Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Big argument with DP. Who is being unreasonable?

140 replies

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:11

DP and I have just had an argument.

I'll give some context to it.

Been together 9 years. Engaged for 5. Mentioned marriage this evening. Not for the first time but it hasn't been mentioned for ages.

Basically it ended with us saying that we won't ever actually get married. DP wants a wedding and I don't.

DP won't get married without his family present.

I have anxiety and low self esteem. The last thing on earth I'd want is to be centre of attention. I want to be legally married. I want us to be husband and wife. I just don't want a wedding.

DP does. Even if it's registry office with family followed by a meal with family. I don't even want this. It's too much for me.

We both have small families. DP has eleven relatives (including children from his previous marriage) that he would want there and who he is close to.

Besides my mother, I have some aunties and uncles and a few cousins. I don't see or maintain contact with any of them. So the grand total of relatives I'd be inviting is 1. My mum. That's it. The only family on my side. And for reasons unrelated she wouldn't come.

I also see getting married about the two of us and not anyone else.

I could probably add a load more about our previous conversations and issues surrounding marriage but it would be really long. Eg. DP being married before, a very shitty engagement and so on.

But the gist of this argument is about wedding v marriage.

So who is being unreasonable here?

I just figured if he really wanted to marry me it wouldn't matter if anyone else was present or not.

OP posts:
YabbaDabbaDooooo · 19/11/2023 23:52

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:49

OK maybe I'm being unreasonable.

Just that he won't ever talk about getting married. It's always me that mentions it and tries to get the ball rolling on plans. If I hadn't mentioned it tonight, first time in probably over a year, then it probably wouldn't have ever been mentioned ever again. So I can't help but feel he doesn't actually want to despite the fact he says otherwise.

You're the one who sounds like they don't want to, to me anyway.

It's all about you. You'll allow two people of his choice into the registry office but no more.

The others have to meet you at the restaurant.

It sounds like you're putting up ridiculous hurdles, not him.

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:52

WallaceinAnderland · 19/11/2023 23:48

He doesn't want to get married.

These are all just stalling tactics. Call his bluff. Say you'll do it his way and watch him back pedal.

I kind of feel like this is what would happen.

I did once say yes to what he wanted (a long time ago, marriage has been discussed several times since then), and it was oh, but that'll be expensive so we'll need to save. No saving happened. No provisional date set. No concrete plans made. Never mentioned again until I brought it up months and months later.

I'll try it. Tomorrow I'll agree and see what he says.

OP posts:
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 19/11/2023 23:50

There's a really simple compromise solution to this. Registry office with just the two of you as per your wishes, family meal afterwards as per his wishes.

If you cannot reach this compromise, then I don't believe that both of you actually really want to or should get married.

DuplicateUserName · 19/11/2023 23:50

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:37

He's adamant that he does. But it doesn't feel like it. There's always a reason why we can't sit down properply to discuss wedding plans. Some reason why this year won't work, next year won't, why this month won't work or that month. No money, etc.

But no, that's me being insecure. He definitely definitely wants us to get married.

Well yes, what's the point in him sitting down to discuss it when you're basically asking that his family stand outside the office (aside from 2 people for legality) before they can finally go for something to eat.

It's 15 minutes in a panelled room to sign some paperwork.

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:49

OK maybe I'm being unreasonable.

Just that he won't ever talk about getting married. It's always me that mentions it and tries to get the ball rolling on plans. If I hadn't mentioned it tonight, first time in probably over a year, then it probably wouldn't have ever been mentioned ever again. So I can't help but feel he doesn't actually want to despite the fact he says otherwise.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 19/11/2023 23:48

He doesn't want to get married.

These are all just stalling tactics. Call his bluff. Say you'll do it his way and watch him back pedal.

DuplicateUserName · 19/11/2023 23:46

There's an awful lot about you and your wants and needs in all this, and not much about your partner.

You've been together for 9 years, you live together, you have DC together. A quick registry office and a meal with his family will not put you at the centre of attention.

It just won't. No matter what way you look at it, it's just a formal bit and then some food.

But if you don't want that and you can't both think of a compromise (I can't either to be honest as he's not asking for the world), then I guess you should just both forget it.

But I'd be really pissed off if the person I love wouldn't agree to a very quick wedding in a room and a bite to eat with my family.

BarryK3nt · 19/11/2023 23:46

Well it doesn’t exactly sound like he’s demanding a huge wedding does it? Just his close family members. So he’s probably already compromising, I think you need to do the same.

5foot5 · 19/11/2023 23:43

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:29

My anxiety mostly manifests as health anxiety. Which I'm medicated for.

I just hate the spotlight. Do family meals out regularly. Function normally, work, shopping, kids, etc. Unaffected by anxiety.

Sorry but this sounds like a huge fuss about nothing which I am sure you could manage if you really wanted to.

You can manage family meals out and it sounds like you could potentially limit guests to less than twenty.

Loads of people don't much like being in the spotlight. It's not "anxiety" it's just normal bashfulness. You can manage it for one day. Once it's over relax and get on with your life. Everyone has to do something they are a bit nervous about sometimes.

Abstractreader · 19/11/2023 23:42

Hang on a sec.

You say he has children from his previous relationship and I'm guessing they wouldn't be of legal age to witness, meaning you'd be denying him the opportunity to have his children there and just choose two of his family members at the registry office?

You need to budge a bit I'm afraid. Eleven relatives is barely anything. Ask if he can cut it to immediate family, siblings, mum and dad and kids, but I don't think it's fair to ask more than that.

No big dress, no aisle, just the formalities and a quick wedding followed by a meal or a spread done by either you or some caterers at home?

Otherwise you'll be in a stalemate forever.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 19/11/2023 23:41

So because you have no longer have anyone you want to share a wedding with, you don't want your DP to have his family there?

You would have put aside your anxiety when there was something in it for you, but now there's not, you won't.

Wow.

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:37

IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 19/11/2023 23:29

He doesn't want to get married at all by the sounds of your update. You've already had a baby with him. There's no reason for him to think he needs to now.

He's adamant that he does. But it doesn't feel like it. There's always a reason why we can't sit down properply to discuss wedding plans. Some reason why this year won't work, next year won't, why this month won't work or that month. No money, etc.

But no, that's me being insecure. He definitely definitely wants us to get married.

OP posts:
Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:34

The man I wanted to walk me down the 'aisle' is dead. I have no friends. No family besides my mother, who wouldn't attend anyway.

I'd be happy to go to the registry office with two witnesses of his choice followed by a relaxed family meal, but I think he wants everyone there at the registry office, too.

OP posts:
margotrose · 19/11/2023 23:31

From your update it sounds like you probably shouldn't marry at all,

everythingthelighttouches · 19/11/2023 23:30

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:17

It just feels like there isn't a compromise.

A few years ago, I didn't mind the idea of a low key wedding and celebrating, in fact, I got quite excited about the prospect, but things have changed, our relationship has changed and I've changed.

This is a bit cryptic OP???

If you have changed your mind to the point where you can’t even have the lowest of low key weddings, then the reason why is probably relevant to any answers we give you.

I don’t think he’s asking too much actually, and agree you need help with anxiety if you can’t manage this.

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:29

Heatwavenotify · 19/11/2023 23:28

Have you ever been out for a family meal? If you’ve never managed a family meal then it’s about your anxiety. If you have, then perhaps subconsciously you are putting obstacles in the way because you don’t really want to get married but don’t want to admit to it.

My anxiety mostly manifests as health anxiety. Which I'm medicated for.

I just hate the spotlight. Do family meals out regularly. Function normally, work, shopping, kids, etc. Unaffected by anxiety.

OP posts:
IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 19/11/2023 23:29

He doesn't want to get married at all by the sounds of your update. You've already had a baby with him. There's no reason for him to think he needs to now.

Heatwavenotify · 19/11/2023 23:28

Have you ever been out for a family meal? If you’ve never managed a family meal then it’s about your anxiety. If you have, then perhaps subconsciously you are putting obstacles in the way because you don’t really want to get married but don’t want to admit to it.

Lovemychair · 19/11/2023 23:27

What has changed, if you were ok with a small wedding before, why don't you want one now?

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:27

BitOutOfPractice · 19/11/2023 23:19

Your relationship has changed? In what way?

When we first got together, I was young and it was my first relationship. I had all these ideas and plans which I talked to DP about.

I made it clear I wanted to get married. I wanted a wedding with friends and family. I wanted a child. Maybe two. Max. But I wanted to be married first.

DP said he didn't rate marriage much and thought it was pointless but if it was what I wanted then we would get married at some point. But he was never ready. I let it go. I kept letting it go. But I was desperate to see some commitment, so form of demonstration of his love.

One night he said he was ready to have a child. I didn't understand how he could commit to that but still not be ready for marriage. I saw children as a far greater commitment. But I was so desperate for his commitment I agreed. I wanted to be married first but I wanted commitment and I wanted children one day anyway.

So, we had a child. Still no signs of marriage. Then he forgot our anniversary and proposed because I was upset. He swore he was planning it for a few weeks later anyway but that was always going to be hard to believe. He did then propose properly a few weeks later but looking back I can barely remember that. I can only remember the upset and the spur of the moment proposal.

We then talked about weddings and marriage, the when, what, etc. Nothing ever came of it. He never seemed to engaged in the convos. Life got in the way, we didn't have much money. And since then I've sort of made peace with the fact that we won't get married. Convinced myself I didn't want to.

But we've gotten a lot closer, lately. And in my head the idea re-emerged.

OP posts:
wesurecouldstandgladioli · 19/11/2023 23:26

I think YABU. He wants your marriage to be witnessed, that’s not a lot to ask.

margotrose · 19/11/2023 23:25

FiveWordsWillDoNotEightyFive · 19/11/2023 23:23

if he really wanted to marry me it wouldn't matter if anyone else was present or not.

but you could flip that and say if you really wanted to marry him, it wouldn’t matter if anyone else was there.

I definitely read this exact same scenario the other night.

I'm glad it's not just me - I've definitely read this before!

FiveWordsWillDoNotEightyFive · 19/11/2023 23:23

if he really wanted to marry me it wouldn't matter if anyone else was present or not.

but you could flip that and say if you really wanted to marry him, it wouldn’t matter if anyone else was there.

I definitely read this exact same scenario the other night.

IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 19/11/2023 23:23

I had the same agreement with a boyfriend. It never happened.

Sockmate123 · 19/11/2023 23:22

Peppermint81 · 19/11/2023 23:15

What about registry office with just your parents, whether 1 or 2?
Then drinks/food spread at your house after?

Need to do something after the ceremony, or it won't be memorable at all!

This, this is a good compromise! Could you invite a couple of friends from 'your' side if not close to family?

Swipe left for the next trending thread