Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you chose to stick with just one DC

108 replies

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 14:54

Curious. After lots of soul searching we think practically this would be best for our family but the biggest factor keeping us on the fence is that we wouldn’t want them to be lonely and miss out on valuable life lessons that a sibling can bring.

Every other reason though points towards having one for us: finances are FAR easier (childcare is so extortionate!), energy, time for one another, maintaining careers, house size, providing support for DC when they become an adult with things like house deposit, driving lessons, uni, wedding

It’s so tricky to know what’s best and what you will/won’t regret

OP posts:
jamstead · 20/11/2023 22:35

The lifestyle suits me. I have one at school now and I get plenty of time to myself as a sahm. I can focus on my DD and ferry her to whatever activities she likes without any clashes or dragging on a sibling. Sit down with her and supervise homework and piano practice and not have to do it for any more children. Much less conflict in the household and easy to accommodate her wishes and my own, no juggling. Nice lifestyle with better holidays, trips and other experiences than we'd afford with more dc. Everything is calm at home and there are very few arguments.

LillyLeaf · 20/11/2023 22:27

SquashPenguin · 20/11/2023 17:25

It’s cost £30k in ivf just to get pregnant with my first. Definitely not having another.

Same, we can't do that again. I would have loved another if we were younger but the thought of going through miscarriages and ivf again is too much. DS is everything to me, I really don't need another one.

CB2611 · 20/11/2023 21:59

I wanted 2 children. When I had my first, I bought all big things in neutral colours to reuse them for my second, regardless of babys gender. My DP and I had a conversation out of the blue one day and decided we wouldn't have anymore children. I always thought that would disappoint me but I actually felt relieved in a weird way. I'm just settled and happy with the decision. My daughter has always been easy. Easy pregnancy with barely any sickness, planned c'section due to her being breach so no labour pains or complications, easy baby who slept through the night from 8 weeks and no terrible 2s (although we are now enduring terrible 3s). I knew that it wouldn't be so easy second time around and I didn't know how I'd cope with a less easy baby plus a toddler when given the easy child I'd been given was still hard enough!

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 21:37

ELMhouse · 20/11/2023 20:59

There is no right or wrong only what is right for your family.

for example I could tell you I have three daughters, my eldest is 18 and just headed off to uni and I can’t imagine being without any other kids now at home (having said that I’m only just 40 so most of my friends still have primary or early secondary age kids), but that’s just me, other might think wow amazing house back to ourselves again etc etc. Or ‘three girls’ would be some people’s less than ideal set up for example! 🤷🏼‍♀️

I didn’t have my second until my eldest was 6 as I was happy with one then suddenly had the urge to have another (then another), but again this was right for us.

I am one of 4 and I am very close to my siblings and all my cousins and nieces and nephews and I think this idea of a big happy family appealed to me.

however nothing is ever guaranteed so follow your own heart as much as you can.

I’m sure whatever you chose will work out for the best as this is what will be best for you.

Edited

Thank you. Love how balanced this is. X

OP posts:
adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 21:05

bookworm14 · 20/11/2023 20:53

And can I just say how refreshing it is that no one has yet come onto the thread and told us how selfish and awful we all are?

Yes! Was unexpected

OP posts:
ELMhouse · 20/11/2023 20:59

There is no right or wrong only what is right for your family.

for example I could tell you I have three daughters, my eldest is 18 and just headed off to uni and I can’t imagine being without any other kids now at home (having said that I’m only just 40 so most of my friends still have primary or early secondary age kids), but that’s just me, other might think wow amazing house back to ourselves again etc etc. Or ‘three girls’ would be some people’s less than ideal set up for example! 🤷🏼‍♀️

I didn’t have my second until my eldest was 6 as I was happy with one then suddenly had the urge to have another (then another), but again this was right for us.

I am one of 4 and I am very close to my siblings and all my cousins and nieces and nephews and I think this idea of a big happy family appealed to me.

however nothing is ever guaranteed so follow your own heart as much as you can.

I’m sure whatever you chose will work out for the best as this is what will be best for you.

bookworm14 · 20/11/2023 20:53

And can I just say how refreshing it is that no one has yet come onto the thread and told us how selfish and awful we all are?

bookworm14 · 20/11/2023 20:48

I am a mum of one and often post on these threads when they come up. My reasons for sticking with one are:

  1. I haven’t felt even slightly broody since DD (now 8) was born. We have a lovely life and it doesn’t feel like there is anyone ‘missing’ from our family.
  2. I have a chronic illness which means I am tired a lot of the time. I think I would struggle to cope physically with more than one child.
  3. I am extremely introverted and dislike too much noise and mess.
  4. We would struggle financially.
  5. I have a sibling with severe disabilities and know for a fact that I wouldn’t cope with that myself. Having a second seems like an unnecessary roll of the dice.

I do sometimes feel guilty at not ‘providing’ a sibling, but I also believe strongly that every child should be as wanted as my DD was, and not just provided as a service to an existing child.

LindorDoubleChoc · 20/11/2023 20:35

Yabu.

