Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with person at hobby group

237 replies

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 09:41

Hi after some advice

I joined a group as a hobby a couple of months ago, we meet each week. I’m really enjoying this and the people are awesome! They are a lot older than me, mainly retired, a bit quirky, really interesting and I feel like I’ve met my tribe- I’ve never really gelled with anyone.

However, one member of the group is very annoying- he’s my age (so younger than the rest, although not sure if that’s relevant). He’s extremely opinionated, has a lot less knowledge of what we do compared to everyone else, loud and brash, sarcastic and basically I’ve really tried to get on with him, I’ve chatted to him in the break time but despite trying I just don’t like him at all.

I feel he spoils the aim of why we meet. This is not a paid a group, it’s just a group of individuals who share a specific interest and enjoy meeting up.

How can I move forward? I don’t want to stop going, and I know he has just as much ‘right’ to be there as me.

OP posts:
topnoddy · 19/11/2023 15:34

saveforthat · 19/11/2023 10:07

Just tell us the bloody hobby. Do you think we are all going to know who you are if you tell us?

Can't do that can they !

It's all got to be vague and drip fed for ages

CoteDAzur · 19/11/2023 15:32

It's easy to challenge his odd ideas about how baroque music should be played. Much of what we know about performance practice of that period is from a handful of written sources. Just ask him which book he bases his opinion on. When he goes quiet, tell him this book says this about vibrato, ornaments in German baroque, or whatever.

Why doesn't the group's leader tell everyone how to perform? You can't have people going about with their own idea of baroque interpretation in a chamber orchestra.

thirdfiddle · 19/11/2023 15:27

As you're a new member yourself perhaps best to have a private word with the leader yourself and say you're finding Dave's behaviour a bit difficult and has he always been like this, that kind of thing. You may find out more. Is he a beginner or what? He reminds me slightly of the behaviour of a member of one of my groups who is genuinely an expert in a very different instrument but doesn't have the physical skills on the instrument he's playing [yet].

My suggestion would be be patronising at him. He'll hate it if he's an arrogant so-and-so, but if you can convince him what he's doing is showing everyone he's a weak player not a strong one, he'll do everything to demonstrate his skill at being subtle. Maybe the leader could have a quiet word and say they've noticed he's finding the baroque bowing style difficult and would he like some tips.

You're kind of awkwardly placed as new member, but also you're in a position to bring new ideas and say 'in a group I used to play in we did xyz, could we try that?'. If you're soloist they clearly rate your expertise too.

What about some contrast exercises - everyone play a scale in their best big beefy Brahms style, now everyone play a scale in their best pianissimo transparent baroque style. So he sees that everyone can play the way he does, but they have the skill not to as well. Okay, could we get that even better blended? Does anyone's sound stick out? Okay, what if [OP] is playing a solo line. Same scale but OP plays a bit more. Now [Dave] is the solo. Now [cello] is the solo. Oops Dave, you're sticking out again, remember that pianissimo stroke?

Scales in tune-up time is an absolute no-no, but I guess if he's relatively new to the whole thing he might not have twigged. He gets bonus points from me for warming up with scales not concertos at least, but he needs to shut up when it's tuning time. 'Sorry, could I have the A again, Dave was still warming up and I couldn't hear myself properly.'

CoteDAzur · 19/11/2023 15:23

I would not have clicked YABU if your OP said baroque chamber orchestra rather than hobby group!

If he plays baroque music like classical, you have to kick him out. There is no other way. I don't understand how he joined in the first place.

Does he not have a baroque bow? He would not be able to sound classical (with long legatos etc) with a baroque bow.

Canisaysomething · 19/11/2023 15:18

This is life. There are loads of annoying people around. All you have to do is to find a way to get along without resorting to bullying or belittling him in front of others. Yes he sounds annoying, but he doesn’t sound cruel and doesn’t deserve your hatred.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 19/11/2023 15:15

Talk to him like he's a really chatty child.

Say things like, huh, I did not know that can you explain why? How weird, how odd, hmm, interesting.

Do not reinforce him with laughing at things that aren't funny, just make huh, oh, ah, hm noises at him.

TucSandwich · 19/11/2023 15:06

Dave is really pissing me off.

PuzzledObserver · 19/11/2023 15:02

@ClippyCloppy I’m therefore thoroughly enjoying this from a social perspective- it’s like a breath of fresh air!

All the more reason then to find a way to either bring Dave/Fred into line, or get the group to invite him to leave.

Since my first reply I’ve read more of the thread, and see that you are a soloist. You must be an accomplished musician if you’ve been given that after just a couple of months. You are more important to the group than he is.

Not that I’m suggesting you play on that of course, but…. maybe a quiet word with the group leader expressing your concerns? You have concerts coming up - and if Dave/Fred is not taking correction about his playing style, the leader may think his presence is detracting from the group and you’d be better off without him.

Unless he’s the only Viola, or something.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 14:46

PuzzledObserver · 19/11/2023 14:35

I’m retired and in loads of hobby groups.

In the book group, there’s someone who dominates the conversation and always manages to bring it round to her experience with Kurdish refugees. In the ukulele group, the leader constantly dithers and changes her mind about what we’re doing next. In the choir, we are told where to sit. The person who does the seating plan seems to move me every 2 or 3 weeks and one person who I was sat next to answered the questions I asked her (“What’s your name? How long have you been part of the choir?”) with brief, factual answers but showed zero interest in me and never talked to me again. One member of another group goes off on long winded stories and explanations, only tangentially related to what we’re there for.

There’s usually one, OP, and often several. You will probably find, as has already been said, that others find him as irritating as you. Some strategies have already been suggested. Ultimately, you either find a strategy which enables you to coexist with him (and you might find allies within the group to help with this)…… or if that doesn’t seem to be possible and it’s ruining your enjoyment of the group, you leave.

We initially joined a community choir as well as the more formal choir. The leader of that ground me down in various ways, until I had eventually had enough, and left. I am far from being the only one - loads of others have moved as well. We have also moved from one formal choir to the new one, because the conductor of the previous one was very demanding and not encouraging, with the result that rehearsals were not enjoyable. We’ve discovered about half a dozen members of the new choir used to be part of the old choir, but left for the same reason as us.

At the end of the day, hobbies are meant to enhance your life and bring you pleasure. Only you can decide how much is too much. If you love your music - and what you’ve described is quite niche and not easy to replace - then you are probably motivated to find a way to coexist. But if the stress is ruining the enjoyment, you have to ask yourself if it’s worth it.

Challenging him is a way: “Why do you say that, Fred?” “What’s your source for that, Fred?” And then of course “That’s interesting, Fred….. what do others think?” That last could be particularly useful….. if everyone else disagrees with Fred, he’s not going to get his way. You may just need to provide the space which will enable others to speak up. Or if the issue is the time he’s taking up with his pontificating, something like “Shall we get on with some playing now?” at regular intervals might work.

Great suggestions and glad I’m not the only one! As most members are retired and I believe attend lots of other hobby groups, they’re probably like you and have encountered this problem in most groups. Maybe they are therefore desensitised to it!

You’re right- hobbies are definitely there to enhance our lives and I really do enjoy this. I’ve always prioritised work and family and now in my forties decided to do something just for me. I feel much happier with this fact and have found something which is both enjoyable and challenging.

I’ve never spent any length of time with people of an older generation (don’t really have any family apart from my husband and children), I have to say I’m loving how knowledgeable, interesting and straight talking these people are. They are fascinating. I’ve not met anyone of my age group (or younger) who doesn’t either endlessly talk about themselves, moan, are quite shallow or just downright boring. (I’m not suggesting in any way people like this don’t exist from any age group- it’s just my personal experience). I’m therefore thoroughly enjoying this from a social perspective- it’s like a breath of fresh air!

OP posts:
Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/11/2023 14:45

Plasmodesmata · 19/11/2023 11:14

Ah, you've found this guy:

🤣🤣

TravelInHope · 19/11/2023 14:44

Try and find some way to humiliate him in public.

PuzzledObserver · 19/11/2023 14:35

I’m retired and in loads of hobby groups.

In the book group, there’s someone who dominates the conversation and always manages to bring it round to her experience with Kurdish refugees. In the ukulele group, the leader constantly dithers and changes her mind about what we’re doing next. In the choir, we are told where to sit. The person who does the seating plan seems to move me every 2 or 3 weeks and one person who I was sat next to answered the questions I asked her (“What’s your name? How long have you been part of the choir?”) with brief, factual answers but showed zero interest in me and never talked to me again. One member of another group goes off on long winded stories and explanations, only tangentially related to what we’re there for.

There’s usually one, OP, and often several. You will probably find, as has already been said, that others find him as irritating as you. Some strategies have already been suggested. Ultimately, you either find a strategy which enables you to coexist with him (and you might find allies within the group to help with this)…… or if that doesn’t seem to be possible and it’s ruining your enjoyment of the group, you leave.

We initially joined a community choir as well as the more formal choir. The leader of that ground me down in various ways, until I had eventually had enough, and left. I am far from being the only one - loads of others have moved as well. We have also moved from one formal choir to the new one, because the conductor of the previous one was very demanding and not encouraging, with the result that rehearsals were not enjoyable. We’ve discovered about half a dozen members of the new choir used to be part of the old choir, but left for the same reason as us.

At the end of the day, hobbies are meant to enhance your life and bring you pleasure. Only you can decide how much is too much. If you love your music - and what you’ve described is quite niche and not easy to replace - then you are probably motivated to find a way to coexist. But if the stress is ruining the enjoyment, you have to ask yourself if it’s worth it.

Challenging him is a way: “Why do you say that, Fred?” “What’s your source for that, Fred?” And then of course “That’s interesting, Fred….. what do others think?” That last could be particularly useful….. if everyone else disagrees with Fred, he’s not going to get his way. You may just need to provide the space which will enable others to speak up. Or if the issue is the time he’s taking up with his pontificating, something like “Shall we get on with some playing now?” at regular intervals might work.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 14:35

roseinthedark · 19/11/2023 13:59

Love this thread, I’m a strings player and early music is my jam!!!

