Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a thing? Or is my friend deluded about her dc?

109 replies

in183 · 20/11/2023 06:54

Friend has a one year old, who will grab your arm/hand to make you press a button or point to something. Friend is ADAMANT that after having five children that she knows it is a sign of extreme intelligence. I’ve recently had a child and I’m being asked almost every few days if they’ve started to do it. Maybe I’m just sleep deprived but I think it’s absolutely crazy (and bloody annoying to be asked all the time). She is smart generally but I honestly can’t get my head around why she feels so strongly about it!!! Is this a thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sixteenfurryfeet · 20/11/2023 17:53

My cat grabs my hand with his paw and pulls it towards him so I can tickle him under the chin.

He's bright, but also as mad as a box of frogs.

<misses point of thread>

JRM17 · 20/11/2023 17:44

Am I missing something here. Surely by 1yr old the child should be pressing the butting them selves not getting you to do it. I'd have thought by this age they would be able to feed themselves never mind press a button

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 20/11/2023 15:50

Neither of my kids understand pointing at all (it's honestly bizarre - they're tweens now, and I generally don't point to things, but if I do, I have to tell them to look where I'm pointing, because they just don't understand the concept, and have never pointed themselves!)

Both are bright kids.

Sartre · 20/11/2023 15:40

My 3 year old DS has speech delay and he does the hand leading thing, it’s how he gets us to get him what he wants. I don’t think it’s a sign of ultra intelligence although he can read a few books already despite not being able to use communicative language very well.

BardRelic · 20/11/2023 15:35

@Emotionalsupportviper Yes, dogs and horses, the animals domesticated the longest and closest, both use and understand pointing. Someone did some studies in which they got horses to point to a diagram on a chart if they wanted to wear a rug. Personally, I find it easier to wait until the weather is filthy, go to the field, hold the rug up and shout 'do you want to wear this or not?', but that's me.

GodDammitCecil · 20/11/2023 14:49

It’s threads like this that remind you how poor the reading comprehension skills are of your average MNer…

beanii · 20/11/2023 12:17

It's not neuro diverse or intelligence - it's simply your child learning.

Watching you press buttons/switches etc and wanting to do the same but are unable to yet. Once they've watched you for a while, that's when you need to baby proof your home.

PLEASE explain that to your friend 🤦‍♀️😂

meemawww · 20/11/2023 12:02

Ummmm my nephews both communicate like this. One is completely non verbal and the other barely speaks. Not saying they aren't intelligent but they are both autistic and the non verbal one has global developmental delay 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheBerry · 20/11/2023 11:59

I think lots of 1yos do this? Mine does, and I wouldn’t have thought he was exceptionally intelligent. Just seems normal.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 20/11/2023 11:01

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/11/2023 09:20

Oooh!

That would be exciting!

You could be the Power behind his Evil Throne - the only person who can get him to behave himself.

"Now, now, @EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness-son, you give the Crown Jewels back to the King this instant, and say you are sorry, and then you can go to your room and think about what you've done. You may be 46 but you aren't to big to be grounded!"

"But Muuuuuuum . . . "

"NOW!

"I'm so sorry your Majesty - you know what kids are like these days!"

<shouts up the stairs>

"And no sneaking out of the window to wee on the Detective Inspector's bed. I don't want his mother coming round complaining."

<turns to king and policemen>

"Would you like a cup of tea while you're here? We have chocolate malted milk biscuits, or gingersnaps."

If I were youI would get cracking on a Supervillain costume for him now. He sounds like he is going to be in the news pretty soon. 😂

🤣 love it

ThePowerOfNext · 20/11/2023 11:00

I would suggest to your friend that she makes a note of this as part of a diary of development - it might be enjoyable for her to look back on later but it will also come in very handy if her child ever has an asd assessment as there is a of focus on the first 5 years and I can be really hard to remember.

My child was assessed at 8 and I remember hand leading/using someone else’s hand to point was one of the questions. It’s one of the more well known potential “signs” I think, is it possible that your friend is aware of this and is actually concerned, and that is why she keeps asking you if your DC is doing the same?

boong121 · 20/11/2023 10:54

My autistic children started to lead with hands instead of talking, one child is still nonverbal at 3 and leads by hand where she wants to go or if she wants something.

It is what it is with kids why is she so obsessed about it anyways? There are many genius kids it doesn't mean they will 100% become billionaires/millionaires. Some kids genius fades away when they become adults, some go on to work an average job etc.

Nonoatchristmas · 20/11/2023 10:52

Best thing to do is nod and smile. I had a mum at pg say to me ‘my two year old can count to x amount of numbers, I can tell she’s going to be clever’. Mmm. My 2 year old (at the time) knew his times tables up to x13, could write out the answer on paper if you wrote out a sum. He also hand lead me everywhere. He’s autistic (obviously 🤣) but making comparisons just upsets people. Nod and smile every time. Bit of a taboo thing to say, but I’d have much rather my child be not doing all these marvellous tricks (because realistically that’s what they are) than have to struggle with everything else that comes with ASD. Everything balances out in the end though.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 20/11/2023 10:48

itsdark · 20/11/2023 07:59

I think it's more intelligent for them just to push the button or point themselves. Weird to do it via someone else's hand.

That's why it's a potential indicator of ND.

For my son, he is a sensory avoider.

He doesn't like the feeling of touching things. So like a monkey with a stick, my own hand being the stick, he would grab it and press the button or touch the thing.

He's 4 now and turning into quite the sensory seeker now and although still hand leads, he is also independent enough to get things himself now, or press things that need to be pressed. He'll also put gloves on to do it if he thinks it's going to be touch much for him to handle.

BlueGrey1 · 20/11/2023 10:48

Ask her in what study / research article does it state that Hand leading is a sign of extreme intelligence as you cant find any and other people that you have spoken to have said it is more likely to be a sign of ND.
Also not all kids have the same habits whether they are intelligent or not, It is also way to early to be able to say a 1 yo has extreme intelligence, she is talking rubbish

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 20/11/2023 10:34

IncorrigibIeRogue · 20/11/2023 06:58

Um, I thought that "hand leading" was actually a very early potential indicator of neurodivergence!

Are you sure she isn't actually worried about it and trying to get reassurance that other DC do it too?

My son is autistic and hand leads and did from before he could walk. He'd grab my hand and hold it in the direction of the thing he wanted.

That's not to say he's not intelligent though, it just means he has a disability as well.

But I don't see it as an indicator of intelligence.

AtomicPumpkin · 20/11/2023 10:32

Tell her you are so jealous, he obviously has a great career ahead of him as a lift attendant.

BlueMongoose · 20/11/2023 10:01

Some parents will clutch at every straw to suggest their kids are exceptional. 🙄 By definition, most kids aren't. And it's not a sign of good parenting to suggest to them otherwise.

3luckystars · 20/11/2023 09:56

My aunt was constantly CONSTANTLY asking me if my (tiny newborn) son had any teeth, and then gurning if I said no, as if I had some control over it. I was getting this sinking failure feeling about it all.
Then after a while I realised it was a bit funny (and he also grew teeth) but it was good learning for me as a new mother, because we have NO control over any of it.

Just laugh it off.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 20/11/2023 09:54

chineapplepunks · 20/11/2023 07:25

My one year old can do this, has for a while but she also walks around the house with a sock on her hand and a plastic bowl in her head so i'm not sure it's an intelligence thing!

Love it!

Branleuse · 20/11/2023 09:48

I think if someone wants to think that their child is super clever, then just let them get on with it. If your own mum can't think you are the best at everything then who can

ManateeFair · 20/11/2023 09:45

in183 · 20/11/2023 07:07

She asks maybe once a week I’d say. My dd is 7 months and hers did it around one she said!

Regardless of what 'hand-leading' does/doesn't indicate, it's incredibly weird of her to keep on about. Very strange thing for her to be obsessed about. I think I would be inclined to come right out and ask her why she's so fixated on this and ask her to stop because you're finding it really weird.

ThisMama1 · 20/11/2023 09:44

Pointing, leading you to something etc was a question during my son’s development due to his severe autism. Obviously there were lots of other signs such as grouping toys in colours or patterns eg cars in a line of red blue green red blue green etc. I’d be looking to see if there were other things there that indicate autism. My son is in a SEN school, didn’t talk until 6 1/2 & has debilitating sensory & anxiety issues however he is really intelligent too. He just can’t cope with the pressures of schooling but knows so much about so much!

startledbypostmodernity · 20/11/2023 09:43

I think you should be careful of friendships that are competitive around children's development and potentially dent your confidence as a parent. Which isn't to say block her on all socials lol, but just be a bit boundaried.

Chonkadoodle · 20/11/2023 09:42

I’ve had three, I’ve got absolutely no idea what she’s talking about.