Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with person at hobby group

237 replies

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 09:41

Hi after some advice

I joined a group as a hobby a couple of months ago, we meet each week. I’m really enjoying this and the people are awesome! They are a lot older than me, mainly retired, a bit quirky, really interesting and I feel like I’ve met my tribe- I’ve never really gelled with anyone.

However, one member of the group is very annoying- he’s my age (so younger than the rest, although not sure if that’s relevant). He’s extremely opinionated, has a lot less knowledge of what we do compared to everyone else, loud and brash, sarcastic and basically I’ve really tried to get on with him, I’ve chatted to him in the break time but despite trying I just don’t like him at all.

I feel he spoils the aim of why we meet. This is not a paid a group, it’s just a group of individuals who share a specific interest and enjoy meeting up.

How can I move forward? I don’t want to stop going, and I know he has just as much ‘right’ to be there as me.

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 18:03

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 17:52

So the leader is not comfortable with confrontation. As the soloist then, you need to woman up and start setting boundaries, perhaps in conjunction with other core members. Otherwise you risk the good players getting fed up and leaving.

Hmm, I don’t think I need to ‘woman up’, I’m actually pretty assertive when I need to be. As I said in a previous post it’s not just about the performance- for some members it’s about sharing an interest and the social aspect which may be the case with Dave. This is why it is a dilemma for me. I do appreciate other people have feelings and although he’s a completely irritating twerp I do not wish to ask him to leave necessarily- for all I know this may be his only ‘outlet’ and may have a really negative effect on him if he left. At the end of the day, he’s annoying but harmless.

I have had some really useful suggestions on how to respond when he pipes up, which I will be escalating over the coming weeks. If things don’t settle down though I will have a rethink and speak to him directly about the objectives of our group and see if he’s open to change and commit more effectively (do some practice).

OP posts:
ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 17:56

Sorry, I might be getting a bit harsh and overinvested... This thread has touched a nerve.

It sounds a very fun endeavour, anyway.

RandomMess · 19/11/2023 17:55

Have auditions for the performance group?

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/11/2023 17:52

So the leader is not comfortable with confrontation. As the soloist then, you need to woman up and start setting boundaries, perhaps in conjunction with other core members. Otherwise you risk the good players getting fed up and leaving.

Clarinet1 · 19/11/2023 17:49

As an experienced musician (albeit in a somewhat different milieu - clue’s in the user name) I free your pain. I’ve been in concert bands where the conductor works on a passage over and over with some of the weaker players until they get it right. Play it through together immediately and they get it wrong again! This is just one example.
In this case, if “Dave” persistently refuses to use a baroque bow, can’t count, insists on playing in a gushing, romantic style and admits he doesn’t practice (!!!!!) I think someone, probably the leader, needs to make clear that he shapes up or ships out. This applies particularly because you are aiming at performances which will otherwise be spoiled

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 17:49

LivingInaBuildingSite · 19/11/2023 17:45

Argh, rests. Pretty sure my guy has no clue what those funny squiggle marks on the page are!! 🤯😂

As another poster has said, if he flounces it’s no great loss. So, while you may feel bad, I think you have to be blunt/clear/direct. Leave no room for misunderstanding.
If he leaves, so be it.

My ‘Dave’ actually did leave another (even more amateur) group we both played in years ago as that conductor went through the stages of correction from polite & tolerant to direct & blunt. Eventually Dave flounced. We all breathed a sigh of relief.

I found out he tried to join a higher level group but they were blunt from the get go so he only went once.

We’ve been far too tolerant. Any delicate quiet piece the conductor has to basically rejig to cut his instrument out so he doesn’t play as pianissimo is just a funny Italian word to him!

Great! There’s always one isn’t there 😂

OP posts:
ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 17:45

Yetmorebeanstocount · 19/11/2023 17:14

He was lent a baroque bow by our leader but returned it the following week complaining that it wasn’t long enough or gave a resonant sound.

That was the perfect opportunity for the leader to make a stand - "you play with this bow or you don't play at all".
Could the leader find some way to re-introduce the correct bow and tell him it is compulsory?
Someone has to actually stand up to him. Your leader seems to have failed here.

Well you’re not wrong, that probably was a good opportunity. I think I should have used the word ‘founder’ not ‘leader’. I don’t think it’s fair, or accurate to refer to him as a failure.

This is a chap in his late 70’s, retired for many years after a successful performance career. He lives alone in a quirky house where nothing matches, full of mismatching furniture overloaded with books, old manuscripts and newspapers clippings everywhere. He buys everything from the junk shop. He’s ‘old school’, just learned how to use email and the internet. He’s a fountain of knowledge, an utterly brilliant academic who knows the ins and outs of most composers, their life, their music. He knows the style, form and content of Baroque music better than anyone I have met.

