Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that not all school dinners are nutritionally balanced?

37 replies

Schooldinner1 · 19/11/2023 09:12

I often see posts with people saying how schools are held to strict guidelines etc but I’m not sure that’s the case if the school is an academy!

some examples (primary school):
-pizza, chips and beans
-half a jacket potato with no butter, a pot of tuna/beans and cauliflower

They have to be chosen in advance so you know what your child is going to get. The options are limited e.g. on pizza day, it’s cheese pizza or chicken pizza with chips and beans. No other option.

I am not criticizing the school as if it’s part of a child’s wider and balanced diet it’s hardly a big deal, I’m merely musing over the fact people often say that schools must follow such strict guidelines but this has not been my experience!

If your child is in an academy and lunches are not cooked by the local authority caterers, what are their lunches like? (Friends with children in schools with local authority caterers seem to get a lot more choice and balance!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DJhowzy · 27/11/2023 12:22

Our primary school is part of an academy and I agree OP, the quality of food on offer is very poor overall. Lots of pizza, pastries, processsed meats and of course chips every day. It doesn't seem like they are following any sensible nutritional guidelines to me.

Also, variety has been a big issue as DD doesn't like potato in general, which rules out many options, so she used to often not eat much and come home ravenous. Since the pandemic, even less choice has been on offer and they have cut the size of portions down also (3 chicken nuggets for a 10 year old!). She struggled to fill herself up for half the week, so we had to switch to packed lunches to ensure she had a more balanced and filling lunch at school.

I guess the Jamie Oliver affect has worn off over time!

TheONLYcarbsIEatAreChocolateCrispsandCrumpets · 26/11/2023 23:19

hskdnek572 · 24/11/2023 13:38

I recently read the ingredients list of a well known catering company that provides foods for many schools and pretty much every meal is ultra processed with emulsifiers, flavourings, stabilisers, maltodextrin etc. even simple mac and cheese or chicken curry has tonnes of ingredients.

It's an absolute disgrace. How dare they feed shit to our kids.

I'm gonna start making some huge noise about this.

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/11/2023 13:50

There’s always a balance to be struck between making meals healthy and nutritious yet also ensuring that the food isn’t rejected by a significant proportion of children because it isn’t what they’re used to eating at home - which is a huge problem where FSM children are concerned, if they don’t eat the lunch which could be their main meal of the day. And it’s children from disadvantaged backgrounds who are most likely to be the least familiar with diverse foods. In short, better to eat fish fingers, beans and chips for lunch than nothing at all, and schools simply don’t have the budget to cater for more than one or two meal options per day.

iamwhatiam23 · 24/11/2023 13:42

I used to work in school dinners and trust me when i say that menus sound far nicer than what is actually served up! They use the cheapest suppliers they can, fatty meat etc!

hskdnek572 · 24/11/2023 13:38

I recently read the ingredients list of a well known catering company that provides foods for many schools and pretty much every meal is ultra processed with emulsifiers, flavourings, stabilisers, maltodextrin etc. even simple mac and cheese or chicken curry has tonnes of ingredients.

bakewellbride · 24/11/2023 13:28

I don't see the problem, pizza once a week isn't going to cause any harm. Our kids have pizza night every week!

Fimofriend · 24/11/2023 13:10

The primary school my kids went to prided itself on the healthy lunches it served. When I read the menu I laughed so much I got an asthma attack! Luckily, I read it online while at home so I didn't offend any of the seriously deluded people employed in the school kitchen.

We made lunch boxes for the kids and only once or twice a year were they allowed the school lunch as we considered it to be fast food in the worst way. Fast food that is very processed doesn't become healthy just because you put a tiny amount of vegetables on the side!

When they went to secondary school they sometimes bought some of the "food" that the school offered if they were going through a growth spurt and were extra hungry or if they felt like a snack. But they absolutely insisted that we kept on making them lunch boxes as they felt that the feeling of having a full stomach just lasts longer when you have eaten open rye bread sandwiches than when you have eaten pretty much everything else. (One with paté and pickels, one with ham or salami and some fruit or vegetables on the side for our daughter, and the same times X for our son. We are Scandinavians and our attitude to the lunchbox was the one place where we didn't make much of an effort to fit in)

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 24/11/2023 12:19

CherryMyBrandy · 20/11/2023 04:34

I think it's utterly ridiculous the shit they serve up for school dinners yet they over analyse the food in children's lunch boxes!

Don't get me started on this 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 24/11/2023 12:19

My daughter is in high school she has autism and recently wanted to try school dinners I was chuffed to bits with this. 3 weeks in she gave them up because ' the only really healthy option is fruit that looks rotten' she loves baked potatoes but say theirs are way too salted and oily. Day to day options are paninis,quesidillas , bacon sausage , baked potatoes, cakes , fizzy drinks , one main meal which looks like it should probably be balanced. There is no option of side salads with a baked potato / panini ect

Natsku · 20/11/2023 05:43

Pizza, chips and beans does not sound balanced to me - why would you have chips with pizza? The pizza already has the carbs for the meal, so should have some salad or vegetables with it

I live abroad, they do not serve things like that for school dinners here. Just looked at this week's menu - today is chicken soup, rye bread and salad, tomorrow is pork sauce and root veggies, the next day is lasagne with grated carrots. There's always salad too and crispbread too. No puddings. The teachers sit and eat with their class (in primary school, not in upper school) and makes sure everyone eats properly with good manners and portion sizes aren't decided for them - they can choose how much or how little to take as they serve themselves, not the dinner ladies (but waste is strongly discouraged, so they soon learn not to take too much but can go back for seconds if they're still hungry)

CherryMyBrandy · 20/11/2023 04:34

I think it's utterly ridiculous the shit they serve up for school dinners yet they over analyse the food in children's lunch boxes!

sashh · 20/11/2023 04:31

Seashor · 19/11/2023 21:05

The food in our school is incredible, absolutely delicious and wholesome. Portions are generous and the food is locally sourced.
But, our headteacher adds funds to the food budget so much more is spent per child.

I bet behaviour is better too. School food should be a resource, something that aids education.

Saschka · 19/11/2023 22:10

Ours is mostly fine - the issue is DS’s limited food choices, not the range of options. He generally has jacket potato with beans and cheese, but he really loves it and would choose it over practically any other option. There are about 4-5 options each day, generally healthy things like jambalaya, pasta, curries, chilli and rice etc. There is a salad bar and fruit available, but it is option. Also bread rolls and butter with each meal.

The one thing I’m not happy about is that on Fridays they have fish and chips, and because DS is vegetarian they let him have just a plate of chips. He’s more than happy with that, but I’m really not (there is a vegetarian option, he would rather have double chips). Having said that, they only serve chips once a week, so not really a hill worth dying on.

OneCup · 19/11/2023 22:08

There was a taster event scheduled at our school as parents had complained about what appeared to be an unhealthy menu.
From the caterer/council perspective, they were offering a healthy menu in so far as there were healthy options. In their eyes it didn't matter if a child only picked pizza and chocolate cake. They had the option to pick salad and fruit too but it was their choice to take it. I disagree with this approach so ended up sending DC with packed lunches and have no regrets.

TheyDo · 19/11/2023 22:00

many kids have admitted this has happens a few times and was told by head and head dinner lady not to tell parents about it

One of the first rules of safeguarding - do not tell children to keep quiet about something. No secrets.

LucyTeatime · 19/11/2023 21:58

It is the lack of culture capital in the very basics of eating which tend to be standard in private schools which leave the vast majority of children who do not get these experiences always catching up. Not even the food, but the process of eating lunch.

Oh don't be a twit!

The food might be foul but state school kids (i.e. the majority of children in the UK) use knives and forks. They don't put their snouts in a trough.

MissAtomicBomb1 · 19/11/2023 21:54

YOOHOOHEYITSME · 19/11/2023 12:31

i home educate so have no personal experience but for our local school(village in south Wales valleys)its the quantity

next door kids are 5 and 8,yougest only started reception in September, he never did nursery
oldest came home Thursday saying he's starving, youngest also said he had very little on his plate

dinner works out as reception first and up a year every 10 minutes so youngest kids get there first, poor y6s

NDN enquired more in the what's app group(obliviously im not part of but was shown) and after asking, many found out they kids were as well
many kids have admitted this has happens a few times and was told by head and head dinner lady not to tell parents about it

tuned up to head on Friday as a group and it turned out they actually run out of food very regularly as budget was cut so much.
many parents actually pay for dinner

now i though free school meals were provided as a physical portion per child
but apparently its given in money not food

this is a small village primary.
ive been told 15-20 a class

head has been covering it up since start of term and said its going to get worse as the year goes on

loads have ganged together and written to the governors about the heads behaviour

NDN is a good friend so ive been told and seen the whatts app messages

2 parents were that outraged,1 chose to home educate and the other to the next village school

my son is 13(mentally years behind though) and would be in a special school
but every day posts on here and what ive heard the last few years how schools have declined so much validate my reasons for not sending him at all

this is mainstream schools, i dread to think what special schools are like

I have worked in many schools and can assure you it is not the case that they routinely run out of food so you don't need to worry on behalf of the rest of us.

MissAtomicBomb1 · 19/11/2023 21:50

My children go to an academy and I'd say they're fine on balance. Examples: sweet potato curry, roast dinner, chill - always fish & chips on a Fri! There's a salad bar, all meals cooked on site.

To the poster who keeps throwing around 'culture capital', it's cultural capital and children eat 5 out of their 21 meals at school. Parents are responsible for teaching children how to sit at a table, use a knife & fork and so on. We can't keep expecting schools to step in and fill the void.

itsmyp4rty · 19/11/2023 21:38

It's just a lot of cheap processed junk generally isn't it - anyone ever seen a chicken thigh or a pork chop on the menu? Thought not. At ds's school they've really gone down hill since covid and they weren't very good before. I only let him have it once a week.

TheONLYcarbsIEatAreChocolateCrispsandCrumpets · 19/11/2023 21:37

hedgehoglurker · 19/11/2023 09:19

Is there fruit and salad available? Are there hidden vegetables in the pizza sauce? Is it a wholemeal pizza base? Is the dessert something like a sugar free muffin made with beetroot, as another one of the 5 a day?

Whilst it looks fairly basic, there may be other elements that combine to make it fulfill the criteria.

😄

TheONLYcarbsIEatAreChocolateCrispsandCrumpets · 19/11/2023 21:34

It's all just a load of highly processed, defrosted, reheated crap.

snoopyfanaccountant · 19/11/2023 21:19

I think that the problem is parents who expect beige food to be served as school meals. A few years ago our council posted its primary school menu online and a parent replied asking what child would eat salmon; mine have eaten salmon since they were tiny (one won't eat white fish thanks to awful school lunches).
I was in the company of a 14 month old and her mum today. The wee one expects to eat the same as the rest of the family and won't eat nuggets/fish fingers unless everyone else is eating the same.

Seashor · 19/11/2023 21:05

The food in our school is incredible, absolutely delicious and wholesome. Portions are generous and the food is locally sourced.
But, our headteacher adds funds to the food budget so much more is spent per child.

YOOHOOHEYITSME · 19/11/2023 12:31

i home educate so have no personal experience but for our local school(village in south Wales valleys)its the quantity

next door kids are 5 and 8,yougest only started reception in September, he never did nursery
oldest came home Thursday saying he's starving, youngest also said he had very little on his plate

dinner works out as reception first and up a year every 10 minutes so youngest kids get there first, poor y6s

NDN enquired more in the what's app group(obliviously im not part of but was shown) and after asking, many found out they kids were as well
many kids have admitted this has happens a few times and was told by head and head dinner lady not to tell parents about it

tuned up to head on Friday as a group and it turned out they actually run out of food very regularly as budget was cut so much.
many parents actually pay for dinner

now i though free school meals were provided as a physical portion per child
but apparently its given in money not food

this is a small village primary.
ive been told 15-20 a class

head has been covering it up since start of term and said its going to get worse as the year goes on

loads have ganged together and written to the governors about the heads behaviour

NDN is a good friend so ive been told and seen the whatts app messages

2 parents were that outraged,1 chose to home educate and the other to the next village school

my son is 13(mentally years behind though) and would be in a special school
but every day posts on here and what ive heard the last few years how schools have declined so much validate my reasons for not sending him at all

this is mainstream schools, i dread to think what special schools are like

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 19/11/2023 10:05

DarkForces · 19/11/2023 09:56

I'm not actually trying to be amusing. I found your remark about state schools setting children up for fast food pretty offensive tbh

It is the lack of culture capital in the very basics of eating which tend to be standard in private schools which leave the vast majority of children who do not get these experiences always catching up. Not even the food, but the process of eating lunch. The speed at which they are expected to eat. The lack of seating. The lack of time to have a conversation as schools are far too small for the amount of students, that so many dont even have dedicated eating areas. They double as classrooms / assembly halls / drama rooms.