Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
PepeLePugh · 20/11/2023 17:55

There is a similar thread on this subject and I can see there are very similar responses.

I myself am not the high earner in my relationship, my partner is. I earn £30k and where I live, I would be paying the same amount in childcare that I earn so we made the decision that I would give up work which is why the cliff edge feels incredibly unfair. I work for the public sector in a high demand job and now I am out of the job market where I could and should be contributing to the pot. Any help would have meant that I could have continued to work and instead my career is now on hold.

crispcreambun · 20/11/2023 17:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 17:48

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 17:33

The point is that someone with a ‘high’ gross salary does not have much higher take-home pay than someone much lower. And yes, that is profoundly disincentivising to work.

And yet if that nursery nurse told you she'd be better off not working you'd have a few choice names to call her.

slugseverywhere · 20/11/2023 17:47

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:40

Nor am I- I also was once a high earner with no family support who had to pay for childcare. That’s the reality of having children. I got 15 free hours and then had to part time. It’s a relatively short period of time and shoving babies and toddlers into full time daycare is not something that should either be encouraged or paid for by the tax payer.
I am sorry if that seems brutal but I think more honest conversations need to be had rather than telling women they can have it all. They can’t.

I have to agree with this.

Putting children in childcare is not the answer, nor should it be encouraged and as you say not funded by the tax payer.

It's a complete false economy. Pay to put your kids in nursery>parent goes out and work to pay for said nursery>child gets raised by an 18 yo with an NVQ. It really is backwards.

At least the govt stats look good and they can create false productivity.

TeenLifeMum · 20/11/2023 17:44

We lost child benefit because dh went over the threshold (only just) which meant out take home was less than the previous year despite him earning more. However, it’s a privileged position to be in that you are taking less from the state and are able to feel proud you are in a position to support those less fortunate.

i mean, by all means, apply for a job under the threshold. Realistically, once your dc is at school the subsidised childcare is gone so it’s only for a very short time and you will have a much healthier pension than those on lower incomes. There has to be a cutoff.

MigGirl · 20/11/2023 17:34

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:01

@SiousieSoo

Why should someone earning £130k a year have less money than someone earning £99k a year, when both have made the 'lifestyle choice' to have two children?

What's the logic for the higher earner having less money per month after taxes and benefits, than a lower earner?

Because there has to be a cut off somewhere, means testing benefits cost to much so a straight cutoff works better.

You should never rely on any benefits when planning your finances this is even pointed out to those on low incomes as they can be changed by the government at any point.

As mumsnet is often fond of saying childcare cost should be split between both parents (unless your single parent, but you would hopefully then be receiving manitance from the other parent). It isn't a tax on your income it's a cost you have to fund as you choose to have children.

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 17:33

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 17:29

Oooh score! You're comparing oranges and apples, picking and choosing what statistics to.use to prove your point.

What about the fact that she won't get a mortgage on £18k and therefore will never own her own home, what about when her children go to university and she's never been able to save a penny to help support them, what about the pension.she'll have, the career progression...

I can believe your jealous of someone on £18k for about 2 years...

The point is that someone with a ‘high’ gross salary does not have much higher take-home pay than someone much lower. And yes, that is profoundly disincentivising to work.

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 17:32

TheCompactPussycat · 20/11/2023 16:27

But it doesn't make financial sense for the government, they should be incentivising me to work more and pay more tax.

This is nonsensical.

If higher earners (over £100K) want the government to subsidise their childcare so they are not paying what is effectively a 100% tax, then the government will be getting less money, not more because their increased taxes will be outweighed by the increased subsidies.

You're massively missing the point.

The government are paying out <x> amount for childcare regardless.

If I earn 99k I'll pay ~£27k income tax if we're doing very basic calculations

If I earn 120k I'll pay ~£39.4k income tax

It's not financially logical because they're paying me the childcare amount anyway. The government would have £12.4k more tax off of me if the system was smarter and didn't penalise me for it. So instead they're still paying childcare, but missing out on a bunch more tax.

I don't necessarily agree with the OP that it's unfair. But even on a society level, it's not financially smart to incentivise higher earners to limit their take home pay. Cause they lose out on income tax as a result. And that income tax is for funding public services.

casuarinatree · 20/11/2023 17:30

shockeditellyou · 20/11/2023 17:24

At the risk of polishing my tin foil hat, posts like this make me think they are posted by political shills before large policy announcements. Such as the Autumn Statement. Especially as there has been a steady drip about the effective tax rate over £100k lately….

I’ll eat my hat if the £100k rate is still the same on Thursday.

This thought has crossed my mind as well.

Or a journo given the current Times campaign.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 17:29

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 17:19

Agree OP and a lot of people here do not realise the impact of the tax and redistribution system. Low earners are very heavily subsidised to the point that they have the same take-home as apparently higher earners.

A nursery nurse on £18k with 2 kids will receive post-tax income of £35528 per year. This is based on £16,264 after tax from her salary and £17256 in tax credits, and £2080 in child benefits. And has their childcare costs paid for. And no need to repay a student loan.

Someone who earns £100k - so in theory 5 times that amount, actually gets much less than half. Their net wage is £60k out of which they need to then pay their nursery costs. In London, that can easily be £25k for two kids, giving them exactly the same income as the nursery nurse.

Oooh score! You're comparing oranges and apples, picking and choosing what statistics to.use to prove your point.

What about the fact that she won't get a mortgage on £18k and therefore will never own her own home, what about when her children go to university and she's never been able to save a penny to help support them, what about the pension.she'll have, the career progression...

I can believe your jealous of someone on £18k for about 2 years...

C8H10N4O2 · 20/11/2023 17:26

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:23

The reason we are suddenly seeing a lot of posts about this topic, is due to 'fiscal drag', and more and more people being pulled into these bands (which have no changed for a long time now).

Ditto on posts about people not being eligible for child benefit. 1 in 3 households with children has one parent earning £50k+ - it impacts a lot of families.

Its still only the top 2% on a 100k for men, less than 1% for women.

Pooooochi · 20/11/2023 17:25

Shockeditellyou
Yup, the tories are desperate, i can believe they'll try and win some "squeezed middle" there

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 17:25

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 17:19

Agree OP and a lot of people here do not realise the impact of the tax and redistribution system. Low earners are very heavily subsidised to the point that they have the same take-home as apparently higher earners.

A nursery nurse on £18k with 2 kids will receive post-tax income of £35528 per year. This is based on £16,264 after tax from her salary and £17256 in tax credits, and £2080 in child benefits. And has their childcare costs paid for. And no need to repay a student loan.

Someone who earns £100k - so in theory 5 times that amount, actually gets much less than half. Their net wage is £60k out of which they need to then pay their nursery costs. In London, that can easily be £25k for two kids, giving them exactly the same income as the nursery nurse.

Ok (I don't have time to check your figures so let's assume you're right), but now calculate it over a lifetime rather than for the few years of costly childcare. The 100k earner is substantially better off. Even more so when they pay off their mortgage.

We don't have these policies to piss off bankers and magic circle lawyers, we have them to prevent the nursery nurse's children growing up in poverty.

spookehtooth · 20/11/2023 17:25

I don't understand why the threshold of a state handout is even allowed to go so high. Unemployed, low earners and disabled people get penalised if they dare to have savings over a single digit number of savings and you want to complain about "penalised" for earning over £100k. Okay.

I hope you understand too that a lot of people, who's taxes go towards this state handout you are upset at not getting, earn less money to you.

You want to go abroad? I'll help pack your bags if you like

Pooooochi · 20/11/2023 17:24

The reality is it hits a relatively small proportion of people.

Not many people have both a 100k plus income AND preschool age kids, and these are fundamentally well off people, who can in most cases afford for whichever parent earns over £100k to reduce hours or increase pension contribs while kids are young to avoid the cliff edge.

That's why changing it never quite takes off and gets widespread support.

shockeditellyou · 20/11/2023 17:24

At the risk of polishing my tin foil hat, posts like this make me think they are posted by political shills before large policy announcements. Such as the Autumn Statement. Especially as there has been a steady drip about the effective tax rate over £100k lately….

I’ll eat my hat if the £100k rate is still the same on Thursday.

user68901 · 20/11/2023 17:23

Because its is not for forever. You are also investing in your career. You now have the perfect opportunity to stash as much as you can into your pension to reduce your taxable earnings and by the time your kids are accessing school you will have potentially picked up pay rises and promotions.
i do agree that it should be based on household income though.

SiousieSoo · 20/11/2023 17:23

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:14

@SiousieSoo So you have no answer as to why its fair, you just don't care because it's about people who you consider to be better off than you.

I don't really think parents of small children should just unthinkingly accept this 'because'. It's quite clearly absurd.

I didn't realise that you were asking me to prepare a thesis on Government Policy. I don't have an answer to a lot of things that I didn't implement so I am not sure what you are asking for here.

I simply said that you are caught by a blunt instrument, similar to the child benefit threshold. You can think it is absurd as you like but that won't change it will it?

Again you have zero understanding of my earnings or financial arrangements so these are just not relevant here. I think it is bizarre that you expect us to be as outraged as you over this... I could list a hundred inequalities that i find way more egrigous and you would not care about them because they do not affect you so I could say the exact same about you...

roses2 · 20/11/2023 17:23

This isn’t new news, it’s been around for awhile. There are three options:

  • suck it up
  • pay into your pension to reduce your taxable pay to £99k
  • If possible work 3-4 days per week so you get pro rata your full salary then go back full time when your child starts school. This way you don’t unfairly get stuck long term on a lower salary
Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:23

The reason we are suddenly seeing a lot of posts about this topic, is due to 'fiscal drag', and more and more people being pulled into these bands (which have no changed for a long time now).

Ditto on posts about people not being eligible for child benefit. 1 in 3 households with children has one parent earning £50k+ - it impacts a lot of families.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 20/11/2023 17:22

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 17:01

@SiousieSoo

Why should someone earning £130k a year have less money than someone earning £99k a year, when both have made the 'lifestyle choice' to have two children?

What's the logic for the higher earner having less money per month after taxes and benefits, than a lower earner?

And yet I've never had someone turn down a promotion or pay rise which took them over 100k.

Possibly its because of all the other benefits of earning at that level, not least the increased subsidy on pension contributions which can be made up to 40k per year (last I checked) and other salary sacrifice schemes subsidised by the tax system which mean you can earn way past 100k before you hit 100k taxable.

And possibly because the costs of small children and day care are short term whereas the tax subsidies continue.

Of all the anomalies in the tax system its one of the easiest to offset or delay.

CherryMyBrandy · 20/11/2023 17:21

aswarmofmidges · 20/11/2023 15:15

So essentially means testing rather than handing out freebies - sounds reasonable

Taxing anyone 100% is not reasonable!

Ascubudr · 20/11/2023 17:20

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 17:02

Because you are expecting the tax payer to pay for your high income. You have been told how to mitigate this by putting money into pension- which you will still have further down the line. 🙄

Just on this, maybe OP can Hospital consultants, dentists and GPs can't, it's a flat rate, either in or out @ 13.5% so with the 45% tax you see 41.5% of any extra earnings, between £100-125k it's 27.5%. I think though might be wrong there is NI to pay on this too. If these senior medics put too much into their pension they will be taxed on that too via the annual allowance https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-your-private-pension/annual-allowance

Tax on your private pension contributions

Tax you pay and tax relief you get on contributions to your private pension - annual allowance, lifetime allowance, apply for individual protection

https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-your-private-pension/annual-allowance

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 17:19

Agree OP and a lot of people here do not realise the impact of the tax and redistribution system. Low earners are very heavily subsidised to the point that they have the same take-home as apparently higher earners.

A nursery nurse on £18k with 2 kids will receive post-tax income of £35528 per year. This is based on £16,264 after tax from her salary and £17256 in tax credits, and £2080 in child benefits. And has their childcare costs paid for. And no need to repay a student loan.

Someone who earns £100k - so in theory 5 times that amount, actually gets much less than half. Their net wage is £60k out of which they need to then pay their nursery costs. In London, that can easily be £25k for two kids, giving them exactly the same income as the nursery nurse.

2thumbs · 20/11/2023 17:19

There has been a glut of threads like this recently and they are starting to do my head in. And I say that as someone with two pre-schoolers and a salary over £100k! Yes, there’s a cliff edge which, on face value, could be quite punitive. But it’s been that way for years, and there are a wealth of options available to avoid falling foul of it - I have little sympathy for those bleating about how ‘unfair’ it is (I think my sympathy is limited to parents with twins+). What happened to taking responsibility for your finances? If you’re going to have children close together, why not save some money beforehand to soften the blow while you ramp up pension contributions for the years affected? Maybe don’t mortgage yourself up to the hilt, leave yourself some headroom? It’s a quirk in the tax and benefits system that affects a narrow group of people (amongst the least in need) for a narrow amount of time, whilst giving them options to mitigate their losses. I would’ve thought someone earning over £100k would be able to display an element of competence in their general lives, but maybe I’m wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread