Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not pick 4 year old DD from school?

444 replies

marshyrun · 20/11/2023 11:10

DD2 is 4 and in reception. She’s had the usual on off cough / colds since starting in September and is just coming to the end of a bad cold, she went to school throughout with me just giving her calpol in the mornings.

She woke up today absolutely fine, had breakfast, in good spirits. Still a slight cough but had some calcough before leaving.

School have just called to say her teacher has said she’s not herself, they checked her temp (all fine), she doesn’t feel sick or anything, they’ve said she’s just being quiet and clingy and not enthusiastic about participating in some of the activities. They’ve asked me to come and collect her if she’s still being “clingy” after lunch.

AIBU to not pick her up unless she’s actually poorly? I’m the first one to drive to school if my child is poorly but this doesn’t seem to be the case today. She’s naturally shy and quiet anyway so her being reserved is not out of character at all!

OP posts:
Humphhhh · 22/11/2023 12:01

Maxus · 22/11/2023 10:27

The teachers also need to protect the rest of the class from illness and also protect themselves. The teacher carnt teach if they are ill themselves due to parents who send their child in sick. They also carnt care for sick children while they teach the class.

That only applies to notifiable diseases. Coughs, colds and Covid are not listed. Of course teachers can't protect their class from sniffles. And as for protecting themselves that's the role of nutrition and vaccination (🫰 for an RSV vaccine imminently) not preventing children from being in school building their immune system.

lilyandrosa · 22/11/2023 12:01

Maybe87 · 22/11/2023 11:44

Take her to the GP. Respiratory inflations causing tiredness. She may need antibiotics. Obviously take her from the school. It is not all about fever.

The GP’s don’t have time for this, you can’t take your child to a doctor and say she’s clingy and tired and expect antibiotics? If she had a respiratory infection that was bacterial then she would have other symptoms like coughing, rattling chest etc

Maybe87 · 22/11/2023 11:44

Take her to the GP. Respiratory inflations causing tiredness. She may need antibiotics. Obviously take her from the school. It is not all about fever.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 22/11/2023 11:31

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 22/11/2023 11:28

Yes. But if your child is ill it’s your responsibility as a parent to come and get them.

Her child had no temperature it was only a cold. She wanted to play in the garden when she brought her home and then in the playground when she picked up her sister. What does that tell you?????

Carpediemmakeitcount · 22/11/2023 11:29

GettinChillyHereFFS · 20/11/2023 13:16

Or my sister is now dead because she was immunocompromised after multi operations, some selfish SELFISH fucker sent their kid to school while obviously ill. My niece picked it up and took it home, my sister got sick, caught sepsis and has now died leaving her child motherless and me sisterless.

DON'T BE SO FUCKING SELFISH, COLLECT YOUR CHILD AND DON'T SEND THEM TO SCHOOL WHEN THEY ARE OBVIOUSLY ILL. Yeah it can't be hleped if no one knows they are sick but once you know, keep it to your fucking selves.

What an awful post to write that isn't true your sister is well and alive. You do realise that coughs and colds linger and don't go away so realistically how long should a child stay at home?

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 22/11/2023 11:28

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 09:49

Do teachers realise that not all parents work locally?

Yes. But if your child is ill it’s your responsibility as a parent to come and get them.

Mariposista · 22/11/2023 11:15

I’d be furious OP.
Of course pick her up if she is vomiting or has had an accident and needs to see a doctor or dentist. But tired???? No way. What happens when she is genuinely ill two weeks later. Another day off work? Boss will soon lose patience with that.

TheJabberwocky · 22/11/2023 11:03

I feel you OP. We’ve all had coughs in our house for a month. Everyone’s fine but constantly coughing. Doing all the usual stuff, no issues. Tiredness here and there from not getting enough sleep due to coughing. It’s hard because if you always took time off due to it you’d never be at work or school. Glad she’s okay though.

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 10:31

Frickles · 22/11/2023 10:23

I've worked in a primary school office and just outside London so lots of parents were commuting and journeys fairly long. Some parents wanted to be called at the tiniest thing and hugely kicked off if they weren't kept informed, so we always erred on the side of caution and called just in case; especially in reception when we may not have known families so well, we would often call if a child was unwell / not engaging / sleepy or clingy in a low key way as described, as lots of parents wanted to know and wanted to come to pick up. We'd often say something like 'do you want us to see how they are after lunch / play / in an hour' if they said they were in work. Sometimes the child perked up and sometimes they got more unwell. We wouldn't have called 20-30 mins before the end of the day unless they were really unwell.

If you do work a long way from the school or in a role you can't easily get away from you also need to consider what to do if there's a more serious incident - e.g. children falling off monkey bars and breaking an arm, or getting a head injury; if there's anyone at all who you'd trust to be there for your child in those situations you need to make sure the school has their details, these things seem to happen more often than you might think! Even with something like vomiting, small children get quite distressed having a long wait to be taken home.

We only had one call from school - DS had fallen in the playground. He had a badly broken leg. DH was contacted and left a roomful of patients to get to the school. I was working in Singapore and got the first flight home. A friend collected DD after school and looked after her until we could make arrangements.
School were sensible and didn’t call for a mild cough/cold.

Maxus · 22/11/2023 10:27

Humphhhh · 22/11/2023 10:17

Most teachers have the sense to realise poverty would be a bigger problem for them.

The teachers also need to protect the rest of the class from illness and also protect themselves. The teacher carnt teach if they are ill themselves due to parents who send their child in sick. They also carnt care for sick children while they teach the class.

blackfluffycat · 22/11/2023 10:24

@Parker231

Do teachers realise that not all parents work locally?

