Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think preferences should be taken into account?

294 replies

SuiGeneris · 19/11/2023 22:38

So: we are spending Christmas with MIL, as every year. Every year she orders a turkey etc and everyone is expected to have some of that and the vegetables. The children and I don't like turkey, so we mostly eat vegetables and just have the smallest decent slice of turkey possible, for appearances' sake.

Yet I do find it odd that no attempt is made to try other things we might dislike less. After all, judging from supermarkets, there are plenty of alternatives people consider and it is well-known none of us like eating meat. We are not vegetarian but just don't like it that much. DH takes the view the kids need to be exposed to Christmas traditions and I am a grown up so can work around the turkey.

Is turkey really such a big deal for Brits? Surely if it isn't a treat it would be better not to have the kids associate Christmas with a meal they have to endure?

Or AIBU and we should just put up with it, after all it is only one day?

OP posts:
purplehair1 · 20/11/2023 21:58

Why don’t you bring an alternative that you like? I agree, Turkey is a bit dry for me. Have to cover it in gravy :)

CaramelMac · 20/11/2023 21:47

I love turkey, I wouldn’t even consider having anything else on Christmas Day, I think if you want something else you need to take it with you.

Duechristmas · 20/11/2023 21:45

YABU, if you were hosting, you could choose, if you're going to somebody else's house, you get on and eat the turkey.

Crazycrazylady · 20/11/2023 21:45

Honestly turkey is so bland , I totally get people not enjoying it but am surprised to hear of people 'hating it' it's pretty inoffensive as meats go.
The trimmings are always the best bits anyway. If it's important to your mil then I would suck it up and fill up on the good stuff.

AuntMarch · 20/11/2023 21:40

I enjoy the traditional dinner (If done well), but I enjoy people's company more. We'll be warming up a curry so nobody has to spend the day in the kitchen.

Ultimately of course it is rude not to eat the meal provided if you have accepted an invitation, but a "are you sure you want to go to all that trouble, we'd be fine with something simpler" ahead of time might be ok?

Citrusandginger · 20/11/2023 21:02

If it's meat you don't like OP could you take some vegetarian canapé type things that would go with the dinner?
Something like mini cranberry & Brie parcels would go well with a small slice of Turkey, a sausage & lots of bread sauce.

I also recommend a meat thermometer. Turkey needs to come out at about 67 degrees. It will reach the magic 75 degrees while resting, and be much juicier if it's not overcooked.

rookiemere · 20/11/2023 20:58

Even if you don't like turkey, surely there must be something you and the DCs like from the pigs in blankets, stuffing, roast potatoes and veg.
Yes it is traditional in the UK for most people to have a turkey dinner. It's traditional. It's one meal. When MIL is unable to cook any more, you can have what you want.

Amberjane41 · 20/11/2023 20:55

This has got to be one of the most entitled posts I’ve seen on here. I am betting that this has absolutely nothing to do with ‘Turkey’ and more to do with the fact that you clearly don’t like your mother in law and probably don’t want to spend Xmas with her and therefore looking for anyway you can to make her the bad guy, even though she is hosting and cooking a dinner for you and your whole family. Poor woman. It’s hard work cooking a dinner for loads of people and your sat there I bet not disguising the fact you don’t like it, even though it’s a traditional Christmas dinner! It sounds to me like what ever she cooked you’d have a problem with

Thudercatsrule · 20/11/2023 20:49

We are spending the day with MIL and she is doing goose and nut roast, neither of which i'll eat or my kids.

So we are having our turkey xmas dinner on xmas eve as a compromise.

Cloie · 20/11/2023 20:46

I used to bring veggie burgers and just fry them and have the potatoes and other trimmings but skip the turkey. These days there are 3 of us who don’t eat meat so we all chip in for a veggie roast and have that alongside the other bits. My mum doesn’t mind at all as long as it’s nothing complicated that will take lots of time or prep and that one of us cooks it.

It’s not a big deal and not over complicated - I think it would be different if we took out a curry and didn’t eat anything she cooked or if we decided we were making something from scratch and started taking up kitchen space.

toomuchfaff · 20/11/2023 20:28

We never cook turkey in our house, it's still Christmas, with Lamb, Beef and Pork..

LeHamelRenard · 20/11/2023 20:27

If I was hosting a meal and I knew full well that the majority of people didn’t enjoy it I’d feel awful. Especially people I loved ie grandchildren. Tradition is overrated.
YANBU

toomuchfaff · 20/11/2023 20:27

YANBU

there's a reason that Tesco and all the other supermarkets and all the adverts show about 5 different meats and vegetarian offerings... Christmas isn't just about Turkey. MIL sounds like she may need a poke, offer to take a nut roast or other suitable addition to "add" to the table. You're not asking her to cook anything else, you're not offending her, simply helping.

TeenLifeMum · 20/11/2023 20:27

I’ve never had dry turkey and the leg meat is fab plus all the sides. I’m doing traditional Christmas dinner and haven’t asked for preferences… I’m not running a restaurant and if I’m cooking I’ll cook what I want to eat. If guests want something different they can go somewhere else.

DinoDunks · 20/11/2023 20:09

We alternate who hosts in my family and we also all being a dish. Means we get a great spread as everyone puts lots of effort into their contribution without anyone being lumped with all the work. Of course the host ends up doing more than others but as we take turns that’s ok.

We tend to have a mix of meats, beef, pheasant/mixed bird roast.

Abbyant · 20/11/2023 20:07

I’m not a fan of turkey and neither our my parents they’d do chicken or beef usually, I’m doing turkey for dp and children and a nut roast for myself this year, as I usually just have the veg.

billyt · 20/11/2023 16:45

I love turkey (and contrary to some posters ) it's never dry.

But I realise not everyone is a turkey-lover so always do beef and pork. (I'd do a salmon as well but no-one wants it. Also, a veggie option.

Roll on Turkey at Christmas.

Desolatewardrobe · 20/11/2023 14:25

I think many of the replies on here are unnecessary in tone. The OP is just wondering what the norm is. And many people wouldn't insist on cooking something their regular guests don't like much so all the people posting how ungrateful a guest the OP is are only representing part of the population.

The many, many threads from people wondering what to cook at Christmas for their family and friends with different dietary requirements demonstrates how common this is, as do the responses that anyone posting 'I make turkey, end of' get when that happens. @SuiGeneris I'd have a look in the Christmas or Food and Drink threads to see how many times this sort of thing comes up and the variety of foods.

There are also a LOT of threads discussing how many of the Christmas traditions are observed under sufferance because of the preferences and demands of other family members. We fit into other people's lives because that's how society works most of the time; we compromise and accommodate. But it doesn't mean expressing a degree of unhappiness about it anonymously in a different place makes us nasty people - the posters attacking the OP on here must be reading a different thread to me.

Disturbia81 · 20/11/2023 14:08

Not had a dry turkey in years as I wrap it in bacon.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2023 13:59

It just seems odd to me to insist on cooking three different kinds of meat (turkey, pigs in blankets and stuffing) when the guests you have never eat meat with you at any other time of the year. It seems there are a few people for whom the tradition is so important that it trumps whether the guests actually like the meal at all. There are others who, like me, are not so bothered and would just try to do something that pleases everyone, but it is clear we are in a minority

So issue closed, we'll continue to eat the turkey as we would if it were served at formal dinner party, when you eat whatever is put in front of you regardless.

This sounds you're not interested in making some adjustments to Christmas dinner to reflect you don't eat much meat, but you're expecting someone else to either not cook Christmas dinner on Christmas day or cook two meals on Christmas day because some of your family are fussy and would rather have a totally different meal.

It sounds like your DH is right about the kids needing to accept different foods.

If you don't want Christmas dinner, don't go round to someone else's house on Christmas Day. Stay at home and cook whatever food you and your children will eat.

mindutopia · 20/11/2023 12:53

I do a turkey for Christmas - though one year we did a goose because it was COVID and I couldn't get a turkey, but a neighbour was selling goose for some ridiculous amount of money and we were stuck. We only have turkey twice a year (I do a Thanksgiving meal too, in a nod to my American heritage). I don't know if guests who show up like turkey or not, and frankly, I've never asked, but if you insist on coming for a meal (we never invite people, they either ask, or just get in touch to tell us what day they will arrive, which is another issue), you get what I'm serving. There's always plenty of sides and no one would go hungry, even if they don't like one part of the meal. That said, we let people serve up themselves and I wouldn't notice or be offended if they didn't take any turkey. I just wouldn't have beef or a ham or whatever on Christmas, because it's not Christmas to me, then it's just Sunday lunch. But I also wouldn't complain if someone else was kind enough to host me and didn't make a turkey.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 20/11/2023 12:37

CremeEggSupremacy · 20/11/2023 09:16

If you want to cook a meal that nobody but yourself likes then don’t host? Just make it for yourself and don’t inflict it on people who don’t like it. Loads of absolutely terrible sounding hosts on here. I bet MIL would also kick up a stink if OP did just stay home and ate something nice instead.

Edited

Unless I have missed it, nowhere has OP said she has discussed this with MIL and she eats the turkey every Christmas, albeit a slice, so I suspect that MIL is blissfully unaware.

I would make pigs in blankets even if one two or three round the table ate them.

ohdamnitjanet · 20/11/2023 12:30

geoger · 19/11/2023 22:43

We, like lots of others I’d imagine, do a selection of meats at Christmas eg Turkey, gammon, beef and a side of salmon.
maybe you could roast a different meat and take it to your MIL or maybe you could make a veggie alternative if your family don’t like eating meat

I’ve only known one person offer a selection of meats at Christmas. I really don’t think many people could possibly afford this, or want the waste. But I do think MIL could be a bit more accommodating or be fine with guests contributing something else.

FinallyHere · 20/11/2023 12:26

the consensus is that that having the traditional meal is more important than people eating something they might enjoy

I had thought that this was a generational thing.

DF was all about tradition and DM always backed him up. It was almost as if he gloried in forcing people to eat things they don't like in order to pay a 'homage' to Tradition in the form of Christmas.

It's been bliss since DP's became too old to manage Christmas, DSis took over catering and manages quietly to cater for different preferences and I take everyone out for a meal to Christmas Eve so her kitchen has a rest the day before the onslaught.

What's more important, doing the same as you last time or catering to some preferences. I'd always prioritise the comfort and wellbeing of my guests. And if they just didn't like anything, I'd have no problem with their not eating it but probably not invite them again.

phoenixrosehere · 20/11/2023 11:45

user1497207191 · 20/11/2023 10:32

I agree. I hate all "meat and two veg" type meals and therefore I hate the traditional turkey dinner. We stopped having it years ago. It's pointless wasting all the time and money preparing and cooking a meal that lots of people don't actually like, just because it's traditional!

Same. Not keen, never have been and usually just filled up on sides. I don’t mind turkey but few actually do it well ime, where it isn’t dry. I have only had turkey once where it was tender and juicy to the point when they sliced into it, clear juices ran out of it at my aunt and uncle’s and that was over a decade ago.

We spend Christmas at the in-laws most years (stay in an hotel) and MIL plates everyone’s food instead of people choosing what they want. I just cover it in vegetable gravy and eat it, hoping dessert will be something nice.

Christmases we spend at home, we order curry instead which I heavily prefer and look forward to this Christmas. DH will likely make his roast on Boxing Day because he enjoys making them even though he leaves the kitchen in a state afterwards that makes me want to chuck every pot and pan that he used unnecessarily to make it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread