Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU 5 year old SEN child - Xmas Dinner?

267 replies

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 16:31

Name changed for this as would be quite outing

Since last year, DM has been arranging a family Christmas get together with all the grandchildren. Last year, she took the children to a pantomime before going for an evening meal. I should stipulate all parents and partners also attended these events.

DD is 5, ASD + chromosomal disorder. Non speaking, still in nappies.You get the picture.

Because of this, we couldn't attend the panto and will not be going again this year but we were hoping to join in for the sit down meal which DD can just about cope with and has been getting better at. It worked for us well last year, with the dinner being later on in the day.

But this year, the meal has been planned for mid morning and this would be enough to prevent us from going as she is frequently up and down during the nights and she would be absolutely shattered if not being challenging for the time the meal has been booked for. When DM originally started planning this meal back in September, I did mention that 11am would be a struggle for us but if it was moved to after the pantomime, we'd be more than happy to attend.

To cut a long story short, the meal has been booked for that time. Its extra problematic for us this year as she has just received a specialist school placement and is due to start that very week, which means her routine including sleep, is likely to be completely out of whack.

I've asked why the time cannot be changed and its because the family don't want to disrupt the 1 year old cousin's bedtime routine. I hold no ill will against DB and SIL and child, but I feel that it is unfair for my DD to not be able to attend any of it all this year for the sake of a baby who, respectfully, isn't going to remember any of it.

To add further, DD has been out of school for some time prior to starting this new school and so would really benefit from spending time around her cousins

AIBU to think that moving the time back to after the show would be far less disruptive to the 1 year old than my DD?

OP posts:
Spideylady · 19/11/2023 22:09

Tgirl19 · 19/11/2023 18:22

YANBU to feel the way you do.
Many don’t realise how isolating having a SEND child can be. They are probably justifying it to themselves that they are making it easier for you by excluding her (and you). There are many things your child cannot access- your family should be the ones creating opportunities for her.

Absolutely, it is incredibly isolating having SEN children.

Spideylady · 19/11/2023 22:06

I understand how much of a kick in the teeth it is, having kids with autism. Sometimes I have been persona non grata and it has been really hurtful.

Spideylady · 19/11/2023 22:03

Or, like someone else has suggested, if it’s been an intense week already, it may be calming to stay at home. You could bake some Christmas goodies, decorate the tree, make a hot chocolate station, watch a nice movie and have a lovely time.

Spideylady · 19/11/2023 22:00

I’d be tempted to be going somewhere fricking amazing afterwards for lunch or ice cream with your own daughter. Announce it to everyone and then waltz off into the sunset with your daughter.

Calliopespa · 19/11/2023 21:48

Please don’t think you are weak. There is a horrible tendency especially these days - and evident on some of these threads at times - to conclude people are weak if they aren’t all mouthy and aggressive. The genuinely strong and intelligent are able to admit to and convey their feelings articulately the way you have done. The fact you aren’t lambasting everyone doesn’t mean you aren’t strong; it simply means you are casting about for an appropriate- and ultimately more effective - way to deal with the situation. I feel certain you will find it because, as others have said, you are so gracious which is a sign of real inner strength.

Abstractreader · 19/11/2023 21:37

Honestly OP and I really hope you read this, as a fellow mother of a SEN child, who is also autistic, disabled in many ways, I completely understand where you're coming from and frankly some of the comments on here are showing some huge privilege and in some it's outright ableism.

You try being up with a child who doesn't sleep properly, who often has huge difficulties doing everyday things and knowing that you have made substantial progress in one area like this family have, yet the child's own family aren't willing to make an change that will benefit the DISABLED child.
Those asking why she will struggle as she will have been getting up for school have no idea how much downtime an autistic child needs to rest and shut down and how much prep it takes to actually get your child into a new routine.

You don't ask physically disabled people to stop making a fuss and just get up physically enter a building. You make adaptations to ensure disabled people can access the building. So I'm going to completely unapologetically tell you that you can't ask to do it to those who are 'invisibly' disabled either. Oh yeah just switch the autism off for a few hours will you? Get out of that routine and make yourself incredibly, sometimes physically uncomfortable for the sake of the Neurotypicals will you? NO.

Your family are being inconsiderate ars*holes. They know your child and the difficulties she faces, she would actually stand to benefit and the other child does not, no you are NOT being unreasonable.

Christmaste · 19/11/2023 21:32

I haven’t read all of this but based on your original post Yanbu. Your family sound really crappy! Your poor child, if you were my family I’d do everything possible to accommodate you so you could be included!

A 1 year old won’t suffer if they’re out of routine for one day, and will probably nap in the pram!

You’re better off without these sods in your life. Plan a nice meal out with just you guys and forget them.

Calliopespa · 19/11/2023 21:24

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 20:31

I live in a 2 bedroom bungalow owned by my father. Its very small. I'm grateful that we pay below market rent to him.

I've made accommodations to the neurotypical children - by not going out of pocket when one particular cousin keeps referring to her as a dog. Thats me being accommodating.

Quite honestly the baby being “accommodated“ shouldn’t really even be going. It’s not fair to other audience members to take a child that young. I would see the point about accommodating the others if it was a case of an older child, but it isn’t. And OP, if they are not making an effort to enable DD to come as well as not absolutely stamping out the “dog” name calling, I’m beginning to wonder if there are cousins on the other side you could work to build the relationship with for DD?

bryceQ · 19/11/2023 21:21

Honestly if your daughter is starting a new school and has significant needs, doing this on a sat would be stressful for her. She won't remember this in years to come. Just have a nice chill day with her to celebrate her first school days. My son has severe autism and we just do our own thing that makes him happy

GlobalCitz · 19/11/2023 21:12

So all the children in the family get to attend the panto and your child's only involvement would be the meal?

And they won't even accommodate that?

I think that's sad.

idealgift · 19/11/2023 21:10

i really feel for you

FloweryName · 19/11/2023 21:05

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 19:28

Last year was entirely incidental. It was a happy accident that it worked for us time wise.

The pantomime will be at 1.30 so there is barely time enough after sitting down, ordering and eating the food before they will need to move on to the theatre - let alone a luncheon! How long are panto performances - a couple hours maybe?

So that takes them to around 3.30, in December so it'll be dark shortly after and it takes an hour or so for everybody to get home.

They are not going to want to hang around later after to do something with us.

I should clarify - my parents are divorced. I appreciate that my mum wants to do something nice for the grandchildren but her plans continue to exclude my child when a reasonable accommodation could be made to include her.

If you can understand the timings of the day around the panto and that people won’t want to get back late, in the dark, with their own young children then I don’t see why you’re taking it so personally.

Although it must hurt and be very disappointing for you, at least you can admit that in these circumstances, you are hoping for others and their children to inconvenience themselves quite a lot, especially when it’s likely that they’re finding it hard to understand why 11.00am. It won’t do you any good to hold on to resentment over this when your family genuinely mean no harm.

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 21:04

idealgift · 19/11/2023 20:53

I've made accommodations to the neurotypical children - by not going out of pocket when one particular cousin keeps referring to her as a dog. Thats me being accommodating.

that puts one hell of a different slant on the entire scenario

Namely why on earth you would want to spend time with family that permit their child to say this truly heinous thing. And it is one of those things where no matter how old the child in question is - it is unacceptable

Tbh mate, I;m more concerned about my other nephew who is also 7 but has always been protective of my daughter because he has been exposed to autism.

My sister - his mother - must know this situation isn't right.

None of them have reached out to me today. I don't know what to do or how to feel.

My loyalty is to my daughter and that will not change. Her above the rest of them .

But I'm constantly finding this whole situation with my daughter requires me to change and be bolder but when it comes to my own family, it requires even more.

I'm just so tired. Do you understand what I'm saying? Protecting my daughter means upsetting people no matter what. Which tbh I'm fine with. But it means decreasing my social circle even more....

I don't mean to drip feed. I genuinely don't know what to do.

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 19/11/2023 21:00

@idealgift I think OP was talking about how it'd be hard for her to host a meal as the home is small.

But it definitely makes things more complicated if she's renting from them.

@BreatheSEN The dog comment is awful. I'm so sorry all this is happening. Sad

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 20:59

idealgift · 19/11/2023 20:55

are you saying that if you said to the child “do not ever call DD that word ever again”, the family member renting your home to you would… kick you out or raise the rent?

This has gone from about lunch plans to a very very dark side to your family OP

Edited

No, my intention was never to drip feed.t
I don't think I can tell my other DB and his wife about how to parent their child. His comments have upset me but he is 7 so I've accepted that he has a lot of maturing to do.

His comments are independent of the nature of the post - totally not indicative of the attitude of today.

I don't know how to describe it. I'm generally a people pleaser but I have little to no social life. I'm suffering mentally and have done for the past two years. I was bullied very hard in my own childhood that I have raged about how my own child has been treated.

I'm in general torment in between wanting that familial connection and protecting my daughter. My family.....they don't respect me. People have been kind as to call me gracious on this thread but honestly, I'm just weak. And sad.

OP posts:
idealgift · 19/11/2023 20:55

are you saying that if you said to the child “do not ever call DD that word ever again”, the family member renting your home to you would… kick you out or raise the rent?

This has gone from about lunch plans to a very very dark side to your family OP

Legoroses · 19/11/2023 20:54

All the 'but how will she go to school, if she can't get to a busy lunch in a strange place at 11' and the 'just try it, OP' people could maybe google 'autism'.

This child's mother is telling you she doesn't do mornings. 'She'll just have a meltdown, otherwise she'll never learn to be flexible' is somewhat like saying 'you'll learn to swim by diving in'. Some very adept people might, but a lot of people would be so traumatised that they never go near the sea again. I trust the mum to make this call.

idealgift · 19/11/2023 20:53

I've made accommodations to the neurotypical children - by not going out of pocket when one particular cousin keeps referring to her as a dog. Thats me being accommodating.

that puts one hell of a different slant on the entire scenario

Namely why on earth you would want to spend time with family that permit their child to say this truly heinous thing. And it is one of those things where no matter how old the child in question is - it is unacceptable

CremeEggSupremacy · 19/11/2023 20:45

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 20:31

I live in a 2 bedroom bungalow owned by my father. Its very small. I'm grateful that we pay below market rent to him.

I've made accommodations to the neurotypical children - by not going out of pocket when one particular cousin keeps referring to her as a dog. Thats me being accommodating.

OP that is utterly dreadful and NOT something you should feel you have to 'accommodate'. No doubt the cousins are picking up on the ableism older members of your family seem to find acceptable. Do the cousin's parents ever tell them off when they say that, or does anyone else say anything?

It's really concerning that some people on here seem to think 'accommodating' a child's preferences is the same as accommodating a disabled child's needs. The disabled child's needs should always come first IMO. If someone thinks that's 'unfair' then perhaps they should consider that it's much more unfair that some children are disabled and then routinely excluded from things even by their own family.

Lougle · 19/11/2023 20:38

@BreatheSEN I'd like to be surprised but in all honesty, it's the reality of life with children who have SEN. It took me a long time to be able to say 'that doesn't work for DD1' rather than trying to contort her and us into impossible situations to try and fit in.

Ratfinkstinkypink · 19/11/2023 20:37

I find it sad that the family are looking to start a new family tradition that excludes one member of the family. YANBU @BreatheSEN

Pigeon66 · 19/11/2023 20:32

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 17:42

Thank you all for responses.

We have decided to bow out - perhaps I've not been clear enough about child's needs and presentation, but they are quite substantial which is why I believe she's not yet ready for something such as pantomime. And why I believe the timing is an issue for what already is going to be a potentially challenging week for her.

I'm upset because I feel her being around her cousins, being used to be around other children will really help her as she begins school. Selfishly, I would have quite liked to have gone as I had to give up work last year to care for her and opportunities to socialise have been quite thin on the ground - however, there will be other family events including those on DH's side.

I have said my piece to DM so she knows how I feel - they are sticking with the 11am arrangement.

Tbh, I don't think there will be time nor inclination for family to stay around longer especially if it means spending more money too. My family are more like the get in and get out, mindset.

It's a shame you have to bow out, but you know your child best and are putting her first. I tried too many times to fit into other people's plans against my better judgement and my DS just had a bad time, which wasn't fair on him.

I am sorry your family are not able to be more flexible and don't understand why this is necessary to be inclusive.

I hope you can find something really lovely to do with DD that day that you will both enjoy.

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 20:31

Mari9999 · 19/11/2023 20:28

@BreatheSEN
As a close relative to a family member with a SN. non verbal child, I understand some of what you must be feeling, but with that comes the awareness that accommodations and arrangements must be made not only with your child in mind but other children as well.

Wouldn't it be simpler for you to host a holiday early afternoon luncheon in your home to which all of the cousins are invited ? Hosting this would give you control over the time, and will allow your child to have the desired cousin and peer interaction.

Sometimes, you have to determine whether it is control over the event or the opportunity to produce the desired outcome that is the goal.

I live in a 2 bedroom bungalow owned by my father. Its very small. I'm grateful that we pay below market rent to him.

I've made accommodations to the neurotypical children - by not going out of pocket when one particular cousin keeps referring to her as a dog. Thats me being accommodating.

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 19/11/2023 20:28

@BreatheSEN
As a close relative to a family member with a SN. non verbal child, I understand some of what you must be feeling, but with that comes the awareness that accommodations and arrangements must be made not only with your child in mind but other children as well.

Wouldn't it be simpler for you to host a holiday early afternoon luncheon in your home to which all of the cousins are invited ? Hosting this would give you control over the time, and will allow your child to have the desired cousin and peer interaction.

Sometimes, you have to determine whether it is control over the event or the opportunity to produce the desired outcome that is the goal.

Night409 · 19/11/2023 20:26

BreatheSEN · 19/11/2023 19:28

Last year was entirely incidental. It was a happy accident that it worked for us time wise.

The pantomime will be at 1.30 so there is barely time enough after sitting down, ordering and eating the food before they will need to move on to the theatre - let alone a luncheon! How long are panto performances - a couple hours maybe?

So that takes them to around 3.30, in December so it'll be dark shortly after and it takes an hour or so for everybody to get home.

They are not going to want to hang around later after to do something with us.

I should clarify - my parents are divorced. I appreciate that my mum wants to do something nice for the grandchildren but her plans continue to exclude my child when a reasonable accommodation could be made to include her.

Why not just meet before the meal for half an hour.

Or at 3:30 there’s still plenty of time left to go to the park for half an hour to play.

Swipe left for the next trending thread