Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be devastated I didn't get the job

213 replies

Ronalling · 19/11/2023 01:27

I'll give a little context, I started at the company I'm at in 2021 (new company so no one is from before 2019, hardly anyone before 2021). I work in the entertainment/creative industries, I don't want to say exact title as could be outing with the other info, but think of the performing arts.
The company are restructuring due to faster than expected growth and wanting to focus on a different market, a new role was made, advertised only internally. I interviewed in June/July, we were told we would hear nearer the time and other things had to be sorted first. It is a middle management role, sort of joining the creative side with the company as a whole, lots of time spent on meetings and admin and making sure others are doing their jobs but still some creative input and studio time. The internal job advert was vague, no time of experience noted, just you had to already be in a certain role. I'm 35, have been doing that job at other companies for 10 years, then for as long as anyone else at this company. I have a degree that is related too.
On Thursday it was announced that a 24/25 year old, who only got the job that was required experience wise last summer, has the job and has known since August!! She is very likable and has climbed the ranks in this company, one of the originals etc. In her first few months she caused waves due to the success of one of her pieces of work. All the normal things were said, she is a breath of fresh air, brings a new level of creativity etc. Honestly I didn't get the hype, she is just very likable and dare I say pretty privilege. After this she was given the opportunity to work with other teams and none of the rest of us were. It has basically gone from me being her boss in 2021, being equals in 2022, to her being my boss now!! They are also paying for her management course (though I think they were going to do this for whoever got it).
I'm so frustrated, I don't understand what she has that I don't, she is 10 years younger, no degree, barely any experience and will be making £80,000+ a year which is substantially more than me!!
It is also unlikely she will leave the job anytime soon and there are no other obvious progression paths at this company so basically I will have to leave if I want to progress.
I guess AIBU to be upset and think it is really unfair that someone who is so much less experienced/qualified has gotten the job over me?? Should I complain to someone??

OP posts:
TripleDaisySummer · 19/11/2023 12:32

Complaining will achieve nothing, whether the appointment is fair or unfair. People always find a justification for recruiting the person they want to recruit.

This - they may have good reasons ie she ridiculously talented or not and I don't think anyone where can say which is the case.

I would ask for feedback - one of DH college did they came back with she needed more experience - she had years of experience including 6 months informally doing the role the man they gave it to had none. She took it as a sign she'd never progress and started job hunting - then left - the management was shocked she do that.

Then they did it again 18 months later - one college had built up with own time and effort over years a significant asset handed over to someone who expected to take credit and do no work - college had 100% of time on other tasks but handed everything over but that wasn't good enough. College left as did many others over time felt management were not valuing them or seeing what they were doing.

So my advice keep your own counsel and have a look round for other jobs and leave when it suit you if you do see something else.

MasterBeth · 19/11/2023 11:55

Treesinmygarden · 19/11/2023 05:12

That is also a horrible and unnecessary comment!

It's not horrible or unnecessary to explore the possibiltiy that this is the case. @gwenneh hasn't said that it is, and how would she know? But it's perfectly reasonable to ask if it's true.

MasterBeth · 19/11/2023 11:45

Aintnosupermum · 19/11/2023 03:07

I don’t apply for internal roles unless explicitly invited to do so. They are always posted as a formality.

For those saying the length of experience is irrelevant, I strongly disagree. I’m a qualified accountant. Lots of people have an MBA and assume they are just as capable at managing a balance sheet as someone like myself. No they are not. I have 20 years of experience starting in audit, in small, medium and global companies both held privately and public. I’ve taken clients through going public, M&A activity and bankruptcy. I’m fed up of MBAs coming in and thinking they are better than a CPA at these things. No, it’s specialist work and no MBA prepares you for the role. Quite frankly, don’t insult the OP by trying to say someone with less than 5 years of experience and no specific education in the field is in any way qualified for this role compared to someone who has an education and experience in the role.

This candidate is the office darling. You say nothing and you start to look for another role elsewhere. They just told you they don’t value you, so go somewhere that does.

You don't know what he role the OP is talking about it, so you don't know how relevant your accountacy experience is when talking about this creative role.

The favoured candidate's personal qualities - including intangible and undefinable qualities like confidence, eloquence, charisma, resilience, attitude, gravitas and likeability - may be what the management has identified as being worth promoting, as well as her obvious creative abilities.

NoGNoDNoClue · 19/11/2023 11:32

NoGNoDNoClue · 19/11/2023 11:21

No, the younger colleague is'one of the providers', so has been there since 2019.

She got a promotion in 2022.

Originals, not providers...

VintageTuppence · 19/11/2023 11:30

Very disappointing for you. All you can really do though is have a cry and a rant (in private) then lift your chin and get on with life.

If it helps, I once lost a job to someone ‘with the same amount of experience’. That was ok until I found out who it was and he wasn’t even born when I started in the same career!
Fingers crossed something better will come up for you.

Lemons1571 · 19/11/2023 11:24

Imagwine · 19/11/2023 08:10

They are frightened she’ll leave so they need a carrot for her. After your length of time there, they don’t think you will. Prove them otherwise.

I did this. They didn’t think I’d leave, as I’m older and had been there ages. I was totally stale in the role they pigeonholed me into, and I recognised it too. But it was a niche role that I could do and it was virtually impossible to recruit into.

I resigned and left for a better job. I subsequently had three directors grill me on why i was going, plus contact for help after l’d left. One of the directors actually said “how could we have been so stupid”.

Sadly I was unavailable for unpaid post employment help! I know from a colleague still there that they are struggling. Touch shit. Onwards and upwards OP.

NoGNoDNoClue · 19/11/2023 11:21

LadyWithLapdog · 19/11/2023 06:00

The OP has only been there since 2021. The younger colleague since 2022. Why are people making out that she’s a dinosaur? She has 10 years experience and formal qualifications. It’s frustrating, we can at least acknowledge that.

No, the younger colleague is'one of the providers', so has been there since 2019.

She got a promotion in 2022.

prawncocktailqueen · 19/11/2023 11:20

Lelliekelliee · 19/11/2023 08:02

I would speak to HR about this to be honest. I often employ people internally in our company. Recently we had 2 applicants- 1 very dynamic, a bit younger so slightly less experienced. The other we have worked with before and she has experience but is very negative and difficult to work with, she puts in complaints if she feels someone has given her a dirty look etc. We had to hire the latter because she was more experienced. You have to give a really good reason to hire someone with less experience.

Did you not base it on interview scoring? Or do you not interview internal applicants? Experience doesn't necessarily make someone better qualified to do a job.

What on earth is the OP going to say to HR? Give me the job I've been here longer? Then you're turning her into the second candidate in your post, a forced hire, and I'm sure OP doesn't want that either!

viques · 19/11/2023 10:20

I think looking at it from your employers perspective there is perhaps another version of the story.

A new company , wanting to make a go in a competitive industry, appoints someone (OP) who has much experience and excellent contacts in the industry. They see her as a safe pair of hands whose knowledge will help to guide the company through its early inception ,will be there when they need to push on and expand and hopefully will also have their own ideas to contribute to the future of the company. A bit later they appoint a young person(YP) to work under (OP) who has no experience or relevant qualification but who really impressed at interview with their enthusiasm and willingness to learn.

For the next two years OP and YP work together. OP brings experience to the role, but doesn’t really seem to be moving things on, or have many ideas apart from those she came with. She does the work well, but is that enough for an ambitious company?

YP on the other hand learns quickly - partially thanks to OPs good example - also does her work well, but also brings lots of sparky ideas to the table. Given the chance to follow through on her own project which she conceived and successfully pitched for, she absolutely smashes it, winning recognition not only within the company but industry wide.

The company realise they have a potential star in their ranks, so they make sure they keep her by creating a new, groundbreaking role for her and tying her into a generous salary scheme. They advertise it internally as they have to and the rest is history.

DahliaJ · 19/11/2023 10:17

Maybe they have created a job - this employee sounds pretty successful achieving recognition for one of her projects. The company will want to keep her, promotion is a way of doing this.

Thedm · 19/11/2023 10:10

Sounds like you’ve spent 10 years moving sideways, not up. So you haven’t progressed in other companies either. Sometimes it’s good to sit down and take stock or where your strengths are and look for a more advanced role with uses those strengths instead of going for roles like this which seem to do a bit of everything.

PriOn1 · 19/11/2023 10:06

I haven’t read the whole thread so I don’t know if anyone else has said this, but there is an incredible fetishisation of youth in more recent years that tends to value youth and enthusiasm over experience and it can be highly frustrating for those who fall foul of it as, once you reach a certain age, that company will pass you over, even if you are perfectly competent.

Difficult to say if that played a role here, but it might have done. My dad fell foul of it as he was entering the last ten years of his career in teaching. As he’d worked his way up, experience was valued and young people rarely got the top jobs. Positions as head teacher were often given to those of his age, who’d worked their way up. Then there was a sudden change and youth and energy were deemed more valuable. It became rare for anyone over forty to be promoted to the top positions. Nowadays, it stretches even younger.

She may have the talent to carry the job, but you might have been equally competent. You’ll likely never know, but there’s no point in complaining. I think, in your position, unless you love your current job and can rediscover your satisfaction, I would start looking elsewhere. If you leave, there might be a leaving interview where you can express your frustration over the way they lied to you when they knew perfectly well you hadn’t been successful, but unless the younger woman is making a hash of the job, any criticism of her promotion will merely look like sour grapes.

Pinkfluff76 · 19/11/2023 10:03

Really sorry OP that really sucks and sounds extremely unfair. I’d really struggle with the situation. Life can be so unfair. Good luck

GarlicMaybeNot · 19/11/2023 09:49

Gettingbysomehow · 19/11/2023 09:46

I do wonder sometimes how employers work these things out. We've had a succession of ghastly morons chosen to be managers who either self combust with stress leave, are cometely toxic and cause others to leave or just never manage to do the job. I haven't gone for any of those jobs because I'm near retirement and don't need the extra stress.

Replace 'managers' with 'ministers' and you've aptly described our government! You're not a backbench Tory, by any chance??

Branflakesbreakfast · 19/11/2023 09:48

That sounds really annoying OP, I'd be upset in your shoes too.

Gettingbysomehow · 19/11/2023 09:46

I do wonder sometimes how employers work these things out. We've had a succession of ghastly morons chosen to be managers who either self combust with stress leave, are cometely toxic and cause others to leave or just never manage to do the job. I haven't gone for any of those jobs because I'm near retirement and don't need the extra stress.

buffyajp · 19/11/2023 09:45

Teateaandmoretea · 19/11/2023 07:29

Eh?

You have evidence she’s wrong right?

You might think it’s acceptable to talk about another woman in those terms but some of us don’t. By all means be disappointed in the recruitment team and process but sneering at a woman because she happens to be young and pretty is most certainly misogynistic. Funny how you talk about evidence when the op quoted has provided none herself to prove the job was given on age and looks.

shoeawsome · 19/11/2023 09:42

bluetongue · 19/11/2023 02:30

Same happened at my workplace. Young, pretty woman who could turn on the charm in an interview. I wasn’t surprised I didn’t get the job as I crashed and burned in my interview but five other experienced staff members also applied and it was generally seen as a dodgy decision by most people, not just those who applied and missed out. We have lost many of those applicants to other departments since the decision.

It’s taken me 18 months but I’ve finally managed to get a promotion to the same level, partly helped by a new manager who has recognised how hard I’ve worked over the years.

Same but I haven't managed to get out yet plus although the person who the job being excellent at interview she is actually really crap at the job!

PosteriorPosterity · 19/11/2023 09:33

Aintnosupermum · 19/11/2023 03:07

I don’t apply for internal roles unless explicitly invited to do so. They are always posted as a formality.

For those saying the length of experience is irrelevant, I strongly disagree. I’m a qualified accountant. Lots of people have an MBA and assume they are just as capable at managing a balance sheet as someone like myself. No they are not. I have 20 years of experience starting in audit, in small, medium and global companies both held privately and public. I’ve taken clients through going public, M&A activity and bankruptcy. I’m fed up of MBAs coming in and thinking they are better than a CPA at these things. No, it’s specialist work and no MBA prepares you for the role. Quite frankly, don’t insult the OP by trying to say someone with less than 5 years of experience and no specific education in the field is in any way qualified for this role compared to someone who has an education and experience in the role.

