Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you chose to stick with just one DC

108 replies

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 14:54

Curious. After lots of soul searching we think practically this would be best for our family but the biggest factor keeping us on the fence is that we wouldn’t want them to be lonely and miss out on valuable life lessons that a sibling can bring.

Every other reason though points towards having one for us: finances are FAR easier (childcare is so extortionate!), energy, time for one another, maintaining careers, house size, providing support for DC when they become an adult with things like house deposit, driving lessons, uni, wedding

It’s so tricky to know what’s best and what you will/won’t regret

OP posts:
BearsBeetsBattlestarGalatica · 20/11/2023 15:18

I believe you should be able to provide for your child all of the below:
Physically
Mentally
Emotionally
Financially
I would not be able to give another child all of the above, I can with one.
My first pregnancy destroyed my body and another could leave me in an even worse way.
We enjoy the quiet, easy pace of life of one, after we leave friends who have 2 or more, it always solidifies our decision.
I get niggles of sadness at not giving them a sibling but that's not enough of a reason to potentially destroy my mind and body. We focus more on the fact we can give them any opportunity they want and build a community around them. Our life is sweet with one.

Harshreality · 20/11/2023 15:17

Agree with @mrlistersgelfbride , brace for the overbearing and interfering opinions of others on how you simply MUST have another one.

I usually respond with, will you be donating your time, money and vagina for this suggestion?

Bosca · 20/11/2023 15:15

Never occurred to me to have another. For me, people having more than one child are making a slightly odd decision.

mrlistersgelfbride · 20/11/2023 15:15

Hoglet70 · 20/11/2023 15:12

I'm just not maternal and didn't want another one! Not all siblings get on either.

Same here! And there's no shame in admitting this.

mrlistersgelfbride · 20/11/2023 15:12

I post about having an only on here quite often. So many reasons.

I had post partum psychosis and don't want to risk that again. I am the default parent and finally have a decent balance and don't want to loose myself again.
In terms of support: DDs dad is lazy. MILs tricky to be around with a baby/toddler as I learnt the first time, and my parents aren't interested.

Finances. Splitting kids hobbies. Needing extra sanity and patience! Sleep!

DD is my whole world and I just can't imagine dividing my love and attention.
I don't feel I need to have another child for her to have a playmate- my house is often full of her friends!- and I won't do it just because society dictates... it's not a good reason to have another IMO.
However, I've not had great experience with siblings which may cloud my judgement.
I have a brother and whilst we were close as children, we aren't as adults and he has a lot of problems (ex drug addict always asking me and parents for money).
My partner has 3 siblings and I can't begin to tell you the fall outs some of them have had. It can be hard work navigating all those different relationships.

There will be people on here saying 2 kids is amazing , they feel sorry for onlies and others saying it's the best kept secret of being a parent and they love it.

I think it's great and apart from a few nosey/tactless comments from people, I've nothing negative to say about having an only, I absolutely love it.

Hoglet70 · 20/11/2023 15:12

I'm just not maternal and didn't want another one! Not all siblings get on either.

DeadButDelicious · 20/11/2023 15:09

Eleven years of unexplained infertility, the loss of our first daughter, resulting in PTSD, a difficult second pregnancy and so many external factors such as finances etc mean that we decided to not push our luck any further. There is no guarantee we would have been able to conceive anyway and my age was against me meaning I didn't have another potential 11 years in me too wait it out or the desire to put myself through anymore medical stuff. I will forever grieve our first daughter and as far as I am concerned I have 2 children, it's just that I only get to raise one. My DD is enough, I'm focussed on raising her to the best of my ability. I try not to get hung up on any hypothetical siblings. It won't do me or her any good. This is just how things have shook out for us.

Harshreality · 20/11/2023 15:09

I only have one dc. We work hard to keep him level and not spoiled and socialise him every chance we get, plus we do every sport and activity together. It has made us a very solid unit and we are able to give him the attention and hearing ear that he needs with problems and his feelings, etc. I'm not a single child myself, I have three siblings. Financially, it's worked out well as regards holidays etc. But we try to always be very firm with not letting him have his way, sharing and accepting others viewpoints.

What stuck with me, I had a conversation with a colleague who was a single child herself when I was at the shall I shan't I phase as you are. She said my parents are my best friends, we've always done everything together growing up and we are a solid team still.

No regrets