Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to cater for allergy request at birthday party?

432 replies

coverp · 19/11/2023 19:30

DD birthday party coming up and have asked attendees for allergies/dietary requirements. Had the usual list back - some Veggie, one no pork, one nut allergy, one gluten free+dairy allergy.

I said - no problem, we will make sure that there are options for all but will be parents responsibility to ensure children are eating the correct thing (kids will be aged 2-5). It will be "normal" kids party food - sandwiches, crisps, vegetable sticks, fruit, yoghurt etc.

Had a reply separately from parent of gluten free / dairy allergy saying "sorry to be difficult, but we need there to be no gluten or dairy served at all - it's too dangerous for X as we can't guarantee he won't eat it. Sure you understand, thanks xx".

AIBU to say that this just doesn't work for us? I'm making the cake and have no idea how (or have any desire to learn) to make a nice gluten free / dairy free option. I was planning to buy little GF vegan cupcakes so that there is something there for the others, but DD has requested a specific thing for her bday which I've already started prepping.

OP posts:
Jojofjo44 · 21/11/2023 14:52

I'd say sorry, I'm not willing to change my entire menu as it will double the cost to do GF/non dairy. I'm sure that you appreciate we are on budgets atm with cost of living. There will be options for your little one, but it's your responsibility to ensure that they eat the correct foods. I understand if that makes you uncomfortable about attending. Sozard.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 21/11/2023 14:49

That’s a bit extreme and if she carries on like that her kid won’t get any invites to parties as they get older! The extra cost to you of making everything gluten and dairy free is also cheeky!

I have friends with both/who have kids who have both and they have no issue with us supplying a separate plate for them.

ellyeth · 21/11/2023 14:25

The parents should be responsible for closely supervising a child with serious food allergies. You can't really be expected to change all your catering to facilitate this requirement, or to be responsible for the wrong food being picked up - especially not when there are several excited children around.

I think TeachFirst's suggestion, with Bournetilly addition is a reasonable response.

The parent should also be present throughout to make sure the child is kept safe.

Edda09 · 21/11/2023 13:33

I think if you were to make everything gluten and dairy free, there might be a lot of disappointed kids as the taste and texture can be very different, especially for bread and pastry. Also, GF and vegan might not be great for everyone; I get terrible indigestion which I only found out about after my husband had to go GF.

AelinGalathynius · 21/11/2023 12:44

YANBU. I have 2 children with multiple allergies, and I make their parties safe from all of their allergens so they can enjoy everything on display (which trust me, is a rare treat) but would never expect other parents to cater their entire parties based on my children’s allergies? It’s ridiculous. If you invited the whole class and all parents demanded the same you’d have a good chance of not being able to feed anyone anything at all. Providing the allergy children with safe alternatives so that they don’t feel left out is more than accommodating enough imo. Also most gluten free cake is vile 😬 You’d probably have to spend a fortune getting a professional baker experienced in GF baking to get a cake that’s even remotely nice. Just crazy to demand this from someone 🥴

Thistlewoman · 21/11/2023 12:23

You are NOT being unreasonable-the other parent is!!! How dare he/she demand that all the other kids' food revolves around their sprog? How does their child cope in school/everyday life-they cant demand a dairy/gluten/nut etc free environment everywhere they go!!! Blooming ridiculous. Tell them that isn't possible and that with that in mind they can decide whether or not their child can/will attend.

Ladymeade · 21/11/2023 12:12

Good grief! I feel for someone whose child has this level of allergy problem but the sense of entitlement is extraordinary! If I were being charitable, I'd say perhaps the parent is just making the position clear...

kneehightoacat · 21/11/2023 11:42

Hi parent

happy to provide GF and DF options but unfortunately I won’t be able to rearrange the whole food offer. So sorry! But of course we hope you can still come and stay to supervise what little xxx eats on the day

i hope you understand!!!!

Thedm · 21/11/2023 11:42

kneehightoacat · 21/11/2023 11:39

Is there such a thing as dairy and gluten allergy so severe that they cannot be in the same room as it?

how does school catering work then?

It’s not that the kid can’t be in the same room. The mum just doesn’t want to have to parent and make sure the kid only eats from
their own plate.

Doone22 · 21/11/2023 11:40

That's an outrageous request. It's far beyond the level of no peanuts which are actually easy to avoid.
I'm coeliac and take my own.
Cakes are actually really easy you just use gluten free flour blend with a little extra milk as its drier. But they're more fragile and don't keep as well.
Biscuits are almost impossible to get nice, as is pastry. Bread can be very variable but it's also the expense. To feed a whole party full of kids with shop bought gluten free biscuits is about 3x more expensive for only 50% of the quantity, same for bread!
Even lots of crisps are full of gluten, you have read every label, same for cornflakes or rice krispies for cake making. They all have added ingredients with gluten in.

kneehightoacat · 21/11/2023 11:39

Is there such a thing as dairy and gluten allergy so severe that they cannot be in the same room as it?

how does school catering work then?

Toomuchfun · 21/11/2023 11:28

Allergy mum here, they are being ridiculous.

Andilew · 21/11/2023 11:27

YANBU My son had a life threatening allergy to eggs and I never once asked anyone to cater for him. I baked all the time and took food everywhere we went. If we popped in to visit a friend and they brought out a cake or biscuits I couldn't explain to a 2 year old that everyone else could eat it but he couldn't so took something for him just in case. His nursery school had a bring and buy so I had to make a selection and told his teacher he could only buy his own food Lol. Other than that I was always there to make sure he didn't eat anything he shouldn't. My child my responsibility.

MigGirl · 21/11/2023 11:10

I think the only issue is if the child is so allergic to gluten that air born is a problem. We have a teacher who has issues and even going into the dinning room after they have cleaned up can be a problem for her. But if you can't cater for this then the parents should be aware that their child won't be able to attend all parties.

If it's just a case of eating the food then they should also know that they may need to take there own food or not expect everything to be safe to eat.

To be honest dairy free is fairly easy now and I have some lovely gluten free cakes, but it is harder the cater for and parents shouldn't expect it.

Mumof3confused · 21/11/2023 11:08

No regular home cook can guarantee a gluten free environment at home so you cannot guarantee that there will be no cross contamination. I choose not to cook for a friend with severe nut allergy for this reason, as I use a lot of nuts in my cooking. Even if I cooked a nut free meal I could not guarantee that no crumbs will come into contact with the food, however much I clean. We eat out!

Ifeelsuchafool · 21/11/2023 11:06

She needs to supervise her own child! She can't restrict what other kids eat on account of her child. Tell her you will clearly label that which is both gluten and dairy free and then it's up to her! CF!
The only time I ever took anything totally off the table was for one of my DC's very best friends who was so allergic to peanuts that she could go into anaphylactic shock just by being in the same room as them. But no gluten AND no dairy in the same items? That's going to be super restrictive and not fair on the birthday girl or other guests!

Mumof3confused · 21/11/2023 11:02

Those parents are insane, actually really dangerous in my opinion to rely on other parents to know how to cater for specific allergies. The cake surely will be cut up and put in the children’s party bags anyway and not actually served at the party?

Ilovecleaning · 21/11/2023 10:57

MarkWithaC · 21/11/2023 10:34

If someone else is cooking then all bets are off and they cook what they want, IMO. And it's easy to say they could have made two versions, but I personally wouldn't cook two lots of food just to cater for a preference.

Although I have to say that I wouldn't choose to cook something for a group if it had an integral ingredient that my DP didn't like Confused

Yes, I know what you mean about all bets are off but the dish could have split into two very easily. Think of a meatball mixture that has onions added: very easy to break off a non-onion portion then add onion to the rest.
I agree with your last point, too and friend was idiotic- friend had said the week before “Oh I love liver and onions! And I know you two love it! Shall I make it for us all next week?”
Friend served it up without the onions ‘because DP doesn’t like them”
It wasn’t actually liver and onions but you get my drift. Maybe he should have made onion soup without onions 🤣Friend can be a bit of an idiot tbh.
The whole thing was just stupid. 🙄

Thegreatestgroaner · 21/11/2023 10:52

As a coeliac I know that even a crumb of bread will make me horrendously ill. Plus gluten /dairy free food is pretty gross and expensive and the kids probably wouldn’t like much of it. Baking gf food takes time and patience to learn. It’s not as simple as gluten containing cakes. They should provide their child with a packed lunch and supervise.

Baldieheid · 21/11/2023 10:40

Just buy a few packaged gf and dairy free items, OP. Leave them in the boxes so Mum can check ingredients before she gives them to her kid.

The other children, including the birthday boy or girl, should not miss out on their favourite treats because of one kid. Fast track to them all hating the fun-spoiler.

MarkWithaC · 21/11/2023 10:34

Ilovecleaning · 21/11/2023 10:04

F*ing ridiculous. Tell her to bring food for her dc.
Reminds me of a friend of ours whose partner does not like onions. Friend was making dinner for us. Onion was an integral part of the dish. We were looking forward to it. Also, it could very easily be split into onion and non-onion. But no - friend make everything onion-free so we all had to eat bland food with one of the main ingredients missing.
I HATE it when one person dictates what a group of people can eat (not including nut allergies etc)

If someone else is cooking then all bets are off and they cook what they want, IMO. And it's easy to say they could have made two versions, but I personally wouldn't cook two lots of food just to cater for a preference.

Although I have to say that I wouldn't choose to cook something for a group if it had an integral ingredient that my DP didn't like Confused

Z1hun · 21/11/2023 10:31

As youve said not that you have a desire to learn but to make a gluten free cake all you do is replace self raising flour with gluten free self raising flour. It tastes exactly the same.

pollymere · 21/11/2023 10:30

My friend who is Coeliac uses the same knives, chopping board and toaster as the rest of her family. I would suggest they stay and supervise their child's food. Making it all no nuts or no pork is actually pretty easy by comparison. Have some food items they can eat but tbh kids don't eat much at parties anyway.

skyeisthelimit · 21/11/2023 10:29

YANBU, you asked the question and made it clear that the parents need to be there and take responsibility.

I had a friend whose child had a nut allergy and she would stay with him at mealtimes to ensure that he didn't eat anything. She never expected anyone to not serve it to other children. She also took some of their own food so that he always had enough to eat.

The parents need to be there at the meal time and take responsibility for watching him, or he doesn't attend, their choice.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 21/11/2023 10:24

Agree with all pp who say this absolutely not your responsibility and the parent is being very unreasonable to expect it. The child's parents, one or other, or carer, need to be there to supervise him/her closely.

Some good suggestions of a response to her too on here.