Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with person at hobby group

237 replies

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 09:41

Hi after some advice

I joined a group as a hobby a couple of months ago, we meet each week. I’m really enjoying this and the people are awesome! They are a lot older than me, mainly retired, a bit quirky, really interesting and I feel like I’ve met my tribe- I’ve never really gelled with anyone.

However, one member of the group is very annoying- he’s my age (so younger than the rest, although not sure if that’s relevant). He’s extremely opinionated, has a lot less knowledge of what we do compared to everyone else, loud and brash, sarcastic and basically I’ve really tried to get on with him, I’ve chatted to him in the break time but despite trying I just don’t like him at all.

I feel he spoils the aim of why we meet. This is not a paid a group, it’s just a group of individuals who share a specific interest and enjoy meeting up.

How can I move forward? I don’t want to stop going, and I know he has just as much ‘right’ to be there as me.

OP posts:
DriftingDora · 19/11/2023 17:10

HeddaGarbled · 19/11/2023 10:02

You just need to accept him as he is if you want to still attend and enjoy the experience. Don’t bother challenging him - you’re not going to change his personality after all this time, and there may be reasons why he behaves like this.

You don’t have to like everyone you meet. It’s OK to find him irritating but not OK to cause upset in the group. Have a little laugh to yourself and be politely non-engaged.

There's a know-it-all in most groups. The best thing to do is to laugh when he starts or just ignore his comment and change the subject completely. I would also feel like asking him why he's there, as he obviously knows everything anyway, so seems pointless?

Really the only way to deal with people like this is to laugh at them, change the subject completely or have the odd polite but subtly sarky comment ready. He'll get fed up when he sees you and others are quietly taking the piss.

ShouldGoToBed · 19/11/2023 17:09

I think you should get together with the leader and figure out the kindest way to kick him out. You could ask him to come early one week because you need to talk to him, explain everything you’ve explained here, tell him to get with the programme or leave, and he’ll either stop being so annoying, or, ideally leave of his own accord. Why should the enjoyment of several people be spoilt by the enjoyment of one? It isn’t fair.

Ponderingwindow · 19/11/2023 16:59

Well for the first time the hobby really was unique. It’s also incredibly relevant. I was originally imagining someone a bit too opinionated about knitting styles or who chatted too much during the board game session.

since he actually is impeding the groups goal, it may be necessary for the organizer to take him aside and speak with him about being more receptive to constructive criticism. It’s obviously very tricky because it’s not an audition group.

FrangipaniBlue · 19/11/2023 16:55

being a good performer within a chamber group doesn’t mean playing the loudest, using the most bow or the fastest vibrato

@ClippyCloppy you need this on a t-shirt!!!

ArthurbellaScott · 19/11/2023 16:51

Oh, sorry, cross post.

ArthurbellaScott · 19/11/2023 16:51

theconfidenceofwho · 19/11/2023 12:39

I know! Fab hobby!

Given his impact on the actual hobby, I think in this situation you are within your rights to tell him he needs to stop what he's doing or stop attending altogether. He needs to listen and learn more and talk less or he needs to leave the group.

Yes, this. He may not be aware how much of a dick he's being. In which case, it needs to be pointed out. It's not fair to let one arse spoil the whole group. I'd speak to the leader of the group, OP.

Canisaysomething · 19/11/2023 16:49

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 15:51

Hatred?? Not sure where that came from. I do think I’ll start calling him Dave though, it seems apt

The hatred I referred to was based on other posters suggestions.

NunsKnickers · 19/11/2023 16:43

AnnaSewell · 19/11/2023 16:35

I've been in a hobby group (walking) where someone was eventually chucked. out. Health problems meant they were way too slow and they were also very accident prone.

I think you have a tactful private chat with the person.

'This is how this group operates. We can see that it can take time for someone who is used to playing in a different style to adjust, but the difficulty they are having in adjusting is causing frustration for others. This is what is required from you.

  • Play with the correct bow
  • Don't play scales while tuning is going on.
  • Though some discussion is okay in rehearsals, ultimately it is the conductor's say and that has to be respected.'

They get a certain period in which to adjust, but if they are unable to do so, then they will be asked to leave. This is in everyone's interest as if Dave can't/doesn't want to play in a manner suited to a baroque ensemble, he will obviously be happier in a different group of players.

I agree with this.

Set some rules or boundaries. If he doesn't like it and flounces then so.be it.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:35

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 16:29

So you were one of the founding members? In which case stop looking on helplessly. Everyone else is probably waiting for you and the leader to address the problem directly.

It’s not that simple though. We are essentially a ‘hobby’. It’s voluntary, unpaid and there for enjoyment. The problem is some of us want exactly that (a hobby to meet like minded people, have a laugh and a socialise), whereas others (like myself) enjoy all those elements but maybe care more about what we are trying to achieve and place the ‘hobby’ elements as secondary in importance. If this doesn’t sort itself out naturally (will continue with suggestions made by posters on this thread), I will speak with the leader.

OP posts:
AnnaSewell · 19/11/2023 16:35

I've been in a hobby group (walking) where someone was eventually chucked. out. Health problems meant they were way too slow and they were also very accident prone.

I think you have a tactful private chat with the person.

'This is how this group operates. We can see that it can take time for someone who is used to playing in a different style to adjust, but the difficulty they are having in adjusting is causing frustration for others. This is what is required from you.

  • Play with the correct bow
  • Don't play scales while tuning is going on.
  • Though some discussion is okay in rehearsals, ultimately it is the conductor's say and that has to be respected.'

They get a certain period in which to adjust, but if they are unable to do so, then they will be asked to leave. This is in everyone's interest as if Dave can't/doesn't want to play in a manner suited to a baroque ensemble, he will obviously be happier in a different group of players.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:30

istolethetalisker · 19/11/2023 16:24

Has anyone said straight: God almighty Dave, quit with the sodding vibrato! You sound like Handel just got dumped!

He thinks he’s Paganini, warming up with fancy dominant and diminished 7ths (3 octaves at great speed in the same bow), then big 3 or 4 note chords, followed by double stops in 10ths. He insists on playing really high up in the rafters which actually makes me wince. His intonation is not even close, but I totally appreciate the sentiment!

OP posts:
ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 16:29

So you were one of the founding members? In which case stop looking on helplessly. Everyone else is probably waiting for you and the leader to address the problem directly.

Mistymountain · 19/11/2023 16:29

It sounds like the wrong group for him. If he isn't adding anything of value to the group, then perhaps the leader should ask him to leave.

BringMeTea · 19/11/2023 16:27

Dave is an insufferable prick. The leader really ought to be asking him to leave. Truly. I wonder if the leader would let all this slide if Dave was Denise? Oh and ignore the mra trolls. They love jumping on threads to criticize women. Don't give them any attention.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 19/11/2023 16:26

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:13

We all have baroque bows and our leader is a bit of a collector of all things musical (instruments, bows accessories). He was lent a baroque bow by our leader but returned it the following week complaining that it wasn’t long enough or gave a resonant sound. Dick

I don't really know enough about music to comment, but could he be told he must play with a baroque bow for performances, as that's how to achieve the sound the group is aiming for?

If he doesn't enjoy playing with the baroque bow, maybe that will help him twig that this style of music isn't quite right for what he wants to do?

Some of this sounds like etiquette that he just doesn't know? Has anyone said to him really bluntly e.g. "don't play scales when we are tuning"?

istolethetalisker · 19/11/2023 16:24

Has anyone said straight: God almighty Dave, quit with the sodding vibrato! You sound like Handel just got dumped!

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:19

PuzzledObserver · 19/11/2023 15:02

@ClippyCloppy I’m therefore thoroughly enjoying this from a social perspective- it’s like a breath of fresh air!

All the more reason then to find a way to either bring Dave/Fred into line, or get the group to invite him to leave.

Since my first reply I’ve read more of the thread, and see that you are a soloist. You must be an accomplished musician if you’ve been given that after just a couple of months. You are more important to the group than he is.

Not that I’m suggesting you play on that of course, but…. maybe a quiet word with the group leader expressing your concerns? You have concerts coming up - and if Dave/Fred is not taking correction about his playing style, the leader may think his presence is detracting from the group and you’d be better off without him.

Unless he’s the only Viola, or something.

like the viola comment 😂 (only joking violas are very important especially in this context). He’s second violin. He mentioned last week he wanted to do a solo with me for one of the double violin concertos (Bach double in D or Vivaldi’s A minor) in our May concert. That may be a tricky conversation!

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:13

CoteDAzur · 19/11/2023 15:23

I would not have clicked YABU if your OP said baroque chamber orchestra rather than hobby group!

If he plays baroque music like classical, you have to kick him out. There is no other way. I don't understand how he joined in the first place.

Does he not have a baroque bow? He would not be able to sound classical (with long legatos etc) with a baroque bow.

We all have baroque bows and our leader is a bit of a collector of all things musical (instruments, bows accessories). He was lent a baroque bow by our leader but returned it the following week complaining that it wasn’t long enough or gave a resonant sound. Dick

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:10

LivingInaBuildingSite · 19/11/2023 16:07

You have my sympathies and not sure I can offer any useful advice.

I have a similar individual in my amateur music group. It’s much lower level music than yours sounds. He just cannot keep to the beat. Always a half beat early.

I nearly quit at one point as I played the same part as him. I couldn’t work out whether to play correctly (but not with him) or try and guess his wrongness and play that with him. 🙄

In the end I got a different (but similar) instrument so I could play a different part. And made my excuses to sit at the end of the row away from him so I don’t have to hear every single wrong note he plays.

He even admitted once that he never listens to anyone else. In a group setting that plays music together. Not helpful.

And he can’t play quietly at all.
And seems to have the skin of a rhino.

He’s totally aggravating and I constantly hope he’ll quit but he’s the one who turns up every sodding week without fail.

Its terrible but he’s not v young and I hope the inevitable happens for him sooner rather than later as he wrecks the music we play.

