Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Big argument with DP. Who is being unreasonable?

140 replies

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:11

DP and I have just had an argument.

I'll give some context to it.

Been together 9 years. Engaged for 5. Mentioned marriage this evening. Not for the first time but it hasn't been mentioned for ages.

Basically it ended with us saying that we won't ever actually get married. DP wants a wedding and I don't.

DP won't get married without his family present.

I have anxiety and low self esteem. The last thing on earth I'd want is to be centre of attention. I want to be legally married. I want us to be husband and wife. I just don't want a wedding.

DP does. Even if it's registry office with family followed by a meal with family. I don't even want this. It's too much for me.

We both have small families. DP has eleven relatives (including children from his previous marriage) that he would want there and who he is close to.

Besides my mother, I have some aunties and uncles and a few cousins. I don't see or maintain contact with any of them. So the grand total of relatives I'd be inviting is 1. My mum. That's it. The only family on my side. And for reasons unrelated she wouldn't come.

I also see getting married about the two of us and not anyone else.

I could probably add a load more about our previous conversations and issues surrounding marriage but it would be really long. Eg. DP being married before, a very shitty engagement and so on.

But the gist of this argument is about wedding v marriage.

So who is being unreasonable here?

I just figured if he really wanted to marry me it wouldn't matter if anyone else was present or not.

OP posts:
Gazelda · 20/11/2023 07:43

Would you be ok if your DC were there?

WiIIowT · 20/11/2023 07:41

I think YABU given that it seems to be more about you having no one from your side there. If you don't like attention you could just make sure everyone knows not to make any fuss of you, and just leave you to it.

gannett · 20/11/2023 07:40

The most surprising aspect of the OP's updates is that she says she and her partner have gotten a lot closer recently. Because the heart of this AIBU seems to be the lingering resentment over his initial reluctance to get married and then the underwhelming proposal. It doesn't sound like the relationship is getting better, from the context.

OP says she would have been fine with a wedding all those years ago, but no longer is. She hasn't said her anxiety has got worse over the years, but the relationship has changed. It seems like at least one of them is playing games over the wedding/marriage. OP thinks her partner still doesn't want to marry her, and is thus suggesting a wedding she "can't" do in order to stay unmarried. At the same time she's weaponising her anxiety to veto a wedding (that she would have been able to do in the past) because she doesn't trust him.

Absolutely none of this is healthy! I have no idea whether OP is right to be mistrustful but the levels of deception she assumes of her partner, and the second-guessing/game-playing she is a full part of herself, are not things anyone should go into marriage with. If the two of them can't untangle all of that, they shouldn't get married at all. (If the OP and her partner have indeed become closer, for reasons she hasn't given, that closeness should be the starting point to actually building some trust into this relationship.)

In light of all that I feel the nature of the wedding is actually a red herring. All I'll say on that front is that her partner's suggestion - low-key registry office with a handful of family members - usually IS the compromise. There isn't much of a compromise beyond that. But it's not actually the point, is it?

Valerianandfoxglovesoup · 20/11/2023 07:35

I don't want to be cruel but I don't think I would be rushing to commit my life to someone who was unable to function at such a basic level. We all do things we hate, I hated my wedding, I have also had a few industry awards which were so painful for me but I needed the legal status of marriage for wills etc, and I wanted the recognition and promotion. In fact, I would be far more comfortable not working at all, it's really stressful but it's just life. In the UK, anxiety seems to be a job title rather than something we want to overcome.

Zanatdy · 20/11/2023 07:29

Well I can understand his upset about getting married without family present as most people want a parent there. If it’s anxiety stopping you then you’re not being unreasonable. It’s you who would be more at risk from not being married, especially if taking time off work or going part time. If I was in that situation I’d suck it up for the day and get married

Laurdo · 20/11/2023 07:24

Maddy70 · 19/11/2023 23:17

Yabu. You Need treatment for your anxiety as its impacting on your lives

This. If your anxiety is so bad you can't be in a room and enjoy a meal with a dozen family members then you need to seek help. Especially since only a year ago you were excited by the prospect. Why didn't you do it a year ago? Why has it taken all this time to get married? Obviously not a money thing since you aren't planning a big wedding.

CommonOrNot · 20/11/2023 07:20

Oh fgs. Yabu.