Who do you think should look after the ill child then? The teacher, TA, Office Staff, Dinner Lady, Caretaker? They all have their own job's.

Withnailandsigh · 22/11/2023 10:24

It’s one of these unwritten rules I’m afraid. If nursery or school or the childminder rings to say the child is ill then someone has to drop everything and go straight there. They’ll judge you big time and it’s also considered a red flag welfare wise not to do it. They don’t do it for fun, the schools like to see high attendance. If they’ve said she doesn’t seem right then she’ll be noticeably out of sorts.

Frickles · 22/11/2023 10:23

I've worked in a primary school office and just outside London so lots of parents were commuting and journeys fairly long. Some parents wanted to be called at the tiniest thing and hugely kicked off if they weren't kept informed, so we always erred on the side of caution and called just in case; especially in reception when we may not have known families so well, we would often call if a child was unwell / not engaging / sleepy or clingy in a low key way as described, as lots of parents wanted to know and wanted to come to pick up. We'd often say something like 'do you want us to see how they are after lunch / play / in an hour' if they said they were in work. Sometimes the child perked up and sometimes they got more unwell. We wouldn't have called 20-30 mins before the end of the day unless they were really unwell.

If you do work a long way from the school or in a role you can't easily get away from you also need to consider what to do if there's a more serious incident - e.g. children falling off monkey bars and breaking an arm, or getting a head injury; if there's anyone at all who you'd trust to be there for your child in those situations you need to make sure the school has their details, these things seem to happen more often than you might think! Even with something like vomiting, small children get quite distressed having a long wait to be taken home.

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 10:18

Maxus · 22/11/2023 10:05

Do working parents realise that that's not the teachers problem?

Agree but I’m often working up to an hour and a half from school. DH is a doctor so not practical to leave surgery. Thankfully DT’s school have only called once and no calls from nursery.

Humphhhh · 22/11/2023 10:17

Maxus · 22/11/2023 10:05

Do working parents realise that that's not the teachers problem?

Most teachers have the sense to realise poverty would be a bigger problem for them.

Maxus · 22/11/2023 10:05

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 09:49

Do teachers realise that not all parents work locally?

Do working parents realise that that's not the teachers problem?

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 09:49

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 22/11/2023 06:26

Speaking from a teachers point of view. We don’t want to send children home and don’t do it lightly but when we can tell that they aren’t being how they normally are at school that does make us keep an extra eye. Then if this doesn’t improve we send them to the first aid trained staff in the office who make a judgement as to whether to send them home. You need to get your DD

Do teachers realise that not all parents work locally?

Humphhhh · 22/11/2023 09:43

Proudbitch · 22/11/2023 08:55

@GettinChillyHereFFS I’m so sorry to hear this :(

sending love out to you

That's a very thoughtful post ❤️. However GettingChilly updated later to say her sister hadn't actually died but she just could have done.

Faking a siblings death to berate someone for sending a child to school with a cold is one of the more batshit incidents on Mumsnet.

Proudbitch · 22/11/2023 08:55

@GettinChillyHereFFS I’m so sorry to hear this :(

sending love out to you

Justanothermum42 · 22/11/2023 08:32

Absolutely not! I’d ask for a meeting with head of year/head of prep school to discuss this. Just because a child is ‘clingy’, it does not mean they have to go home. What if you simply cannot go to collect her?

lilyandrosa · 22/11/2023 08:03

I think you got an necessary hard time OP.

Kids have off days like us, and despite her cold it sounds like this was one of them.
You know your child best and this shows by her saying she wants to play in the garden when you got home!

Some of the replies on this thread make out that her arm was hanging off and you left her at school it’s crazy!

Im sorry but we all send our kids to school with colds, it would be unreasonable not to and they’d spend more time at home than at school as colds can linger on for ages and then another one shows up anyway!

Parker231 · 22/11/2023 07:39

Florrieboo · 22/11/2023 07:22

I haven't read the rest but if a child is unwell enough to be medicated (with Calpol) then they should not be at school. A 4 year old is a baby, in most countries she wouldnt even be going to school.

Mine had calpol before nursery and school if they were a little under the weather - typical for many children. A slight cold and cough isn’t an illness which warrants a normally healthy child staying at home. A four year old is not a baby!

where are all these jobs which you can leave to collect children at the drop of a hat!

Baba197 · 22/11/2023 07:39

Are you at home and not working? If so then you should’ve kept her off whilst she’s poorly! She’s prob exhausted and drained poor thing! If school say she isn’t coping then you go and get her. I work in a preschool and the amount of parents who send their child in when poorly annoys me, not only is it unfair to the child but it spreads the bugs to others!

Loulou560 · 22/11/2023 07:28

This is a very divisive post. My two DD are still small but one is in nursery two sessions a week. They’re very good at knowing if a child needs picking up and I’ve never questioned this myself. In saying that, little ones catch colds etc all the time. Some people on here seem to think that they shouldn’t be spreading their germs. In that case, schools would then single out children for attendance!
We have to remember too, that some people have no support network. Very few people would understand what it’s like to be in those shoes. My mother passed away when I was pregnant, and when people innocently ask me sometimes ‘does your mother help?’ It’s like a kick in the guts.
In saying all of this, I hope OP’s DD is ok bless her, and I wouldn’t question the school’s intention for her to come home in future. Maybe OP needs to chat to school and ask what their policy is.

Florrieboo · 22/11/2023 07:22

I haven't read the rest but if a child is unwell enough to be medicated (with Calpol) then they should not be at school. A 4 year old is a baby, in most countries she wouldnt even be going to school.