Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 20:35

So you are right that it affects a small population for a small period of time.

Actually no... It's a transient population so it'll always exist whilst the boundaries are in place. It'll just be a small but consistent population.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 20/11/2023 20:21

I can see that there have to be cut-offs somewhere. I can live with not getting funded hours. But what I really resent is the fact that my nursery fees will inevitably be cranked up to subsidise all the new ‘free’ hours for other children because the government will underfund the scheme and nurseries have to recoup the lost cash from somewhere. As well as paying through taxes.

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 20:20

Plus I think there are a lot of people who argue a case to maximise their personal income dressed up as an argument for macro economic policy

@LaBaDeeLaBaDa TBF it can be both. It can make economic sense in terms of tax and benefit someone's financial situation.

If I get a pay rise/ promotion it benefits me either way. It's just whether I take that as money or as time. The money option is better economically cause of the additional income tax. But cause I won't benefit financially (and actually end up worse off) I'll choose to take the time and put additional money into a pension instead. Basically rather that it being a win:win for me and the government, it ends up being a win:lose 🤷

I disagree with the OP about it being unfair. I don't think it's unfair. But I do think they could do a better job incentivising me to earn more. It's a moot point in a few years though. So you are right that it affects a small population for a small period of time.

Circe7 · 20/11/2023 20:18

If I got a promotion my full time salary could potentially go up to £125k. At that point (leaving aside the option of putting the extra into a pension which isn’t very attractive for various reasons) I’d lose £500 per month by working 5 rather than 4 days, after accounting for the extra childcare.

This is perhaps at the extreme end because I have two young children in childcare but not unique.

The promotion would increase my target hours by 5 per week.

I don’t mind working 4 days anyway but the bad design of the policy does annoy me. It would be completely possible to design a tax system without disincentives to increase hours / get promoted and without cliff edges and where the tax take is still the same or higher overall.

Added to that I’m a single parent so at a £125k salary I’d make c.£6,500 per month with a childcare bill of over £3k. Not terrible but not exceptional as a household income.

LaBaDeeLaBaDa · 20/11/2023 20:05

OnMyYaught

I agree with you on the general principle that tax policy needs to incentivise high earners (and everyone who can) to earn. There's no economic consensus on where the sweet spot is to maximise tax yield generally, though, and it's nowhere near as straightforward as some posters are claiming. I also don't think this policy is the best example of it given that the cliff edge only exists for a sub-cohort of an already small group and for a small amount or time, and the purpose is a social policy rather than a fiscal one. Plus I think there are a lot of people who argue a case to maximise their personal income dressed up as an argument for macro economic policy (not saying you're doing this, but I think OP are some others are)

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 20:05

TheCompactPussycat · 20/11/2023 19:04

I'm not missing the point at all.

The simple fact is that the tiny amount of income tax the treasury is losing is not worth offering the scheme to higher earners. And people earning over £100K generally don't need to be incentivised to work.

Edited

You really are missing the point. I will artificially cap my earnings through working less and putting money into my pension. So they will then pay the full childcare allowances.

If they paid the allowances at a higher income amount then I wouldn't cap my earnings. I'd still get the same amount from the government for childcare but they would get more tax from me.

It's literally only net positive for the treasury.

The only way this policy financially makes sense from a social /government perspective is if more people who pass that £100k barrier don't do anything about it and accept the hit. For those people you're correct that the government is better off as they save the childcare fees and continue to get more tax on the increased income. But I'm yet to meet anyone with kids in childcare who aren't aware of the £100k cliff edge and who aren't planning to avoid it through one way or another for a couple of years until kids are at school.

Also "people earning over £100k don't need to be incentivised to work" - they definitely do. Myself and several others have said we'd drop days/hours before we throw money down the drain working more hours than we need to literally be worse off.

Princessandthepea0 · 20/11/2023 19:46

bombastix · 20/11/2023 19:38

Yes. And it's why Labour are very quiet about looking at higher tax rates for top earners, I believe.

It’s why they backtracked yes. It maybe the minority but they are funding the majority by paying the majority of income tax. Cliff edges which stop them working and paying as much tax means there is less income to the treasury. It’s basic social and economic behaviour. Despite how much mn posters claim they would do 50Ks worth of work for free.

Missamyp · 20/11/2023 19:45

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 15:34

Why should it be universal? Having two children so close together is a lifestyle choice. There are many many things that income tax could be used on. Endless free childcare isn’t one of them- especially for high earners.

The high earners pay the most tax and subsidise others, but are denied benefits.

Robinnuts · 20/11/2023 19:44

bombastix · 20/11/2023 19:38

Yes. And it's why Labour are very quiet about looking at higher tax rates for top earners, I believe.