This made me laugh! Don’t get me started on inability to feel the pulse or being incapable of counting rests. We were only in common time counting up to 4 😂 He often decides to count in quavers and come in half a bar early aaargh!

OP posts:
LivingInaBuildingSite · 19/11/2023 16:07

You have my sympathies and not sure I can offer any useful advice.

I have a similar individual in my amateur music group. It’s much lower level music than yours sounds. He just cannot keep to the beat. Always a half beat early.

I nearly quit at one point as I played the same part as him. I couldn’t work out whether to play correctly (but not with him) or try and guess his wrongness and play that with him. 🙄

In the end I got a different (but similar) instrument so I could play a different part. And made my excuses to sit at the end of the row away from him so I don’t have to hear every single wrong note he plays.

He even admitted once that he never listens to anyone else. In a group setting that plays music together. Not helpful.

And he can’t play quietly at all.
And seems to have the skin of a rhino.

He’s totally aggravating and I constantly hope he’ll quit but he’s the one who turns up every sodding week without fail.

Its terrible but he’s not v young and I hope the inevitable happens for him sooner rather than later as he wrecks the music we play.

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 16:07

thirdfiddle · 19/11/2023 15:27

As you're a new member yourself perhaps best to have a private word with the leader yourself and say you're finding Dave's behaviour a bit difficult and has he always been like this, that kind of thing. You may find out more. Is he a beginner or what? He reminds me slightly of the behaviour of a member of one of my groups who is genuinely an expert in a very different instrument but doesn't have the physical skills on the instrument he's playing [yet].

My suggestion would be be patronising at him. He'll hate it if he's an arrogant so-and-so, but if you can convince him what he's doing is showing everyone he's a weak player not a strong one, he'll do everything to demonstrate his skill at being subtle. Maybe the leader could have a quiet word and say they've noticed he's finding the baroque bowing style difficult and would he like some tips.

You're kind of awkwardly placed as new member, but also you're in a position to bring new ideas and say 'in a group I used to play in we did xyz, could we try that?'. If you're soloist they clearly rate your expertise too.

What about some contrast exercises - everyone play a scale in their best big beefy Brahms style, now everyone play a scale in their best pianissimo transparent baroque style. So he sees that everyone can play the way he does, but they have the skill not to as well. Okay, could we get that even better blended? Does anyone's sound stick out? Okay, what if [OP] is playing a solo line. Same scale but OP plays a bit more. Now [Dave] is the solo. Now [cello] is the solo. Oops Dave, you're sticking out again, remember that pianissimo stroke?

Scales in tune-up time is an absolute no-no, but I guess if he's relatively new to the whole thing he might not have twigged. He gets bonus points from me for warming up with scales not concertos at least, but he needs to shut up when it's tuning time. 'Sorry, could I have the A again, Dave was still warming up and I couldn't hear myself properly.'

I’m not a new member! It was founded by the leader and I was the first person to join him. We then recruited others to join us (the leader recruited Dave, however he was under the impression he was reasonably accomplished at that time).

He’s (Dave) new to the whole playing with others, especially in a chamber scenario. He is essentially self taught, he doesn’t have the musical training or theoretical knowledge everyone (most of us) else has. We often (me mainly) demonstrate passages to show different techniques/ bowing styles but he either doesn’t do it effectively or then forgets moments later. As I said previously, this is not necessarily about lack of knowledge- it’s about arrogance and inability to understand improvement or just plain belligerence.

I appreciate the idea of warm up exercises such as forte / pianissimo, or vibrato / non vibrato, but to be honest this is something I would do when teaching. It’s not something that is appropriate in this setting with accomplished musicians (apart from Dave) and I feel it would be a tad patronising.

I have made a pained expression when tuning and have loudly said sorry I can’t hear the A, sometimes he shuts up, sometimes he’s oblivious 😂

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 15:56

CoteDAzur · 19/11/2023 15:32

It's easy to challenge his odd ideas about how baroque music should be played. Much of what we know about performance practice of that period is from a handful of written sources. Just ask him which book he bases his opinion on. When he goes quiet, tell him this book says this about vibrato, ornaments in German baroque, or whatever.

Why doesn't the group's leader tell everyone how to perform? You can't have people going about with their own idea of baroque interpretation in a chamber orchestra.

The leader does tell him! (And us if necessary). I’ve put more details in other posts on this thread

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 15:54

topnoddy · 19/11/2023 15:34

Can't do that can they !

It's all got to be vague and drip fed for ages

What? I said the hobby within a couple of minutes of posting the op! And that was only because I was asked to. However, not sure how this would be a drip feed anyway as this is a general problem encountered in many hobby groups regardless of what the hobby is.

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 15:51

Canisaysomething · 19/11/2023 15:18

This is life. There are loads of annoying people around. All you have to do is to find a way to get along without resorting to bullying or belittling him in front of others. Yes he sounds annoying, but he doesn’t sound cruel and doesn’t deserve your hatred.

Hatred?? Not sure where that came from. I do think I’ll start calling him Dave though, it seems apt

OP posts:
saveforthat · 19/11/2023 15:38

To be fair @topnoddy they have now 🙂