Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a thing? Or is my friend deluded about her dc?

109 replies

in183 · 20/11/2023 06:54

Friend has a one year old, who will grab your arm/hand to make you press a button or point to something. Friend is ADAMANT that after having five children that she knows it is a sign of extreme intelligence. I’ve recently had a child and I’m being asked almost every few days if they’ve started to do it. Maybe I’m just sleep deprived but I think it’s absolutely crazy (and bloody annoying to be asked all the time). She is smart generally but I honestly can’t get my head around why she feels so strongly about it!!! Is this a thing?

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 20/11/2023 08:23

I would stear clear or send a strong message that you're not interested in comparing your child's milestones with hers.
If she is already starting with this at 7 months, it will never end...

JellyMops · 20/11/2023 08:22

"No she doesn't do that, she doesn't need to now she's talking and can tell me what she wants. Didn't any of your children talk at 7 months...?"

HoppingPavlova · 20/11/2023 08:22

My only one that did this has ASD, but is also very intelligent. Is all of this coincidence? Very likely.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 20/11/2023 08:21

Noicant · 20/11/2023 07:08

Lying early is a sign of intelligence apparently, so if your toddler is a massive fibber they are probably quite clever.

My youngest apparently has a very high IQ. Testing was done as part of ASD assessment, but I've also had it said to me by his early teachers. He's doing fine at school but not brilliantly. The only real sign I've seen of brilliance is his very creative ability to lie and his utter commitment to those lies.

IncorrigibIeRogue · 20/11/2023 08:21

I'm surprised by how many posters seem to think the words "potential" and "indicator" are absolutes. Very strange.

IncorrigibIeRogue · 20/11/2023 08:18

Soontobe60 · 20/11/2023 08:03

Is it heck!
Children who have not yet learned to talk may well use hand leading to get what they want, it doesn’t mean they’re ’neurodivergent’!

And again...

Hand leading is not an absolute sign that a child is definitely neurodivergent. Not all ND children do this and not all children who do this are ND.

It is (as I made very clear) a potential early indicator of neurodivergence. One of many potential early indicators, and one to be taken in context of a child's overall development and skills.

All2Well · 20/11/2023 08:18

Before I get flamed...I am ND and just giving anecdotal history from my own life.

Anyway, the only two children that I personally know who did this (one family member, one friend's child) are both autistic. Both very intelligent, with one being exceptionally gifted at maths, but both struggle very much with sensory issues and communication with their peers, needing a lot of emotional support.

ChannelNo19EDT · 20/11/2023 08:18

Ps, I think the behaviour is called joint referencing, if I recall correctly, and the child should be doing it by 12 months.

Catza · 20/11/2023 08:13

Some more mothers are truly nuts. One of my colleagues had an 18 months old who was going through a bit of a funny spell mood-wise. She read developmental literature and decided the child was frustrated because “he was developmentally 3 years old trapped in 18-month-old body”. We heard about it for about a week and then it turned out that the child had an infection and was acting out because he felt poorly.
I would just request that she stops asking or, if I liked her a lot, would ask here of there was anything she is worried about.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 20/11/2023 08:12

iloveherons · 20/11/2023 07:04

if it really is that extreme (in asking daily) I would ask her to stop asking daily. Tell her she will be the first to learn if your DC is doing so.

Fwiw, hand leading can be a sign of Asd. I have two on the spectrum. neither did it but doctors always asked if they did when they were little.

That's interesting. I have 3 Autistic DC and have never even heard of it. Never been asked about it by any of the various therapists we've worked with or the psychologist that diagnosed them. One did point and wave, I'm not sure the other 2 have ever pointed at anything using their hand or mine.

IncompleteSenten · 20/11/2023 08:09

He's also very intelligent. Got a 2.1 in his degree and is now doing his masters.

Theunamedcat · 20/11/2023 08:09

Three neurodivese children one hand leads one spoke at an early age one walked at an early age two stutter one severely one top notch pupil one barely scraping by one hopefully going to special school he cannot cope in mainstream all three autistic

My point is indicators are indicators not necessarily proof of absolutes

IncompleteSenten · 20/11/2023 08:08

IncorrigibIeRogue · 20/11/2023 06:58

Um, I thought that "hand leading" was actually a very early potential indicator of neurodivergence!

Are you sure she isn't actually worried about it and trying to get reassurance that other DC do it too?

That's interesting. I didn't know that.

My eldest did this and was DX with autism at 2 and a half.

He'd take our hands and direct them to what he wanted. Particularly nice when what he wanted was to see how hot something was 😂

BelindaOkra · 20/11/2023 08:08

My son did this. Still does and he’s an adult. He’s non-verbal, autistic and has severe learning disabilities (which doesn’t mean he’s anything ‘less’ than someone super bright).

BreatheAndFocus · 20/11/2023 08:07

in183 · 20/11/2023 07:07

She asks maybe once a week I’d say. My dd is 7 months and hers did it around one she said!

That’s weird! I’d just reply with a jokey answer so she hopefully gets the message and stops asking, eg “Yes, my baby does that sometimes when they want a pen to do the Times cryptic crossword”.

ChannelNo19EDT · 20/11/2023 08:05

I remember this tedious nonsense, I used to shut it down with "I just hope he's a good average". People know you're opting out of the bragathon.
My second child scored superior in a cognitivev function test but as I always knew, it's the social and emotional skills that are more nebulous that are holding him back, frustrated, his perception of himself is that he's a genius and now he's exasperated that other skills he can't see/learn allow others to overtake him

Canisaysomething · 20/11/2023 08:03

Maybe you should ask your friend if she’s ok. It’s seems a pretty strange thing to keep asking you. Maybe she’s very anxious about her baby generally.

Soontobe60 · 20/11/2023 08:03

IncorrigibIeRogue · 20/11/2023 06:58

Um, I thought that "hand leading" was actually a very early potential indicator of neurodivergence!

Are you sure she isn't actually worried about it and trying to get reassurance that other DC do it too?

Is it heck!
Children who have not yet learned to talk may well use hand leading to get what they want, it doesn’t mean they’re ’neurodivergent’!

Fundays12 · 20/11/2023 08:01

My oldest did this. He is nuerodiverse but also very bright. He has been assessed as being well above average in maths and reading. Intelligence and nuerodiversity are different things.

Anyway OP it must be frustrating but as a mum of 3 I can assure you kids develop different skills at time different times. It's not a competition and don't let her make you feel it is. My youngest probably developed quicker than my older 2 as he has older siblings to copy. This helped him but also comes with negatives as they learn things you don't always want them to.

itsdark · 20/11/2023 07:59

I think it's more intelligent for them just to push the button or point themselves. Weird to do it via someone else's hand.

honeysuckleweeks · 20/11/2023 07:56

My youngest DS didn't say a word until he was 3yo . The things people said about him. Varied from Einstein to severe intellectual disability depending upon who you spoke to. Not ND. Just him.Never shut up once he started talking though. Never had one of my four do the hand dragging thing. Seems quite an intelligent to do to me as they are making sure you know what they want. People get hung up on things . Ignore, smile and nod.

BruceAndNosh · 20/11/2023 07:56

Passepartoute · 20/11/2023 07:49

Say to her "No, he doesn't need to point, he tells me what he wants using full sentences. Doesn't yours do that yet?"

My one year old sends me a WhatsApp when her nappy needs to be changed😁

Beseen22 · 20/11/2023 07:54

My youngest who is speech delayed hand led constantly and I asked my best friend who is a speech and language therapist about it because I had heard about the link to ASD though realistically I couldn't see anything else that would indicate that. She said that it can be a sign but most children who are speech delayed will show some hand leading because its a method to get what they need without speaking.

Passepartoute · 20/11/2023 07:49

Say to her "No, he doesn't need to point, he tells me what he wants using full sentences. Doesn't yours do that yet?"