Unfortunately quite a lot of the electorate are quite ignorant when it comes to taxes and just think tax cuts for the rich are unacceptable.

bombastix · 20/11/2023 19:38

Princessandthepea0 · 20/11/2023 19:28

The chancellor commissioned a report which showed that the cliff edges at 100k harm tax take. Not just child care but the personal allowance withdrawal. It maybe a tiny amount of people however they pay the most tax. Literally funding the majority. The government can’t afford these people to reduce productivity.

Yes. And it's why Labour are very quiet about looking at higher tax rates for top earners, I believe.

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 19:36

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 18:49

@TotesABoats I wasn't the poster you originally responded too. I agree with your scenario about the two salaries you mentioned there. I was making the assumption you were referring to the OP / other similar people.

But either way I was just making the general point that I made up thread. I doubt it makes a huge impact overall to the country's finances, but it definitely doesn't make financial sense for the government to have this set up like this.

Ah, I'm sorry, I must have got my posters mixed up.

I'm not persuaded the deadweight costs wouldn't offset the tax gain tbh, but I'd have to look at the numbers earning 100-140, 140+, 200+ etc to know for sure.

But the main thing for me (as I said earlier) is that the point of the childcare subsidy is to enable and encourage women back to work. In terms of that policy outcome I don't think the £100k cohort is the one to worry about, as many other factors are at play in those back to work decisions. That may feel very unfair to those on the wrong side of the threshold, but it doesn't make it a badly designed policy like OP keeps stating.

Princessandthepea0 · 20/11/2023 19:28

The chancellor commissioned a report which showed that the cliff edges at 100k harm tax take. Not just child care but the personal allowance withdrawal. It maybe a tiny amount of people however they pay the most tax. Literally funding the majority. The government can’t afford these people to reduce productivity.

Wrongpostcode · 20/11/2023 19:18

After tax and all other costs, the cost of nanny and nursery probably work out the same but it would be disruptive to DC1 to come out of nursery. And then when DC1 starts school, there’s no guarantee of getting a nursery place for DC2 . Have seriously considered it though.

TheCompactPussycat · 20/11/2023 19:04

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 17:32

You're massively missing the point.

The government are paying out <x> amount for childcare regardless.

If I earn 99k I'll pay ~£27k income tax if we're doing very basic calculations

If I earn 120k I'll pay ~£39.4k income tax

It's not financially logical because they're paying me the childcare amount anyway. The government would have £12.4k more tax off of me if the system was smarter and didn't penalise me for it. So instead they're still paying childcare, but missing out on a bunch more tax.

I don't necessarily agree with the OP that it's unfair. But even on a society level, it's not financially smart to incentivise higher earners to limit their take home pay. Cause they lose out on income tax as a result. And that income tax is for funding public services.

I'm not missing the point at all.

The simple fact is that the tiny amount of income tax the treasury is losing is not worth offering the scheme to higher earners. And people earning over £100K generally don't need to be incentivised to work.

randomsabreuse · 20/11/2023 19:01

The other issue is this affects the highest paid public sector workers far more than private sector city types who will find it easier to get through the zero net increase period and come out the other side but for GPs, Consultants and Dentists there is less prospect of getting out the other side meaning they would tend to reduce hours longer term - not ideal as there's a bit of a shortage there...

I have no fish to fry as DH and I are both in professions that will top out below 100k but we'd quite like there to be a functioning NHS and this kind of cliff edge just doesn't make good economic sense...

OnMyYaught · 20/11/2023 18:59

The government tax things that are of social detriment, like smoking, to make it most costly to people to stop them doing it.

The government also subsidise things, like childcare, because of the social benefits of it.

Thats how it works. The social benefit of subsidising high earners childcare is that they are more likely to work and provide value plus pay more tax.

OnMyYaught · 20/11/2023 18:50

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 18:40

Curiosity101

You're conflating two things there. The cliff edge on tax care does incentivise extra pension contributions / dropping hours etc. I think the net tax and productivity impact is negligible or negative when you look at the cohort overall, rather than one individual (your mileage may differ). But you were suggesting that an 18k nursery nurse having a similar income as someone on 60k is a disincentive to take the 60k job, and that doesn't stack up at all. It's annoying, not a disincentive to maximise your own long term earnings potential.

I have a lot more sympathy with the poster who's DH earns more than 100k and she could earn 30ish, because at those levels the childcare policy definitely isn't helping her to work, when on both an individual and cohort level it makes a lot of policy sense to do so. Tricky to find a policy solution for that which doesn't create other difficult trade offs.

Make it universal. People who earn more will still pay more tax and at that point in their earnings it’s 60% effective tax, so it’s a huge amount. The extra they pay in tax for working more will generally pay in more to the pot than they take out with childcare.

We should be glad they pay so much tax and are working. Don’t say others are subsidising them - let’s be honest and clear, someone earning 100k will be putting in more than they take out and certainly aren’t being generally subsidised by the govt (though yes, this policy means they essentially pay less than they otherwise would because they get some back as this benefit, they are still paying in far, far more than taking).

The 10% of income taxpayers with the largest incomes contribute over 60% of income tax receipts. Keep these people doing that.

I mean this in the best possible way, you want those people working and earning tax to pay into the pot for everyone, you don’t want those people to decide they’d actually be better off working less, as nobody wins from that.

It will never happen because we probably can’t even begin to imagine the amount of backlash the govt would get if they suggested the rich get an additional benefit. Would be hard to see through all the anger that would cause to see that actually, everyone is better off as they pay more tax than they would have.

If the govt give me £5 and I use it to earn £100 and then pay £60 in tax as a result, people will complain that the govt gave me £5, not that they are now £55 better off.

blueshoes · 20/11/2023 18:50

This is the law of unintended consequences.

Years ago, I experienced the 100K tax cliff edge but I knew if I sucked it up for a year or so (from 100 to 110K? cannot quite remember), I would come out of the woods soon and continue my upward trajectory.

If I had to lose all the childcare benefits and suck it up from 100 to 148K, I would throw in the towel and get more free time for myself at 99K and leave the powering of the economy and cost to my personal life to someone else.

Multiply that across high earning households and all that tax and GDP lost and female progression in the workplace lost. Hence the law of unintended consequences for means tested benefits.

Doubt if anyone is shedding any tears because it is great to punish high earners. A real vote winner there.

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 18:49

@TotesABoats I wasn't the poster you originally responded too. I agree with your scenario about the two salaries you mentioned there. I was making the assumption you were referring to the OP / other similar people.

But either way I was just making the general point that I made up thread. I doubt it makes a huge impact overall to the country's finances, but it definitely doesn't make financial sense for the government to have this set up like this.

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 18:40

Curiosity101

You're conflating two things there. The cliff edge on tax care does incentivise extra pension contributions / dropping hours etc. I think the net tax and productivity impact is negligible or negative when you look at the cohort overall, rather than one individual (your mileage may differ). But you were suggesting that an 18k nursery nurse having a similar income as someone on 60k is a disincentive to take the 60k job, and that doesn't stack up at all. It's annoying, not a disincentive to maximise your own long term earnings potential.

I have a lot more sympathy with the poster who's DH earns more than 100k and she could earn 30ish, because at those levels the childcare policy definitely isn't helping her to work, when on both an individual and cohort level it makes a lot of policy sense to do so. Tricky to find a policy solution for that which doesn't create other difficult trade offs.

OnMyYaught · 20/11/2023 18:29

Would you rather:

Work a few days less and take home 99k plus tax free childcare and 30 hours free worth about 20k in total.

Or

Work really hard every day and earn 110k and then have to pay 20k more in childcare and so take home 90k, rather than the 99k you’d have if you worked less?

Clearly the first one - less work, more free time and more money. That’s what this system incentivises and that’s the point of the OP.

Who wins in that situation? Not the taxman. Not the child.

123sunshine · 20/11/2023 18:15

I don’t disagree with you. As a high earning household and financial adviser I understand entirely.

Curiosity101 · 20/11/2023 18:07

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 17:57

Savourycrepe
The point is that someone with a ‘high’ gross salary does not have much higher take-home pay than someone much lower. And yes, that is profoundly disincentivising to work

You might find it annoying, or depressing. It's not actually a disincentive unless someone is incapable of looking beyond the short term.

It discentivises in the sense that the person it more likely to drop down their hours temporarily or ferret away money into a pension when they could be paying more income tax. That's not short sighted, that's sensible. You up your hours again once it makes financial sense.

Not to mention with the higher take home wage they'll then spend more money too.

Savourycrepe · 20/11/2023 18:06

The tapering of the personal allowance at 100k was a disincentive to me to work harder. I reduced my hours to stay below the threshold. Made individual sense to me as I could spend more time with the kids with no real impact on my income.

At a societal level, these individual decisions have a huge impact.

TotesABoats · 20/11/2023 17:57

Savourycrepe
The point is that someone with a ‘high’ gross salary does not have much higher take-home pay than someone much lower. And yes, that is profoundly disincentivising to work

You might find it annoying, or depressing. It's not actually a disincentive unless someone is incapable of looking beyond the short term.

Swipe left for the next trending thread