Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not commit to school runs for other kid

228 replies

oepeabsin · 20/11/2023 13:10

DD has a friend who has little other social contact except her. We have had a few play dates at soft play etc. Parents want to apply for all the same schools as us even though they are way out of catchment and would never have even thought of them if we weren't applying..recently lots of hints being dropped about sharing drop off and pick ups if they get into the same school.
Which won't benefit me as I have a flexi job and my mum to do the days I can't but would them for two days a week.
AIBU to say don't apply for the same school on the basis that I will be doing the school runs on their working days?
Also they live about 20 mins in opposite direction to school so would add about an hour on to my school run due to traffic and I am not keen on their child at all as she is rude and doesn't like DD to play with any other kids. It's all about what benefits them and their child and nothing about us or our child.
DH is a safeguarding lead and wouldn't want them to pick up DD anyway as we don't know them well enough to entrust them with our child and there is a long history of mental illness with them too.
Wtf do I say? I'm starting to avoid a bit and not commit to which school we will chose.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/11/2023 15:33

Sorry to hear about your dad, OP Flowers

On the "hints" about lifts I'd bring it out into the open and ask nicely how she's planning to get her DC there since it's quite a distance. If she then says something about car shares, that's your opportunity to reply "I'm afraid that won't work for us"

No need to elaborate, make excuses, hide away or make things more complicated; just be kind but frank and shut this down

LikeaHurricane · 20/11/2023 15:30

oepeabsin · 20/11/2023 13:45

@ManchesterLu
Yes it is bonkers, which is why it worries me they will copy us. I used to be an assistant head pre-DD and the school on their road is excellent, lots of very happy parents I know. But I think they aren't happy with the after school hours

OP, I agree with others who have advised that this needs nipping in the bud right away. Just remember, you will have dealt with more difficult situations than this previously and no doubt will do so in the future, so you CAN do this.
Also, do you think the other parents will be taking your familiy's feelings, needs, situation etc, into account the way you are doing theirs?They definitely won't be. They sound like they are CF's
Their working/childcare situation is not your problem or responsibility. I would have hated to commit to this and would only have been resentful if I had. (I'm not saying you would be resentful towards them or their child, but it's worth considering...that would not be a nice experience for you or anyone else)

My advice would be to tell them in no uncertain terms that you wouldn't ever want to have this agreement with anyone. It's not something you've ever considered previously and you're not about to. You don't have to give any reasons, so don't. They'll only latch onto them anyway. Just make it really clear. The worst case scenario is that DD doesn't see as much of the other little girl, but that's a small price to pay.

Wanttobekind · 20/11/2023 15:26

As everyone else has said, distance yourself from the CFs! “That doesn’t work for me” is one of my favourite phrases - my in my head version is a variation on “not my circus, not my monkeys” or “your lack of planning does not constitute my emergency”. There’s friends you put yourself out for and then there’s everyone else.

billy1966 · 20/11/2023 15:16

CleptoCleoCookoo · 20/11/2023 14:26

You need to nip this in the bud now, because otherwise you're going to have it hanging over you, and despite your DH's waffly "oh i'm sure it'll be fine/not happen", that doesn't really help with the ambiguity going on.

For them, and you, you need to make it 100% clear, politely, that this won't be happening.

"Hi, just to confirm after we discussed school applications this week/last week/whenever - to be clear: we won't be sharing school runs with anyone and we're making our own arrangements xx"

Just write it clearly, without any room for "but what if"... nonsense.

OP, stop dithering here and just cut it off at the root.

If you and DH need to work on boundaries, this is a great time to start.

And TBH the relationship doesn't sound healthy or one i'd want to encourage for my DD so i'm wondering why you're even keeping it going - it's sometimes not enough that your DD might want to keep a friend that she gets on with. Your job as a parent is to manuver her through challenges and develop her resilience, but at such a young age, reducing contact with children who aren't a good role model or influence is a good move - i'm wondering if you're such a people pleaser you can't think clearly about WTF you're doing here. (I mean that nicely, i used to be a people pleaser until it absolutely broke me, now i realise that being seen as "rude" is mostly just "other people walking over you".)

Excellent post.
Read and re read OP.

