Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

100% effective tax on earnings £100-148k

216 replies

Childcare47 · 20/11/2023 15:03

I have posted in the past about the impact of loss of 15 'free hours' plus loss of 'tax free childcare', which combined with the 60% tax rate creates a severe cliff edge in earnings.

The situation is in fact even worse - as it has been announced parents earning >£100,000 will not be eligible for any free hours from 9 months.

For two children therefore:

  • Loss of £4,000 annual tax free childcare
  • Loss of 30 free hours for the under 3 = £800pcm
  • Loss of 15 free hours for the over 3 = £400pm

This is £18,400 a year lost if you earn a penny over £100k.

To therefore break even on that £18,400 loss, you need to earn... £148,000? To have exactly the same income as at £99,000?

Why does the government not address this absurd 'quirk' in the system, surely not one can think its right to be taxed at a rate of 100% on a third of your income, what's the point in earning it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Xenia · 21/11/2023 11:39

It is appalling.
My own view is we shoudl have one flat rate of combined tax and NI on all income including pensioners who earn enough to pay tax, everyone gets the same single person allowance and once you have paid a particular sum of tax in a year eg £100k or £250k, then all income over that is untaxed as you have paid your dues. I think Guernsey had that or still has that. What that flat rate should be could perhaps be the current basic rate tax of 10% and main NI rate of about 13% so about 33%, a third of your income.

Or we could let all full time working parents set all their childcare costs against their tax bill nad we could be rid of all the complext 15 free hours for 3 year olds or 30 free hours for XYZ. just allow a simple tax off set and leave parents who work full time free to choose the care, child minder, nursery, nanny

Robinnuts · 21/11/2023 11:28

nanodyne · 21/11/2023 10:47

Unfortunately this isn't the only area in which the system doesn't make sense - I sw something yesterday that said that the marginal tax rate for a single-income household with 3 kids, gross salary £50-60k was something like 72% (jumping to 78% if you include student loan) because of the removal of CB, the highest marginal tax rate across any income group.

These thresholds have all been frozen for too long. No one can really think a £50k salary - earned by ~20% of the population and rising - is a high income, but at least CB tapers. As you say, it's strange to not have a taper on at least the "tax-free" (I use quotation marks because it's a complete misnomer, even in Yorkshire it's not covering a full 20% of my costs) childcare allowance, although I can see that a taper on the hours might be more complicated to administer.

In Scotland the higher rate threshold has been frozen for much longer. It is £43,662.

Curiosity101 · 21/11/2023 11:17

@laclochette Sorry! Completely misread the context of your post 😅😁

laclochette · 21/11/2023 10:48

@C8H10N4O2 My recruiter tells me she is regularly asked to negotiate a salary of exactly £99,999 and no more, because of exactly this issue. so it does happen.

nanodyne · 21/11/2023 10:47

Unfortunately this isn't the only area in which the system doesn't make sense - I sw something yesterday that said that the marginal tax rate for a single-income household with 3 kids, gross salary £50-60k was something like 72% (jumping to 78% if you include student loan) because of the removal of CB, the highest marginal tax rate across any income group.

These thresholds have all been frozen for too long. No one can really think a £50k salary - earned by ~20% of the population and rising - is a high income, but at least CB tapers. As you say, it's strange to not have a taper on at least the "tax-free" (I use quotation marks because it's a complete misnomer, even in Yorkshire it's not covering a full 20% of my costs) childcare allowance, although I can see that a taper on the hours might be more complicated to administer.

laclochette · 21/11/2023 10:44

@Curiosity101 God me neither! I literally do this. That's why I said that it's great advice for individuals - but the fact that this is the call we have to make belies a terrible system that desperately needs to be fixed.

Curiosity101 · 21/11/2023 10:20

can't you see that it's incredibly bad for the economy

Yes, but I'm yet to meet someone who would choose to work for less money if they did genuinely have a choice.

If the government changed the system they'd get more tax from me... But I'm not going to be ashamed of refusing to work for less money when my alternate option is more free time and a better pension.

Janedoe82 · 21/11/2023 10:00

Maybe it would be nice to have more time with your young children rather than outsourcing their care. The long term benefit having more time with their mother surely outweighs paying more tax to the government 🙄

laclochette · 21/11/2023 09:43

People who say you can cope by putting more money into your pension or by dropping hours - well yes, you can, it's good advice for individuals, but can't you see that it's incredibly bad for the economy?

  • Putting more money into your pension: the govt isn't getting any tax on that money to spend on services now. So this reduces the money we have to spend on things we need.
  • Reducing your hours: we have a terrible productivity issue in this country, which means we are stuck flatlining as an economy. Reducing hours contributes to that.
Childcare47 · 21/11/2023 09:19

From @laclochette's article:

“Like many of my colleagues I have young children and claim funded childcare hours,” says the thirtysomething family doctor. However, the doctor points to the “tax cliff edge at £100,000”, where if a household earns this much or above it loses this funding.

“This is coupled with the loss of the personal allowance from earnings over £100,000, which results in a marginal tax rate of 62% including national insurance. Factor in pension contributions and student loan repayments, and I would only take home 15.5p for every pound earned.

“I did some calculations and realised that, factoring in the loss of childcare hours and the higher tax band, I would need to earn about £120,000 to ‘break even’ with earning just below £100,000.

“As a result, after Christmas I’m reducing my hours to keep my earnings down. This means at the busiest time of the year for the NHS I’ll be sitting at home twiddling my thumbs when I could be at work seeing patients.”

Reducing hours to stay below the £100,000 income threshold was, they added, “a regular topic of discussion” among colleagues. “It’s utter madness. Apologies to patients who can’t get in to see me in February and March. I’ll be back in April.”

OP posts:
laclochette · 21/11/2023 09:08

This article demonstrates well why this system is terrible for the country.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/21/im-reducing-my-hours-fiscal-drags-impact-in-the-cost-of-living-crisis
You've got doctors turning down hours they could be working because they can't afford to work more, as they will be worse off for it. That is a truly broken system. Nobody should be WORSE off for working more.

‘I’m reducing my hours’: fiscal drag’s impact in the cost of living crisis

Guardian readers share how frozen income tax thresholds have tipped them into higher brackets, affecting household budgets

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/21/im-reducing-my-hours-fiscal-drags-impact-in-the-cost-of-living-crisis

dolorsit · 21/11/2023 08:45

One of the reasons why it was set up like this is to deal with the issue that my family faced 17 years ago.

I couldn't afford to return to work as my husband's salary plus bonus took us over the threshold for support at around 32k.

We could afford for me not to work but we couldn't absorb the drop in household income that paying a child care bill more than my salary would incur.

We chose to have a second child sooner rather than later to get through the child care years quicker.

Unfortunately it didn't turn out that way and I have never returned to the work force properly.

I have sympathy with the cliff edge cut off. As a single income household changes to child benefits hit us hard (the equivalent at the time of 2% income tax rate increase on husband's salary)

However I played myself the tiniest violin at the time. You do have options, you can drop hours, increase pension contributions probably without impacting your quality of life.

I am a believer in the concept of universality but unfortunately pushing that is the equivalent of flogging a pritt-stick!

PepeLePugh · 21/11/2023 08:41

I am reading this morning about the governments plans to push benefit claimants into work and that we should be "making work pay" and yet we have a problem on the other end of the spectrum where high earners are being disincentivised to work due to childcare costs, or the partners of high earners are giving up careers to stay at home and look after the children. Seems pretty barmy to me.

Lilothblos · 21/11/2023 08:24

The situation is ridiculous, I totally agree. Dh and I are both stuck in the 100-150k bracket, working full time, and as a result we are both planning on dropping days at work to bring us under it. Not sure why we should both be effectively working for free for a significant part of the week due to the tax / childcare impact. From the government’s perspective this policy is so counterproductive.

AddGif · 21/11/2023 08:04

randomsabreuse · 20/11/2023 19:01

The other issue is this affects the highest paid public sector workers far more than private sector city types who will find it easier to get through the zero net increase period and come out the other side but for GPs, Consultants and Dentists there is less prospect of getting out the other side meaning they would tend to reduce hours longer term - not ideal as there's a bit of a shortage there...

I have no fish to fry as DH and I are both in professions that will top out below 100k but we'd quite like there to be a functioning NHS and this kind of cliff edge just doesn't make good economic sense...

Yes. None of my GP friends work full-time now (aged early 50s). The ridiculous pension tax (now abolished I think) and then childcare cost issues means it made sense for them all to go part-time. Men and women. How on earth is this good for the country?

spriots · 21/11/2023 07:38

I agree, up to a point, that two children under 5 is a choice and it is a relatively brief time when they are both in nursery.

However, the tax-free childcare also covers wraparound and holiday clubs - so the pointlessness of earning between £100 and 148k persists to a large extent through the primary years as well.

Like most people we know in this bracket, we both work four days a week and pay extra into our pensions in order to keep the tax-free childcare - because it seems pointless to spend less time with our children for basically the same amount of money.

A lot of jobs in this salary range are quite niche and employers really want your skills so are quite happy to allow you to work part time.

It works nicely for us in some ways - both being part time is a nice work life balance - but I do question whether it's achieving what the government wants..

AddGif · 21/11/2023 07:27

Janedoe82 · 20/11/2023 16:07

As I said above telling women they can have it all is a lie. You can’t. Something has to give.

What about men, can they have it all?

I am against any policy that forces more women out of the workplace than men. Passionately so.

shockeditellyou · 21/11/2023 07:16

The idea that jobs earning more than 100k are somehow the kind of jobs where it is trivial to drop to 4 days a week or less, is nonsense, as is the idea that there is a pool of people to backfill the time. We are 8 oncologists down in my directorate at work, and if more start dropping hours, we’ll be even more stuffed.

It’s very easy in the SE to earn over 100k and not be well off, by the time you pay for housing and childcare. I don’t mind paying more tax but the current cliff edge is ludicrous.

