Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister dropped off mother to mine, saying 'my turn'

168 replies

DjBloke · 20/11/2023 08:43

Hi,

Needed some urgent advice here. I am a 50-ish man, 2 college kids, who moved out of my mother's place in the mid 90s, less than a yr after father unexpectedly passed, so it was just her and my sister, who was 8 at the time, and they live in Leicester.

Now, i admit, I haven't visited as much as I should and kept a distance as we never saw eye to eye on lifestyle. She is now in her late 70s, and still lives with my sister, who is 11+ years younger. We don't really have a relationship, but she has been her primary caregiver and has never left home since birth, since 1983 (being Asian, this isn't unusual, especially for girls).

She has never had a partner either, as far as I'm aware. Cut to now, our mother is in ailing health, and randomly turned up outside my place a few days ago with packed bags. There was a long email from the sister, who said she was 'burdened' and felt like she was 'stuck' looking after her etc.

Now legally, she solely owns the property in Leicester, so our mother doesn't actually have any legal rights to stay there, or does she, given the many decades she lived there?

My sister said she would change the locks and even move tenants in, and is even willing to give up living there herself, as she feels i have been 'ignoring the situation' (she did ask for help before here and there over the years, but honestly I thought it wouldn't be an issue, maybe, naively, because of the female bond they would have) and because this is the first time I've seen her react this way.

I think sending her here out the blue is not on, and have been making plans to send her back to Leicester. I know it sounds harsh, but I certainly don't want her to live with me / my family, and her even being here is already stressful (she's deeply religious). I wouldn't be able to afford a caregiver / carehome fees anyway as I have rented in London for decades/COL etc.

What to do?

OP posts:
wishihadagoodone · 20/11/2023 13:05

Aishah231 · 20/11/2023 12:59

I think some people are missing the point OP. You sound like you haven't stepped up to help BUT - your sister has never left home and has now seemingly been gifted your Mum's house - now your Mum is elderly she dumps her on you. I'm sorry but your Mum gifting your sister the house was clearly in the expectation she would look after her in old age - foolish but correct. Your sister can't now renege on her side of the bargain. You left home and it doesn't sound like you have a good relationship with your Mum. I don't think children owe their parents care. I would look into care homes OP and your sister may well have to sell the house to pay.

OP never said his sister was gifted the house.
The house his mother lived in was owned by his sister.
What he's trying to say is he wants a judge to force his sister to take their mother back because she's lived there for so many years and therefore she has that right.
Another way to shirk responsibilities.

greenwichvillage · 20/11/2023 13:04

Well done to your sister, why should she have to give up her life to care for your mother whilst you get away scot free. She is your mum too and maybe now you need to take some responsibility. Your sister also deserves to live her life just as you have. Stop being selfish and do the right thing.

Aishah231 · 20/11/2023 12:59

I think some people are missing the point OP. You sound like you haven't stepped up to help BUT - your sister has never left home and has now seemingly been gifted your Mum's house - now your Mum is elderly she dumps her on you. I'm sorry but your Mum gifting your sister the house was clearly in the expectation she would look after her in old age - foolish but correct. Your sister can't now renege on her side of the bargain. You left home and it doesn't sound like you have a good relationship with your Mum. I don't think children owe their parents care. I would look into care homes OP and your sister may well have to sell the house to pay.

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 12:45

margotrose · 20/11/2023 12:42

Why does the mother need to go back to the daughter’s house?

Because that's her place of residence and where all her connections are.

She won't qualify for council support in an area where she's never lived.

So her son can get her council support.

It’s the least he can do.

margotrose · 20/11/2023 12:42

Why does the mother need to go back to the daughter’s house?

Because that's her place of residence and where all her connections are.

She won't qualify for council support in an area where she's never lived.

Allergictoironing · 20/11/2023 12:41

Allfur · 20/11/2023 11:37

Why didn't she look for a partner

I doubt she would find a partner willing to take on her elderly (now with care needs) highly religious mother as well as her! Plus having caring responsibilities doesn't give someone much time or opportunity to go partner hunting. Now if her brother had just once or twice helped out so she could have the odd holiday.....

Whiteday · 20/11/2023 12:39

Quite rightly handed your arse on a plate OP!! Step up!

Ponoka7 · 20/11/2023 12:26

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 11:52

But why can’t he get in touch with the council? She is with HIM right now.

Why does the mother need to go back to the daughter’s house?

Because you need a connection to the LA that you are claiming care/housing needs in. The Council will refer her back to Leicester. Communication is going to be a nightmare because they will try to get out of responsibility. The Mother's GP and pension/benefits will be at the DD's address.
OP your start is adult SS. Unless there's been a sale at the true value of the home (or it was your sister's from day one) that could be complicated. Your sister will have to state that your mother is now homeless because of the legal/funding/placement side.

sollenwir · 20/11/2023 12:22

tuvamoodyson · 20/11/2023 09:07

#teamsister.

#teamnobodyshouldbeforcedtotakecareofanolderrelative

  • long, but you get the idea.
Fortunefavoursthebrave · 20/11/2023 12:02

It should be 50/50. Good for your sister for waking up to this.