Mumofonlyone · 20/11/2023 20:34

All of the reasons you listed in your OP. DS is 22, we've helped with driving lessons, uni, house deposit. We could never have done this with more DC. Also our house is too small for more than one.
I think he's well adjusted enough...living with gf, decent friend group, graduate etc etc. And as pp have said, I have a brother but barely see him/ speak to him and had very little in common as children/ teenagers.

bippityboppity87 · 20/11/2023 20:25

I only have one DC. And I don't plan on having anymore. He has ASD, which obviously comes with its own challenges. I don't think he's missing out on anything. Has plenty of cousins he sees regularly and it means I can focus my attention on him and only him. He's 7. Also makes birthdays and Christmas easier

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 20:24

singlemum93 · 20/11/2023 20:16

Everything you mention, finances, cost of childcare, living space, the thought of doing it all again. I honestly don't think I can handle anymore sleepless nights. My DS is constantly ill.. I'm always having to stay off work to take care of him it depends how much support you have around you also. I can't say I've enjoyed being a parent enough to want to do it again sadly

I understand what you mean! My cousins toddler DC is always poorly

OP posts:
singlemum93 · 20/11/2023 20:16

Everything you mention, finances, cost of childcare, living space, the thought of doing it all again. I honestly don't think I can handle anymore sleepless nights. My DS is constantly ill.. I'm always having to stay off work to take care of him it depends how much support you have around you also. I can't say I've enjoyed being a parent enough to want to do it again sadly

FloraSpoke · 20/11/2023 20:06

For us, a combination of factors:

6 Year fertility struggle to have our DS (2) involving significant trauma: struggle to conceive, treatment for pre-cancerous cell changes after routine smear test, miscarriages when we eventually did conceive, disastrous round of IVF on the NHS which ended up in my developing sepsis and nearly dying, then finally private IVF during the pandemic at a cost of £££

Result of long delay being that I was 39 and DH 46 when DS was born so we would
be significantly older parents and DH says he feels too old for another

Significant PPH when DS was 6 days old which resulted in my losing at least 2.5 litres of blood, being blue lighted to hospital in the middle of the night and needing emergency surgery and blood transfusion… am lucky to be here. Would be at risk of another PPH if we had a second. DH traumatised by this and struggled with mental health in first few months after our son born

No family support with childcare

We can afford lots of extra mural activities for 1 and possibly private school which we wouldn’t be able to do with 2.

Concannon88 · 20/11/2023 20:04

I think it may be more valuable to ask why people had more than one

xyz111 · 20/11/2023 19:49

I only have one. We just couldn't manage work and childcare as don't have much support. I was worried about the same thing, but then I'm not close to my brother at all.

Younghearts · 20/11/2023 19:37

For me personally if someone’s reasoning is having another child because they want their only child to have a sibling I say DO NOT DO IT! That is not a good enough reason.

If you reason was because you really want another, you think you could afford it, you have the space etc I’d say do it but from your OP I think right now the answer should be a no.

Orangeandgold · 20/11/2023 19:32

Had one and happy with my life as it’s going - I have so many other things to focus on that I’m grateful with one.

plus raising children in the city is pricy.

MRSMTO · 20/11/2023 19:14

Because the one we do have cost almost 50k to make!

SquashPenguin · 20/11/2023 19:00

@adotonthespectrum I had one cycle on the nhs which resulted in a miscarriage. None of my cycles ever produced enough embryos to have anything frozen, so every attempt was the cost of a full cycle, plus all the medication and testing. It’s ridiculous! I can’t ever put myself through it again.

Turnoffthelight · 20/11/2023 18:58

Always thought I wanted 2 children but needed IVF to have DD and wasn’t going to go through that again!
Now she’s 5, I love having just one.
She gets all our attention, can afford for her to do several hobbies, easy for us to take it in turns for some downtime and the 3 of us are so close. I spend time with friends who have more than one and it all seems so chaotic! Not for me!
I think having one is the best!

searchfortruth · 20/11/2023 18:49

Money
My age
Awful birth
Too many people on the planet already

Panda89 · 20/11/2023 18:46

We have just the one DD (7).
Reasons for this are financial, we have a comfortable life and enjoy holidays etc. We didn’t want to stretch ourselves having another child and not being able to give them so many nice experiences.

Childcare - we are lucky to have both sets of grandparents keen to look after DD so we can have weekends away etc. That would become much harder to organise with more children.

Work - I can quite easily fit DD various school plays/clubs/swimming around my WFH job. Again this would be much harder with more children.

I am an only child and my mum is also an only child so it is very normal to me. I had a lovely time growing up and never wanted a sibling as I saw my best friends and their sisters fight so much.

GreyhpundGirl · 20/11/2023 18:32

We were ambivalent about having any, so one is an achievement. My pregnancy and birth were straightforward but I can't imagine choosing to go through that again. My daughter is 3 and is a pretty easy child but throwing a newborn into the mix would alter the family dynamic to a detrimental effect. We can afford lots of activities, and to travel. We don't have any family support nearby to help with childcare. Having an only was t really a conscious decision- it's just how it was going to be if that makes sense.

adotonthespectrum · 20/11/2023 18:26

myotherkidisacassowary · 20/11/2023 18:12

I’m undecided like you. I have a pros and cons list:

cons:

I am physically damaged in quite significant ways from birth and this would likely get worse if I had a second

I hated being pregnant

I felt like I nearly died from sleep deprivation in the first year when my baby would wake up screaming every hour of the night without fail

I had terrible post partum anxiety

We can afford private school, good holidays etc with one but would struggle to do so with two

pros:

after the first year things got so much easier and my son now is the most perfect delight. I have so much fun with him, he’s so enjoyable to be around. If I could be given baby #2 at 12 months I wouldn’t hesitate

I’m good at parenting and I find it very fulfilling

I have very close and loving relationships with my siblings and would hate to be without them. I would like my son to have the opportunity of the same.

The cons list is longer than the pros but the pros are more powerful. It’s a very difficult choice. I would mourn not having a second, but I also don’t know how would get through another ‘year one’, especially with another child to look after too.

I don’t know how to make the decision!

So hard to choose isn’t it.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread