Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL has told me I can't give my baby a certain name because I "didn't try" for my baby and she has been trying for years

214 replies

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 21:22

So me and SIL are both pregnant. She is due around a month after me. I have two daughters already and she has a 4 year old son.

She has been trying for a baby since her son was about a year old, she's had two miscarriages (I had a miscarriage between my two daughters so I understand how painful it can be and I've always been very supportive with her)

When I fell pregnant this time we hadn't been trying and it was a bit of an "accident" for want of a better word. We found out at a similar time but it turns out I'm further along than I thought, she became instantly frosty towards me and outright told me I'd "stolen her limelight" because I'd got pregnant just before her. I tried to just ignore this and put it down to her still being upset about the previous miscarriages etc.

However, we were discussing names recently and I said I was thinking of calling my baby a name and she straight away said "no you can't do that because I'm calling mine X" she then followed up by saying I should let her have first choice because she tried so hard for her baby and I didn't try at all. For context the names are very similar , think Georgie and Georgia (not the actual names)

AIBU to be really annoyed about what she's insinuating here, almost like my baby isn't wanted so I should give up the name I love?

OP posts:
Wibblywobblylikejelly · 18/11/2023 23:54

It doesn't matter if she's sad, struggling or having u reasonable feelings.

Toddlers have all of that and we don't give into their every tantrum.

She can be told No Nicely. But that doesn't change the outcome.

As she isn't a toddler but a full grown woman she should the use the tools she should've gained through life to manage and conduct herself in an appropriate manner and suck it up.

Any failure to do that is a failure on her. And any loss of relationship due to this is also a failure on her.

Sometimeswinning · 18/11/2023 23:52

DragonFly98 · 18/11/2023 23:46

You already have two daughters so it's clearly not your favourite name or even your second favourite, for her it is.

It’s just as difficult to find a name you love as much as the first name/s. I’d go as far to say no person gets a say in the name of the child you carry and give birth to. Why anyone is so entitled to think they are is laughable.

RedToothBrush · 18/11/2023 23:52

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:03

This is what I think, my baby will be no less loved than hers. What she's said has really quite upset me. I just have no idea what to do now.

Do whats right for you.

She's the type of person who will always have something she doesn't like and you can't please.

Don't be a people pleaser. She will get over it. If she doesn't she just proves what an immature madam she is.

Allofaflutter · 18/11/2023 23:50

The only time someone can call dibs on a name is when the child has died. That would be the only circumstance that would be appropriate not to use the name. Thankfully that’s not the case so take no notice.

Sometimeswinning · 18/11/2023 23:47

SeriousFaffing · 18/11/2023 23:01

‘Never discuss baby names’

@wokbun Agree wholeheartedly.

Why? Incase someone is offended?

I loved talking names with my friends. It shouldn’t be a case of upsetting someone. I would never have chosen my oldest daughter’s name without a chat with my pregnant friend.

Just ensure your baby is due first!

DragonFly98 · 18/11/2023 23:46

You already have two daughters so it's clearly not your favourite name or even your second favourite, for her it is.

Amybelle88 · 18/11/2023 23:39

If it's not the same name what's her problem, tell her to sod off.

moderationincludingmoderation · 18/11/2023 23:38

@CJsGoldfish So well put.

One of my close friends got pregnant after we'd been trying for 3 years. Named her DD the name we'd had in mind. It was like a double kick in the guts. It's not jealousy. It's just like every pregnancy announcement, especially accidental ones, accentuate your own sadness.

AhNowTed · 18/11/2023 23:37

Do NOT pander to this nonsense.

What's next.. you can't have a 1st birthday cos it's "stealing" her baby's limelight.

And every other milestone...

You would be bonkers to give an inch here. Giving her the name actually demotes your baby in her crazy immature ridiculous mind.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 18/11/2023 23:37

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 18/11/2023 21:27

Do not entertain her utter nonsense..

This. I can't believe people even give this sort of nonsense a second thought. Call your baby whatever you want to and if you choose to go with the name your SIL wants, tough luck. She sounds like a entitled princess and those who pander to people like her are making rods for their own backs.

gnarlynarwhal · 18/11/2023 23:36

Your sil is being totally unreasonable and I say that as someone who had two miscarriages, tried for years for dc and eventually had to have ivf treatment to have my children. Don’t not choose the name to keep the piece with someone who is being so u reasonable- why should you? A) she might never end up having a baby and b) if she does she might change her mind and not want to use the name anyway.

RudsyFarmer · 18/11/2023 23:30

If you avoid a name only for her to not use the one she’d planned you would be so pissed off. I think refuse to discuss it again. Pick the name you want to on the birth certificate and you could always pick a nickname that’s slightly different to hers. Think Amelia on birth certificate Millie for everyday.

CJsGoldfish · 18/11/2023 23:30

I never understand why names are discussed like this. It's like no one's ever read MN before 🙄

There is a lot of nastiness towards the SIL here and I can see why. Seems pretty unreasonable of her. All I can say is that trying for SO long to have a baby can be soul destroying and changes you in ways you don't even understand yourself. Especially with miscarriages thrown in the mix.
It's not a case of her M/C trumps your M/C, but that that whole journey really can be a mind fuck.

Because I understand that, I'd choose another name. With no fuss, no conflict whether I liked her or not. I wouldn't try and point score with it, I'd let it go 🤷‍♀️

AboutYouTalk · 18/11/2023 23:29

She sounds deranged. Your baby, your name choice. Tell her straight.

TeaGinandFags · 18/11/2023 23:28

SeriousFaffing · 18/11/2023 23:01

‘Never discuss baby names’

@wokbun Agree wholeheartedly.

Agree completely!

However, when I was pregnant the world and her dog spent serious time and effort trying to winkle my name out of me.

OP, you're learning the hard way that a mother's place is in the wrong. Since you're damned if you do and damned if you don't, you might as well do what you want.

The sooner you learn this, the happier you'll be.

Sometimeswinning · 18/11/2023 23:21

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:14

Yeah I do understand this which is one of the reasons why I didn't start an argument with her when she said it and one of the reasons why I'm unsure how reasonable/unreasonable I am to feel this way.

You’ve got an issue with letting others be unkind to you because you are nice. I’ve known people who have had issues with pregnancy and fertility. None have them have been unkind to my face with the fact I’ve been very lucky. No excuses for her, get a back bone (I mean this in the best way possible) be offended by what she said and wait for her to apologise. Or at least never mention it again.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 18/11/2023 23:19

My daughter has a similar name to my niece and it’s never been an issue… actually I didn't noticed how similar they were which is so strange 😂 my brother had his daughter 1st and name I picked .. well my ex picked - I wasn’t even keen on but he wanted it so much.

Anyway it’s never been an issue and my brother was a bit annoyed at 1st saying they would be called the same nickname, which they never ever was either of them,

All worked out in the end.

MadameameBeans · 18/11/2023 23:17

" I'd "stolen her limelight" because I'd got pregnant just before her."

Not sure how that is your fault, it's not like you hopped in a time machine when you heard she was pregnant so you could get there first.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 18/11/2023 23:16

Nope if you have a name in mind no-one else gets to decide or dictate if you can use it. She can bugger off. If someone said that to me I would absolutely use the name!

saythatagaintome · 18/11/2023 23:16

Riverlee · 18/11/2023 21:27

Does the name have any special significance to her? Ie. Her Grandmother's name? If so, then that’s a valid reason not to use it.

However, there’s no top trumos about which baby is more important.

The names are NOT the same. Op mentioned a name she loved. SIL says she can’t use it.

Op can name her child whatever the heck she so pleases. Can’t believe you people making excuses.

unicornflakegirl · 18/11/2023 23:16

Yes you were foolish to discuss names but it’s done now. If the name is the one you want then use it. If SIL really wants the similar name she can still use it, there is no reason why cousins can’t have similar names. On both sides of my family there are cousins with the same first name (on one side they also share the same surname, people just refer to the parent’s name if context doesn’t make it clear which one).

If this is out of character I would let it go, it sounds like she has been through a lot and still raw. People probably have feelings like her, they probably just don’t say them out loud. As in her feelings are logical to her, this pregnancy for her was long-awaited and yours was ‘effortless’, I can see why she feels as she does. But most people wouldn’t say that, especially not to the subject of their envy.

Good luck with the rest of your pregnancy and don’t stress about this. It has just worked out in our family a few little sets of cousins around the same age and it’s really nice to see.

As an aside in the country I live in now people announce the name well before the birth, it blows my mind as in my family there is usually a shortlist but no name actually chosen until the baby is born and see what suits it.

PickAChew · 18/11/2023 23:15

I told everyone that Ds2 was going to be called Ogbert. No one claimed it as their own 😅

moderationincludingmoderation · 18/11/2023 23:13

zurala · 18/11/2023 21:28

Unless that's the only name you want I would choose a different one. It's very different having one miscarriage to having more than one and struggling to get pregnant (she's obviously struggled when you look at the age gap). She will mentally be in a very difficult place and full of anxiety, just let her have the name she wants.

THIS. As someone who had struggled with secondary infertility and had best friends accidentally get pregnant whilst I struggled.. I can understand where your SIL is coming from.
It's hard to explain because it kind of is irrational and unreasonable, but it's just a feeling you can't shake.

saythatagaintome · 18/11/2023 23:12

😂 lol!

SIL is batshit. And so is anyone else justifying her batshit reasoning. Newsflash: You can name your child WHATEVER you please!

Fedupofballs · 18/11/2023 23:10

My sister and cousin are close in age and have very similar names (only ending letters different). It’s always accentuated the bond between them, rather than cause issues. They are now in their thirties.