Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be tearing my hair out at autistic DS's refusal to wash his hands?

107 replies

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 08:25

DS is 11yo and autistic. He manages ok in mainstream secondary school but it is safe to say he doesn't mask particularly well. I am autistic too (recent diagnosis) so have some sympathy with this, but do think a baseline level of rote politeness and cleanliness makes everyone's lives much nicer and so have encouraged him to learn these skills. It has been (and continues to be) a struggle.

The most recent battle is over handwashing, which he avoids whenever possible. I know this because if he gets close enough I can smell his hands (although tbf I am hypersensitive to smells). I've tried explaining about bacteria, I've tried explaining that people will recoil from him, I've tried explaining that job recruiters tend to prefer people whose hands are clean - none of it works as he doesn't think there is a point. We have similar battles over clothing presentation, hair brushing, washing ketchup off your face, etc.

I don't want him to be dirty. I don't want him to be teased/made fun of. I don't want him to be embarrassed.

What on earth do I do please?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 19:19

FlipsSakeMum judging by the speed with which he goes in and leaves again (door ajar), I'm fairly sure. He doesn't see the point in flushing wees either <yuck>

OP posts:
FlipsSakeMum · 20/11/2023 18:09

It would be interesting to know how many 11 boys wash their hands regularly.

Are you sure he doesn't wash his hands after going to the bathroom?

PurpleBugz · 20/11/2023 17:23

My autistic son refused to wash his hands. Then he got a really nasty sick bug off his sister and I didn't - I told him it's because of the germs getting into him and if he washed his hands like I do he may not have got sick. Worked wonders. It did feel cruel but during Covid it was mega stressful and it's disgusting for everyone else living with someone who doesn't wash their hands. I do empathise as I'm autistic too and have some sensory sensitivity over clothes and showers but I do it because I need to

EmpressSoleil · 20/11/2023 16:31

I have sensory issues and don't like the feel of any kind of liquid soup, shower gel, that kind of thing. I also hate showers. So for me it has to be bar soap and baths. I'm not quite as bad as the pp upthread but I probably don't wash my hands as often as most people. I know as a kid I'd always get told off for not washing them properly.

It's hard to explain, but it doesn't "feel" nice. And it's something you're expected to do multiple times a day for your whole life! Add in things like pain from hair brushing, or having to wear something that doesn't feel right. It's a lot when you actually think about it. You have to do all these things every day that don't feel good. And it's true, you're not doing them for yourself, you're doing them for others as obviously society expects people to be clean and presentable.

My DS has aspergers and we've had similar battles. What I will say is that he improved a lot as he got older and realised he would not have any friends, get a job or anything else if he was dirty and smelly. I know it's hard for you but maybe your DS needs to feel that embarrassment for himself. He needs to want to do these things for his own sake.

EmmaEmerald · 20/11/2023 15:43

caringcarer · 20/11/2023 15:26

This is so gross. At home you poo and don't wash your hands but you prepare food for your family. Tell your friends this and see if they want to eat anything you prepare.

I would guess your friends just think you wash your hands after using the loo but not otherwise. There's no way I'd meet up with someone who didn't wash their hands after taking a crap. The mind boggles.

keye · 20/11/2023 15:41

crazyBadger · 20/11/2023 15:03

Buy some agar plates (from Amazon)..

Get him to push his hand on, and watch all the bacteria grow....

It he can see it it becomes real

This is a bit of a risk, it has the potential to spake a real anxiety, I would tread very carefully when trying to scare an autistic child into washing; even if it is factual and scientific evidence.

caringcarer · 20/11/2023 15:26

crispcreambun · 20/11/2023 13:16

You are disgusting. Typhoid Mary had the same selfish attitude and lack of hygiene.

This is so gross. At home you poo and don't wash your hands but you prepare food for your family. Tell your friends this and see if they want to eat anything you prepare.

crazyBadger · 20/11/2023 15:03

Buy some agar plates (from Amazon)..

Get him to push his hand on, and watch all the bacteria grow....

It he can see it it becomes real

Lizziebest · 20/11/2023 15:02

Lizziebest · 20/11/2023 14:53

Do you prepare food for people and if so do you wash your hands before doing so?

OP Sorry for the distraction from the thread..I salute all the ASD parents on this thread reading it has been an eye-opener.

Lizziebest · 20/11/2023 14:53

PosteriorPosterity · 20/11/2023 10:37

Unless it’s a public toilet, no. And even then I only use soap if the toilets don’t seem to be kept clean.

(I’m prepared to be told I’m disgusting, but I don’t actually see why it’s an issue - I’m hardly ever ill (like once every 3-4 years) and neither is anyone else in my family, so I don’t see how washing my hands more often would benefit anything).

Do you prepare food for people and if so do you wash your hands before doing so?

keye · 20/11/2023 14:51

MintJulia · 20/11/2023 13:43

My DS, when 13, had a similar refusal to wash his face. He is probably mildly autistic - I am. He divides his food by type, isn't the fastest to make friends etc.

Months of nagging him to wash his face got nowhere, so I started waking him up by washing his face with a clean warm soapy flannel. He hated it but the only way to stop me, was to wash his face himself.

Which he now does, once a day.

I am unrepentant, before anyone tells me I am cruel. It worked. He no longer has spots. His hands are cleaner from the process too. He's getting close to showering voluntarily. Like pp, hygiene is non-negotiable in my house.

Mildly autistic isn't a thing.

Also, waking someone up worth a soapy flannel in their face is fucking brutal.

If you want to suggest you, and he, are autistic I would suggest basic research into what autism is first of all, then progress to how difficult things can be for autistic people and how to help them. A clue, force isn't it.

ginasevern · 20/11/2023 14:03

@PosteriorPosterity

"I very rarely wash my hands. I’m talking once a day, or I will rinse them after using a public toilet. I’ve got quite a strong immune system and people at rarely ill in our house."

Out of interest, do you wash your hands after going to the loo at home, returning from the supermarket, using public transport, digging the garden etc. Do you crack on and handle food without washing your hands? What about after eating something a bit messy or sticky. Why do you feel that your own strong immune system protects other people from the germs on your hands?

Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 13:59

@MintJulia washing his own face is no where near the only way to stop you doing that to him-

he could have blocked his door,

refused to go to bed,

refused to go to sleep,

made sure to wake before you every day,

punched you in the face every time you did it,

refused to come home,

thrown out all the flannels,

wrenched all the taps off

Woken before you and woken you by taking a wet rag to your face… if someone did what you did to me I’d have woken them with a bucket of cold water to the face and I would have been unrepentant.

You got lucky that he didn’t retaliate.

Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 13:50

DisquietintheRanks · 20/11/2023 13:36

Routines and "rules" have also really helped with my autistic son. So from a young age there were rules on washing hands, changing clothes, brushing teeth etc
As he got to puberty we had to update these eg showering every day and using deodorant, but with my ds, once things get imbedded they stick. Routinely doing things also helped him with desensitisation where there were issues eg shaving.

All my boys (nt and nd) had a soap dodging phase at 11 as I recall, so you're probably dealing with some natural age related resistance as well.

It’s so tricky to know the best way isn’t it because they are all so different. Mine needs a regular sort of rhythm, but real routines become demands and he won’t do it.

MintJulia · 20/11/2023 13:43

My DS, when 13, had a similar refusal to wash his face. He is probably mildly autistic - I am. He divides his food by type, isn't the fastest to make friends etc.

Months of nagging him to wash his face got nowhere, so I started waking him up by washing his face with a clean warm soapy flannel. He hated it but the only way to stop me, was to wash his face himself.

Which he now does, once a day.

I am unrepentant, before anyone tells me I am cruel. It worked. He no longer has spots. His hands are cleaner from the process too. He's getting close to showering voluntarily. Like pp, hygiene is non-negotiable in my house.

DisquietintheRanks · 20/11/2023 13:36

SecretsOfSunshine · 20/11/2023 11:10

Sounds like mine.
All I’ve ever been able to succeed with us creating a routine and enforcing it.
Some are positive, teeth brushing at x time leads to x.
Others I’ve occasionally had to have consequences for more persistent issues. Eg if you haven’t showered in two days on the third you lose devices.
Eventually these routines become natural and embed without monitoring.
He doesn’t place value on certain things, he cannot put himself in some one else’s shoes. Telling him I think it’s smelly means nothing, he doesn’t. Explaining reasonably is dismissed completely, even when it’s logical

Routines and "rules" have also really helped with my autistic son. So from a young age there were rules on washing hands, changing clothes, brushing teeth etc
As he got to puberty we had to update these eg showering every day and using deodorant, but with my ds, once things get imbedded they stick. Routinely doing things also helped him with desensitisation where there were issues eg shaving.

All my boys (nt and nd) had a soap dodging phase at 11 as I recall, so you're probably dealing with some natural age related resistance as well.

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 13:35

Moredarkchocolateplease that sounds awful! We're lucky DS2 is not a sugar fiend like his brother and so needs a dentist rarely. Small mercies...

OP posts:
HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 13:33

I do appreciate all the viewpoints. I had a despotic probably-autistic mother, who in retrospect was desperate for me to fit in and so did whatever she thought would achieve that goal. I'm lucky to live in a different age where different approaches are known about and advertised - she didn't necessarily know she had other options. Well that's the explanation I go with anyway!

I'd prefer to have a happier home life than a stricter one, within certain hygienic limits....

OP posts:
Moredarkchocolateplease · 20/11/2023 13:33

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 13:22

Lots of replies! I would like the social story information please, for sure. There are also lots of other ideas which, as you say, I can possibly amalgamate and use to come up with a plan which suits DS.

I wonder though if it might be more effective not coming from me, because I am Enemy #1 in his head atm. Maybe DH will have more luck.... he did get DS to change toothpaste after years of patient struggle (he graduated from 3-6yo toothpaste - reluctantly - when he was 8 :D) so is not too shabby at these things.

DS refuses to use anything but the 9-12 toothpaste. Dentist said it has the same flouride content as adult toothpaste so it doesn't matter.

On the other hand he's only ever had two exams from a dentist, my absolute favorite appointment ended with him running outside onto the main road and puking on a lamp post. I'd been struggling to keep him in there and on my knee. (aged 8)..

If I tried it now, he'd hit me. Simple as that. And he'd mean it!

MummyJ12 · 20/11/2023 13:29

Couldn’t agree more with you @Heresapickle
It’s the Explosive Child: South Pole and South Pole scenario. Our ND children need flexibility and a different approach. Benevolent parenting, not a dictatorship.

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 13:25

And thank you to the person who said it must be doing my head in - it really does. I have obsessively washed my own hands since I was 17 as I can't stand them smelling Wrong, so being touched by a child's grotty hand (you know when they are practically radiating dirt and heat simultaneously?) is just ugh. My older son (not definitely NT, but more NT than DS2) is better at spotting my face and popping off to wash, because he likes approval. DS2 doesn't care :D

OP posts:
Heresapickle · 20/11/2023 13:23

InattentiveADHD · 20/11/2023 10:53

Also ND with an autistic and ADHD son. This would also be a non-negotiable to me.

Like washing and teeth brushing and wearing clothes that fit (yes, a massive issue!!!).

I would work with them to find as an acceptable solution as possible sensory wise but not doing it is not an option.

I would accompany to bathroom and literally nothing else would be happening until hands were washed.

As you say this is not just an issue for you (as it's pretty disgusting), but could make him a target for bullying. My DS already experienced enough of that and I know personally how damaging it is. I moved heaven and earth to ensure that anything that made him a target that could be changed, was changed.

How would this work?

You start by dragging/carrying a kicking screaming teenager into the bathroom (quite a feat in itself)

…then what? You say wash your hands- they say no… you say you can’t do anything else until you do… so you have to sit there guarding them (presumably rendering the bathroom unusable for anyone else).

All the while you are not getting anything done- not making dinner, not doing homework with other kids or the one you have trapped in the bathroom, not doing any housework, not walk the dog, not getting anyone to their clubs/activities, not working yourself etc

How long do you think you could actually do that for? And again the next day and the next.

What happens when it’s bedtime? Are they not allowed to go to bed?

And that’s supposing you CAN physically force the child to a sink, and have a child that will turn it into a battle of wills and sit it out rather than a child who will attack when you trap them and smash up the room and hurt themselves and you.

HalebiHabibti · 20/11/2023 13:22

Lots of replies! I would like the social story information please, for sure. There are also lots of other ideas which, as you say, I can possibly amalgamate and use to come up with a plan which suits DS.

I wonder though if it might be more effective not coming from me, because I am Enemy #1 in his head atm. Maybe DH will have more luck.... he did get DS to change toothpaste after years of patient struggle (he graduated from 3-6yo toothpaste - reluctantly - when he was 8 :D) so is not too shabby at these things.

OP posts:
crispcreambun · 20/11/2023 13:16

PosteriorPosterity · 20/11/2023 10:37

Unless it’s a public toilet, no. And even then I only use soap if the toilets don’t seem to be kept clean.

(I’m prepared to be told I’m disgusting, but I don’t actually see why it’s an issue - I’m hardly ever ill (like once every 3-4 years) and neither is anyone else in my family, so I don’t see how washing my hands more often would benefit anything).

You are disgusting. Typhoid Mary had the same selfish attitude and lack of hygiene.

EmmaEmerald · 20/11/2023 13:12

@InattentiveADHD "I moved heaven and earth to ensure that anything that made him a target that could be changed, was changed."

please may I ask how you went about this?