Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be devastated I didn't get the job

213 replies

Ronalling · 19/11/2023 01:27

I'll give a little context, I started at the company I'm at in 2021 (new company so no one is from before 2019, hardly anyone before 2021). I work in the entertainment/creative industries, I don't want to say exact title as could be outing with the other info, but think of the performing arts.
The company are restructuring due to faster than expected growth and wanting to focus on a different market, a new role was made, advertised only internally. I interviewed in June/July, we were told we would hear nearer the time and other things had to be sorted first. It is a middle management role, sort of joining the creative side with the company as a whole, lots of time spent on meetings and admin and making sure others are doing their jobs but still some creative input and studio time. The internal job advert was vague, no time of experience noted, just you had to already be in a certain role. I'm 35, have been doing that job at other companies for 10 years, then for as long as anyone else at this company. I have a degree that is related too.
On Thursday it was announced that a 24/25 year old, who only got the job that was required experience wise last summer, has the job and has known since August!! She is very likable and has climbed the ranks in this company, one of the originals etc. In her first few months she caused waves due to the success of one of her pieces of work. All the normal things were said, she is a breath of fresh air, brings a new level of creativity etc. Honestly I didn't get the hype, she is just very likable and dare I say pretty privilege. After this she was given the opportunity to work with other teams and none of the rest of us were. It has basically gone from me being her boss in 2021, being equals in 2022, to her being my boss now!! They are also paying for her management course (though I think they were going to do this for whoever got it).
I'm so frustrated, I don't understand what she has that I don't, she is 10 years younger, no degree, barely any experience and will be making £80,000+ a year which is substantially more than me!!
It is also unlikely she will leave the job anytime soon and there are no other obvious progression paths at this company so basically I will have to leave if I want to progress.
I guess AIBU to be upset and think it is really unfair that someone who is so much less experienced/qualified has gotten the job over me?? Should I complain to someone??

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 19/11/2023 06:25

Obviously they have decided this is the person they want. Quite possibly the wrong choice was made and they were hoodwinked by charm, attractiveness and ability to talk the talk. Which doesn't always mean ability to do the job. But under the circumstances I would leave. I certainly wouldn't tolerate having this inexperienced person as my boss.

TempyBrennan · 19/11/2023 06:21

ilovepixie · 19/11/2023 01:47

All the normal things were said, she is a breath of fresh air, brings a new level of creativity etc.

You said it yourself OP, she brings something new, a fresh pair of eyes.
Working ten years in the same company can equate to being stale and stuck in a rut, doing something because it's always been done that way.
Whereas she brings fresh ideas, and she has no loyalty to past behaviours or procedures.

I just came to say this - you’re potential blind to what they were looking for as you’ve been in the industry so long.

she can see something, she may have even brought some exception ideas to interview which made her the better candidate.

I would ask for feedback though, in a less emotional way.

Hellenabe · 19/11/2023 06:13

@Ronalling as others have said, sometimes it's just the face that fits. I'd just lay low and keep an eye out externally for ops. It may be a blessing in disguise in terms of work but they would have known you'd be annoyed yet still went with it.

This happened to me, I was extremely experienced but our team leader role came up as a vacancy and went to a quiet newbie, Oxbridge educated, 1st class degree. My then boss went on sick that day and emailed the outcome to me as couldnt face me. TBH she was right for the role in many ways as fit the company mould and people were in awe of her academics but I couldn't bear the humiliation and left for a much better role as soon as I could.

My advice, you aren't valued here, look elsewhere

LadyWithLapdog · 19/11/2023 06:00

The OP has only been there since 2021. The younger colleague since 2022. Why are people making out that she’s a dinosaur? She has 10 years experience and formal qualifications. It’s frustrating, we can at least acknowledge that.

sollenwir · 19/11/2023 05:57

I get how you feel OP, but it just sounds like the other candidate was a better fit. Nothing wrong with asking for feedback after a knockback though, to help you decide how to proceed.

LadyWithLapdog · 19/11/2023 05:53

It’s frustrating, OP. But you may have dodged a bullet. The management side of this job might be horrendous and not worth it.

I applied for a promotion last year. It went to another colleague. I’ve seen him do the job and I know I wouldn’t have enjoyed it. I wouldn’t have been “naturally” good at it, but I’m diligent and would have worked hard to make it work. I’m glad I don’t have the responsibility, though. I see how stressed he is by that aspect of the job. If the company you work for is good in other ways, I’d carry on there till new openings.

BettyPhuckzer · 19/11/2023 05:53

Time in the role is ABSOLUTELY no indicator for promotion. Neither is having a relevant degree

In fact longevity can make staff stale and complacent and a degree doesn't help in the arts imo

Your employer doesn't want you in a senior role

Of course, you'll organise a meeting for detailed feedback, but you might not get the full truth, which is a shame as you need to know where you've gone off kilter to help in your next job

You'll obviously have to leave where you are now and your employer will know that

NoGNoDNoClue · 19/11/2023 05:43

What you can't do is change the situation. What you might need to do, for your own sake, is change your attitude towards it. Your resentment is clear. If you let that show, then you'll never get ahead.

Take this as a push to excel in your role so the next time it will be you

NoGNoDNoClue · 19/11/2023 05:38

I've been in my role less time than a colleague in the same role. I am confident that if a promotion came up (unlikely at this stage, but possibly in the future), she definitely wouldn't get it, and I would stand a reasonable chance, although not guaranteed.

Time in the role is less important than what you have brought to the role in the time you've been there. You've talked about her success - but you have said nothing about yours.

Also you are minimising the fact that she has been at that company longer, it sounds like two years longer. That's not irrelevant either.

Treesinmygarden · 19/11/2023 05:33

Dibbydoos · 19/11/2023 05:24

Promotion is not about age and experience, it's are about talent. She sounds like she's talented and your employers recognise this.

I was her once. I was called a 'bit of a kid', but I worked miracles in my job, so people stopped going on about me being a head of service in local government at the age of 24. Support her, she could take you with her.

I also recall a guy going on about a colleague, let's call him Dave, who joined a co through the same grad scheme as him. He didn't think Dave was great, but the co did. Dave is now the CEO of that multi national co earning millions in salary plus millions in bonuses every year. He was clearly talent.

Promotion is not about talent at all - it's about your face fitting.

I recall a mediocre management consultant where I worked in what was a big five consultancy back in the day.

She was crap as a management consultant, but as her interview notes from one of the partners said, "she looks like a Vogue model" - so they shoved her into Marketing instead...

Treesinmygarden · 19/11/2023 05:26

I'm so sorry this has happened to you. It's devastating. If I were you, I'd be looking elsewhere. This organisation doesn't value you. They're blindsided by the eye-lash fluttering, ass kissing johnny come lately, and you deserve better.

I went for an interview 3 years ago. Far the best qualified candidate in terms of experience and qualifications, and I know I did a decent interview. Had also been carrying out the majority of the role for 10/11 months and it had gone well. Manager came into the office post-interviews raving about how good everyone had been and how hard the decision had been. When I asked for feedback, I got my answers to the questions recited back to me.

It turned out that the job went to someone half my age, with a fraction of my qualifications, and a fraction of my experience, who had only been in the organisation for a wet weekend, but malleable! This totally unimpressive, uninspiring individual had already been promoted by 3 grades within months, but has now been promoted by a further 3 grades in less than 3 years! Am I bitter, am I fuck!

However, I had 2 things go against me. One, I expressed my opinions, when the expectation was that I should put up and shut up. I will never do that. Two, I was late 50s, and the general recruitment situation showed that I was firmly in the 'too old' category. There is potentially a three, which is that I was massively more qualified educationally and in experience, than the twat manager doing the recruiting. Her loss.

Vote with your feet. I would have, if I hadn't been too old to be considered worth of employment!

Dibbydoos · 19/11/2023 05:24

Promotion is not about age and experience, it's are about talent. She sounds like she's talented and your employers recognise this.

I was her once. I was called a 'bit of a kid', but I worked miracles in my job, so people stopped going on about me being a head of service in local government at the age of 24. Support her, she could take you with her.

I also recall a guy going on about a colleague, let's call him Dave, who joined a co through the same grad scheme as him. He didn't think Dave was great, but the co did. Dave is now the CEO of that multi national co earning millions in salary plus millions in bonuses every year. He was clearly talent.

Treesinmygarden · 19/11/2023 05:12

gwenneh · 19/11/2023 01:37

You would think that should be the case, but it's also possible that someone has been mediocre for 10 years and is easily outdone by a talented newcomer - particularly in creative fields.

That is also a horrible and unnecessary comment!

Treesinmygarden · 19/11/2023 05:10

gwenneh · 19/11/2023 01:30

The length of time you have spent at a role is no indication of how good you actually are at it. Sounds like the role went to the person who earned it, and it wasn't you.

How can you say that, when you don't have a clue?? Don't you understand the prejudice that goes with recruiting??

ChocolateCinderToffee · 19/11/2023 05:07

I also think they created the job for her. If I were you, I’d move on.

Emeraldsanddiamonds · 19/11/2023 03:16

I once missed out on a job where I had more experience than the whole team including the person who would have been my boss. I moved on to other things and eventually had to manage the person who had turned me down while he was working out his notice after being made redundant. It was a lucky escape and I was merciful - I gave him a secluded desk so he wasn't on display. I actually am competent and the person who got the job I'd applied for certainly wasn't.

I think you might have to work on gravitas. Don't smile away like a Cheshire cat. Cultivate a modulated but firm and measured voice. Project an air of competence and unflappability. Endless books on the subject. Might be different in my industry but have a look at the senior managers in your organisation and try to emulate them. If all else fails, ask yourself what a man would do or the one who got the job. Sometime though it is just favourites.

Aintnosupermum · 19/11/2023 03:07

I don’t apply for internal roles unless explicitly invited to do so. They are always posted as a formality.

For those saying the length of experience is irrelevant, I strongly disagree. I’m a qualified accountant. Lots of people have an MBA and assume they are just as capable at managing a balance sheet as someone like myself. No they are not. I have 20 years of experience starting in audit, in small, medium and global companies both held privately and public. I’ve taken clients through going public, M&A activity and bankruptcy. I’m fed up of MBAs coming in and thinking they are better than a CPA at these things. No, it’s specialist work and no MBA prepares you for the role. Quite frankly, don’t insult the OP by trying to say someone with less than 5 years of experience and no specific education in the field is in any way qualified for this role compared to someone who has an education and experience in the role.

This candidate is the office darling. You say nothing and you start to look for another role elsewhere. They just told you they don’t value you, so go somewhere that does.

Nynaeva · 19/11/2023 02:58

Not creative industries here but have had similar experiences, the only times I've been promoted have been when I've moved organisations.

Of course now I'm so old I'm half dinosaur I'm presuming I'm probably going to get stuck for a bit in my current role so am concentrating on my self employed stuff outside the day job. We've also had a whole slew of new very young managers arrive with no previous experience in the sector and it is starting to show in the decisions they have made and are making. Almost everyone I work with is now looking to leave.

Lick your wounds, ask for feedback, and be on the alert for new job openings.

CherryMyBrandy · 19/11/2023 02:55

I do think it's more than a little out of order to keep unsuccessful candidates waiting since July when they told the successful person in August! They could have told you three months ago! Very rude.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/11/2023 02:51

I think it’s impossible for us to say. We don’t know you or her. Most of us don’t know the industry, and none of us know the company.

That said, it must be incredibly disappointing.

Ask for feedback, but also look for another job.

I lost out on a job I really wanted in early 2022, there were two openings and I really thought one of the two people who were successful was much less qualified or suited. The job had a very inflexible interview process, and I slightly fluffed the interview.

I left to go elsewhere and now have a better than equivalent job. It was right for me to leave.

HoppingPavlova · 19/11/2023 02:31

Doing the job for 1 year vs 10 surely makes a difference???

Nope. Nope. Nope. I’ve come across people who have been in a role for decades, yet still incredibly average at their job, whereas others who have been in the same role, or a lesser role, and are inherently suited to it, very good at it, and would have a good future if given opportunity. Guess who gets the job!

bluetongue · 19/11/2023 02:30

Same happened at my workplace. Young, pretty woman who could turn on the charm in an interview. I wasn’t surprised I didn’t get the job as I crashed and burned in my interview but five other experienced staff members also applied and it was generally seen as a dodgy decision by most people, not just those who applied and missed out. We have lost many of those applicants to other departments since the decision.

It’s taken me 18 months but I’ve finally managed to get a promotion to the same level, partly helped by a new manager who has recognised how hard I’ve worked over the years.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 19/11/2023 02:23

Ronalling · 19/11/2023 01:33

Doing the job for 1 year vs 10 surely makes a difference???

Staying in position doesn't always mean getting better at it.

There's a famous old quip: 'A lot of people in business say they have twenty years experience, when in fact all the really have is one repeated twenty times'.

Your company didn't recognise your worth OP. If you think you deserve the job and would do it better - you need to move to a company that sees you.

Ihavetoleavemyjob · 19/11/2023 02:22

It’s a horrible feeling. Especially if you know the job should’ve been yours. I missed a promotion and was devastated as I found I was being backstabbed by the colleague that got the job. I couldn’t work under her, so I left. I got another job in the position I wanted at another place and am so glad I did, especially as it stuffed the new job up for the colleague. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to be upset, if you can find another job take it. Especially if it puts you in a position to move up. You don’t owe them loyalty.

jemenfous37 · 19/11/2023 02:19

It is awful to feel ovelooked. But instead of tying yourself in knots and resenting the girl, just ask for interview-panel feedback. There may be a myriad of reasons she was chosen and you were not, but you have to ask rather than assuming.