This candidate is the office darling. You say nothing and you start to look for another role elsewhere. They just told you they don’t value you, so go somewhere that does.

I assume you’re American, but I’m also an accountant (Big 4), ten years post graduating and a Director leading a team of people with average service of 15+ years, some doing it longer than than I’ve been alive.

It doesn’t mean they’re better than me at what I do. In a lot of cases, far from it. I bring in more revenue, have better client service scores and am a technical expert on more areas than they are. They might have seen more, but I’m more capable
of drawing on my network and other people’s experiences and learning from others than they are.

And I have no family connections to the industry, from a working class background and work at a large firm with fair progression processes.

Time served does not mean better.

TheLonelyStarbucksLovers · 19/11/2023 09:32

Doing the job for 1 year vs 10 surely makes a difference???

What I’ve realised after twenty years of work is that some people are naturally suited to progress quickly in a workplace. The kind of person who tends towards seeing the strategic side of things, rather then the practical day to day. The kind who just naturally seems to get ‘corporate speak’ so sounds intelligent in meetings. Often they’re people-persons who can hack days of non stop meetings.

I’m the opposite of this. I’m much more suited to the day to day doing of the work, not the overseeing and management of the work. Which is why in my forties I’m now managed by 30-somethings!

Rewis · 19/11/2023 09:30

Ask for feedback and about your options at the company. Don't make it about the person who actually got the promotion.

It is possible she was the best person for the job or it could be that she wiggled her way in. We've recently expanded and after manager had hired her favourites then the rest were given to the best candidates.

WhichIsItWendy · 19/11/2023 09:30

Often it's simply a case of "the face fits". Not always physically but there's a LOT to be said for relationships and people getting advancements based on contacts and relationships rather than expertise and knowledge.

Life isn't fair. I have a degree, over 10 years experience and earning £40k and that was a fairly recent promotion. I wish I was on £80k but I'm not.

We ALL wish we were on £80k getting every promotion possible. I think you'll feel better when you stop comparing.

GarlicMaybeNot · 19/11/2023 09:28

Attempting a detached summary here:

OP was the winning candidate's boss in 2021, the same year OP joined this company. So the 25-year-old has been at this outfit at least as long as OP, and possibly since they launched in 2019.

The winning candidate hasn't got a degree, so has probably gained 7 years' work experience, not significantly different from OP's 10 years.

She delivered a very successful project with an innovative approach: she's creative, courageous, "a breath of fresh air", and profitable. She's also popular, energetic, and has good networking skills.

It isn't hard to see why they hired her.

@Ronalling, I'm afraid your own account of yourself boils down to knowing how things are done. You said the contested position relates to a new branch of the business; doesn't it make sense that Ms Creatively Courageous And Well Liked would be a promising leader where new ideas and the ability to attract new revenue streams are at a premium?

YANBU to be bitterly disappointed. As it goes, though, you'd be best advised to dial down the 'bitter' side of that, and apply yourself to a review of both your performance and your aspirations. If that role is what you truly want next, should you be maximising your creative opportunities, coming up with smart ideas at every turn, and shining up your industry profile?

If, on the other hand, you'd prefer a more predictable and hierarchical scene where 'seniority' counts in years, then look at moving to a more established and less hungry setup. (It's still worth polishing your network, though; it always is.)

Devaluing a colleague for being different from you does you no favours, not even to yourself. Better luck next time!

PortalooSunset · 19/11/2023 09:26

Complain? No. That just looks like you're sulking and bitter (which you are, but it's not a good look professionally!). Definitely ask for feedback on your application/interview and what could have been done differently though.

I've worked for an organisation where a new role was created. They knew who they were going to give it to before the advert went out, never mind at interview stage. I suspect that may be the case here.

AnonyLonnymouse · 19/11/2023 09:25

As above, it is something of a numbers game. If you wait for internal promotion you are effectively only applying to one employer.

Update your CV and Linkedin profile.
Get in touch with any contacts you have elsewhere and let them know that you’re open to new opportunities.
Enquire about the management course - could you self-fund?
Are there employment agencies or head-hunters in your field?

Any way, take this as a sign to become proactive in addressing your career progression.