Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you chose to stick with just one DC

108 replies

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 14:54

Curious. After lots of soul searching we think practically this would be best for our family but the biggest factor keeping us on the fence is that we wouldn’t want them to be lonely and miss out on valuable life lessons that a sibling can bring.

Every other reason though points towards having one for us: finances are FAR easier (childcare is so extortionate!), energy, time for one another, maintaining careers, house size, providing support for DC when they become an adult with things like house deposit, driving lessons, uni, wedding

It’s so tricky to know what’s best and what you will/won’t regret

OP posts:
JimnJoyce · 20/11/2023 16:25

I was 42 when I had DD and a single parent 3 years later. I didn't want to do it all again .

MossBross · 20/11/2023 16:22

Age, finances, lack of local family support and no burning desire to have a second.

It was the right decision for us. I can relate to the poster above who talked about being a tight unit. We do a lot of things together and have fun together (DD is now 13). I hope we can continue to have fun together as she gets older but also mindful that she now prefers to spend a lot of her time with friends rather than us. I'm pleased for her. She is a sociable and friendly soul.

A lot of people project their own issues about 'being alone' or fear of loneliness onto the only child. You only have to look at the number of people who stick with incompatible, even abusive partners, because they prefer that to potentially being on their 'own'. So watch out for that!

We are open with her about our decision to not have any more children and we talk about what it might have been like to have siblings, the good and the bad. talk about the future with her and how I rely on my sister for a lot of emotional support and she won't have that as an adult. I encourage her to always have good friends in her life and to keep close to her cousins if that is a relationship she enjoys and wants to maintain so that she has supportive people around her who are family and non family.

Good luck with your decision!

Vegetus · 20/11/2023 16:18

Skint, small house, few health issues in the pregnancy and at the newborn stage requiring emergency heart surgery. We got lucky with one now healthy 4 year old I'm not going to roll the dice again.

SynchOrSwim · 20/11/2023 16:18

I couldn't do giving birth or the newborn bit again, found it really awful.

But also finances, peace, etc as others have said.

Someone upthread said something about cutting your cloth to have a second. But I don't want to. I want DD to live in a decent sized house in a nice area with a good catchment school. I want to travel with her to lots of interesting places, have her do lots of enriching extracurriculars, be able to afford tutors and and when needed (currently 11+ prepping). Without having to do the maths to work out if I can afford it for a second child.

FlamingoHels · 20/11/2023 16:18

Numerous reasons already listed above (time,money etc) but a big one was not wanting to roll the dice again once we had one healthy child, having seen a couple of people I know have severely disabled children.

I’m so damn grateful for what I have.

Beezknees · 20/11/2023 16:16

Couldn't afford more than one. Couldn't afford the one I had to be honest as me and his dad split up and even now I'm reliant on UC top ups despite working full time.

I'm an only child myself and was never lonely so I never felt guilty about DS being an only.

SgtJuneAckland · 20/11/2023 16:11

We have one for all of the reasons you've mentioned, we have a nice comfortable life, DS can have lots of opportunities and our undivided time and attention. Holidays, activities etc can be geared towards his age group and we don't have to worry about different needs and interests ( DNs have a 5 year age gap). He has cousins, we have some friends with children, he has lots of friends of his own. He is confident and sociable. We do make maybe more effort than parents with multiple children to make sure he has extra curricular activities and opportunities to play with other children, but he also is happy in his own company.

DH is a happy only too. I have a sibling and we get along fine but we're very different people, wouldn't likely be friends if not related and there's not a hope in hell he'll be of any help/support if it gets to a time when our parents' health is ailing.

I also had a really horrific labour, needed a blood transfusion etc and I don't think I could go through that again. I also had SPD, PGP and gestational diabetes during pregnancy. Not much fun.

PinkRoses1245 · 20/11/2023 16:09

You don't need a reason, although plenty. It's your choice and no one else's business. Pretty appalled anyone would challenge you on it. Odd that having more than 1 is seen as the 'norm'. You are also doing the planet a favour by having one.

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 16:09

Fluffyc1ouds · 20/11/2023 16:00

My reasons are:

Financial - I can't afford another maternity leave and don't want to have to buy a bigger house (nor be squeezing into a smaller one). I can buy whatever uniform, shoes, clothes, etc that DS needs without needing to spend the same amount on extra kids. Days out are much cheaper.

Peace - my friends with 2+ kids always comment on how quiet and peaceful my house is. I try to avoid going to theirs because it's a bit full-on. DS will happily sit down with an activity or a film if I need to crack on with something.

Birth - my child is school age and I'm still kept awake some nights having flashbacks of childbirth. It was honestly hideous and I can't believe any woman wants to do it again.

My own sanity - parenting doesn't come naturally to me! So I find it much easier to give my all to one child. Lots of my friends have chosen not to have any kids at all and I find it much easier to socialise with them with my one child (walks, afternoons in the pub garden, bbqs, etc) whereas the friends who have 2+ kids never get invited to anything.

Thank you. Sounds like our reasons

OP posts:
Eike · 20/11/2023 16:03

CBA to do it again. As it stands my child will be an adult before I'm 40. I'm happy with that

I think I feel a bit "been there, done that", I can't see why I would want another one. It's lovely while it all lasts and all.

Fluffyc1ouds · 20/11/2023 16:00

My reasons are:

Financial - I can't afford another maternity leave and don't want to have to buy a bigger house (nor be squeezing into a smaller one). I can buy whatever uniform, shoes, clothes, etc that DS needs without needing to spend the same amount on extra kids. Days out are much cheaper.

Peace - my friends with 2+ kids always comment on how quiet and peaceful my house is. I try to avoid going to theirs because it's a bit full-on. DS will happily sit down with an activity or a film if I need to crack on with something.

Birth - my child is school age and I'm still kept awake some nights having flashbacks of childbirth. It was honestly hideous and I can't believe any woman wants to do it again.

My own sanity - parenting doesn't come naturally to me! So I find it much easier to give my all to one child. Lots of my friends have chosen not to have any kids at all and I find it much easier to socialise with them with my one child (walks, afternoons in the pub garden, bbqs, etc) whereas the friends who have 2+ kids never get invited to anything.

ringmybe11 · 20/11/2023 15:59

Mainly age for us I think. We both had long term previous relationships but no children so met when I was 35 and DH 42. Because we were both recently single when we met we dated and took our time settling down so had DS when I was 39 and DH 46. DS is 16 months now and the light of our lives but we're knackered, just feel like we're settling into routines of work, occasional hobbies etc. we both have siblings and I do feel bad that he will miss out on that but we knew before we had him that we only wanted one. The irony is that if we'd met 10 years prior I'd have likely wanted another child but our careers wouldn't have been as well established as they are now, so finances would have been a lot tighter.

soberfabulous · 20/11/2023 15:58

I'm a very happy only child and have a very happy only child!

DH has two siblings, one sister he never sees and one brother who is a massive prick that he hasn't spoken to for 20 years.

Siblings are no guarantee.

I love our peaceful happy life together: she has all of my time and attention. We have a great quality of life as not stretched financially with one.

My career has flourished as one gives much more flexibility when it comes to work.

I see harassed parents of multiples with chaos surrounding them and it's just not for me. At all.

MinnieMountain · 20/11/2023 15:54

I’m not particularly maternal either. I love our 10yo and don’t regret becoming a mother but I’m an introvert and just can’t imagine giving emotional support to more than one child.
Plus you never know what life’s going to throw at you (breast cancer at 39).

TropDrôle · 20/11/2023 15:46

Hoglet70 · 20/11/2023 15:12

I'm just not maternal and didn't want another one! Not all siblings get on either.

Me too. I hated it, the job of being a mum. It was boring, relentless and exhausting.

Shes 22 now and about to graduate law. Best thing I ever did was stick with one.

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:45

DeadButDelicious · 20/11/2023 15:09

Eleven years of unexplained infertility, the loss of our first daughter, resulting in PTSD, a difficult second pregnancy and so many external factors such as finances etc mean that we decided to not push our luck any further. There is no guarantee we would have been able to conceive anyway and my age was against me meaning I didn't have another potential 11 years in me too wait it out or the desire to put myself through anymore medical stuff. I will forever grieve our first daughter and as far as I am concerned I have 2 children, it's just that I only get to raise one. My DD is enough, I'm focussed on raising her to the best of my ability. I try not to get hung up on any hypothetical siblings. It won't do me or her any good. This is just how things have shook out for us.

I’m sorry you’ve had it so tough but so happy for you that you have your second DD, I’m sure your first DD will always be with you all. X

OP posts:
adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:43

Summermeadowflowers · 20/11/2023 15:25

I think that’s changing - I keep reading somewhat odd posts comparing having more than one child to infidelity in a marriage!

There are lots of benefits to only having one. I had another because I wanted one than to benefit ds!

Yes I’ve seen that! I suppose they were used to being no.1 & the attention divides by two overnight… which is surely positive for some children, but if the child is too young to understand I imagine they feel quite devastated! Even if for a short time

OP posts:
adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:42

Bosca · 20/11/2023 15:15

Never occurred to me to have another. For me, people having more than one child are making a slightly odd decision.

How do you mean?

OP posts:
adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:38

tokirara · 20/11/2023 15:27

You need to accept the possibility they they may oftentimes be alone, compared to children who are constantly surrounded by one or more siblings - but they needn't be lonely.

I grew up with several siblings but conversely felt very lonely at times.

We now have only one DC and are not having another one. Do I worry about their socialisation and life lessons they'll miss out on due to no siblings? Yes. Is it hard work to fill the gaps ourselves and having to fill the role of playmate sometimes rather than merely parent? Yes. However, DC is super happy and knows they're incredibly lucky and privileged the ways PP mentioned -
Physically
Mentally
Emotionally
Financially

We are also very clear between me and DH (and will be with DC when DC is older) that we have no expectations that DC will look after us when we're elderly as it's unfair for them to assume the solo caring burden. I suspect not everyone takes this view and some parents do intend to rely on their multiple children for care and support when they're elderly.

Thank you. I like that you outlined that to them, so they know you won’t be expecting it all to fall to them

OP posts:
tokirara · 20/11/2023 15:27

You need to accept the possibility they they may oftentimes be alone, compared to children who are constantly surrounded by one or more siblings - but they needn't be lonely.

I grew up with several siblings but conversely felt very lonely at times.

We now have only one DC and are not having another one. Do I worry about their socialisation and life lessons they'll miss out on due to no siblings? Yes. Is it hard work to fill the gaps ourselves and having to fill the role of playmate sometimes rather than merely parent? Yes. However, DC is super happy and knows they're incredibly lucky and privileged the ways PP mentioned -
Physically
Mentally
Emotionally
Financially

We are also very clear between me and DH (and will be with DC when DC is older) that we have no expectations that DC will look after us when we're elderly as it's unfair for them to assume the solo caring burden. I suspect not everyone takes this view and some parents do intend to rely on their multiple children for care and support when they're elderly.

Summermeadowflowers · 20/11/2023 15:25

Harshreality · 20/11/2023 15:17

Agree with @mrlistersgelfbride , brace for the overbearing and interfering opinions of others on how you simply MUST have another one.

I usually respond with, will you be donating your time, money and vagina for this suggestion?

I think that’s changing - I keep reading somewhat odd posts comparing having more than one child to infidelity in a marriage!

There are lots of benefits to only having one. I had another because I wanted one than to benefit ds!

nodogz · 20/11/2023 15:24

Unsupportive partner who decided not to work as a team and let me pick up most of the child rearing and housework. I was resentful and it really killed my sex drive. (No indication of this beforehand)

Job instability / panicking about career.

Serious autoimmune disease and the treatment was not compatible with a pregnancy. Alternatives were available but weren't shared with me by nhs drs.

But it is lovely having one. To know he doesn't feel rubbish in comparison to a sibling (like me) is very comforting. Personality wise, we are very similar and I think I could develop a bias if another kid came along. I'm a great mum to one and think I could only achieve good mum to two or more.

user1497207191 · 20/11/2023 15:22

We only have one. We tried (not much) for a second, but it didn't happen and we're really not bothered. We had pressure from our parents to have more than one as they were "Only ones" and they really thought they'd missed out, and they hated the idea of their grandchild being an only one.

But, we were aware of the issues and did our utmost to "socialise" him with friends etc. Have to admit, he was a bit of a "loner" during his teenage years, but we've always had a great "grown up" relationship with him, and we think he "grew up" much quicker than his peers/friends and matured quicker. We did loads of things with him, took him places, facilitated his hobbies, etc. He's now got loads of friends, and he says he doesn't miss not having a sibling as he knows no different - a fair few of his friends are "Only ones" too!!

Neither me nor OH have much contact with our respective siblings, just birthday and christmas cards really, neither of us have anything in common with them. I think we both "tolerated" our siblings as children rather than actually liking them or doing things with them. I think both sets of parents pushed us together too much, made us do things together, etc., to make up for them not having siblings and "missing out" as they saw it.

At the end of the day, lots of siblings don't have much in common, some have outright fallen out, some move away, etc. I think the key thing is for parents of only ones to make a bit of extra effort to arrange play dates etc in early years, and then to encourage hobbies/socialising etc in the teen years, to give them the opportunity to forge good friendships, or at least have interests to keep them busy and interested.

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:22

And I’ve shared these concerns with people in real life and they say, you can make it work… you just cut your cloth, have a shorter second maternity leave, live in a cheaper area, don’t holiday. None of those things do I feel overly willing to do though if it can be avoided as it sounds miserable. We don’t earn terribly but also aren’t rolling in it and will probably never earn more than 80k combined.

OP posts:
adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 15:20

Thanks everyone it’s interesting to read so far. I think the problem is I always dreamed about having a huge family as I am very maternal, but the realities of things are a lot different. Nursery fees alone for 4-5 years will be 50k. New shoes every 2-3 months. It’s all a lot and yes you can do it cheaply but I don’t want to be fraught, frazzled, never have any time to myself at all and worried about money. This particularly resonates with me since I don’t overly get on with my own sister. Age isn’t a factor for us hugely as we are only in our mid 20s - but all the practicalities remain whether you’re having a baby at 23 or 43.

OP posts: