Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to cater for allergy request at birthday party?

432 replies

coverp · 19/11/2023 19:30

DD birthday party coming up and have asked attendees for allergies/dietary requirements. Had the usual list back - some Veggie, one no pork, one nut allergy, one gluten free+dairy allergy.

I said - no problem, we will make sure that there are options for all but will be parents responsibility to ensure children are eating the correct thing (kids will be aged 2-5). It will be "normal" kids party food - sandwiches, crisps, vegetable sticks, fruit, yoghurt etc.

Had a reply separately from parent of gluten free / dairy allergy saying "sorry to be difficult, but we need there to be no gluten or dairy served at all - it's too dangerous for X as we can't guarantee he won't eat it. Sure you understand, thanks xx".

AIBU to say that this just doesn't work for us? I'm making the cake and have no idea how (or have any desire to learn) to make a nice gluten free / dairy free option. I was planning to buy little GF vegan cupcakes so that there is something there for the others, but DD has requested a specific thing for her bday which I've already started prepping.

OP posts:
Juneday · 21/11/2023 08:28

Less than one in 1000has gluten intolerance, no one has a true gluten allergy which is when the body goes into shock and is of course highly dangerous. BUT one in 100 have coeliac disease, an incurable immune disease where eating gluten will cause food poisoning type symptoms and damage to the villi which will take weeks to repair. People with coeliac are more likely to be lactose intolerant too. But again an intolerance will not be life threatening. A dairy allergy, very rare, will as with all allergies Br dangerous due to anaphylaxis. My concern is people self diagnosing such things in their children. If this child has a medically prove allergy they will have an epi pen. If I was their parent I would do as one did at a party I once held, send their child with a Tupperware of safe food and we liaised on what party food they could have. My DD had coeliac, diagnosed the only medically proven way from a biopsy carried out under surgery and camera ‘both ends’, she also was diagnosed through blood tests with an IGA deficiency that can Co exist with lactose intolerance, asthma and hay fever. I wouldn’t wish either on anyone. She is an adult now and it restricts every meal out and even where she can go on holiday. We host Christmas every year (happily) because there is no fear of cross contamination as the whole house becomes gluten free when she stays. I wouldn’t expect others to do this. Offer what you can but you cannot make a gluten free environment, it is extremely difficult and very expensive as my daughter and I know.

eyeofthundera · 21/11/2023 08:20

@coverp .
I have two 3 year olds with allergies. I would totally not expect there to be no food with “gluten/dairy/nuts” as that wouldn’t really be fair on everyone. At this age the parents should be supervising. I usually say that I’ll bring along a little pack lunch if there is any problems, as I know it’s a bit of a minefield.

In the persons defence as an “allergy mum”, it is very stressful to navigate birthdays if you have a child who loves food and tries to grab everything. Luckily mine are usually too busy with playing to care much about food

Keeper11 · 21/11/2023 08:17

Well you did ask about allergies! There is a child attending with a serious allergy and you are saying - tough - not going to help.
In future word your invites better - say you are happy to cater for dietary requirements, but do not want to take responsibility for children with serious allergies. Parents of those children are more than welcome to attend as well or provide their child with their own packed lunch. At least the parents of children with life threatening conditions know where they stand.
YANBU to take responsibility for these poor kiddies, but YABU to offer and then withdraw.

Sleepytiredyawn · 21/11/2023 08:10

I’ve been to a few parties where little packed lunches have been made for the children in nice paper lunch bags. I’m not sure how you plan to serve the food but if this is an option for you, they could easily bring their own food and you could give them a bag to put their food in so their child feels included. This is as far as I would go in ways of pleasing everyone and I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. Personally I’d never ask and be awkward, I’d just be glad my child was invited to the party and the rest I would sort myself.

anon2134 · 21/11/2023 08:04

We've taken our own food to parties before to cater for dds allergies. Can you ask the parent to bring something to reduce cross contamination?

SpangleSparkle · 21/11/2023 07:59

YANBU
I always offer to bring her own food, payment towards the extra costs. Usually parents will find something for her to have and say no, however, it should be her offering to help you rather than whole party being made GF/DF/NF etc

Moll2020 · 21/11/2023 07:51

It’s the parents responsibility to make sure the child doesn’t eat anything he shouldn’t.

Snowflakeslayer · 21/11/2023 07:47

Definitely reply, with fewer words the better, to stop further dialogue.
“As you can appreciate, this isn’t manageable at an event like this, so you will need to help your child plate their food”

Zerosleep · 21/11/2023 07:46

I understand their concern but that just feels really rude to me. Why should all plans change just for one child that isn’t even your own, that’s crazy I’m sorry. YANBU.

CantFindMyMarbles · 21/11/2023 07:44

I would just ‘I will do a specific separate plate for him but I won’t be making it all dairy/gluten free. I’m confident he will be absolutely fine as he is at school lunchtimes’

forgotmyusername1 · 21/11/2023 07:39

In my sons class we had a child who was so allergic to egg that when the class mascot teddy bear went to his house he ended up in hospital as an earlier parent had included it in a baking session with her child (each child had it for the weekend and had to do an activity, take pictures and do a diary entry as the toy)

The mum should have washed the toy before allowing her son to touch it but allergies can be really dangerous

Ask the parent if it is an allergy with anaphalaxis or an intollerance. Is it only triggered by ingestion or are they touch allergic (can trigger without eating it)

If they are touch sensitive with a dangerous allergy then i would exclude the triggers for the party as we did for this lad. The only thing which had egg was the cake (his mum brought him a slice of his own he could have) and the cake was cut up and taken home and he went nowhere near where it was.

If it is intollerance and has to be eaten i would go down the individual boxes route with everyone having a lunch box and some additional safe options in the middle for extras. You can ask mum for a list of safe options or ask her to provide her childs food but have all the kids with those party boxes so the poor child isnt sitting with a tupperware and singled out as different.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 21/11/2023 07:38

Make a little lunch box like thing for gluten free child. Say this is x's safe foods please only let x eat this.

IsobelElsie123 · 21/11/2023 07:37

i agree you should suggest the Mother of X should provide her food - but I would also say she must stay and supervise.

LePanthere · 21/11/2023 07:30

If it’s so dangerous the parent should be providing the food.

kindly tell them your not confident in getting it right and would hate to put their child at risk with a simple mistake and ask them to provide their own food for the kid.

Rainbowshit · 20/11/2023 23:38

CurlewKate · 20/11/2023 09:52

One thing I have noticed on this thread is how ignorant people are about gluten/dairy free food. It's fine to be ignorant- it's not something most people need to think about. But expensive, rank and not very nice? Absolute rubbish!
I certainly couldn't be arsed to cook separately for someone with an allergy. So everyone gets the same at my house/parties. I hate the idea of a couple of children having to eat at a different table or bring their own or (seriously?) not come. A party should be a fee for all!

Because my children have multiple food allergies very often the free from options available are gluten free too. Sorry the rolls, biscuits, cakes etc that they have had have been tank, the texture is gritty and they are far more expensive than "normal" options.

determinedtomakethiswork · 20/11/2023 22:40

I would be tempted to send a message out saying can you lot sort out the menu between you and I'll provide it?

WrongSwanson · 20/11/2023 21:21

BlueMongoose · 20/11/2023 20:59

I respectfully suggest that's not the whole story. I don't remember any kids failing to thrive at my schools, or being in any way sickly, and none died young. And I'm not Victorian, I'm talking about the 1960s and 1970s, we did have antibiotics and vaccinations then. I lived in a pretty poor area of the country, too- pre-secondary, I'd say it was a deprived one- the only kids who were on the thin side were a very small number of kids who didn't get enough to eat (though it was not as bad then as it is now). I asked DH and he remembers two kids with allergies in all his years at school. I'm not saying this to be critical, quite the reverse. We need to find out what's causing this. Because there is definitely something worrying going on, apart from things like thanks to our appalling government there are now around 3x as many kids with rickets -actual rickets- as there were back then.

There is lots of research going on into the environmental factors exacerbating the issues. But (having spoken to some of the people involved in the research) there is also very much an accepted view that allergies have always existed and children would have just died in infancy (or been unwell throughout childhood) ..increased diagnosis is absolutely a factor.

I was a very poorly small child until I got old enough to refuse egg and milk. I know now I undoubtedly have an egg and milk allergy as well as a kiwi allergy. I had all the symptoms as a child but wasn't diagnosed. I have spoken to plenty of other adults who have since realised the same.

BlueMongoose · 20/11/2023 20:59

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 20:59

Allergies have always been there, but they weren't diagnosed unless immediately life-threatening because they weren't understood. Instead, you had a child who was sickly and failed to thrive, either dying young or becoming a sickly adult. Remember also that before vaccines and antibiotics, 25% of children didn't make it to their fifth birthday, largely because of childhood infections. I hypothesise that many of those children died because they were weakened already by allergies or coeliac disease when they caught the infection and so were less able to fight it off. The non-allergic children would have been more likely to survive an infection.

I respectfully suggest that's not the whole story. I don't remember any kids failing to thrive at my schools, or being in any way sickly, and none died young. And I'm not Victorian, I'm talking about the 1960s and 1970s, we did have antibiotics and vaccinations then. I lived in a pretty poor area of the country, too- pre-secondary, I'd say it was a deprived one- the only kids who were on the thin side were a very small number of kids who didn't get enough to eat (though it was not as bad then as it is now). I asked DH and he remembers two kids with allergies in all his years at school. I'm not saying this to be critical, quite the reverse. We need to find out what's causing this. Because there is definitely something worrying going on, apart from things like thanks to our appalling government there are now around 3x as many kids with rickets -actual rickets- as there were back then.

stichguru · 20/11/2023 20:33

"It's too dangerous for X as we can't guarantee he won't eat it." I'm sorry but THAT is the voice of lazy, lousy parents who cannot be bothered to feed or control their child. They absolutely CAN guarantee he won't eat it, they just monitor what is on his plate. If that's really too hard, they pack him a lunch box, or even ask you to put him together a plate of food he can have before putting the food out, but not ban the other food. If the allergies are really serious, they might be concerned cross contamination from children with other food on their hands. We have two friends who are coeliac, and they would probably bring packed lunches to the party. This is because child 1 might take some bread, then take some cheese. My coeliac friends couldn't then take cheese to eat, unless they were 100% sure that either the first kid didn't touch the cheese they would take, or that he'd washed his hands before between touching the bread and touching the cheese. However, that is NOT expecting the host to change everyone's food plan, or being unable to guarantee their child won't "eat it"!

Hmcs · 20/11/2023 20:24

Instead of doing a table full of lots of food

you could do individual boxes

a sandwich, crisps, sausage roll or similar

most would have the same anyway
so it’s only a couple of boxes that would need different prep

WrongSwanson · 20/11/2023 20:07

coldcallerbaiter · 20/11/2023 20:00

It actually was childhood infections that protected people.
The immune system had something to fight ( not always successfully).

Now without the germs, dirt and infection, the immune system malfunctions and latches on to harmless foods. It then is passed on in the DNA of a parent.

Pesticides was seen as a culprit too, the 1960s onwards was the start and then it exploded.

Milk allergy is the failure to thrive in some babies we heard of in the past but the others like kiwi and nut - they are new, recent maybe 1-2 generations old.

In fairness kiwi allergy is largely only "new" because we only started seeing kiwi fruit in the supermarket a couple of generations ago

I am not disputing environmental factors but better diagnosis is also a big part of it. Looking back I obviously had egg and milk allergies growing up. I vomited every time I had them and had a real aversion. But even my family (stuffed with doctors) concluded I was fussy rather than exploring allergies. I also now realise I have a kiwi fruit allergy but growing up I didn't think to mention that I avoided them because they made my mouth and throat itch. It was only when my children were diagnosed with allergies that the penny dropped that I had also had them throughout my childhood

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 20/11/2023 20:05

Blogswife · 20/11/2023 19:15

I would go back and say that it’s not possible as you are catering for a number of children’s dietary requirements and non dairy / non gluten doesn’t work for all . My DGD has a dairy intolerance and my DD either takes her own food or closely supervises what she eats .

This. There are other children with other food needs. They need to supervise their child.

coldcallerbaiter · 20/11/2023 20:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 20:59

Allergies have always been there, but they weren't diagnosed unless immediately life-threatening because they weren't understood. Instead, you had a child who was sickly and failed to thrive, either dying young or becoming a sickly adult. Remember also that before vaccines and antibiotics, 25% of children didn't make it to their fifth birthday, largely because of childhood infections. I hypothesise that many of those children died because they were weakened already by allergies or coeliac disease when they caught the infection and so were less able to fight it off. The non-allergic children would have been more likely to survive an infection.

It actually was childhood infections that protected people.
The immune system had something to fight ( not always successfully).

Now without the germs, dirt and infection, the immune system malfunctions and latches on to harmless foods. It then is passed on in the DNA of a parent.

Pesticides was seen as a culprit too, the 1960s onwards was the start and then it exploded.

Milk allergy is the failure to thrive in some babies we heard of in the past but the others like kiwi and nut - they are new, recent maybe 1-2 generations old.

Sartre · 20/11/2023 19:36

‘Sure you understand’- no I don’t, actually. It’s rude to expect everyone to pander to your very specific needs, not many would do this unless it was for a very close relative. She should just bring food for her child and keep them away from the party food, that’s just life with allergies.

welovetv · 20/11/2023 19:35

What @Blogswife said. Tell the person you can't cater for that and if they'd rather not come because of it, you totally understand.