Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be tearing my hair out at autistic DS's refusal to wash his hands?

107 replies

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 08:25

DS is 11yo and autistic. He manages ok in mainstream secondary school but it is safe to say he doesn't mask particularly well. I am autistic too (recent diagnosis) so have some sympathy with this, but do think a baseline level of rote politeness and cleanliness makes everyone's lives much nicer and so have encouraged him to learn these skills. It has been (and continues to be) a struggle.

The most recent battle is over handwashing, which he avoids whenever possible. I know this because if he gets close enough I can smell his hands (although tbf I am hypersensitive to smells). I've tried explaining about bacteria, I've tried explaining that people will recoil from him, I've tried explaining that job recruiters tend to prefer people whose hands are clean - none of it works as he doesn't think there is a point. We have similar battles over clothing presentation, hair brushing, washing ketchup off your face, etc.

I don't want him to be dirty. I don't want him to be teased/made fun of. I don't want him to be embarrassed.

What on earth do I do please?!

OP posts:
Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 13:07

Sturnidae · 20/11/2023 12:06

Have you ever been around an autistic person? Or anybody ND? I had a massively reduced diet as a child which I've now realised is due to my brand of neurospicy. I just didn't eat when people pulled the "eat this or nothing" shite. Its not a choice FFS.

Mine only eats in the evenings as it is, he would just stop altogether if I made any rules about food.

I have got mine to shower today (first time in several days)- still working on the ‘morning’ tooth brushing…

Moredarkchocolateplease · 20/11/2023 12:38

Balloonhearts · 20/11/2023 09:50

Hygiene is one of those things that is non negotiable in my house. Same as teeth brushing. They do it willingly or I pin them down and do it for them. They quickly learnt that it gets done either way but doing it themselves is a lot more pleasant.

You don't have a 5ft7 broad 13yr old autistic child do you 😂

OP I gave up on hands. DS didn't use handgel during the pandemic and I'm not sure he washed them much either.

He is now occasionally using cold water to rinse his hands.
And showering.

gamerchick · 20/11/2023 12:24

PosteriorPosterity · 20/11/2023 08:40

What is he doing that his hands smell?

Much to MN chagrin, I very rarely wash my hands. I’m talking once a day, or I will rinse them after using a public toilet.

I’ve got quite a strong immune system and people at rarely ill in our house.

But my hands are visibly clean and absolutely do not smell (I’ve just checked with the friends that I’m with!).

Can you relax the rule to “dirty/smelly hands should be washed” as that is at least logical (to me) and I maintain is the only time you really need to wash your hands.

You tell your friends you don't wash your hands and ask them to smell them?

Ecoli is small enough to pass through several sheets of toilet paper. Not washing your hands properly after taking a shit may be a risk someone is willing to take, but I pity everyone using something like a cashpoint after them like.

lifeturnsonadime · 20/11/2023 12:17

Shopper727 · 20/11/2023 11:03

@Balloonhearts would love to see you try to pin my 12 year old down to brush his teeth. As if I don’t have a hard enough job with comments like that. I have a pda asd child very similar by sounds to op son. He doesn’t like water/washing teeth brushing and also toileting is also an issue it’s tough.

do people think we don’t try to instil good hygiene etc? Or we just let them get away with anything? I’m a nurse so I know he needs to be clean, he needs to brush his teeth however the battle to get those done is real. Interested to hear some strategies on here as obviously I can try them with him. Would referral to ot help? It’s been mentioned in the past. It’s diffuse as you don’t know what to try and trying some things can make them more resistant, bit of a vicious cycle,

OT definitely helped both of my DC with sensory issues around washing/ toothbrushing.

They helped break down what the fear stemmed from and gave them strategies around that.

Both have gone from underwashing to overwashing as a result of these strategies.

So I would suggest asking GP for a referral. Definitely worth it in the long run because the cost of poor teeth to the NHS and personally is expensive and our ND kids often also hate dentist.

Sturnidae · 20/11/2023 12:06

LlynTegid · 20/11/2023 10:30

Time for tough love, be it hand gel or soap and water. No meals at least when at home until he washes hands.

Have you ever been around an autistic person? Or anybody ND? I had a massively reduced diet as a child which I've now realised is due to my brand of neurospicy. I just didn't eat when people pulled the "eat this or nothing" shite. Its not a choice FFS.

Djimm · 20/11/2023 12:01

Interesting point @SecretsOfSunshine - now you say that I can totally imagine it with the bread experiment.

As always it's figuring out what works for the one person. OP you've had a range ideas approaching different angles, which hopefully is really helpful even if you only use one or two.

Routine is always our main strategy, bolting it onto something that happens anyway at a time when he tends to be fairly settled. Things are much easier after dinner than before. My son would relate quite positively, I think, to the idea that smelly hands make it uncomfortable for me at mealtimes. He might not put himself out for an abstract "society in general" but for me personally, he might.

Flannels are good for single use hand towels so there is no risk of touching an already damp towel. I tend to encourage baths over showers in the hope that a good soaking is of some use even if they dodge the soap. If rinsing is difficult, foam soap rinses away more easily because it uses a lot less actually soap

Even if it is "behavioural" more than sensory, sensory adjustments can help send the message that you are on his side and supporting, rather than butting heads.

Sturnidae · 20/11/2023 11:57

SecretsOfSunshine · 20/11/2023 11:17

Btw I also in the teenage years tried the touching bread and Petri dish experiments.
I just got back LOADS of facts about bacteria. Examples like ‘your mouth is full of essential bacteria, seeing bacteria isn’t bad’. ‘If you heard the bacteria in your water bottle had multiplied lots but there was a small change of bacteria left on your toilet seat, which would you lick? Lots doesn’t mean bad nor does smell’ or ‘your immune system is anti-fragile…’ or ‘I’m less likely to develop allergies…’
Honestly, autistic logic and NT logic aren’t simply exchangeable

I have worked with ND kids that it has worked with, hence the suggestion. It's worth a try if it's something that may work for OPs son, baring in mind all kids are different, especially when it comes to neurodiversity.

I am also ND and a parent of two ND kids, I have issues with hand washing for sensory reasons however I'm able to cope when not at home with my preferred soap smells/temperature water, but also I'm the exact opposite of OPs child and wash my hands too much, which presents its own issues. Point being that I am very aware of how ND logic and NT logic work differently!

SpaceRaiders · 20/11/2023 11:29

I agree with @caringcarer if he’ll shower then encourage doing so daily or even twice daily if he can handle it.

SpaceRaiders · 20/11/2023 11:25

No meals at least when at home until he washes hands.

Yeah, mine would just go without food.

It’s funny that posters with no lived experience of Autism keep suggesting tactics that are akin to abuse of a disabled child. Consequences or bribing won’t work if the issue is a sensory need or avoidance that isn’t being met.

SecretsOfSunshine · 20/11/2023 11:17

Btw I also in the teenage years tried the touching bread and Petri dish experiments.
I just got back LOADS of facts about bacteria. Examples like ‘your mouth is full of essential bacteria, seeing bacteria isn’t bad’. ‘If you heard the bacteria in your water bottle had multiplied lots but there was a small change of bacteria left on your toilet seat, which would you lick? Lots doesn’t mean bad nor does smell’ or ‘your immune system is anti-fragile…’ or ‘I’m less likely to develop allergies…’
Honestly, autistic logic and NT logic aren’t simply exchangeable

Lougle · 20/11/2023 11:12

I empathise with you @HalebiHabibti . My DD currently can't go to school because she's so concerned about germs. It would be nice if we could meet in the middle!

Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 11:11

LlynTegid · 20/11/2023 10:30

Time for tough love, be it hand gel or soap and water. No meals at least when at home until he washes hands.

WTAF?! You would starve a disabled child because you don’t like a symptom of their disability? That is abuse.

SecretsOfSunshine · 20/11/2023 11:10

Sounds like mine.
All I’ve ever been able to succeed with us creating a routine and enforcing it.
Some are positive, teeth brushing at x time leads to x.
Others I’ve occasionally had to have consequences for more persistent issues. Eg if you haven’t showered in two days on the third you lose devices.
Eventually these routines become natural and embed without monitoring.
He doesn’t place value on certain things, he cannot put himself in some one else’s shoes. Telling him I think it’s smelly means nothing, he doesn’t. Explaining reasonably is dismissed completely, even when it’s logical

caringcarer · 20/11/2023 11:10

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 08:36

It is part sensory issue, part I can't see the point (he has explained at length that he sits down to pee and so doesn't need to wash hands afterwards as he hasn't touched any bits), and part 'don't you tell me what to do'. So it is complicated.... he does take showers occasionally as he likes them, which is great. But it does make eating with him a bit bleurgh as you can't ask him to pass anyone anything and certainly wouldn't want to share.

If he likes the shower he should be having one every day not just occasionally. His hands wouldn't smell then. Has he tried wet wipes?

IncompleteSenten · 20/11/2023 11:09

Shopper727 · 20/11/2023 11:03

@Balloonhearts would love to see you try to pin my 12 year old down to brush his teeth. As if I don’t have a hard enough job with comments like that. I have a pda asd child very similar by sounds to op son. He doesn’t like water/washing teeth brushing and also toileting is also an issue it’s tough.

do people think we don’t try to instil good hygiene etc? Or we just let them get away with anything? I’m a nurse so I know he needs to be clean, he needs to brush his teeth however the battle to get those done is real. Interested to hear some strategies on here as obviously I can try them with him. Would referral to ot help? It’s been mentioned in the past. It’s diffuse as you don’t know what to try and trying some things can make them more resistant, bit of a vicious cycle,

Yup. My eldest (also autistic) needed to be pinned down by two people when he was a toddler for teeth brushing and medication. He's had to have several teeth removed because they were so badly decayed. No fucking chance anyone's pinning down an autistic teenager / young adult who doesn't want to comply unless they're professionals trained in manual restraint and there's a few of them.

Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 11:06

fearfuloffluff · 20/11/2023 10:15

Some stats as well if that helps
https://www.cdc.gov/handwashing/why-handwashing.html

Or the history of handwashing (someone twigged that doctors moving between the morgue and the maternity ward without washing their hands was a bad idea)
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/18/keep-it-clean-the-surprising-130-year-history-of-handwashing

The history thing would work here- mine needs to know the reasons why and the history or every buggering thing before he will accept it.

He refused to learn any numbers/maths at school (he did up to year 2) because no one could tell him why a number 3 is that shape, who invented numbers, why they are in the order they are, why one is called one and two called two etc 🤦‍♀️

Bryzoan · 20/11/2023 11:03

Hello! I have an early teens daughter with disabilities, who is also on the ASD assessment pathway. This (and hygeine generally) has been a real ongoing issue for us too. Eventually I was able to get a referral to the children’s learning disability nurse - even though dd didn’t meet quite meet the ld criteria - just because of the impact the difficulties we’re having. Although the nurse was working with dd saying essentially the same things I had been, having another (and by this time more patient) voice going through it and taking time to deep dive some of the issues with us really helped. Not totally fixed but much better.

Shopper727 · 20/11/2023 11:03

@Balloonhearts would love to see you try to pin my 12 year old down to brush his teeth. As if I don’t have a hard enough job with comments like that. I have a pda asd child very similar by sounds to op son. He doesn’t like water/washing teeth brushing and also toileting is also an issue it’s tough.

do people think we don’t try to instil good hygiene etc? Or we just let them get away with anything? I’m a nurse so I know he needs to be clean, he needs to brush his teeth however the battle to get those done is real. Interested to hear some strategies on here as obviously I can try them with him. Would referral to ot help? It’s been mentioned in the past. It’s diffuse as you don’t know what to try and trying some things can make them more resistant, bit of a vicious cycle,

Conkersinautumn · 20/11/2023 10:59

Has he ever had worms? My autistic son has finally accepted that the worming medicines could be excluded if he washes his hands before eating. It really was a case of the greater evil in sensory terms.

Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 10:57

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 09:38

Some great insights here, thank you. PDA had definitely crossed my mind too....

Mine has pda (diagnosed) in the mix, and washing is an issue- although he does wash his hands a lot but doesn’t want to wash the rest of him (he is only 9 so doesn’t smell yet therefore doesn’t see the point, and it’s a Demand, and it’s a horrible sensory experience).

I don’t have any tips I’m afraid- just solidarity!

I get him to shower by bribery/having absolutely no other demands that day/catching him in a good mood…

museumum · 20/11/2023 10:56

Would he use a babywipe type handwipe? Terrible for the environment but I think perfectly understandable in this situation. I grew up in a house with an old fashioned hot water tank so sink taps were cold unless you waited a few minutes for them to run warm and used to try to avoid washing my hands as a child as I just didn't have the patience.

IncompleteSenten · 20/11/2023 10:56

If he sees it as pointless you're not going to get his cooperation. My youngest (22) has autism and ADHD with PDA and the only way we get him to do stuff is to convince him that he wants to do it. And we have to be subtle about it. He doesn't give a flying fuck about other people's wants so there's no point appealing to the social side. It sounds like your son is similar.

NT methods just don't work. It's like giving someone directions in a language they don't speak. It's just a waste of everyone's time. I do love the 'they have to... You make them... It's non negotiable ' stuff though. Try that with an aggressive severely autistic massive 22 year old and see how many teeth you lose. (Is there a laughing and crying at the same time emoji? )

You need to find something that makes him want to build it into his routine. I liked the Petri dish idea. Worth a shot.

Are there things he does that he will find better, nicer or easier with clean hands? That's your angle.

Arabels · 20/11/2023 10:56

OP I just want to say that while this must be absolutely doing your head in, you come across as a very committed, compassionate parent. You’re absolutely right to help him learn this stuff as it is necessary for adult life.

You’re trying to unpick the relationship between whether he thinks it’s necessary/worthwhile and whether he just hates the experience-keep trying!

If sensory, would a basin filled with warm water be easier for him to use?

Hand cream does sound like it might help.

I didn’t wash my hands as a child/teen/young adult as I never liked them being wet afterwards.

InattentiveADHD · 20/11/2023 10:53

Also ND with an autistic and ADHD son. This would also be a non-negotiable to me.

Like washing and teeth brushing and wearing clothes that fit (yes, a massive issue!!!).

I would work with them to find as an acceptable solution as possible sensory wise but not doing it is not an option.

I would accompany to bathroom and literally nothing else would be happening until hands were washed.

As you say this is not just an issue for you (as it's pretty disgusting), but could make him a target for bullying. My DS already experienced enough of that and I know personally how damaging it is. I moved heaven and earth to ensure that anything that made him a target that could be changed, was changed.

Superscientist · 20/11/2023 10:52

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 10:26

I've got a friend who still works in labs... I quite like the idea of doing the petri dish experiment :D

I came to suggest the Petri dish experience.
We did it during my a levels and discovered we were all terrible and washing and drying our hands as our plates were worse after washing our hands and swaps from the floor and door handle. We repeated the following week making sure our hands were properly dried and as expected washed hands were better that unwashed.

You could get some cotton wool swaps and swap the door handles and the toilet flush and other place we would generally touch. To see how dirty they go. I would do a test without him there is possible to check something shows up! If water doesn't work try something like mouth wash or nail varnish remover.

When try to change someone's behaviour you usually have to figure out how their brain and mind works first to see what they respond best too