Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to cater for allergy request at birthday party?

432 replies

coverp · 19/11/2023 19:30

DD birthday party coming up and have asked attendees for allergies/dietary requirements. Had the usual list back - some Veggie, one no pork, one nut allergy, one gluten free+dairy allergy.

I said - no problem, we will make sure that there are options for all but will be parents responsibility to ensure children are eating the correct thing (kids will be aged 2-5). It will be "normal" kids party food - sandwiches, crisps, vegetable sticks, fruit, yoghurt etc.

Had a reply separately from parent of gluten free / dairy allergy saying "sorry to be difficult, but we need there to be no gluten or dairy served at all - it's too dangerous for X as we can't guarantee he won't eat it. Sure you understand, thanks xx".

AIBU to say that this just doesn't work for us? I'm making the cake and have no idea how (or have any desire to learn) to make a nice gluten free / dairy free option. I was planning to buy little GF vegan cupcakes so that there is something there for the others, but DD has requested a specific thing for her bday which I've already started prepping.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 19/11/2023 21:13

I think that's a very cheeky request, because catering for GF/DF is far more hassle and more expensive, as well as no consideration that the birthday child may have some ideas what they like.

What I've always done is made sure that there is something any child can eat. I've done dairy free and gluten free at parties for guests, so made sure that anything that has equivalent (eg crisps sometimes have gluten in so make sure that the crisps I get don't) I get the one everyone can eat. Then for key things like sandwiches I will make sure they have some they can eat. I'd normally try and get a treat thing just for them so they have a special treat too.
For the cake I did do a dairy free cake (which was pretty easy) but the year I had a couple of gluten free I did cupcakes for them all to take away.

But in those cases both the parents stayed to watch, but also they weren't severe allergies as in they would have had a stomach upset but not life threatening. And I knew the parents well enough that if there had been an issue they would not have blamed me for doing my best. Which means I was happy to try.
With the above request I'd be tempted to ask them to bring their own stuff simply because you can tell if they suspected something wasn't quite right, then you'd get blamed.

CremeEggSupremacy · 19/11/2023 21:09

Halfemptyhalfling · 19/11/2023 21:06

You could do a gluten and dairy party quite easily: lots of veg sticks and hummus, baby tomatoes potato crisps, rice cakes, popcorn, ham, prawns, bananas, jelly, satsumas, grapes, raisins. Then you wouldn't get left with loads of half eaten squished sandwiches to clear up.

With the special thing your DC wants, you could just say to the parent to avoid that one thing.

This sounds totally miserable for a child’s birthday party

ColleenDonaghy · 19/11/2023 21:09

Jl2014 · 19/11/2023 20:58

If it was a sever nut allergy I would ensure all was nut free- fair enough. But no dairy and no gluten for everyone is ridiculous. It is just far too restrictive and they are not being very realistic with this ask. They need to supervise their child.

It's not about nut allergies and other allergies - anything can cause anaphylaxis, including milk and egg. Not relevant to the thread but important to note, as people who are at risk of anaphylaxis from other allergens often struggle to get people to take it seriously.

sunnydayhereandnow · 19/11/2023 21:08

Wow, I'm surprised by the answers here. I live in a different country. In my son's preschool there are kids with severe dairy, sesame and nut allergies, and this automatically means that no kid is allowed to bring any food containing these in their lunches because of cross-contamination that could endanger those kids (and the most severely allergic kid has a medical assistant who actually checks every lunchbox during the morning, including phoning parents to make sure that the chocolate spread is the dairy free one). Same with primary schools - if there are severely allergic kids then nobody brings food with the allergens to school. Nobody thinks it's ridiculous - we all just deal with it, despite 90% of the popular options for lunch involving hummus (which all has sesame in) or cheese. When the parents plan events for all the kids, we are all told exactly what we can bring that would be safe for everyone - so my default planning my kid's upcoming 4th birthday is that of course I won't serve the foods those kids are allergic to.

Of course it's a pain to make things without gluten but if the child coming to the party is very severely allergic I'd just get on and do it tbh.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 19/11/2023 21:08

You have already made reasonable accomodations. Unfortunately children with allergies have to be supervised until they understand the boundaries. They can stay and supervise but that is not your responsibility.

PumpkinFence · 19/11/2023 21:06

as a coeliac and friend with a daughter with a dairy allergy, she always just goes with her daughter and supplies her own food. I would do the same.

Halfemptyhalfling · 19/11/2023 21:06

You could do a gluten and dairy party quite easily: lots of veg sticks and hummus, baby tomatoes potato crisps, rice cakes, popcorn, ham, prawns, bananas, jelly, satsumas, grapes, raisins. Then you wouldn't get left with loads of half eaten squished sandwiches to clear up.

With the special thing your DC wants, you could just say to the parent to avoid that one thing.

lljkk · 19/11/2023 21:06

There was a child at DC school who was dangerously touch sensitive to his allergenic foods. He had a special table to eat at (never used for anything else). Was really sad bec other kids could in theory join him but of course they were all frightened they might contaminate his area, so he always ate alone.

I am not sure if other kids in his class all had to do extra handwashing, they probably didn't, let's face it.

cakewench · 19/11/2023 21:04

YANBU. She sounds quite presumptive tbh.

"I'm happy to provide gluten-free/everything-free options, however we will also have some of DC's favourite foods there, as it is their birthday, and those foods won't be gluten free. I'm sorry if this means you're unable to make the party."

or whatever. But the actual cheek of her assumption that you'll just comply. When your child has a severe allergy, you attend the parties until they learn to not eat whatever food they clap their eyes on.

(My DS had a nut allergy and an epipen so my judgement is from experience!)

ColleenDonaghy · 19/11/2023 21:03

handmademitlove · 19/11/2023 20:43

As a parent of children with multiple allergies / coeliac disease, I would say you will be doing that child a favour to say no! It is not a reasonable request and the parents really need to understand this! The world will not revolve around them so they need to teach their child to manage this themselves. From a young age my children understood they could not eat anything without checking with me ( or whoever was taking care of them) that it was safe. No swapping food, no helping themselves. This is how to help keep children safe! And I say that a parent of children with autism and other additional needs.

Completely agree with this, I have a DD this age with a peanut allergy and the most important thing we can do to keep her safe is teach her to check foods and not share without asking a trusted adult. Not try and put her in some peanut-free bubble.

Agree with PP who mentioned crazy expectations on allergy FB groups and forums, it doesn't help parents reach a balanced position.

OP, I would refuse but if possible offer to keep the food until the last half hour so they can come for the playing and leave when it's food time.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 19/11/2023 21:01

"I do understand, however, that's why you'll need to supervise what he eats as the food has already been planned and we are unable to make the whole event gluten + dairy free. I'm more than happy to provide some food that is gluten & dairy free and I'll be labelling food and keeping it away from the rest of it for you so you know what is safe for him. You're free to bring your own packed lunch if you'd prefer x"

TillyTrifle · 19/11/2023 20:59

At that age the parent will be staying to supervise anyway, and these aren’t airborne allergens, so tbh it sounds like they just don’t want their child to be any different or to not be able to have food the others kids can. Which of course is understandable to wish in passing, but surely no one actually ASKS the host to cater a fully tailored free spread 😳 They will have to get used to managing a difficult and unfortunate situation without being CFs, just like thousands of other parents out there do.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 20:59

BlueMongoose · 19/11/2023 20:47

Frankly, if there are so many allergies in your kids' friend group I just wouldn't do any event that included food. I'd find some other things for them to do that didn't involve party eats. Sad for the kids, but it's just too complicated.
As for the CF who wanted to decide what other kids would eat- I wouldn't have their kid in the house at all- that parent is not just totally self-centred, arrogant and entitled, they're Trouble with a big T. Imagine what they would do if their kid fell over while playing, didn't win at games, or just didn't get its own way.....

Where the heck are all these allergies coming from, by the way- what's happening? Back when I was a kid there wasn't one kid in my class all through school that had one, except, ironically me- with bananas . And even that wasn't a big deal, I just got a rash from the things, esp if I ate over-ripe ones. Nothing threatening, by the time I knew I had it I was old enough to avid it myself.

Yes, we did have one or two with asthma, and a few other things like hay fever problems, and eczema, but food allergies, not a single one. We had milk every day in the early years, and though some kids didn't like it a lot because it was a bit warm by the time we got it, there wasn't one I recall that was allergic to it.
Something more recent must be causing all these allergies.

Allergies have always been there, but they weren't diagnosed unless immediately life-threatening because they weren't understood. Instead, you had a child who was sickly and failed to thrive, either dying young or becoming a sickly adult. Remember also that before vaccines and antibiotics, 25% of children didn't make it to their fifth birthday, largely because of childhood infections. I hypothesise that many of those children died because they were weakened already by allergies or coeliac disease when they caught the infection and so were less able to fight it off. The non-allergic children would have been more likely to survive an infection.

gotomomo · 19/11/2023 20:59

The best option if there's multiple different dietary restrictions is boxes. Sainsburys have gf &vegan cakes, and they do a gf vegan sandwich cut up and serve 2 quarters, add some carrot, cucumber sticks plus some grapes and gf dairy free crisps which as easily bought.

Jl2014 · 19/11/2023 20:58

If it was a sever nut allergy I would ensure all was nut free- fair enough. But no dairy and no gluten for everyone is ridiculous. It is just far too restrictive and they are not being very realistic with this ask. They need to supervise their child.

TillyTrifle · 19/11/2023 20:56

‘I do of course understand that it must be very difficult to manage severe allergies; however we’re not able to make all the party food completely free of the allergens that have been flagged by various guests, that’s really quite an ask! We will of course ensure there are tasty options that everyone can eat, and you’re more than welcome to bring food with you if that makes you feel more comfortable, but we won’t be able to restrict all the food available in line with one child’s allergies. With you there to supervise closely while we’re running around hosting, I’m sure little Jimmy won’t eat anything he shouldn’t!’

handmademitlove · 19/11/2023 20:54

I was allergic to milk as a baby.... My mum was told I was just a sickly child. I think there are many children who were simply not diagnosed. Just ill all the time. Or died of "severe asthma" when it was actually anaphylaxis....

NutellaNut · 19/11/2023 20:54

She’s being totally unreasonable. If the child’s allergies are really that bad, she needs to provide totally separate food and supervise his meal herself. I wouldn’t be happy to take on the responsibility and in any case, she’s doesn’t get to dictate food options to everyone else. I’d say we can’t do that and withdraw the invitation if she can’t take responsibility for her child’s special food.

ExTheCheater · 19/11/2023 20:54

Rude womans a bad mum for asking that. She needs to watch her child.

theriseandfallofFranklinSaint · 19/11/2023 20:54

As a parent of a coeliac child who can't eat the tiniest amount of wheat/gluten/barley derivatives without being severely poorly, I'd be more than happy to bring my own food. We do it at family gatherings so a kid's party wouldn't be a problem at all.

AutumnLeaves333 · 19/11/2023 20:52

YNBU My kids had quite severe allergies when they were that age and I always took food to parties for them and they knew not to eat anything else. I kept some cupcakes in my freezer and would take them out and ice a couple so dc still had some cake as well.

ElfDragon · 19/11/2023 20:52

The other parent is being totally unreasonable. When mine were small, I made them a lunchbox to take to parties, and they knew they could only eat their food, from their lunchbox, unless I (or other, specific, named trusted adult) had actually okayed a particular food for them to eat. From the age of 2 (so from when they could actually verbalise it), dd2 and ds would ask, about every food, ‘is this ok for me to eat?’ - asking either me, or a close friend’s mum (who would know they were in that role, as I had pre arranged with the, for that party if I was unable to stay, for eg). It was never put onto the party host to sort out, and although I was always pleased when they checked, my reply was invariably ‘please don’t go to any specific trouble, I am happy to supply safe food’

thenightsky · 19/11/2023 20:51

We had milk every day in the early years, and though some kids didn't like it a lot because it was a bit warm by the time we got it, there wasn't one I recall that wasm allergicto it.Something more recent must be causing all these allergies.

It does make you wonder. I was at school in the 60s and 70s and everyone got a bottle of milk for morning break. It was a bit yuk in the summer when it was warm but nobody got let off drinking it and nobody got ill.

momonpurpose · 19/11/2023 20:49

No way. I would by a sice of gluten free cake and that's as far as I'd go

RM2013 · 19/11/2023 20:49

I think it’s unreasonable of the parent to ask you to cater exclusively for their child. I get that you asked about allergies but they could have said that x is severely gluten intolerant so we have to be really careful and we will obviously supervise their food choices.
id be happy bringing some GF items but making sure all parents are vigilant with their own children if they have very severe allergies

Swipe left for the next trending thread