Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL has told me I can't give my baby a certain name because I "didn't try" for my baby and she has been trying for years

214 replies

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 21:22

So me and SIL are both pregnant. She is due around a month after me. I have two daughters already and she has a 4 year old son.

She has been trying for a baby since her son was about a year old, she's had two miscarriages (I had a miscarriage between my two daughters so I understand how painful it can be and I've always been very supportive with her)

When I fell pregnant this time we hadn't been trying and it was a bit of an "accident" for want of a better word. We found out at a similar time but it turns out I'm further along than I thought, she became instantly frosty towards me and outright told me I'd "stolen her limelight" because I'd got pregnant just before her. I tried to just ignore this and put it down to her still being upset about the previous miscarriages etc.

However, we were discussing names recently and I said I was thinking of calling my baby a name and she straight away said "no you can't do that because I'm calling mine X" she then followed up by saying I should let her have first choice because she tried so hard for her baby and I didn't try at all. For context the names are very similar , think Georgie and Georgia (not the actual names)

AIBU to be really annoyed about what she's insinuating here, almost like my baby isn't wanted so I should give up the name I love?

OP posts:
bananabug · 18/11/2023 22:36

My SIL and I had babies 1 month apart (mine first) and the name they chose was very close to the one we chose. It annoyed me slightly at the time, especially as my mum kept getting them mixed up all the time, but it isn't an issue at all now as they have their own distinct personalities. I think pregnancy hormones can make people a bit unreasonable (your SIL), and she will probably look back on this in embarrassment after the babies are born. Go ahead and name your baby exactly what you want to!

snackatack · 18/11/2023 22:35

My OH gave my top baby name to his sister when I was pregnant = in a don't use this - and she used a very similar name. I was kicked him for telling her - and to be honest it was no surprise she took the name - she is a very selfish person . It did tarnish the relationships (she was not even brave enough to tell OH, we found out through a friend).

In the end the baby did not fit the name,, and a different one on the list fitted far better. However, suck it, had the name of been right they would have ended up similar.

If you like a name - don't tell anyone until the child is named - then they can't say anything anyway.

FMW · 18/11/2023 22:35

It’s a bit surprising that no one can empathise with the SIL. It is very difficult not to get pregnant/have losses and see your friends and family ‘use up’ all the names you’d wanted to use for your baby (if it’s ever eventually born). No one is entitled to a name, but I do wonder whether she actually feels desperate rather than thinking her baby is more important. In the five years it took to have children, all the names I’d wanted to pick were used by other people and so we couldn’t pick them and had to choose something different. So it wasn’t only getting pregnant that didn’t go to plan, it was also names that didn’t. It seemed even more unfair somehow.

SiousieSoo · 18/11/2023 22:19

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:12

He's ready to go in all guns blazing and tell her where to go. I'd really rather he doesn't do this as I'd love for our kids to have a good relationship growing up, we don't have a lot of family close by and I feel like it would be a real shame for this relationship to be ruined. But then I am reluctant to just roll over and give up the name we love. Completely in two minds

Is it really necessary to go in 'all guns blazing'? Sounds a bit overbearing and confrontational to me. You just say that you have thought about it and will be keeping the name you originally chose and which was discussed during your conversation.

thelongwayhome · 18/11/2023 22:18

She will get over it. People do get possessive over baby names, I'm guilty of it too but never to the point of saying anything. One of my close friends has started saying she's going to name her child my (7 year old) daughter's name and if I'm honest, I don't like it (she's told DD this, who turned to me and said "but that's my name, mum", so she's not keen either). But of course, my child isn't the only person in the world with that name, it is what it is, so I am just smiling and nodding at her about it. Your SIL will survive, it's not even the same name. Maybe go OTT about how adorable it will be that the cousins will have similar names.

Shakesapear · 18/11/2023 22:16

She is obviously being a dick but I think if I was in your situation id choose another name as id feel that name was now tainted by her.

Inthebleakmidwinter2 · 18/11/2023 22:15

I'm guessing she means that even though your baby is coming first, she's been planning for a baby for longer and thinking of names for longer. Rather than your child being less loved in any way.

I'd tell her that the name belongs to your baby already because you've chosen it early on in the pregnancy, and you didn't realise that she had a similar name in mind but it really feels like your baby's name now. And say that you'd have no problem with two cousins Georgia and Georgie, leaving the choice up to her.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 18/11/2023 22:15

The girls will probably like it. Annie and Anna? Olive and Olivia? It'll be fun for them.

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:14

Edf · 18/11/2023 22:12

Don’t have an answer on names either way but just to offer a bit of food for thought- I got pregnant with dd after years of issues- sil 10 weeks later- first try, luckily we had no name clashes but coming out of years of infertility it defo messes with you and does a lot of mh damage that isn’t that easy to identify from the outside, I would maybe just consider her name issue may be more than just that- maybe she’s still suffering a bit that her life didn’t pan out exactly as expected, maybe a bit resentful of you getting pregnant without trying (nothing against you- just the notion that you could do what she couldn’t) and is just manifesting in a way that she’s coming across unreasonable whilst she is most likely just a little jealous that you did what she always wanted to. I don’t think you are being unreasonable at all- but I think she might just be expressing her years of anxiety and pain through this one area she thinks she can control - but- saying that- it is not your fault and you name your child whatever you want 😊

Yeah I do understand this which is one of the reasons why I didn't start an argument with her when she said it and one of the reasons why I'm unsure how reasonable/unreasonable I am to feel this way.

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 18/11/2023 22:14

Why would you change it? She's only just told you her name the children won't see that much of each other especially when older. She can change the name if she wants but she shouldn't be bullying you

Weenurse · 18/11/2023 22:14

Many people in the same family have the same name and families just work out a way of identifying everyone.
Think James Smith senior who goes by Jim and James Smith junior who goes by James or JJ ( James junior).
Use the name you like

Traceyislivid · 18/11/2023 22:12

YABU even discussing this with her.

MissingMoominMamma · 18/11/2023 22:12

Is she your husband’s sister? If so, he needs to tell her it’s his choice too.

I do feel a bit sorry for her though. She probably has raging hormones and can’t help how she feels , even if it is hugely unreasonable!

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:12

xyz111 · 18/11/2023 22:09

Is this your DH's sister? What does he say?

He's ready to go in all guns blazing and tell her where to go. I'd really rather he doesn't do this as I'd love for our kids to have a good relationship growing up, we don't have a lot of family close by and I feel like it would be a real shame for this relationship to be ruined. But then I am reluctant to just roll over and give up the name we love. Completely in two minds

OP posts:
Edf · 18/11/2023 22:12

Don’t have an answer on names either way but just to offer a bit of food for thought- I got pregnant with dd after years of issues- sil 10 weeks later- first try, luckily we had no name clashes but coming out of years of infertility it defo messes with you and does a lot of mh damage that isn’t that easy to identify from the outside, I would maybe just consider her name issue may be more than just that- maybe she’s still suffering a bit that her life didn’t pan out exactly as expected, maybe a bit resentful of you getting pregnant without trying (nothing against you- just the notion that you could do what she couldn’t) and is just manifesting in a way that she’s coming across unreasonable whilst she is most likely just a little jealous that you did what she always wanted to. I don’t think you are being unreasonable at all- but I think she might just be expressing her years of anxiety and pain through this one area she thinks she can control - but- saying that- it is not your fault and you name your child whatever you want 😊

olivialennox · 18/11/2023 22:11

You were pregnant first so technically she stole YOUR limelight 😜

In all seriousness just don’t discuss names ever, until baby is born and you announce it.

RachelFuchsalot · 18/11/2023 22:10

Just use the name you like. Don't overthink it.

ghostestwiththemostest · 18/11/2023 22:10

It's tough, particularly if she'd had that name in mind for the years that she was trying and was longing to use it. And then it does seem unfair if suddenly you use it when you haven't been trying or wanting to use that name for as long. It's really tough. I kind of think that you should both use it if it's very similar but not identical. How would you feel if she told you that she was going to use it anyway? Would it bother you if they were called the same?

xyz111 · 18/11/2023 22:09

Is this your DH's sister? What does he say?

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:06

HeavenCANTwait · 18/11/2023 21:59

Well Georgie and Georgia are not the same name

Neither is Ellie and Ella - totally different

So use what you want

Yes this is the sort of similarity, not the same name but very very similar

OP posts:
romdowa · 18/11/2023 22:05

If your baby is born first then use the name you want. That's just the luck of the draw really

Butchyrestingface · 18/11/2023 22:04

She sounds like a big baby herself. Stop discussing your baby with her. She is not on her your side at the moment. Hopefully only a temporary hormonal blip.

Iwasafool · 18/11/2023 22:03

HerMammy · 18/11/2023 21:49

I know two sisters who have sons with identical names, about two years apart and yes the sisters are close, bit odd.

My aunts were the same but my cousins are closer in age. They both liked the name, it was a family name with a big emotional tie so they both used it. My one cousin used the full name the other a shortened version so like one is James and one is Jim. No one in the family ever mentioned it being odd.

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:03

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 18/11/2023 21:50

I agree. It's not pregnancy loss top trumps. I've had miscarriages, my children aren't more special than the child of someone who has "only" had one (or the child of someone who has never miscarried), nor was I more deserving of my own way during pregnancy.

Use the name, she being absolutely ridiculous.

This is what I think, my baby will be no less loved than hers. What she's said has really quite upset me. I just have no idea what to do now.

OP posts:
trainboundfornowhere · 18/11/2023 22:01

I know two sisters with the same first name as each was named after a different grandmother but 1 is known as Chrissie and 1 as Tina. Use the name you love.