Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be devastated I didn't get the job

213 replies

Ronalling · 19/11/2023 01:27

I'll give a little context, I started at the company I'm at in 2021 (new company so no one is from before 2019, hardly anyone before 2021). I work in the entertainment/creative industries, I don't want to say exact title as could be outing with the other info, but think of the performing arts.
The company are restructuring due to faster than expected growth and wanting to focus on a different market, a new role was made, advertised only internally. I interviewed in June/July, we were told we would hear nearer the time and other things had to be sorted first. It is a middle management role, sort of joining the creative side with the company as a whole, lots of time spent on meetings and admin and making sure others are doing their jobs but still some creative input and studio time. The internal job advert was vague, no time of experience noted, just you had to already be in a certain role. I'm 35, have been doing that job at other companies for 10 years, then for as long as anyone else at this company. I have a degree that is related too.
On Thursday it was announced that a 24/25 year old, who only got the job that was required experience wise last summer, has the job and has known since August!! She is very likable and has climbed the ranks in this company, one of the originals etc. In her first few months she caused waves due to the success of one of her pieces of work. All the normal things were said, she is a breath of fresh air, brings a new level of creativity etc. Honestly I didn't get the hype, she is just very likable and dare I say pretty privilege. After this she was given the opportunity to work with other teams and none of the rest of us were. It has basically gone from me being her boss in 2021, being equals in 2022, to her being my boss now!! They are also paying for her management course (though I think they were going to do this for whoever got it).
I'm so frustrated, I don't understand what she has that I don't, she is 10 years younger, no degree, barely any experience and will be making £80,000+ a year which is substantially more than me!!
It is also unlikely she will leave the job anytime soon and there are no other obvious progression paths at this company so basically I will have to leave if I want to progress.
I guess AIBU to be upset and think it is really unfair that someone who is so much less experienced/qualified has gotten the job over me?? Should I complain to someone??

OP posts:
myotherkidisacassowary · 19/11/2023 08:35

I think it’s understandable that you’re upset and disappointed, anyone would be.

I don’t think it’s fair to denigrate your colleague and claim she only got the job because she’s likeable and pretty, especially because elsewhere you allude to the fact that she has done good work that has been well received. Experience can be an important indicator of suitability for a role, but it’s not the only indicator, in this case it was clearly less important than other qualities which she has.

I absolutely don’t think complaining would be appropriate but you can ask for specific feedback on why your application was unsuccessful and see your areas of weakness so you know what to work on.

It’s also natural that you’re considering leaving the company - if there are no promotion opportunities for you then you will need to look elsewhere, but if it’s a growing company I wouldn’t write it off just yet. There may well be more opportunities for advancement in future.

AgaMM · 19/11/2023 08:29

Teateaandmoretea · 19/11/2023 07:29

Eh?

You have evidence she’s wrong right?

There is nothing at all to suggest that she’s right and more to suggest that she’s wrong.

The other candidate may be younger, but OP has already admitted that she impressed the company with her work shortly after joining. OP said nothing similar for herself, and believes shes more deserving simply because she’s older and has more on the job experience.

Sometimes someone younger and less experienced comes along who is better than others. To say that she only got the promotion because of eyelash fluttering and ass kissing is nasty.

43ontherocksporfavor · 19/11/2023 08:28

I totally understand your disappointment and it’s ok to feel it. You’ve waited a long time to be let down. If she’s known since August, the company hasn’t treated you very well.
However, it sounds as though she has what they want and there’s not much you can do about that. I would ask for some feedback and weigh up your options Don’t take it out on her.

Blogswife · 19/11/2023 08:26

They obviously see something in her that they like / want
You could complain but I suspect they’ll be able to justify their decision. Perhaps asking for feedback is a better way forward
It stinks that she found out ages ago but kept you waiting - I would complain about that !

Sparehair · 19/11/2023 08:26

Not sure why people are talking about nepotism because there's absolutely no implication that that was the case here.

I agree that experience isn't entirely irrelevant, but at the same time, young stars do come through and should get recognition for that, and conversely, most companies are carrying a fair bit of dead wood at middle management levels, unless they operate an aggressive "up or out" policy which only really happens in a few professions (I'm not saying the OP is dead wood btw, just that generally, long tenure and suitability for promotion can't be conflated).

There is also some argument for promoting people based on potential rather than because they completely fulfil the requirements of the job. Roles should offer development potential and some people really thrive on a steep learning curve and are happy to be completely out of their comfort zone while they bridge the gap.

"She is very likeable". Well yes and that makes her effective. Technical competency is only part of why someone can succeed in a role. Having a company wide network, being generally liked and leveraging that makes it easier to get things done (which is why I think permanent wfh in most large corporate roles is a massive fuck over for mid-career women but that's a whole other thread).

So yes, it totally sucks to lose out on roles and promotions but it doesn't mean that the wrong candidate was chosen. What was badly handled was the communication as the OP should have been told much earlier that she'd been unsuccessful.

Wafflesandcrepes · 19/11/2023 08:21

Hi OP, I was in a job where it was clear I would never be promoted. I left, got a job in an amazing company and was promoted within nine months. Polish your CV, follow the many interviews tips from insta influencers (Anna Papalia in particular) and focus on the rest of your career. Don’t look back - it will only raise your blood pressure unnecessarily. Good luck.

CommonOrNot · 19/11/2023 08:20

Complain? She’s a more likeable person so more suited to the role. End of. You sound a bit overly envious op.

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2023 08:19

You're not unreasonable to be upset, anyone would be.

But it is what it is. Looks like they created this role for her. Maybe she was threatening to leave and they didn't want that? Nothing you will do or say now is going to change anything (though getting feedback is a good idea).

Many people find they have to move companies to progress. So I'd suggest you start to look for something else.

Fran2023 · 19/11/2023 08:17

gwenneh · 19/11/2023 01:37

You would think that should be the case, but it's also possible that someone has been mediocre for 10 years and is easily outdone by a talented newcomer - particularly in creative fields.

Brutal.

Neriah · 19/11/2023 08:16

Lelliekelliee · 19/11/2023 08:02

I would speak to HR about this to be honest. I often employ people internally in our company. Recently we had 2 applicants- 1 very dynamic, a bit younger so slightly less experienced. The other we have worked with before and she has experience but is very negative and difficult to work with, she puts in complaints if she feels someone has given her a dirty look etc. We had to hire the latter because she was more experienced. You have to give a really good reason to hire someone with less experience.

TBH you don't sound very experienced yourself. What kind of advice is "go whine to HR that you didn't get the job"? And it is relatively easy to hire someone "with less experience" - you appont the person who is the best fit for the entire job, and "experience" (which is a rather subjective opinion based on time-served rather than ability) is only one factor amongst many. Hiring somebody who is known to sow dissension and is likely to alienate their staff and colleagues just because they have a year or two longer at the job suggests that either your job descriptions are lousy or your don't have much experience of recruitment.

Thingamebobwotsit · 19/11/2023 08:13

You are not BU for feeling upset, but if she fit the bill and was the better candidate against the criteria then she is the right person for the role and I would keep quiet and look for a job elsewhere.

There isn't a lot you can do in this set of circumstances except either consciously decide to support her in the new role, or move on. The choice is yours.

user1471538283 · 19/11/2023 08:12

This is infuriating for you. I would let her get on with it. Do your job. Don't support or train her. Do as she asks.

And look around for something else. In the meantime get all the training and shadowing you can.

I've met so many that have been promoted outside their competency and I've struggled to support them, do their work and it has crippled me. Not anymore.

The business made this decision so they can manage it.

Imagwine · 19/11/2023 08:10

They are frightened she’ll leave so they need a carrot for her. After your length of time there, they don’t think you will. Prove them otherwise.

ThanksItHasPockets · 19/11/2023 08:08

I appreciate that you don’t want to state the sector but I wonder if you work in a field where degrees are not essential and therefore someone of 25 with eight years’ work experience could quite easily be considered alongside a graduate with ten.

Can you access any careers support within your sector? My main question is why you want to continue in a role that you’ve already done for ten years elsewhere, albeit in a new setting. I think it’s very common for women in particular in their 30s to reach a point where they think younger people are being promoted over them, when in fact the issue is that they are not being ambitious enough in the roles they apply for. Ten years in an equivalent role could mean that you should be applying for much more senior jobs.

Starsalign · 19/11/2023 08:07

inquisitiveinga · 19/11/2023 08:01

The thing that isn't OK here is that the person who got the role has known since August, your company should've definitely respected you enough to atleast let you know the score.

However, you do sound slightly entitled and rude to say that you don't get the "hype". Surely if she got so much attention for her work there is something to sing her praises for?

Also, as a 26 year old with a small family on much less than £80k, I can't help but bring my personal views into this and say our generation absolutely deserve that wage. Many of us have missed the property ladder entirely due to massively inflated property prices not matching wages in the slightest, and are paying 80k + worth of student loans. Go her! Move on and don't let this bitterness show, it's not a great look.

To be fair OP is only 35, hardly like we had brilliant housing prices either or very low student loan repayments.

anotherside · 19/11/2023 08:05

@YireosDodeAver

You aren't appreciated there so it's time to start job hunting and find something where you are appreciated

Certainly an option worth considering. Nobody owes anyone else more money or a promotion. But nor do you owe them your loyalty.

ShenleyWillow · 19/11/2023 08:03

It's disappointing for you. Employers often have a very clear idea of the candidate they'd like to recruit and if someone exhibits these qualities it usually trumps everything else.

Tryingtohelp12 · 19/11/2023 08:03

I would express your disappoint bc and request feedback. Also possibly maturely give them feedback on the application process (including unreasonable timeframe). Use it to scope out a more senior role if that’s genuinely what you want. But no I don’t believe in time in service being a priority over performance when it comes to hiring

ayegazumba · 19/11/2023 08:02

I'd feel devastated too. Sorry you didn't get it. Time to leave. Might be a good thing. Good luck, you'll find the right role and be grateful you didn't get this one even though it doesn't feel like it now

anotherside · 19/11/2023 08:02

24-25 isn’t really that young. And if she has no degree then she’s presumably been working for around seven years already, which is a decent enough chunk of CV experience - arguably enough to make your relative experience less of a factor.

KimberleyClark · 19/11/2023 08:02

Are the senior management team male? Unfortunately fifty plus men are prone to seeing all sorts of business talent hidden behind a nice face and attractive figure when recruiting. They genuinely don’t even believe that they are being biased. Many of us (including me) have probably benefited from this at one time or another.

I remember doing a course on unconscious bias at work. The one type of bias that was not dealt with was the physical attractiveness bias. This affects women and men and can work both ways a.though more often it benefits good looking people.

Lelliekelliee · 19/11/2023 08:02

I would speak to HR about this to be honest. I often employ people internally in our company. Recently we had 2 applicants- 1 very dynamic, a bit younger so slightly less experienced. The other we have worked with before and she has experience but is very negative and difficult to work with, she puts in complaints if she feels someone has given her a dirty look etc. We had to hire the latter because she was more experienced. You have to give a really good reason to hire someone with less experience.

ditzzy · 19/11/2023 08:01

Not at all unreasonable for being upset and feeling sorry for yourself.

But completely unreasonable for begrudging another person’s success.

I strongly recommend not even thinking about officially complaining, but there’s no problem with asking for feedback and finding out if there’s something you can do to make yourself more suitable for the next promotion opportunity (or the next job elsewhere!). Perhaps ask about courses they could recommend to help you improve too.

inquisitiveinga · 19/11/2023 08:01

The thing that isn't OK here is that the person who got the role has known since August, your company should've definitely respected you enough to atleast let you know the score.

However, you do sound slightly entitled and rude to say that you don't get the "hype". Surely if she got so much attention for her work there is something to sing her praises for?

Also, as a 26 year old with a small family on much less than £80k, I can't help but bring my personal views into this and say our generation absolutely deserve that wage. Many of us have missed the property ladder entirely due to massively inflated property prices not matching wages in the slightest, and are paying 80k + worth of student loans. Go her! Move on and don't let this bitterness show, it's not a great look.

Starsalign · 19/11/2023 07:59

Time alone in a job doesn't necessarily suggest someone is 'better' for the role, especially in the creative industries there are lots of soft skills also that can't be learnt that are really valuable. If she's had a very successful project and is also personable and a good advocate and rep for the company then that's a huge plus.

Personally I would ask for feedback for yourself and not mention that you're bitter. It does sound strange that they've strung you along for all these months when they knew in August she had the job, and I think that's fair to raise; but don't go and tear her down because they've made their decision and aren't going to change their minds as you're annoyed and neither should they. Perhaps time to look elsewhere if you've been in the role for a decade?