About your Heifetz lad, I don’t know what to say. I feel wound up just reading your posts. 😂 Maybe a, “are you stuck in the 1950s with your ridiculous dynamics? Get in the f-ing 18th century with the rest of us!”

Is there a chamber or amateur orchestra specialising in romantic work? Could it be suggested that they are struggling for players and that the material they play there might suit him more, or, “they really need your valuable creative input!”

At least Heifetz played in tune 😂

there is a local amateur orchestra which I have suggested. I also said how they’d be lucky to have him.

His response was, ‘that’s too much of a commitment and I’d have to practise!’ Oh the irony!

OP posts:
Bodoni · 19/11/2023 14:32

"You’ve got some really interesting theories, Dave, but we’re here to play so why don’t you write an essay about them we could read at our leisure? Or post a video on Youtube, playing how you think it should be played, for us to watch later?"

CombatLingerie · 19/11/2023 14:28

I agree with @SirVixofVixHall I have given up on group activities. There is always one like your guy OP. It spoils the enjoyment of the activity. I remember one art group where a woman kept getting the terms ‘opaque’ and ‘translucent’ muddled. She just wouldn’t accept she was wrong when the tutor explained it to her. I think your hobby group would make a great story line for Midsummer Murders😂. Your annoying member would be the victim due to his irritating ways. Is a Baroque music style murder possible? Barnaby swoops in to interview you all. Got the theme tune in my head now!

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/11/2023 14:22

I think you need to have a chat with one or two of the others, the more forthright leadery ones.

Is there a chance they're tolerating him because they think he's nearer your age and you'd like that... because that would be horrific!

MargaretThursday · 19/11/2023 14:12

I think you need to be careful about this.

You're both relatively new, and it could easily have the older members thinking you are as much the problem if you try some of these "snappy" answers.
I can see them thinking that it was a lovely group until he joined and tried to take over, then you joined and tried to put him down all the time.

roseinthedark · 19/11/2023 13:59

Love this thread, I’m a strings player and early music is my jam!!!

About your Heifetz lad, I don’t know what to say. I feel wound up just reading your posts. 😂 Maybe a, “are you stuck in the 1950s with your ridiculous dynamics? Get in the f-ing 18th century with the rest of us!”

Is there a chamber or amateur orchestra specialising in romantic work? Could it be suggested that they are struggling for players and that the material they play there might suit him more, or, “they really need your valuable creative input!”

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 19/11/2023 13:56

We had this the other week, at Weight Watchers. A new overweight man joined to lose weight like all of us.

Maybe it was nerves but he spoke up countless times and was an authority on exercise and losing weight Hmm but held up the WW coach. We would’ve accommodated him if he came again but luckily he didn’t attend the following week.

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 13:48

I'm actually feeling really annoyed by him from a distance!

I think your group leader needs to be stricter. If it's already been discussed that he shouldnt vibrato / play loudly in section B / whatever, I think the leader should stop and remind him every time he does it. And if that fails, then have a private conversation to say "I don't think you're taking on board what I'm saying about vibrato, why is this? How can we help you? ". Ultimately if he can't be helped to change, and his playing is ruining the group's sound -either he can't learn or chooses to ignore others knowledge- then he needs to be asked to leave.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 13:47

Jewelspun · 19/11/2023 13:37

Have a Christmas getogether and ply him with drinks in the hope he makes a tit of himself and is too embarrassed to see you all again.

I don’t think he suffers with embarrassment

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 13:46

weirdoboelady · 19/11/2023 13:42

When someone really irritates, it sometimes helps me to consider how I would feel about them if I had already been told that they were autistic and had problems in engaging with others. Originally I felt this might help you, but (excessive) vib in a baroque group really IS beyond the pale.

To cheer yourself up, join this Facebook group! (Fellow musician - classical, but plays baroque oboe poorly - here.)

https://www.facebook.com/groups/323971011806686

Oh that’s great thank you!

Gosh the oboe is so hard! Keep it up!

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 13:42

penjil · 19/11/2023 13:38

I say just call him out on his BS, and tackle it head on.

Say "Don't be silly, that can't be right". ...."Where are you coming from with that idea?"....No, history likely has it it's not that way".....etc. etc. etc.

Or just simply say "I've got a bit more experience in this department, so let me take the lead here..."

Edited

We do all this either directly or indirectly, but to no avail!

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 19/11/2023 13:42

When someone really irritates, it sometimes helps me to consider how I would feel about them if I had already been told that they were autistic and had problems in engaging with others. Originally I felt this might help you, but (excessive) vib in a baroque group really IS beyond the pale.

To cheer yourself up, join this Facebook group! (Fellow musician - classical, but plays baroque oboe poorly - here.)

https://www.facebook.com/groups/323971011806686

Log in or sign up to view

See posts, photos and more on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/323971011806686

ChickenSoupAndLokshen · 19/11/2023 13:41

Do you know of another group (preferably closer to his home) that would suit him better? Less experience required? Different playing style? Suggest it to him, saying how much he'd like it. Fingers crossed he'd leave you all alone then!