably very low on the pecking order for many people. It is the notion that we are all expected to share in the collective outrage that is quite bizarre to me, and which led to my observation that the post is quite tone deaf. It is still a perfectly valid thing to post about, as is my response.

GasDrivenNun · 20/11/2023 16:51

Shudacudawuda · 20/11/2023 15:48

The point is that once your kids hit school age you'll get the benefit of your high salary back. They're only in nursery for a short while, especially two at once unless they're twins.
I chose to leave a 4 year gap between my two because I couldn't afford two in nursery at once, we all have to make these kinds of decisions.

Edited

We did exactly this. Also meant we didn't have 2 at university at the same time.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:49

Hercisback · 20/11/2023 16:46

The PPs balling about the £1200 mortgage and £1k nursery bill on £100k is ridiculous. Try the same mortgage and nursery on £50k, cus that's what lots do.

Just for some context, two children in nursery in London with no free hours etc is going to be more like... £4k a month.

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 20/11/2023 16:48

The problem isn't so much the individuals who will artificially cap their earning as the societal impacts of potentially high earning, hard working people needing to work less to keep their effective take home the same.

The classic example in this tax bracket is hospital consultants, who already showed that they would prefer not to take overtime shifts for a negative take home pay... Not great for society really...

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:46

Ascubudr · 20/11/2023 16:44

Raise the higher rate of income tax ? to what ? Even without the childcare complications the marginal tax rate between 100-125K is 60%. 45% thereafter with no personal allowance. Just how much do you think it's reasonable to ask people to pay ?

Agree. We need to allow high earners to keep the tax free band but increase the higher rate accordingly. These cliff edge rates help no one.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:46

Iamblocked2 · 20/11/2023 16:45

what is it with the recent influx of posts from folks earning 6 figure salaries and pleasing poverty?

No one is 'pleading poverty'.

The issue is that the loss of childcare benefits + personal allowance removal creates a >100% tax rate for some people.

Pointing out that this is absurd is not 'pleading poverty'.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 20/11/2023 16:46

The PPs balling about the £1200 mortgage and £1k nursery bill on £100k is ridiculous. Try the same mortgage and nursery on £50k, cus that's what lots do.

anicecuppateaa · 20/11/2023 16:45

The responses here are predictable but frustrating. I have 3 in childcare in the South East and it costs a fortune. More than double the cost of our mortgage. We live in a modest 3 bed semi, have been abroad once in the last 4 years yet get slated on threads like this.

I think the government should incentivise women back into the workplace. I am working PT and avoiding going to promotions to avoid going over the 100k threshold and losing 30 funded hours.

Iamblocked2 · 20/11/2023 16:45

what is it with the recent influx of posts from folks earning 6 figure salaries and pleasing poverty?

Ascubudr · 20/11/2023 16:44

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 15:33

jeez, what a …!

free childcare ought to be universal. Up the higher rate income tax rate to cover this. We are trying to be a civilised society afterall.

Raise the higher rate of income tax ? to what ? Even without the childcare complications the marginal tax rate between 100-125K is 60%. 45% thereafter with no personal allowance. Just how much do you think it's reasonable to ask people to pay ?

SaltyGod · 20/11/2023 16:44

I’m also a high tax payer at over £100k, and honestly no one should be subsidising my child care. There has to be a cut off, and this is it.

I understand the OPs point but it’s an unfortunate nuance of the system. There will always be winners and losers, time with you benefit and time when you don’t.

Is it frustrating, sure. Is it a temporary problem for the OP, sure. Can she take steps to potentially mitigate, of course.

There are bigger problems I’d like to see the gov tackle than this tbh.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 16:44

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:39

It's not really the same thing. Support for childcare costs are means tested (one of the points of the post) but education and health aren't. A lot of people go private because they're so used to forking out £1000s for childcare that it's a natural progression. And if I go private for school then I expect I'm paying for a far better 'service'. There is no better service option for me paying more for nursery fees. It's the same nursery.

Well with the expansion of the free (funded) hours, there will be a 2- tier service in the childcare sector. It's on its knees! As I said above, nurseries and childminders cannot afford to subsidise this. Those offering to pay privately will get more choice, better selection, variety, flexibility etc. You're very naive if you think it will be equal and like for like.

SovietSpy · 20/11/2023 16:42

zendeveloper · 20/11/2023 16:22

This thread is quite a sad read. Such a dog eat dog, or rather bitch eat bitch atmosphere.

I am actually pretty sure if a problem like that was a "male" (for the lack of a better word) problem, and was discussed on one of forums close to "manosphere", with all the toxicity that exists there on many other topics, the unfairness of the situation would have been understood and acknowledged. And the general consensus would be "fair play to you bro, yes that sucks and completely illogical, needs to be fixed".

But here, just wow. A woman DARES to have a high paying career and young children. Who does she think she is! Does she think she's better than a nursery worker! Is she above wiping bums?! Did she think of giving all her extra money to the poor! Why did not she plan her children better! My eyes bleed.

Exactly my thoughts. It’s a race to the bottom mentality that’s so endemic in British culture now. Hatred of anyone doing well and how dare anyone be successful and get some help from the state. Yet many countries who posters on MN admire like Norway and Sweden have progressive family policies that benefit all workers because they recognise that universal childcare helps keep people in work and earning which also helps the economy and tax receipts.

Theres a stat like nearly 50% of British adults pay no income tax. Which means the same group of workers are expected to largely subsidise everyone else’s childcare, pensions, etc but get zero help to themselves to keep them in the jobs that actually provide the taxes! And we wonder why so many women step out of the workplace or take lower paid jobs. It’s lack of affordable childcare every time.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/11/2023 16:42

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 16:23

But if you let the top earners wear more they will pay more tax that will go to the poorest in society, instead of it being squirrelled away in their pensions.

Many will use the tools at their disposal to pay as little as possible.

Charlie2121 · 20/11/2023 16:42

There are some very predictable responses on this thread.

I found myself in this position. The point that most appear to be missing is that the solution is nearly always to work less for a period of time and thereby pay less tax. That helps nobody.

I timed my return to work and my child starting at nursery such that I only earnt £99k in the first tax year after maternity leave as I didn't work a full year. That meant the Treasury missed out on significant additional tax from me that I would normally have paid.

It is not about whether higher earners need supporting with childcare costs it is whether the system disincentivises them to work more. If I had my child when I was younger and earning far less I would never have been in a position to turn down any work. As it was I took longer off because I could afford to but that results in less tax being paid to help support others.

My average tax bill is 80k + NI. I think I more than pay my fair share.

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:41

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:34

You have absolutely no idea of my earnings or the earnings of any other person on this thread. I simply said that I found the post to be tone deaf. Check yourself before you post

I don't earn anywhere close to £100k either. But I'm supportive of those who do and take an interest in things like this because of the job I do. The title of the post is quite clear so if you're triggered by higher earners, scroll on.

Who is 'triggered' I don't understand? Is it for you to decide if anyone is triggered? What does triggered mean in this context? I think people are capable of making up their own mind as to what they decide to read.

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:39

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 16:32

Its amazing how many of the high earners moaning about paying for childcare will suddenly find the money for private education, private health care etc when there are free options available then.

It's not really the same thing. Support for childcare costs are means tested (one of the points of the post) but education and health aren't. A lot of people go private because they're so used to forking out £1000s for childcare that it's a natural progression. And if I go private for school then I expect I'm paying for a far better 'service'. There is no better service option for me paying more for nursery fees. It's the same nursery.

zendeveloper · 20/11/2023 16:38

So disincentivising someone to take the pay rise that would have resulted in a tax income that equalled the benefit makes the government and the woman who declined the promotion worse off.
Let's be realistic. The promotion will just be given to a man if a woman declines it. Such a win for equality.

Sconehenge · 20/11/2023 16:35

People seem to be forgetting that the person earning £148k is paying around £64k in tax.

In the OPs example - the country earns around £19k additional tax income from the woman who gets the £48k pay rise from £100k to £148k. The high earner paying 45% tax isn’t just bludging off the government to get free childcare, their tax is literally over-paying for it.

So disincentivising someone to take the pay rise that would have resulted in a tax income that equalled the benefit makes the government and the woman who declined the promotion worse off.

Woman earns £99k and government gives child benefits of £18k - government down -£18k.

vs

Woman earns £148k, giving government extra £19k in tax and government gives child benefits to her - government is up +£1000 !

Heatherbell1978 · 20/11/2023 16:34

You have absolutely no idea of my earnings or the earnings of any other person on this thread. I simply said that I found the post to be tone deaf. Check yourself before you post

I don't earn anywhere close to £100k either. But I'm supportive of those who do and take an interest in things like this because of the job I do. The title of the post is quite clear so if you're triggered by higher earners, scroll on.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 16:32

Its amazing how many of the high earners moaning about paying for childcare will suddenly find the money for private education, private health care etc when there are free options available then.