Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think preferences should be taken into account?

294 replies

SuiGeneris · 19/11/2023 22:38

So: we are spending Christmas with MIL, as every year. Every year she orders a turkey etc and everyone is expected to have some of that and the vegetables. The children and I don't like turkey, so we mostly eat vegetables and just have the smallest decent slice of turkey possible, for appearances' sake.

Yet I do find it odd that no attempt is made to try other things we might dislike less. After all, judging from supermarkets, there are plenty of alternatives people consider and it is well-known none of us like eating meat. We are not vegetarian but just don't like it that much. DH takes the view the kids need to be exposed to Christmas traditions and I am a grown up so can work around the turkey.

Is turkey really such a big deal for Brits? Surely if it isn't a treat it would be better not to have the kids associate Christmas with a meal they have to endure?

Or AIBU and we should just put up with it, after all it is only one day?

OP posts:
Coconutter24 · 21/11/2023 14:10

Not being unreasonable to not want to eat something you don’t like but YABU if you want them to scrap the turkey altogether to try something new. I would just send a message as a heads up that you will be bringing an alternative to dinner, your kids can have the turkey or alternative which ever they fancy, MIL can have her turkey surely then everyone is happy. Your DH said about traditions, well the kids can see there’s a turkey and can choose it if they wish. A tradition is great yes but doesn’t mean it’s the law everyone has to eat turkey (although I couldn’t have a Christmas dinner without turkey lol)

crumblingschools · 21/11/2023 13:30

Do you not take any contribution to the food/drink when you go? As the same person is hosting every year, it is polite to offer to bring something

rookiemere · 21/11/2023 12:48

It is quite common in the UK to have smoked salmon as a starter to a Christmas meal.

So with your update, maybe the way to make this more palatable is bring along some nice packets of smoked salmon to serve either as a starter, or alongside the turkey- so the DCs don't spoil their appetites before the main course.

MassageForLife · 21/11/2023 12:36

TheAlchemistElixa · 21/11/2023 07:25

Isn’t goose or capon much more traditional in Britain than turkey? I thought the turkey tradition was a more recent import from America around the 1950s or so. Happy to be proved wrong though.

Anyway, regardless, turkey is a truly miserable food and only just about tolerable in a sandwich with lots of other things to distract from its miserableness.

It's much, much earlier than that. Turkey has been in the UK since iirc the 1500s, and has been standard for Christmas dinner since the 1800s.

1950 was when Bernard Matthews decided to cash in on it.

Talipesmum · 21/11/2023 12:09

kidneymidney · 21/11/2023 11:57

@Spirallingdownwards how do you cook it so it isn't dry?

Smother with seasoned herby butter, cover in bacon and wrap in foil for most of the cooking.

To think preferences should be taken into account?
kidneymidney · 21/11/2023 11:57

@Spirallingdownwards how do you cook it so it isn't dry?

Silvers11 · 21/11/2023 11:39

I don't enjoy Turkey, especially the darker meat from a Turkey, so I never cook one. It's pretty tasteless. Chicken is only marginally better. But if I went to someone's house and they were doing the cooking I would eat it and not actually complain.

Having said that, when I am at home and doing the cooking, We usually have Beef Wellington or occasionally goose, if I can get one. But I should say, we usually go out for our Dinner on Christmas Day, and Beef or Salmon are often options on the restaurant/hotel menus, so not a problem

I agree with you though @SuiGeneris - If MIL knows you aren't keen on meat, especially turkey, it seems a shame that she doesn't also provide an alternative. Most people I know would want to serve food options which everyone could eat

Talipesmum · 21/11/2023 11:38

(2) MIL is aware we don't eat much meat but we don't make a big deal of it because we don't want her to feel uncomfortable if she does decide to serve meat. If it gets served (as it will) we just take a small helping. All of us do, children included. And of course we don't comment about it, as that would be rude.

Good background, OP. As you’ve seen, though there are variations, turkey is very embedded as a key ingredient of Xmas meal for many.

With my family, the above point would be key. A traditional Xmas lunch has so much part of it that isn’t meat, I can well imagine that someone who vaguely knows that you “don’t eat much meat” would find plenty to enjoy, especially as she knows you aren’t vegetarian. But I think you’ve kind of shot yourself in the foot here by not clarifying your preferences - or your DH clarifying them for you. She may well genuinely think all is well. If it were me, I’d want to know that you’d really appreciate some cooked salmon or extra smoked salmon to add into the meal, and I’d be fine to do that. But it would be “too much” to ask her not to serve turkey - presumably she and your DH both really like it and it’s very traditional.

SuiGeneris · 21/11/2023 11:15

There is nothing more annoying on Mumsnet than an OP who disappears with open questions, so:

(1) there are reasons that would be too "outing" to set out as to why the kids don't eat roasts or sausages (meat or vegetarian). Being fussy isn't one of them: they actually have a pretty varied and healthy diet that includes favourite dishes from many countries, Britain included, but not meat.

(2) MIL is aware we don't eat much meat but we don't make a big deal of it because we don't want her to feel uncomfortable if she does decide to serve meat. If it gets served (as it will) we just take a small helping. All of us do, children included. And of course we don't comment about it, as that would be rude.

(3) the cultural question is very relevant because, as this thread shows, for many people in the U.K., not all of them, but clearly a sizeable proportion, questioning turkey at Christmas is problem. In many other countries there are multiple traditional foods and people are therefore less attached to any particular option. Here too there are multiple options but there is a greater proportion of people who serve turkey and see it as the food that characterises Christmas lunch.

(4) again for reasons that are too outing to describe beyond what has been said, offering to host, which I would very happily do, is not an option.

(5) what would I serve instead of turkey? If a roast is required, perhaps salmon with all the usual vegetables and roast potatoes. If not, maybe serve more substantial canapés and then have smoked salmon, other smoked fish, some crudités and dips on the table alongside a smaller turkey so that everyone can help themselves to what they prefer. This is not about depriving anyone of what they would like, just about taking everyone's preferences into account.

OP posts:
Doone22 · 21/11/2023 11:15

If you host you choose. Otherwise suck it up

Lots of people don't eat turkey and eat other things for Christmas.
You could always offer to take some new dishes to try.

zingally · 21/11/2023 10:48

Roast dinners were a weekly Sunday staple of my 80s/90s childhood. Unfortunately, whilst my mum has many wonderful virtues, cooking isn't one of them, and her roasts were notoriously bad.

She would cycle between chicken (okay) to lamb (tolerable) to beef (bad) to pork (inedible).

My poor older sister, who has since got an autism diagnosis (that wasn't a thing for girls in the 80s/90s), found the weekly roast an absolute nightmare. And because our parents were of the "eat it and be grateful!" type, she'd swallow lumps down whole, as the sensory aspect of fatty, stringy meat was intolerable.

Once we got to be teenagers, we started rebelling against the food standards. My sister would get sausages or breaded fish with her roast, and we switched to chicken for the Christmas meal, as it was a meat we could broadly agree on as a family.

To this day, sister will only touch chicken out of the roast meats, and only the white meat. The others are no-go. I'm better generally, but still won't touch pork, and am definitely wary of beef.

Time to start putting your foot down OP. Or staying at home.

Sister and her partner have spaghetti bolognaise for their Christmas dinner these days! Neither are enamored by roasts, and are both fairly absymal cooks anyway.

Spirallingdownwards · 21/11/2023 10:24

walkingintothefuture · 19/11/2023 23:03

Me neither! It’s dry and really mediocre. I don’t know anyone who eats turkey on any other day of the year either so it can’t be that delicious as otherwise why doesn’t anyone eat it at other times?! It’s so silly 🙃

It isn't dry if it is cooked properly. Unfortunately many people don't.

My DH always thought it was dry because of the way he had it at family meals. He couldn't believe the difference once he had it cooked properly

SallyWD · 21/11/2023 10:24

Honestly, we've been hosting for years as we have the bigger house. I'd be so insanely grateful if someone hosted us for once and I didn't have to do the cooking!
It's only one meal a year and turkey is very traditional. I'd just be thankful you can sit back and relax!

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 21/11/2023 10:15

@SuiGeneris What would you eat instead given the choice ?

cheddercherry · 21/11/2023 10:15

I don’t think you’re unreasonable, me and my husband in our respective childhood homes always had turkey but now in our own home when we cook Xmas dinner we skip it! Neither of us are that fussed by it, we don’t dislike it but there’s many other foods we’d rather have so now we vary it, last year we did an Italian style and this year our five year old has asked for Mexican food! I’m sure at some point over December we’ll do a roast dinner style (and if we go to relatives over Xmas then sometimes we have a late Christmas dinner on Boxing Day if that’s their plan) but at home we choose as a family what we prefer.

My little boy understands the tradition of people eating turkey etc but also that it’s not “not a Christmas dinner” if we don’t have it. We still decorate and set the table together, have crackers and games etc so I don’t feel he misses out not having turkey.

