Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with person at hobby group

237 replies

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 09:41

Hi after some advice

I joined a group as a hobby a couple of months ago, we meet each week. I’m really enjoying this and the people are awesome! They are a lot older than me, mainly retired, a bit quirky, really interesting and I feel like I’ve met my tribe- I’ve never really gelled with anyone.

However, one member of the group is very annoying- he’s my age (so younger than the rest, although not sure if that’s relevant). He’s extremely opinionated, has a lot less knowledge of what we do compared to everyone else, loud and brash, sarcastic and basically I’ve really tried to get on with him, I’ve chatted to him in the break time but despite trying I just don’t like him at all.

I feel he spoils the aim of why we meet. This is not a paid a group, it’s just a group of individuals who share a specific interest and enjoy meeting up.

How can I move forward? I don’t want to stop going, and I know he has just as much ‘right’ to be there as me.

OP posts:
Ilovecleaning · 21/11/2023 13:30

ElectiveAffinities · 21/11/2023 13:10

The hobby was named within a very short time, if you’d bothered to check. OP is a member of a Baroque music group, which is a very specialised kind of ensemble. ‘Dave’ isn’t fitting in and doesn’t seem to have any interest in doing so.

When people come into a thread after it’s been going for a while, it’s really a good idea to read the whole thing.

Ffs, jog on!
I actually checked just after I posted. And don’t be so bloody sarcastic with your ‘if you’d be bothered’ and ‘it’s really a good idea’ - why does it matter to you?

ElectiveAffinities · 21/11/2023 13:10

Ilovecleaning · 21/11/2023 10:33

OP probably feels that naming the hobby would be too ‘outing’

The hobby was named within a very short time, if you’d bothered to check. OP is a member of a Baroque music group, which is a very specialised kind of ensemble. ‘Dave’ isn’t fitting in and doesn’t seem to have any interest in doing so.

When people come into a thread after it’s been going for a while, it’s really a good idea to read the whole thing.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/11/2023 11:52

Wow! This is such a fascinating thread! I don’t know much at all about this subject (save very basic) but it’s so interesting. I have a Dd who plays / is learning the cello so maybe will be able to pretend I know something when she talks about it 😂

In terms of this scenario, having rtft I think you need to be direct. “No Dave, that’s not what we’re here for”, “no Dave, that’s not how this style of music is played” or whatever - and tell him he’s wasting everyone’s time.

I liked the early suggestion that it was bell ringing though!

moonriverandme · 21/11/2023 11:39

Would it be possible or useful to record your sessions so he could listen to how he sounds & that his way of playing doesn't fit in with the style/ interpretation of the rest of the group? You could use it to support everyone if you don't feel it appropriate or comfortable to single him out.

KnittingSister · 21/11/2023 10:56

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 14:35

roseinthedark · 19/11/2023 13:59

Love this thread, I’m a strings player and early music is my jam!!!

About your Heifetz lad, I don’t know what to say. I feel wound up just reading your posts. 😂 Maybe a, “are you stuck in the 1950s with your ridiculous dynamics? Get in the f-ing 18th century with the rest of us!”

Is there a chamber or amateur orchestra specialising in romantic work? Could it be suggested that they are struggling for players and that the material they play there might suit him more, or, “they really need your valuable creative input!”
At least Heifetz played in tune 😂

there is a local amateur orchestra which I have suggested. I also said how they’d be lucky to have him.

His response was, ‘that’s too much of a commitment and I’d have to practise!’ Oh the irony!

theres your answer, start learning music and asking people to practise this for next week, do that for a month or two...

Ilovecleaning · 21/11/2023 10:33

saveforthat · 19/11/2023 10:07

Just tell us the bloody hobby. Do you think we are all going to know who you are if you tell us?

OP probably feels that naming the hobby would be too ‘outing’

OVienna · 21/11/2023 10:27

AnnaSewell · 20/11/2023 09:03

I think there is a problem about traditions of politeness and #BeKind. These seem to be inhibiting the non-Daves.

But this obscures the fact that if Dave really wants to perform with other musicians, it is - in the longer term - a kindness to him to point out the need to listen to others and be willing to change. It means he will get better and enjoy more musical opportunities.

If he really doesn't care enough to do this there'll be some entry level amateur orchestra that would accept him. But maybe he - unconsciously or otherwise - has picked a small relatively unstructured (but good)) ensemble as somewhere he can try to dominate and feel good about himself.

It reminds me a bit of the arguments about trans women and sport. Why not include them? Why 'deny' them the chance to take part. But Dave is not being denied the opportunity to make music. He simply needs to find an appropriate group. (Actually Dave's situation is more fortunate than that of trans woman wanting to enter a women's race. He can actually carry on in the group if he is willing to make some relatively simple accommodations and work on his musical technique.)

100% this. It's a music GROUP and if he says he wants to participate and progress he has to take on feedback or find a other group. This is a kindness.

loserssaywhat · 21/11/2023 10:11

Oh I can really relate to this one. I am also in a fairly quirky hobby group and it sound like yours might be similar. There’s lots of discussions and each person is involved in their own particular way. We have a member very much like this, suggests nonsensical things that tend to derail what we are doing and I feel it’s for attention. I don’t think you’ll be the only one who finds this annoying. Sometimes other members of our group give eachother a look which suggests they feel the same. I’m wondering if there’s a particular person leading your group who might be able to steer the person in another direction or take more control? Otherwise you may have to just suck this up for a while, he or she may settle down after a few weeks.

EarthyMangold · 21/11/2023 09:20

Your initial description of the ways in which he is irritating sound really like an autistic guy who volunteers at my sister's workplace. That guy also presents as an arrogant, unsympathetic know-all, and it can be very annoying being around him. But it is much easier to be patient with him when you know why he's doing it.

Is it possible that this guy also has some additional needs? Not that that trumps your right to enjoy yourself, or will make him any different, but maybe will help you to understand where he's coming from....?

Just a thought. Apologies if it's not relevant here.

OVienna · 21/11/2023 08:52

Eddielizzard · 19/11/2023 12:55

Trouble with Baroque music though, is that you're only as strong as your weakest link. It's so pared back and transparent. Vibrato will always be heard, it projects more. A lack of understanding of Baroque bow technique will ruin it for you all as you won't be able to create the shapes you like, as will poor intonation.

I think your group leader should be asking him to move to a less experienced group, and audition again in a few years when he's learnt some technique.

I have experienced this, and I'm afraid that my answer was to leave. But as you're the soloist I can appreciate that this isn't something you can or want to do. I think he should be gently encouraged to fuck off.

I agree with this.

Keeper11 · 21/11/2023 08:43

I am retired and belong to several such groups. I promise you there is always one such irritating member! You just need to learn to deal with him. Other people have given you tips, but don’t be afraid to be a little rude - it’s really OK to say - “I am so sorry but Xxxxx has just walked in and I must speak to her” Or “Sorry I must talk to Xxxx because he knows so much about ????”
Don't let this person spoil your enjoyment! Good luck!

LimePi · 21/11/2023 00:36

sorry I think you need to find a way to kick him out
its not your problem if he’s suffering without a social outlet - he can find something else. This isn’t just a social group - it’s a hobby which requires serious skill

AnnaSewell · 20/11/2023 09:03

I think there is a problem about traditions of politeness and #BeKind. These seem to be inhibiting the non-Daves.

But this obscures the fact that if Dave really wants to perform with other musicians, it is - in the longer term - a kindness to him to point out the need to listen to others and be willing to change. It means he will get better and enjoy more musical opportunities.

If he really doesn't care enough to do this there'll be some entry level amateur orchestra that would accept him. But maybe he - unconsciously or otherwise - has picked a small relatively unstructured (but good)) ensemble as somewhere he can try to dominate and feel good about himself.

It reminds me a bit of the arguments about trans women and sport. Why not include them? Why 'deny' them the chance to take part. But Dave is not being denied the opportunity to make music. He simply needs to find an appropriate group. (Actually Dave's situation is more fortunate than that of trans woman wanting to enter a women's race. He can actually carry on in the group if he is willing to make some relatively simple accommodations and work on his musical technique.)

moonshinepoursthroughmywindow · 19/11/2023 22:59

What a fascinating thread! I love the sound of this group and am particularly pleased to hear the name Graupner mentioned - it's not one you come across much in everyday life!

It's a tricky situation because in some ways you as a group are so serious (knowing a lot about the subject, being interested in studying the music as well as just playing it, having specialist period equipment) and in others less serious (not having a really structured hierarchy or rules). I agree with those who have said he either uses that bow or doesn't play at all, but because there's no specific person "in charge" and he knows it, he may well feel that nobody has the right to give him an ultimatum like that. But if you want to be any good as a group, you need to not have him around.

I think a drip-drip-drip approach is probably the best answer here. Just keep pointing it out every time he's not playing in the right style, dominating the conversation or interfering with tuning. I don't mean just you, but everybody who can see and hear what he's doing. You need to make him want to leave if nobody has the authority to force him to leave. The bow, which the most empirically provable thing he's doing wrong, is the hill you need to be willing to die on. He uses it or he can't participate. Take a vote if necessary (if you're confident the vote will go the right way). Everything else is just useful ammo for gradually convincing him you're not the right fit for him.

Fossie · 19/11/2023 22:33

What a fascinating thread. And so many knowledgeable music people exist.

Could you raise some of these points directly in a meeting and try to get consensus? Not in a nasty way but just in an open, straightforward way.

“I m sorry i can’t get over sound made by not using the right bow, Dave I really think you need to change your bow”. If he disagrees, ask for a quick show of hands from those not bothered by the sound made by the bow.

Maybe if it seems like there isn’t a natural leader by the group exists by consensus, you can ask for the changes you are looking for. He may respond well but if he doesn’t he’ll see he will have to go.

StoatofDisarray · 19/11/2023 22:18

We had one of these in our D&D group. The Dungeon Master had a word with him a couple of times and in the end we just moved venues without telling him.

Is there an organiser or leader in your group who can take him aside and have a word?

Saschka · 19/11/2023 20:36

OP, how did he end up joining your group? You say he lives a long way away from where the group meets, so he can’t be the only local violinist. You’ve said he isn’t very good technically, so he wasn’t headhunted on that basis.

I’m just really confused how he’s ended up in a group which is such a bad fit for him in terms of playing style. Is he friends with another member or something? I wouldn’t apply to join a baroque group 50 miles away unless I really, really liked playing baroque music…

Chipsatsunset · 19/11/2023 19:45

His playing is as problematic, if not more so, then his personality here. He shouldn’t be allowed to play in a way that totally changes the whole point of your ensemble. If you are performing in public, then the audience are hoping and expecting to hear something as close to a recreation of a period sound as possible. There are different types of ensembles for different sounds and if you are going to be part of one, you shouldn’t be able to sabotage it by not doing what the rest of the players are doing. You’d not join a traditional Irish folk group and decide to play like Fritz Kreisler. It’s not on. I think the leader should talk with him and be firm.

CremeEggSupremacy · 19/11/2023 19:15

Sounds like there's actually quite a few issues going on here. A casual music group is not the same as one being booked for performances IME - at this point you really do need a leader, or a group chair, or whatever you want to call it, to ensure the group has direction. If you just don't like the personality of this guy that's one thing as you can obviously minimise chatting to him, but if he's spouting off stuff that isn't accurate and you know it, I would start calling him out e.g. 'actually AnnoyingGuy, that isn't correct because blahblahblah'. If he's waffling on about irrelevant crap then it's a gentle cutting off 'thanks AnnoyingGuy, now back to (whatever it is you're meant to be doing)'. A few times embarrassing him gently like this and he will likely start shutting up or, if you're lucky, leave the group entirely

AnnaSewell · 19/11/2023 18:59

The point is it isn't just about the people. It's about the music. To serious musicians (whether professional or amateur) - and to audiences - the music really matters. It has to come first.

youveturnedupwelldone · 19/11/2023 18:56

I work with someone like this, I can confirm that turning it into a game is the way forward if you don't want to leave the group.

Also set some good boundaries - my "colleague" assumed I would want to do his work for him and let him take the credit (he called it "collaborating") and was most offended when I politely said no. Based on his general attitudes, I presume his assumption was based on me being a woman and him being a man.

Bingo! is my favourite way to deal with this sort - write down his 9 most common irritating things to say and mark them off as he says them. Just remember not to actually shout BINGO! (Or do 😂) for extra effect you could keep copy on your music stand.

Give it time though, everyone gets tired of these sorts and they usually flounce off because everyone isn't falling at their feet gushing about their brilliance.

Wormwoodgal · 19/11/2023 18:34

How about making it a rule that the whole group must use Baroque bows - perfectly reasonable if the intention is to be as close as possible to the original historical performance? Then, if he has still trouble using one (as he did before) maybe he'll decide to leave. If he refuses to use one then the group can use his refusal to gently eject him 'unfortunately we really want the same sound created by using the same bows, so if you can't use one then we'll have to find someone else'. That way it's his own fault that he has to leave. And if he does agree to use one and is rubbish, then he's out.

thirdfiddle · 19/11/2023 18:29

I'm finding this very confusing. In some ways you sound like a high level group, in others you're putting up with stuff my kids' beginner up community orchestra wouldn't tolerate. It's okay to be an amateur group and want to play at a high level, it's very normal and much more fun that way.

My wording may not have been pitched right for your level, but doing scales and working on blending is very normal at any level.
Can't you and leader get together and have a quiet word? See if he's willing to work with you or if he'd rather leave and find a group more suited to the style he clearly wants to play in?

ClippyCloppy · 19/11/2023 18:06

RandomMess · 19/11/2023 17:55

Have auditions for the performance group?

I think it’s too late now as we’re all formed. That would have been an excellent suggestion in hindsight though. I think as I said in a previous post it was a very casual, fun arrangement when we first started - then things became really intense as we grew (in a good way, performance and analysis), then before we knew it our founder was booking venues for concerts.

OP posts:
Chipsatsunset · 19/11/2023 18:04

That was the perfect opportunity for the leader to make a stand - "you play with this bow or you don't play at all".
Could the leader find some way to re-introduce the correct bow and tell him it is compulsory?
Someone has to actually stand up to him. Your leader seems to have failed here

I agree with this. Ok this is not a professional group, but it does have a definite ethos and purpose, which is to recreate period music as authentically as possible. He’s screwing this up by refusing to use the right bow and going out on a limb with adding his own inappropriate flourishes. What happens if he decides to change his violin to an electric one or channel Stephan Grapelli and chuck a bit of jazz into the mix. It’s the wrong group for him if he wants to play in a way that messes up the sound of the ensemble and won’t listen or try to learn .

Swipe left for the next trending thread