Charlie2121 · 21/11/2023 07:14

Princessandthepea0 · 21/11/2023 06:44

Back in the real world where we have one of the largest, economically inactive populations in the world. Who do you think is paying for all of these people?

There was an ONS report that stated anyone earning under 70k was not a net contributor when cost of services were considered.

Only those earning above this figure were paying in more than the average cost per person for NHS, government, roads, social care etc.

The reality is that society is reliant on a fairly small number of people to bankroll everyone else. Thats why dissuading or over taxing higher earners is never a good plan.

Princessandthepea0 · 21/11/2023 06:44

YireosDodeAver · 20/11/2023 23:03

It's really not a problem for the members of the wealthiest 1-2% who are affected by this issue to drop their hours to stay under the threshold. It is far better for the economy and for the country and for the individuals and families concerned to have two people working at 50%fte with a salary of £60k each than it is to have one person earning £120k. I get that some people are sufficiently talented and skilled enough to deserve those salaries but no I don't want to incentivise anyone operating at that level to work more hours in order to earn more money. Working more hours at that level leads to burn out crises and all sorts of unfortunate fall-out. It would be better all around for their employers to be incentivised for anyone earning at that level to be expected to do their main job part-time and to dedicate a proportion of their available time to mentoring training and supporting more of the people currently operating at a level where the remuneration is more like £50k-ish for 100% fte to gain the skills and experience they are missing to operate at that higher level, increasing the number of higher earners rather than the wealth of the highest. Why do we need a level of super-rich who earn over 5 times more than most ordinary people can hope to? Why not build a society where it's generally flatter and more equal because once you hit an income of £60k or so you stop trying to earn more and start using your time to do other things?

It's only so expensive to live in the southeast because of self-perpetuating vicious spirals of decisions to prioritise more-more-more. We could choose to stop that. We would all benefit.

Back in the real world where we have one of the largest, economically inactive populations in the world. Who do you think is paying for all of these people?

Robinnuts · 21/11/2023 05:41

I have a high salary and work 9-5 so certainly am not getting ‘burnt out’. I’d be much more burnt out if I was a carer, or a teacher etc. most people on high salaries earn well due to their intellectual skills. Think patent lawyers, actuaries, financial modellers. I’d see that some NHS consultants get burnt out.

People earning high salaries pay high tax and are therefore vital for this country. The reason why the government invests in education and encourages university is that an educated workforce are paid more and pay more tax. Multinational companies are more likely to base themselves in a country with a highly educated workforce. These people are an asset and the government ought to be encouraging them to work full time if they want to, rather than giving them incentives to drop their hours.

Ascubudr · 21/11/2023 03:51

It is far better for the economy and for the country and for the individuals and families concerned to have two people working at 50%fte with a salary of £60k each than it is to have one person earning £120k

It is certainly more pleasant for those families to have 2 people earning £50K (we did this for about 4 years) and you don't need childcare. However as multiple pp have pointed out, it is definately not better for the ecomony or society. Most jobs at that level have plenty of mentorship built in.

YireosDodeAver · 20/11/2023 23:03

It's really not a problem for the members of the wealthiest 1-2% who are affected by this issue to drop their hours to stay under the threshold. It is far better for the economy and for the country and for the individuals and families concerned to have two people working at 50%fte with a salary of £60k each than it is to have one person earning £120k. I get that some people are sufficiently talented and skilled enough to deserve those salaries but no I don't want to incentivise anyone operating at that level to work more hours in order to earn more money. Working more hours at that level leads to burn out crises and all sorts of unfortunate fall-out. It would be better all around for their employers to be incentivised for anyone earning at that level to be expected to do their main job part-time and to dedicate a proportion of their available time to mentoring training and supporting more of the people currently operating at a level where the remuneration is more like £50k-ish for 100% fte to gain the skills and experience they are missing to operate at that higher level, increasing the number of higher earners rather than the wealth of the highest. Why do we need a level of super-rich who earn over 5 times more than most ordinary people can hope to? Why not build a society where it's generally flatter and more equal because once you hit an income of £60k or so you stop trying to earn more and start using your time to do other things?

It's only so expensive to live in the southeast because of self-perpetuating vicious spirals of decisions to prioritise more-more-more. We could choose to stop that. We would all benefit.

Xenia · 20/11/2023 21:46

It is appallling. My advice to women has been get yourself well over the £100k mark if you can as you then get out the other side as it were but that is not easy for most.

I wouldn't mind high tax if women could set off all childcare against tax eg £60k a year off set if that is what the childcare costs you or if the state offered almost free childcare for all but instead fewer and fewer people now support more and more and it becomes very unfair and the state loses out as those people work less. I had a doctor sibling (male) who stopped working on Sundays at one stage tax went to 50% because might as well be with the children.,
It is also a benefits issue too -that we have these income levels where people might as well not work at all as the small amount they get if they work at low pay and get benefits means work does not pay - something IDS tried very hard to sort out with UC but did not quite manage.

We seem to have the worst of all worlds, massive childcare costs, highest tax burden for 70 years and not much of a welfare state.