We met at a concert I was performing at and I was completely blown away with his knowledge and interest. We chatted about getting together to play music. It was then that he said he’d always wanted to put together a chamber group. It was a casual arrangement, but the interest grew and we now have quite a few members.

I do not think he is a natural leader, he just wants to analyse and play different genres (Italian at the moment) of Baroque. It was only once we got going as a group that he suggested expanding and putting on concerts.

He’s very vocal at our meetings (as you would expect given his level of knowledge), however he’s not a natural leader. He doesn’t like confrontation or awkwardness (of course understandable).

Therefore I’m not sure he himself was aware he would ever be in the position to ‘lead’ the group. He does lead in a sense that he arranges what we play, organise the meetings (rehearsals) and concerts, he makes suggestions and moves things along where necessary but I don’t think he would be at all comfortable with this kind of interaction with Dave.

OP posts:
LivingInaBuildingSite · 19/11/2023 17:45

Argh, rests. Pretty sure my guy has no clue what those funny squiggle marks on the page are!! 🤯😂

As another poster has said, if he flounces it’s no great loss. So, while you may feel bad, I think you have to be blunt/clear/direct. Leave no room for misunderstanding.
If he leaves, so be it.

My ‘Dave’ actually did leave another (even more amateur) group we both played in years ago as that conductor went through the stages of correction from polite & tolerant to direct & blunt. Eventually Dave flounced. We all breathed a sigh of relief.

I found out he tried to join a higher level group but they were blunt from the get go so he only went once.

We’ve been far too tolerant. Any delicate quiet piece the conductor has to basically rejig to cut his instrument out so he doesn’t play as pianissimo is just a funny Italian word to him!

Talkingtothecat247 · 19/11/2023 17:44

He probably knows how you feel about him being there.
Vibes can be picked up on.
The loud, brash, sarcastic front is likely a cover up for his insecurity.
The chances are he might decide to stop attending the group of his own accord without you needing to say or do anything.

weirdoboelady · 19/11/2023 17:42

SoddingWeddings · 19/11/2023 17:37

I absolutely love those teatowels! Definitely offer them out / sell them to anyone in strings 😂

t-shirts, not t towels! You are right, I should get my act together and put them on ebay again. (LOL - DMs welcomed if anyone wants one! Appreciate they are a bit irrelevant to a baroque group as - eep! - the cello has a spike!)

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 17:42

@ClippyCloppy

I need to learn skills to tolerate being with people. I guess people have to deal with numpties all the time, maybe in a work environment. I’m lucky though as I’m freelance so work mainly alone or can choose (to some extent) who I work with. I need some tips on tolerance I guess.

OP it sounds as if you slightly struggle with assertiveness with people like this: you've talked about wanting to be "kind" to him (which is nice and understandable) but its clear that his incessant centring of himself is not only a drain on everyone else's time and patience, it's not particularly kind on his side. He is patronising, deliberately time-wasting and probably a bit misogynistic. It sounds as if he thinks (consciously or subconsciously) that because he is a man he has a primacy in this group and wants to constantly assert himself and his views. There's a bloke like this in every workplace/volunteer group/hobby group in the world. They assume a sense of innate superiority over the women and want to imprint their territory like tom cats.

I've spent 30 years working environments dealing with men who assume that their views are automatically more important than mine purely because they are men. After a while you learn to spot it a mile off and either screen it out or call it if it needs to be called. You say you need tolerance, and up to a point you're correct: you shouldn't be shitty to him because of his lack of knowledge and expertise and you shouldn't gang up on him.

But the bottom line is his questions and observations are disruptive to the members of the group. You don't have to tolerate that. He has every right to be there but he has to behave in a way which doesn't constantly derail the group.

I think you (collectively) need to get better at shutting him down in a polite and no nonsense way: when he starts banging on about something which is just wrong you just politely say "Thanks X but this isn't really relevant and we have five minutes left so can we crack on?" It sounds as if others in the group are starting to do this already. You clearly know your stuff and you have every right to do the same. You don't really need to discuss it with the others: you'll probably find the more people who start to assert themselves, the more others will feel emboldened to do the same.

He will eventually get the message and will either grow up and learn to wind his neck in or push off to patronise another group of people who know less about Chamber Music than he does.

AnnaSewell · 19/11/2023 17:42

Music making is not like, say, painting. If you have someone slightly annoying in an art group you can still concentrate on your individual artwork. Someone who is highly 'individual' can be accommodate in an art class.

Chamber music is collaborative and depends on a) shared understanding and b) the ability to follow whoever is leading/directing/conduction.

When you're playing, say, a concerto if someone is playing out of time/in the wrong rhythm/using incorrect technique and will not listen and learn the music is spoiled for everybody else and the quality of any public performance will also suffer.

girlfriend44 · 19/11/2023 17:42

This happens in most groups. There's always someone you don't take too.
Just the way it is.

ManchesterLu · 19/11/2023 17:40

Either just talk to other people, or find another hobby group. You can't gatekeep who attends the group, if you've only been going a few weeks you're the new person.

ElectiveAffinities · 19/11/2023 17:40

The thing is, 'hobby group' doesn’t really do justice to what you do, @ClippyCloppy - it’s a very specialised activity involving considerable skill and artistry (and training, clearly, on your part). Yes, it’s fun and gives a lot of satisfaction to you all, but playing Baroque string music is hardly like a book group where all you really need is the ability to read and give an opinion and drink wine

Dave isn’t the right fit for the ensemble. Unfortunate for him, but he can’t expect to throw his weight around and behave like that and play so badly - you say he seriously expects to perform the Bach Double with you?!

I'm struggling to see why he was invited to join in the first place.

Brexile · 19/11/2023 17:39

Circularargument · 19/11/2023 17:31

Come on, he's definitely less famous. Doesn't mean worse.

I guess it depends whether we're talking about music as music, or the "on hold" call centre music. Poor Vivaldi!

SoddingWeddings · 19/11/2023 17:37

I absolutely love those teatowels! Definitely offer them out / sell them to anyone in strings 😂

weirdoboelady · 19/11/2023 17:34

back

Problem with person at hobby group
category12 · 19/11/2023 17:34

If other members are rolling their eyes and so on, I imagine he won't last long.

Probably just hang on in there and someone else will confront him or he'll find himself ousted.

weirdoboelady · 19/11/2023 17:33

Gosh, you've just reminded me of some t shirts I had printed about 100 years ago. Available from all good linen cupboards near you! (They seem to have bred, I was never very good at getting round to selling them)

Front

Problem with person at hobby group
Circularargument · 19/11/2023 17:31

Brexile · 19/11/2023 10:44

YABU for insinuating that Lully is less famous than Vivaldi 😀but you clearly know more about the topic than I do so maybe YANBU!

As long as the annoying man (there is always one...) isn't specifically targeting you with his mansplaining annoyingness, it's probably best to try to ignore it. If you can't do that, it's a good idea to talk to the founder, who can tell him to rein it in. While that might possibly backfire on you, the fact that others find him annoying too is in your favour. If it gets to the point that Annoying Guy is utterly ruining the experience for you, you've nothing much to lose by tackling his behaviour. Good luck, it sounds like a brilliant project.

Come on, he's definitely less famous. Doesn't mean worse.

MercyIsEliminated · 19/11/2023 17:24

Just ignore him. Who knows, he may well find you as annoying as you find him.

Yetmorebeanstocount · 19/11/2023 17:14

He was lent a baroque bow by our leader but returned it the following week complaining that it wasn’t long enough or gave a resonant sound.

That was the perfect opportunity for the leader to make a stand - "you play with this bow or you don't play at all".
Could the leader find some way to re-introduce the correct bow and tell him it is compulsory?
Someone has to actually stand up to him. Your leader seems to have failed here.

SmudgeButt · 19/11/2023 17:13

There needs to be someone in the group who takes charge and tells him to pipe down. A group I meet with has a chap who is, well, odd. Someone will be giving a demonstration or a talk about something and he'll be loudly going "huh! oh yes? ahuh!!" the whole time. Occasionally he'll start talking adding something which he feels is obviously a valuable bit of extra information. The group generally likes him and so tolerates this behaviour.

On Saturday we met and he was doing his usual and started to talk over the person giving the chat. And was promptly told that, no, he was wrong and maybe he could wait til the end to provide any further input. Complete silence!! Bliss!!! I did overhear later him apologising for interrupting

I'm thinking of mentioning this to the organiser tomorrow so that the next person demonstrating knows it's ok to tell him to be quiet. We've talked about him before and no one is quite sure if he is autistic in some way. I've suggested that maybe it's just that he's lived on his own for 50 years so has just forgotten how to act around others.

CoteDAzur · 19/11/2023 17:10

He was lent a baroque bow by our leader but returned it the following week complaining that it wasn’t long enough or gave a resonant sound. Dick

Shock

Kick him out! You can't have a 2nd violin with modern bow in a baroque ensemble.