You have 7 years ahead of you.
Children change their friends easily at this age.
You do not want to be entangled with anyones arrangements.
What about extra curricular activities that might arise?
What about other play dates with other children?
What about sick days?
They want you tied to them two days a week, why would you do that?
These are plain garden variety CF's looking for free convenient childcare.

These people will mishear you.
You need to send a clear unambiguous text that you will not be involving yourself in their lifts or childcare, no apology.
Just that it will not be happening.

This child is not a good fit with yours and actively interferes with her interactions with others.

You are setting her and yourself up for a whole load of grief by not distancing yourself from them now.

Be unavailable.

So what if your daughter likes this child, you are her parent and can see that this whole set up is not in your very small childs best interests.

Fill her time with other friends and activities and move on from these people who will be nothing more than users if you give them a chance.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 20/11/2023 15:15

Oh and if they do get into the same school and there is more than one class per year group, ask for the other girl to be in the other class!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 20/11/2023 15:15

I'd just distance yourself.

You don't owe this mother anything. So what if they lose a place at a local school because they are holding out for you to do their school runs. Their problem. That's what comes of being CFs.

I'd not get involved at all, apply to the schools you want to apply to and move on.

I can't see how they'd get into a school (at least) 20 minutes drive from them unless the catchments are very odd. But if they do, and then talk about sharing lifts, then you say "no we don't want to get into that sort of commitment, we've our own lives to coordinate".

itsmyp4rty · 20/11/2023 15:13

Tell them your top choice is the school on their road. Then when your dd gets into a different school you can say you didn't get your first choice. I would also start distancing yourself from them as they sounds like hard work.

LookItsMeAgain · 20/11/2023 15:11

MzHz · 20/11/2023 14:50

100% this

@oepeabsin just be honest! “Look friend, I’m hearing the hints and mentions about sharing lifts if your dd gets into x school, and just need to be clear that I won’t be able or willing to entertain any kind of shared lift scenario for the school run. I have my own life etc to juggle and can’t be beholden to the routines of others. If you’re considering the school and making me part of your school run plan, please don’t. I won’t be able to accommodate this”

This suggested text absolutely clears up any ambiguity in the situation and still remains polite and friendly.

LookItsMeAgain · 20/11/2023 15:10

Firstly, if reading the number of threads on MN is any sort of a gauge, your DH will not be involved in the dropping off or collecting so of course he would say don't say anything until we know the situation. It's not going to impact on him at all (or if it is, it'll probably be a very infrequent thing).
Next, if you don't say something to them now and they get accepted to the school nearest them but they decline that on the off chance they get accepted into the school that your DD goes to (also with the not so subtle hints of you doing pick up and dropping off), that could result in them losing a place in the school nearest them so you have to say something.

I would use some form of the suggestions above but instead of saying "Oh that doesn't work for us" say something like "Oh, you must have got the wrong end of the stick there. I can't do dropping off and/or collecting of little Alice (no idea of the child's name) as we already have our childminding sorted out so you'll have to find someone else or do it yourself" or better yet try to guide them in the direction of getting their child into the other school to broaden their social circle, and it will be with other children in their immediate locality so its more than likely going to be something that can expand over time.

You can still remain friends with them but their child and yours will be expanding their circle of friends themselves. It might end up that this particular friendship fizzles out because their child is so busy with their new friends from school.

Have they given you any indication as to why they want to follow your child to the same school (apart from the friendship element)?

HardcoreLadyType · 20/11/2023 15:07

You’re not responsible for their assumptions.

If they come out and ask, then you can give a direct answer.

If the topic comes up, you can be more explicit.

As suggested by PP, you could try to bring the subject up, but if you do, you must make sure you are clear with them.

It sounds like both your DH and you have been caught on the hop with this a little, and you both need to be ready with a clear answer if they make vague comments again.

Crumpleton · 20/11/2023 14:59

I would just mention in conversation that she must have some patience choosing a school so far away, followed by saying you couldn't be doing with sitting in all the traffic twice a day, far to busy for all that faff so it'll be the nearest one and that's it.

Xiaoxiong · 20/11/2023 14:58

I agree with everyone saying that you've got to be direct. If they get the hump with you, it sounds like no great loss anyway.

I've been in various school run lift shares over the last 6 years and the only ones that have worked out have been the ones where a) there is strict 50/50 sharing of lifts, b) where they live so close that it's not out of either of our way and c) where we can be completely honest in terms of communication, so I know the other family won't get offended if I say I can't do more than 2 lifts a week or can't swap the days around.

And definitely don't say emergencies as their perception of what an emergency is may be very different to yours!

NunsKnickers · 20/11/2023 14:56

Some people are ridiculous. Assuming lifts, choosing a school based on which one you've chosen. So irrational.

2024writeanovel · 20/11/2023 14:55

Just be honest say it’s making you stressed and uncomfortable thinking about logistics and you have sorted your own childcare with your mother and you would appreciate that you are excluded from any plans regarding school pick ups and drop off lane in the future as it is having a negative effect on what should be a happy part of your child’s experience starting school.

housethatbuiltme · 20/11/2023 14:52

If you they live nowhere near you or the school why would the even suggest any of that?

It just doesn't make sense, the school wouldn't accept them anyway unless theres more to the story.

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/11/2023 14:52

Beautiful3 · 20/11/2023 14:35

Honestly I'd nip it in the bud now. I'd message saying, "hi I thought about what you said regarding shared school run. I'm really sorry but I'm not able to, because my mum is doing most of mine, and it wouldn't be fair to ask her to have another child too. So sorry. I've looked into x school near you. Its actually a really good school, how come you're not thinking of there?"

This

Tbh unlikely she will get into the one near you if 20min drive

SamPoodle123 · 20/11/2023 14:51

I would just be honest and say why you can not share the school run. Say, you just can not commit to driving an extra hour for the school run, as they do not live close by and also do not want the responsibility of another dc.

cantseethetrees · 20/11/2023 14:50

And another thing, again speaking from experience, do not say you will cover for emergencies etc as you may find they experience "emergencies" on a regular basis!

MzHz · 20/11/2023 14:50

Notjustfish · 20/11/2023 13:12

I would send a text message now just to make it clear.

100% this

@oepeabsin just be honest! “Look friend, I’m hearing the hints and mentions about sharing lifts if your dd gets into x school, and just need to be clear that I won’t be able or willing to entertain any kind of shared lift scenario for the school run. I have my own life etc to juggle and can’t be beholden to the routines of others. If you’re considering the school and making me part of your school run plan, please don’t. I won’t be able to accommodate this”

shams05 · 20/11/2023 14:49

I think you do have to mention that you'll not be available for lifts but just want to reassure you that if school places are in demand they'll probably not get a look in at a primary further away from them. It would be wiser for them to put their nearest school as first choice than one further away as they may get stuck with one that they'd never have even considered if the closer schools are all filled by people who put them down as first choice.
I know with my eldest, our school choices were tactically chosen so we had the best likelihood of getting in atleast one of our preferred schools.

Bournetilly · 20/11/2023 14:47

YANBU and you definitely need to tell them you won’t be doing this.

To be honest I’d be tempted to tell them I was changing the first choice of school to somewhere else (then they would have to arrange their own pick ups and drop offs or could choose another school if they were only choosing that one because you were). Tell them your putting the school as your 2nd or 3rd choice then when your DD gets in say you didn’t get your 1st choice. Hopefully they will of sorted something by then or changed their minds.

Seascape1325 · 20/11/2023 14:46

I would just say as DH is a safeguarding lead your unable to share lifts unfortunately. Thanks for the suggestion but you hope they can find another solution.

Simple and as it's a work related reason they can't say anything. I know people that have used this as a reason before and it is valid.

SageLavenderThyme · 20/11/2023 14:46

I would just say, best not to base school applications on the idea you'll be sharing lifts as you won't be able to share lifts.

purplecorkheart · 20/11/2023 14:44

Also be prepared that they might suggest that they/get someone to drop their DD to your house and that you do the school run from there. I might be overthinking but better to be clear now that you will not being doing school/runs or drops regardless of what excuses or help they come up with.

Hunkydory99 · 20/11/2023 14:43

Are they outright asking OP or just dropping hints? If outright as others have said a simple ‘that won’t work for us’ or ‘I can’t commit to anything right now’. If hinting dont commit or makes negative noises or comments

Swipe left for the next trending thread