Sparkletastic · 20/11/2023 07:10

You don't sound very happy with your life OP.

pickledandpuzzled · 20/11/2023 07:07

I’m a bit worried about you! It sounds like it’s been a difficult relationship, with him calling the shots and you having to fall into line.

It sounds like he’s manipulating things so it’s always your fault.

On a practical level, what’s in it for you both now? Are their inheritance implications, is it financially most beneficial for him or for you to marry?

If it is in your interests to marry, could you do so in a private ceremony with just parents but have a meal with guests afterwards?

I’m not sure finding a way that works is in your interests, to be honest. I feel it may just give him another opportunity to disappoint you.

It gives him so much power, repeatedly offering and then backing out of marriage.

💐

willWillSmithsmith · 20/11/2023 06:56

Octavia64 · 19/11/2023 23:16

So for example you could do the registry office with his 11 relatives but then him and his 11 relatives go out for the meal and you go home to chill.

That would be very weird to go to the meal without the person you just married.

NumberTheory · 20/11/2023 06:53

Why don’t you have any friends to invite? Have they all fallen away as you’ve become less confident?

It sounds to me as though his lack of interest in getting married over the years (and possibly other ways he’s treated you) has left you feeling a bit worthless and unsure of yourself. Is marrying him actually a good idea? You say it’s your only relationship - is it possible you’ve settled for someone who doesn’t treat you that well, where things are a bit one sided? Have you considered getting yourself some counseling to try and work out where your confidence has gone and what you can do to rebuild it.

SunRainStorm · 20/11/2023 06:26

It's just a registry visit and then a meal with his family- does your anxiety really restrict you to the point this isnt possible?

Your child will be there so you will have a relative in attendance.

If I was you and I really wanted to be married I'd pop a Valium and get on with it. It's an hour or two and it probably won't be as bad as you think.

I'd ask DP to word his family up prior so no fuss is made.

I had a massive wedding for the sake of my family. DH and I both HATE being the centre of attention. We hacked this by asking the cheekiest children we knew to be in the bridal party- it worked a treat- everyone was looking at them because they were adorable and hilarious and out of control.

How old is your child? Buy them an adorable outfit and load them up with sugar- no one will look twice at you.

Hibiscrubbed · 20/11/2023 05:14

When we first got together, I was young and it was my first relationship. I had all these ideas and plans which I talked to DP about

Is there an age gap here? You say he has children from his previous marriage, but he’s your first relationship.

It all sounds a bit miserable now. I can’t work out what your main issue is, that he wants his meagre family there or that you think he’s pretending and is using that to delay, knowing it’s ’too much’ for you.

monsteramunch · 20/11/2023 05:05

user1492757084 · 20/11/2023 03:47

I thought Meghan Markle was the only person who had only one relative worth sharing any celebration with!!
You both sound like you have been stubborn or selfish over time about the wedding/committment.

Could you compromise.
Unless you do then you will not get married.

You could plan a wedding but make it a surprise to all the guests.

Invite people to your child's Christening or something.
Book a hotel venue for a special meal before the Christening with all the family and meet at the hotel.
An MC invites every one out to the garden (or to the registry office or church next door) for a wedding.
Get married, eat, dance, laugh and share the joy. Your family will be happy for you. MC has written a speech, a toast.

You guys respond with thanks for every one for coming.

Ask your family to post you any photos they took.
.. Happily ever after ...

How is that a compromise considering OP says the below?

The last thing on earth I'd want is to be centre of attention. I want to be legally married. I want us to be husband and wife. I just don't want a wedding.

DP does. Even if it's registry office with family followed by a meal with family. I don't even want this. It's too much for me.

YerArseInParsley · 20/11/2023 04:30

user1492757084 · 20/11/2023 03:47

I thought Meghan Markle was the only person who had only one relative worth sharing any celebration with!!
You both sound like you have been stubborn or selfish over time about the wedding/committment.

Could you compromise.
Unless you do then you will not get married.

You could plan a wedding but make it a surprise to all the guests.

Invite people to your child's Christening or something.
Book a hotel venue for a special meal before the Christening with all the family and meet at the hotel.
An MC invites every one out to the garden (or to the registry office or church next door) for a wedding.
Get married, eat, dance, laugh and share the joy. Your family will be happy for you. MC has written a speech, a toast.

You guys respond with thanks for every one for coming.

Ask your family to post you any photos they took.
.. Happily ever after ...

Have you read the post? Op doesn't want to get married with anyone there. I don't understand your idea of pretending to invite people to a christening?

user1492757084 · 20/11/2023 03:47

I thought Meghan Markle was the only person who had only one relative worth sharing any celebration with!!
You both sound like you have been stubborn or selfish over time about the wedding/committment.

Could you compromise.
Unless you do then you will not get married.

You could plan a wedding but make it a surprise to all the guests.

Invite people to your child's Christening or something.
Book a hotel venue for a special meal before the Christening with all the family and meet at the hotel.
An MC invites every one out to the garden (or to the registry office or church next door) for a wedding.
Get married, eat, dance, laugh and share the joy. Your family will be happy for you. MC has written a speech, a toast.

You guys respond with thanks for every one for coming.

Ask your family to post you any photos they took.
.. Happily ever after ...

Concannon88 · 20/11/2023 03:34

That was a different poster, they had children together and other differences and hadn't had any conversations in the past about a wedding

Concannon88 · 20/11/2023 03:30

You are bot being unreasonable to not want a wedding. But he is not being unreasonable to want one. I think you'll have to leave the idea altogether and let the engagement go.

junbean · 20/11/2023 03:28

Weddings have very little to do with marriage! I can't see how he's a good match for you if he can't understand your side of this. How will it be a good marriage if it's all his way or the highway? You won't have any guests! That alone is enough to plan something else, like an intimate ceremony for just the two of you. He can go have a party with his family later. Everything you mentioned is the opposite what a marriage is about. I would be thinking of other possible life paths besides staying with him...

YerArseInParsley · 20/11/2023 03:24

Isittimeformynapyet · 20/11/2023 00:26

I find it very sad that you don't have any friends. And perhaps a bit odd.

I hope you are happy with that though 💐

I don't have any friends either and there's nothing odd about me.

I dumped my friends years ago, all they ever done was take from me or used me until something better comes along. I've been there for people but it's never given back. I would love friends but it's not easy making friends in your late 40s, besides I've come to the conclusion that I'll never get a decent friend, I'm only good for helping others when they need me.

YerArseInParsley · 20/11/2023 03:18

Elentwelvedoc · 19/11/2023 23:34

The man I wanted to walk me down the 'aisle' is dead. I have no friends. No family besides my mother, who wouldn't attend anyway.

I'd be happy to go to the registry office with two witnesses of his choice followed by a relaxed family meal, but I think he wants everyone there at the registry office, too.

Why don't you, like someone suggested already, be in the room before the guests arrive? At least you don't need to walk in and feel like people are looking at you. You could also ask to be seated so yous aren't standing up infront of everyone.

I think your husband only having 11 people is quite reasonable. You could also ask that guests be seated at the back of the room so they aren't right behind you. That could be your compromise.

Do you think that would be doable?

BlueEyedPeanut · 20/11/2023 03:14

He doesn't want to get married. You could try telling him ok you'll have the wedding the way he wants, then see if he actually makes any effort, but I strongly doubt he will. Quite simply, if he wanted to marry you, he would.

pizzaHeart · 20/11/2023 00:58

I can’t help thinking that it’s not about your anxiety, it’s about your frustration and disappointment that you still are not married and you blame your partner for this, rightly so by the way. So you have problems in your relationship and it affects your communication. I’m not surprised that you can’t find a compromise as you are discussing the wrong issue.
You want your DP to behave differently and show that he wants to marry you and takes this seriously. Atm it looks like he just wanted a kid at some point and now wants a celebratory meal with his family.
It’s just my feeling from your posts, I might be wrong of course.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 20/11/2023 00:37

@Elentwelvedoc She's an alcoholic with agoraphobia who won't even leave the house to get food shopping.

She also hates weddings and said she won't go to weddings (predating the agraphobia) I asked if she would make an exception for mine and she said no.

So you want to do to your DP what your DM is doing to you?

Isittimeformynapyet · 20/11/2023 00:26

I find it very sad that you don't have any friends. And perhaps a bit odd.

I hope you are happy with that though 💐

Swipe left for the next trending thread