1mabon · 21/11/2023 10:09

When my family spends Christmas Day at my home I always ask what they would like as meat.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 21/11/2023 09:59

@stickypoint It’s not clear if MIL is aware it’s not enjoyed.

rookiemere · 21/11/2023 09:58

I think there's a big difference between hating a food item and it not being your favourite. If you can eat a small amount of turkey it suggests it's the latter.

stickypoint · 21/11/2023 09:40

YANBU
I think it is incredibly rude as a host to prepare food that you know will not be enjoyed by most people. And Xmas "tradition" is no excuse either.

But then I suppose it is more important for me as a host to make sure my guests are happy rather than adopt a my way or the high way approach.

Elastica23 · 21/11/2023 09:30

I think some people saying goose is better and more traditional have never actually cooked or eaten one.

I did a huge one (for 8-10 people) ten years ago and it wasn't all that, even though it was free range etc and expensive. It made me appreciate why turkey is so popular- particularly crowns. Goose has a tremendous amount of fat and is more gamey than some people may like - I like it, and the goose fat is good for potatoes, but even then rapeseed oil has a higher frying point and I prefer potatoes done in it. There is also a ton of waste and inedible bits, far less meat than a turkey even from a really big goose. So turkey has a wider appeal to people who don't like more fatty meat. I don't have a problem with fatty meat but DH only likes really lean meat.

Also always used to buy turkeys from a local farm, but they kept giving me much larger ones than I actually wanted and I could hardly get them in my roasting tin/oven, plus they were so expensive.

So now I just get a free range bronze turkey crown from Waitrose or Sainsbury's. I cook it Italian style with lots of lemons and garlic and can taste no difference from the more expensive local farm ones. Cheaper. And there is no waste.

crumblingschools · 21/11/2023 09:18

@SuiGeneris do you not bring a contribution to the meal? Many families share the load of Christmas food, especially if the same person hosts every year

Deathinvegas · 21/11/2023 09:12

If you don’t like meat I don’t think it would be unreasonable to request a vegetarian option, you know the sort if option your mil can open the package and pop in the oven. Lots of supermarkets do really tasty ready made vegetarian Christmas food.

Jellytot1234 · 21/11/2023 09:03

AutieAngel- Don’t go then? How entitled and ungrateful do you have to be to be offended that the person who’s cooking is choosing to cook what they all like? What’s the saying… take it or leave it. Presumably you’re too lazy to cook for your own family so it’s easier to just piggy back on someone else’s effort but then still moan about it. You’d be uninvited swiftly if I found out you grumble at what I serve but still happily arrive to eat it every time.

Jellytot1234 · 21/11/2023 09:00

So you’re quite happy to go, put your feet up and have everything paid for and done for your on Christmas Day yet are making out she’s unreasonable for not doing you your own meat? I would suggest you start taking on the task of Christmas dinner if you’re going to be so ungrateful. Her house, her traditions and her choice.

LolaSmiles · 21/11/2023 08:57

It’s a bit weird that you’re being a bit passive-aggressive on here about it, and trying to make it a really big cultural thing rather than a mother in law thing. No, the entirety of Britain is not so culturally attached to a bland dead bird that none of us can conceive of serving anything else to guests that don’t eat meat/turkey. But perhaps your MIL is.

I think you either need to explain to her very clearly now that you don’t eat meat/rarely eat meat so won’t be eating the turkey this year - would she mind if you provided something else for you and the children. Or you do what you’ve always done and eat mostly the trimmings. One less slice of meat isn’t going to ruin a Christmas neal for you, surely, unless you don’t like any of the Christmas meal at all?
I agree with you.

There's some obvious solutions to adapt Christmas dinner to include a vegetarian or non-turkey option without losing it being Christmas dinner.

  • Nut roast or a vegetarian stuffing instead of meat stuffing
  • have meat free sausages instead of traditional pigs in blankets, explain to MIL that OP and the children don't eat much meat so are happy to bring a packet
  • OP or her DH could offer to add a substantial non-meat side dish
  • OP and her DH could suggest MIL does a smaller turkey and they'll contribute some fish, an alternative joint of meat, or a vegetarian alternative

None of it involves moping that a country is obsessed with turkey because MIL isn't a mind reader.

Though I suspect that given the OP hasn't actually said what she wants other than complaining that MIL is serving Christmas dinner on Christmas and that if she brought something the children want to eat then none of the 'traditional' food will be touched, I can't help wonder if what the OP actually wants is her MIL to not serve Christmas dinner because OP and/or her children are fussy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread