Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not pick 4 year old DD from school?

444 replies

marshyrun · 20/11/2023 11:10

DD2 is 4 and in reception. She’s had the usual on off cough / colds since starting in September and is just coming to the end of a bad cold, she went to school throughout with me just giving her calpol in the mornings.

She woke up today absolutely fine, had breakfast, in good spirits. Still a slight cough but had some calcough before leaving.

School have just called to say her teacher has said she’s not herself, they checked her temp (all fine), she doesn’t feel sick or anything, they’ve said she’s just being quiet and clingy and not enthusiastic about participating in some of the activities. They’ve asked me to come and collect her if she’s still being “clingy” after lunch.

AIBU to not pick her up unless she’s actually poorly? I’m the first one to drive to school if my child is poorly but this doesn’t seem to be the case today. She’s naturally shy and quiet anyway so her being reserved is not out of character at all!

OP posts:
BumpyaDaisyevna · 22/11/2023 07:20

If school call it's real! You should collect her.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 22/11/2023 07:12

momonpurpose · 22/11/2023 02:27

That's the great thing about mumsnet! All the different opinions! Have a lovely dayCarpediemmakeitcount ❤️

I have a lovely day everyday because my conscience is clear and I understand families who are struggling and living on the breadline in this cost of living crisis. I tend to think more broadly and critically when I give my opinion.

violetcuriosity · 22/11/2023 07:11

If you're DD is usually shy and reserved and is now standing out from a group of 30 4 year olds as more so, she must be quite poorly. When I was teaching KS1 I used to have parents complaining that we hadn't picked up on their children's colds quick enough and we had to explain that there are so many of them that unless they tell us or they're noticeably struggling it's just impossible to notice every single time. My point is, she must be pretty bad for them to have phoned you. Also, she's just a baby, she needs you. Why should school look after your ill child? Poor teacher, hopefully she has a robust immune system!

blackfluffycat · 22/11/2023 07:01

The amount of times my dds have come home from school saying they felt ill but school wouldn't phone me!!

I even send in notes (if there seem well enough but slightly off) incase they want to come home.

School never call me and I so wish they would.

Although if you are at work I can understand your frustration and you seem to think it could be her anxiety not a physical illness? So if you collect her she will know what to do to stay home.

I used to tell my mum I was unwell as I didn't know how to explain I was sad / worried / lonely.

KJKB · 22/11/2023 06:53

So, your child has been under the weather for a while, their school phones because they're concerned about her, but rather than immediately going to pick up your poor 4 year old so that they can rest at home in a safe, quiet, loving environment, you hit the internet for an AIBU post? It was very unreasonable... in fact a better question would have been AITA, and the answer would still be yes. Your kid needed you.

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 22/11/2023 06:26

Speaking from a teachers point of view. We don’t want to send children home and don’t do it lightly but when we can tell that they aren’t being how they normally are at school that does make us keep an extra eye. Then if this doesn’t improve we send them to the first aid trained staff in the office who make a judgement as to whether to send them home. You need to get your DD

Dinobot · 22/11/2023 06:20

In addition, I would take her to the GP to listen to her chest if she's had a cough she can't shake since September (!) Or even just more than a few weeks requiring calpol. Reception is brutal for kids in terms of tiredness and immune system. Sounds like she needs a sofa day to rest and recover too.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 22/11/2023 03:34

Mrgwl29 · 21/11/2023 16:03

@Caplin does the vicks on the feet work??? My 18 month old is always up and grizzly with nasal drip and coughs lately and I'll try anything!

When you say Nasal Drip, do you mean Post Nasal Drip down their throat?

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 22/11/2023 03:17

You quite literally said she is now dead

AIBU to not pick 4 year old DD from school?
PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 22/11/2023 03:12

Goldbar · 20/11/2023 13:22

YANBU. I was called last term to collect a bouncing 5yo who "looked a little quiet and wan" in class. They soon cheered up when we went out to an adventure playground, visited a farm park and had ice cream 😂. I told the teacher where we'd been the next day and funnily enough DC wasn't sent home again that term.

I agree with @GotMooMilk and @bahhamburgers . Especially in the winter months when there are so many cold and bugs about, I don't think just generally "under the weather" is sufficient excuse to miss school/be sent home, otherwise some children would constantly be off and some parents wouldn't be able to hold down a job. Days off should be reserved for when children are actually unwell.

Wan?

momonpurpose · 22/11/2023 02:27

Carpediemmakeitcount · 21/11/2023 17:35

That comment on its own says a lot about society.

That's the great thing about mumsnet! All the different opinions! Have a lovely dayCarpediemmakeitcount ❤️

Spicastar · 22/11/2023 01:21

[edit: read all the updates, you did the right thing]

Smallerthannormalpeople · 22/11/2023 00:08

What kind of parent doses their child up every morning before school and then refuses to pick them up when the school requests them to? Sure sounds like a neglectful parent to me. You seriously need to rethink your priorities.

Fluffybunniesandkittens · 21/11/2023 23:29

I have 1 dc that copes very well with coughs and colds and still attends school. The other dc gets really poorly with coughs and colds and is not well enough to go to school for 1 or sometimes 2 weeks.
If children are well enough to be at school with or without medicine then they should go to school. Most schools are even happy for a parent to come at lunchtime to give them another dose of calpol.
As for spreading germs. That is how children build up their immune system.
The first time school called me to collect either dc and it turned out that actually they wasn't poorly enough to need to be at home and they wanted to do something fun, I told them that if they are poorly enough to stay home, then they are poorly enough to need to be in bed. Which is where they stayed apart from meal times. They both would rather stay at school than try to blag a home day.
The 1 that does genuinely get very ill, does get to have a duvet day watching movies if awake. It's obvious that it's genuine illness and not put on.

Jellytot1234 · 21/11/2023 22:07

The school would not be benefiting from your child going home…. Because they have a whole class of other children so you are being totally unreasonable to think they are pulling the wool over your eyes.

Poor little girl having a mum lacking any compassion at all. She’s 4 for goodness sake! Sometimes children don’t have to have a temperature or be throwing up every 5 minutes to be poorly!!

Findinganewme · 21/11/2023 21:24

I have a 4 year old. When she’s unwell, I go into overdrive in trying to get her to rest and recover, with lots of nutrients packed in.

  1. why are you giving her calpol if she’s ’absolutely fine’? Calpol is for pain and fever, which one does she have? If she has fever, she shouldn’t be in school. If she’s in pain, it’s going to deplete her, she will be clingy. She needs some rest.

  2. it’s now November. Her teacher will know her well enough to understand that your daughter is not her usual self. If your daughter is run down, uncomfortable, or Just not well, she will be clingy. She is obviously seeking comfort. This is why they’re asking you to comfort your daughter and allow her to recover.

  3. if you are working in a high pressured, unforgiving environment, I understand how stressful it can be. It’s not easy. Your daughter will do much better after some time to recover.

bahhamburgers · 21/11/2023 21:14

Honestly, I felt for some of the parents. I really understood the frustration sometimes.

One child in particular would get upset after drop off and was one of those children who vomited when they cried hard (one of mine is just the same).

The first term this happened almost every time they were dropped off. So they were sent to me with the teacher insisting they were ill and had to stay home for 48 hours.

The poor parents. Obviously, the child wasn’t ill. They knew they did this when they cried and explained it to the teacher. My own child was prone to the same thing. No one saw sense. attendance was dire because they kept making me send them home for 48 hours as per school rules even though once they had calmed down in my office doing puzzles, they were fine. The parents would be so angry at me when I had to keep informing them attendance was dropping - no shit. It was just horrific and an absolute joke.

(This isn’t outing for them. It was years ago and I’ve not even named gender).

Mumto2kids86 · 21/11/2023 20:49

She’s 4 and you know she’s been poorly. Ffs. Are you serious?

JSMill · 21/11/2023 20:35

marshyrun · 20/11/2023 11:10

DD2 is 4 and in reception. She’s had the usual on off cough / colds since starting in September and is just coming to the end of a bad cold, she went to school throughout with me just giving her calpol in the mornings.

She woke up today absolutely fine, had breakfast, in good spirits. Still a slight cough but had some calcough before leaving.

School have just called to say her teacher has said she’s not herself, they checked her temp (all fine), she doesn’t feel sick or anything, they’ve said she’s just being quiet and clingy and not enthusiastic about participating in some of the activities. They’ve asked me to come and collect her if she’s still being “clingy” after lunch.

AIBU to not pick her up unless she’s actually poorly? I’m the first one to drive to school if my child is poorly but this doesn’t seem to be the case today. She’s naturally shy and quiet anyway so her being reserved is not out of character at all!

Why wouldn't you pick her up? She sounds quite unwell.

Lachimolala · 21/11/2023 20:32

bahhamburgers · 21/11/2023 13:28

Yes, that used to drive me insane. I was the one who had to call parents to come and collect when teachers kept sending them to me to be sent home (after the head insisted that children should be given calpol and sent in), and got shitty if I said they were fine to go back to class, and as welfare AND attendance officer, I then had to call a lot of those poor parents and stress them out about attendance.

I had a lot of parents telling me I had a fucking cheek as well as the head having a go at me for sending kids home and ruining his attendance (and his bonus), and on the other hand, I had teachers bitching at me when I didn’t.

I had to sit in attendance meeting while parents shouted at me and then when they left, have SLT bollock me too. I couldn’t do right in that job for doing wrong.

3 years I did that bloody job before I snapped and walked out one day.

Well that’s just awful, so sorry you had deal with such nonsense from staff and parents!

Carpediemmakeitcount · 21/11/2023 19:53

Parker231 · 21/11/2023 19:16

Agreed. The OP has said her DD didn’t have a temperature, slight cough and was coming to the end of a cold. Normal for many children throughout the winter. Can’t imagine many employers being happy if you left work to collect in these circumstances. I’d have waited until the end of the school day. By the time I’d have got to school, it would probably be the end of the school day.

Exactly! Posters on here have called her neglectful because she is a struggling single parent with no support. I have known teachers to go to work with a bad cold. It's just a cold you have to work through it.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 21/11/2023 19:46

Concannon88 · 21/11/2023 19:03

The schools I have worked in would class not collecting an unwell child as neglect. School is not childcare, where they will look after them in almost all circumstances. News flash I've had to work too and have no one to ask to collect my child from school either, I never questioned collecting my unwell child when literally asked to. If op is hesitating because of work then she needs to check her priorities or change to a more flexible job, as I mentioned school is for learning not childcare.

Do you want to pay for a course and help her to get a better job with better working conditions or help her to become self-employed by offering a loan?

You're an angel in disguise 😇

Parker231 · 21/11/2023 19:16

Jizzle · 20/11/2023 14:18

I'm going to take the opposite view to most here, if I got the same call there is no way I would be picking my DD up. I am in work, 1hr30 minutes away from her school, working in a high pressure job, i'm not going to take the afternoon off because she is 'clingy'!

If they said she had fallen and hit her head or something, sure, work would understand, I would be there as quickly as possible, but in this instance they would just have to wait until normal pick up time.

Agreed. The OP has said her DD didn’t have a temperature, slight cough and was coming to the end of a cold. Normal for many children throughout the winter. Can’t imagine many employers being happy if you left work to collect in these circumstances. I’d have waited until the end of the school day. By the time I’d have got to school, it would probably be the end of the school day.

Concannon88 · 21/11/2023 19:03

The schools I have worked in would class not collecting an unwell child as neglect. School is not childcare, where they will look after them in almost all circumstances. News flash I've had to work too and have no one to ask to collect my child from school either, I never questioned collecting my unwell child when literally asked to. If op is hesitating because of work then she needs to check her priorities or change to a more flexible job, as I mentioned school is for learning not childcare.

Concannon88 · 21/11/2023 18:59

So you want your child in an environment where they arent equipped to feal with her. Why does your job take president over theirs? OP started this thread by saying she'd been unwell and dosed up on calpol. Clearly she was being clingy because she was unwell.