BenZodiazapam · 20/11/2023 11:59

So you think you get you absolve yourself of providing any support and letting your sister do all the care just because you have a penis? Is this for real? I’m not saying your mother has to live with you but by your own admission you knew there was an issue and just chose to ignore it when you and your sister could have worked together to develop a solution that works for everyone. Instead you just left her to it and she hasn’t been able to have any sort of life or a family of her own.

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 11:53

SwiftieGrainger · 20/11/2023 11:21

It's true so I'd say yes

And you think you are ‘perfectly balanced’ 😂

Ok mate might be time to return to pistonheadscom

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 11:52

margotrose · 20/11/2023 11:26

There's another thread running at the moment where there's a sister in a very similar position to you and most of the replies are along the lines of "you're not required to care for your parents".

It's interesting that when it's a man involved, the responses are very different.

I actually don't think it's your responsibility and if your sister doesn't want to do it anymore (or is no longer able) then she needs to get in touch with the council.

But why can’t he get in touch with the council? She is with HIM right now.

Why does the mother need to go back to the daughter’s house?

Emeraldsanddiamonds · 20/11/2023 11:40

There is nothing to suggest that the mother transferred the house to the sister - just that she's lived there a long time with the sister. Honestly, it's no wonder the sister has never had a partner with her deeply religious mother ensconced in her house for decades. I think she has well and truly done with the mother living with her and wants to seize some joy for herself.

aswarmofmidges · 20/11/2023 11:37

I don't think it's because the op is male

I think it's because the OP expected the women to look after the mum and refused to engage with the sister at all because he thought it women's work

it sounds like the mother needs to go into a care home or sone kind of she can't look after herself , and it will be a council one if there isn't money for private

If he had helped a little with that process is suspect things would not have got to this stage

Allfur · 20/11/2023 11:37

Why didn't she look for a partner

margotrose · 20/11/2023 11:35

You let your sister take on all the burden with no life of her own, no chance to find a partner, no chance of independence,*

Why is any of that his fault?

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 20/11/2023 11:34

You let your sister take on all the burden with no life of her own, no chance to find a partner, no chance of independence, because you saw her life being one of duty and drudgery and servitude. You saw her as less worthy than you of a having a decent life. She asked you for help and you turned your back on her.

Women aren't domestic slaves. Good on her. It IS your turn, so suck it up buttercup. Don't you DARE try and take her back and force your sister into that role again so you can swan about without a care in the world. If you don't want your mum living with you, then YOU sort out what to do, without defaulting back to that misogynistic stance of 'it's wimmins work'.

margotrose · 20/11/2023 11:26

There's another thread running at the moment where there's a sister in a very similar position to you and most of the replies are along the lines of "you're not required to care for your parents".

It's interesting that when it's a man involved, the responses are very different.

I actually don't think it's your responsibility and if your sister doesn't want to do it anymore (or is no longer able) then she needs to get in touch with the council.

Lochness1975 · 20/11/2023 11:24

My mother was the main carer for her mother and disabled brother. My aunt who moved away done nothing. Visited once every 3/4 years. When my grandmother died mum took over looking after my disabled uncle, when it got too much (dementia) he was put in a home. You couldn’t begin to imagine the arguments this caused from my aunt. The person who had done NOTHING all those years. No life herself. Even though we are/were low contact I still looked after he/both so mum could go away and have a break. No help from my brother or cousins. Every annual leave I had was to look after them- and I was the only one with small children at the time. The emotional stress is massive!

SwiftieGrainger · 20/11/2023 11:21

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 11:19

She said ‘women on Mumsnet hate men’. How is that ‘perfectly balanced’?!

It's true so I'd say yes

Squeezita · 20/11/2023 11:19

SwiftieGrainger · 20/11/2023 10:27

She's just asking, it's a good thing to ask if it's a possibility given that the Op has posted here for help. It's like people responding bounce off each other and don't read the Op properly.

She said ‘women on Mumsnet hate men’. How is that ‘perfectly balanced’?!

FrustratedMumHelp · 20/11/2023 11:17

Brilliant. Your sister has finally reached her limit. Shes put her life on hold to live with and care for your mum and, despite asking for help from you over the years - which seemed to have been ignored- shes dropped her off at yours for your turn. Your not happy with this but ok for your sister to do all the hard work?! Sheesh 🙄

FruitPizza · 20/11/2023 10:54

And completely agree that even if OP doesn’t take care of their mother, they could at least support the sister in finding appropriate care

FruitPizza · 20/11/2023 10:52

minipie · 20/11/2023 10:48

What is the context for you having little to no relationship with them? If your mother has been toxic

No indication of toxicity or abuse at all in the OP, just says he didn’t see eye to eye on lifestyle with his mother. I would imagine he has had little relationship because he didn’t want to share the responsibility - seems pretty clear given he ignored his sister’s requests for help over the years.

But we don’t know what was going on there.

for example of OP was gay and DM was deeply homophobic would they be expected to look after her? OP would have been 19/20 when they left from the sounds of things so I doubt it’s a decision taken lightly.

I might be wrong but I also think there’s a loooooot of reaching here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread