Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
oilrig · 20/11/2023 17:18

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:33

If your childcare costs are that high you might need to consider not living in London/ taking a career break/ not having two children so close together. The kind of decisions loads of us have made- it isn’t up to everyone else to subsidise your choices so you can earn 100k 🙄

I agree with this.

QuiQuiKitty · 20/11/2023 17:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WrongSwanson · 20/11/2023 17:16

I definitely think better tapering is needed not a cliff edge. And £100k isn't an extravagantly high salary in London.

It's economically stupid to have any policy that pushes people to decide to work less /chuck everything into pensions etc.

I'm weighing up whether to drop a day a week or chuck a lot more money into my pension for similar reasons.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 17:16

But you don’t have to live somewhere hugely expensive. It is expensive due to over crowding and this isn’t going to change.

Syndulla · 20/11/2023 17:16

DH is salary sacrificing as he's on just over £100k and the tax system at this point just doesn't make any sense.

My kids are older primary so don't need a lot of childcare, other than holiday clubs. I'm not sure I expect other tax payers to fund our childcare though when we can afford to do so.

That being said, it's frustrating to know that all of this money is being paid in tax and we're not seeing much benefit from it at the moment.

Can't get a GP appointment.

Can't get an NHS dentist.

Police not interested in most crimes.

Kids' school doesn't have enough resources.

Local roads are full of pot holes.

So it's a little disheartening to see all that money go to the government each month.

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:15

@Janedoe82 lifestyle choices like 'having a roof over your head'?

OP posts:
Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:14

@SiousieSoo So you have no answer as to why its fair, you just don't care because it's about people who you consider to be better off than you.

I don't really think parents of small children should just unthinkingly accept this 'because'. It's quite clearly absurd.

OP posts:
Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 17:13

Again lifestyle choices

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:11

@Kitte321 I agree the income vs wealth issue isn't often talked about enough in these contexts.

Particularly when you consider high housing and childcare costs.

OP posts:
SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 17:10

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:01

@SiousieSoo

Why should someone earning £130k a year have less money than someone earning £99k a year, when both have made the 'lifestyle choice' to have two children?

What's the logic for the higher earner having less money per month after taxes and benefits, than a lower earner?

You are simply caught by a very blunt instrument that is the government's taxation system. It is the same issue with th child benefit threshold, you either have to suck it up given the relatively short number of years your children will be in nursery, or find ways to navigate it, as have been suggested above. There is no point in asking me for the logic, I did not set the policy. There are so many inequalities in life, I simply cannot get outraged by this one.

Baffledandalarmed · 20/11/2023 17:09

Sigh. Penalising the high earners again.

But you're a high earner so you're the devil incarnate, OP. Prepare to get a pasting about how you should be grateful and it's completely reasonable etc

Kitte321 · 20/11/2023 17:08

Completely agree that this is a hugely unfair, ludicrous taxation system. I earn over £100k when my bonus is added. I now salary sacrifice every penny I earn over to avoid the cliff edge.
I also work 4 days to minimise earnings and will until my youngest is at school.
I have no problem paying tax, I do begrudge working for nothing.
We really need to look at taxing wealth as opposed to just focusing all of the tax burden on ‘high earners’.

Dodgygeezer · 20/11/2023 17:07

That’s the point. It benefits everyone if the higher earner is not incentivised to put a significant chunk of cash in to their pension but rather pay tax on it to add to the pot for everyone. The benefit of the additional tax take in many cases exceeds the child care subsidy. The loss of personal allowance is already an absolute pisstake

App13 · 20/11/2023 17:07

I'm pretty heartbroken 😞

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 17:07

I can see why you don’t like it, but that doesn’t make it a badly designed policy.

Firstly (on your calculation of 18k a year in childcare benefits), it would only become a net gain for the taxpayer once the person starts earning about 140k. There will be many more people earning between 100k and 139k than 140k+, so the collective impact is likely to be a net loss to the taxpayer

Secondly, the point of the policy is to get people (mostly women, let’s be honest) into work, or working more hours, than they otherwise would. It’s a growth and productivity policy (also a political one, see below). It doesn’t make any real impact on growth and productivity whether you earn 99,999 or 132k (unless you choose to be part time to stay under the 100k barrier, but again you’d want to be sure that the number affected would be worth it - probably wouldn't at a cohort level)

Thirdly, it is politically unpalatable to subsidise very high earners for what is a short period of their working lives. Extending would likely have a net negative impact politically (Ie there are lots more people who will be pissed off than pleased)

So it's not a particularly badly designed policy, it’s just one you personally don’t benefit from.

Xenia · 20/11/2023 17:06

Very wrongly the UK moved from a we are all in together putting in and taking out welfare state of the kind Beveridge set up - much much higher benefits for out of work workers who had paid in NI than those who never did a day's work in their life. My uncle even despite being a doctor got a council house at one point in the 40s or 50s as you paid in and took out - universal, shoulder to shoulder - not one group paying masses of tax getting very little back and the other 75 just taking.

Then we lost child benefit ( I got it for my 5 back in the day but none of my grandchildren's parents get it. My parents didn't have to pay university fees but my children did (and I paid it for them). My father could even covenant money tax free to me when I started university to help pay my rent and make the minimum grant up to the maximum. All in it together.

taht has been chuipped back and back to a position where we have the highest tax burden in 70 years, £59k to £60k full time childcare costs for 2 children in London due to all kinds of reasons and a massively high tax state. it is a perfectly storm of incentives of these levels of earners to work less.

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 17:02

Because you are expecting the tax payer to pay for your high income. You have been told how to mitigate this by putting money into pension- which you will still have further down the line. 🙄

EatYourVegetables · 20/11/2023 17:02

StamppotAndGravy · 20/11/2023 16:57

But surely you care when you can't get a GP appointment or similar service because it only makes sense for such people to work 2 days a week? This group of people contribute the most significant proportion of tax take (much higher than the super wealthy for example) therefore encouraging them not to work or to emigrate directly hurts you because they fund your schools and NHS. Yes, maybe it's an obscene salary, but they pay a significant amount back. Would you rather pay 40% on the whole of your 30k salary?

https://www.prospects.ac.uk/job-profiles/general-practice-doctor#salary

General practice doctor job profile | Prospects.ac.uk

Discover what it takes to be a General practice doctor. Find out expected salary, working hours, qualifications and more.

https://www.prospects.ac.uk/job-profiles/general-practice-doctor#salary

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:01

@SiousieSoo

Why should someone earning £130k a year have less money than someone earning £99k a year, when both have made the 'lifestyle choice' to have two children?

What's the logic for the higher earner having less money per month after taxes and benefits, than a lower earner?

OP posts:
bombastix · 20/11/2023 17:00

The current tax arrangements for high earners are ludicrous; basically disincentives to work.

We have got into an extremely stupid position where something like only the top 10 per cent of earners make a net contribution given spending elsewhere. That isn't sustainable and I'm not surprised at the resentment on tax.

MissusNiceGuy · 20/11/2023 16:58

I agree the cliff edge scenarios are ludicrous. However I also expect higher earners are capable of informing themselves around the costs of bearing children and consider how policy changes may affect them when they are doin Family Planning. I waited until my eldest was in school so I avoided paying childcare for 2 kids at the same time - as this seemed financially the safest and wisest a approach. I didn’t get any free hours until age 3 and coped on a much lower salary than £100k. So sure, it’s a disincentive, to work, but you have to go in with your eyes open: tax and benefits are not fair.

I struggle to see this Government correcting this ludicrous cliff edge when they have created so many other ludicrous problems they need to solve.

StamppotAndGravy · 20/11/2023 16:57

But surely you care when you can't get a GP appointment or similar service because it only makes sense for such people to work 2 days a week? This group of people contribute the most significant proportion of tax take (much higher than the super wealthy for example) therefore encouraging them not to work or to emigrate directly hurts you because they fund your schools and NHS. Yes, maybe it's an obscene salary, but they pay a significant amount back. Would you rather pay 40% on the whole of your 30k salary?

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:57

Herecomestreble1 that isn’t my point. I think it unrealistic to accept thousands of pounds of subsidies for childcare to enable you to continue to earn over 100k when that money should be going to those who really need it. Many of us have had to cut our cloth/ make hard decisions. The sense of entitlement is grating.

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 16:54

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 16:49

Just for some context, two children in nursery in London with no free hours etc is going to be more like... £4k a month.

I had extremely high nursery costs also for my two kids, who are 21 months apart. That is a lifestyle choice though isn't it if you have children close together?

Charlie2121 · 20/11/2023 16:54

EatYourVegetables · 20/11/2023 16:07

£148K salary is obscene. Don’t try to tell
me you work 10 times as hard as the nursery lady who wipes your child’s bum.

And don’t talk to me about how hard you had to work to get there and how educated you are, I have a PhD.

If you’re earning £148 and chose to procreate, you should not expect to cover your procreation costs by from taxpayer’s money that your nursery nurse, your cleaner, your gardener and I have contributed to.

It is not obscene. You also conveniently omit to mention the vast levels of tax that higher earners pay. Nursery nurses, cleaners and gardeners are not net contributors and are therefore subsidised by higher earners. The top 1% of workers pay over 1/3rd of all income tax.

I earn well over the figure you refer to. Salaries are by and large related to how easy it is for someone to replicate what you do. Some jobs may be hard in terms of physical effort but anyone could do them if circumstances dictated.

If you have a role with significant barriers to entry such as very specific experience being required, it will remain highly paid as there is no short cut to compete with current incumbents of those roles.

People fall short because their career plans are poor or non-existent. Many of the people I know who earn hundreds of thousands are no different to anyone else aside from being shrewd in knowing where to target their efforts.

There are plenty who are more educated or have "harder" jobs that get paid far, far less.

Swipe left for the next trending thread