Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL has told me I can't give my baby a certain name because I "didn't try" for my baby and she has been trying for years

214 replies

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 21:22

So me and SIL are both pregnant. She is due around a month after me. I have two daughters already and she has a 4 year old son.

She has been trying for a baby since her son was about a year old, she's had two miscarriages (I had a miscarriage between my two daughters so I understand how painful it can be and I've always been very supportive with her)

When I fell pregnant this time we hadn't been trying and it was a bit of an "accident" for want of a better word. We found out at a similar time but it turns out I'm further along than I thought, she became instantly frosty towards me and outright told me I'd "stolen her limelight" because I'd got pregnant just before her. I tried to just ignore this and put it down to her still being upset about the previous miscarriages etc.

However, we were discussing names recently and I said I was thinking of calling my baby a name and she straight away said "no you can't do that because I'm calling mine X" she then followed up by saying I should let her have first choice because she tried so hard for her baby and I didn't try at all. For context the names are very similar , think Georgie and Georgia (not the actual names)

AIBU to be really annoyed about what she's insinuating here, almost like my baby isn't wanted so I should give up the name I love?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 19/11/2023 02:48

She's being ridiculous. Whoever has their baby first gets first pick of names. That's just how it is. I'd laugh at her. 🤣🤣🤣

KingofIthaca · 19/11/2023 02:32

Have whatever name you like OP
People shouldn’t be dictated what you call your child. You and your child will be living with this choice for ever.
I note you have not told your SIL she can’t chose the name she has chosen, why, because you don’t sound unreasonable.

Don’t worry about it. For what it’s worth many families have cousins with the same name, it’s really not unusual.

Delphinium20 · 19/11/2023 02:05

I really think that the two girl cousins will love the similar shared names and will have a lot of fun at some point playing games w/ their similarities (like tricking others!), but only if the parents act like adults about it. Clearly, your SIL is struggling to be the adult here. I'm not sure if she wants to be mature, though. Of course infertility and miscarriages are awful and can mess w/ your head, but taking action and trying to control others like she has isn't a healthy way of dealing w/ loss. It will only reinforce her poor mental health. Someone needs to gently tell her that she IBU. Probably not your DH or you.

Go ahead and name your daughter the name you chose, but don't engage with her about it. Frankly, it's not healthy for her to be affirmed in her unreasonable demands. Your soon-to-be DD's name belongs to DD as much as your SIL's chosen name will belong to her DD. Good luck!

Asiatoyork · 19/11/2023 02:04

My OH gave my top baby name to his sister when I was pregnant = in a don't use this - and she used a very similar name

But what if they were already planning on using it? It’s just what it is when someone else is due first.

CatMandarin · 19/11/2023 01:59

I had 3 mcs before my dds but I still think saying "no you can't" at a name someone says they picked is silly

Planesmistakenforstars · 19/11/2023 01:50

She might have had the name picked out for one of the children she lost and is using it now, so it could be incredibly emotive for her. You sound lovely OP for considering that she might be reacting out of hurt and taking that into account, rather than just going with "fuck off" as some people suggest. Although you wouldn't be unreasonable really to stick with the one you've chosen, in the circumstances I would try and choose another name.

2021x · 19/11/2023 01:43

pizzaHeart · 19/11/2023 01:18

This^
very wise approach. I wouldn’t share any plans about baby with her e.g name, layout of your nursery, potential godparents, choice of toys etc etc,
It’s nothing about your child being unloved and everything about your SIL being mentally unstable because of her difficulties.

I disagree with this approach. It is only designed to keep the peace not deal with the problem.

If you SIL is having experiencing mental distress about her miscarriages that is crossing over into dictating how other people behave in their lives then, that is her issue to sort out.

When you have a mental health disorder; empathy from others is important, but this approach is showing her as she is distressed it is permissable for her to have unreasonable expectations of others (and for her to say disrespectful things).

If you decide to change the babys name based purely on what she said, you will at some point feel resentment when everyone is saying what a lovely name her daughter has.

Her emotions are her problem to manage, not yours.

determinedtomakethiswork · 19/11/2023 01:29

Has she ever mentioned this name before?

Shalopea · 19/11/2023 01:28

She’s being unreasonable. Does it matter to you if the cousins have similar names? It wouldn’t bother me. Use the name you have decided on. It’s nothing to do with her and she doesn’t get to choose your child’s name.

The “stealing her limelight” comment is unreasonable as well. Does she have form for this kind of silliness?

2021x · 19/11/2023 01:26

Lots of people in families have the same name (The Royals?!!!), its crap that she is making your feel guilty. Name your child what you want, in the grand scheme of things... no-one will actually care.

SequinsandStiIettos · 19/11/2023 01:21

Do you definitely both know what you're having then?

pizzaHeart · 19/11/2023 01:18

zurala · 18/11/2023 21:28

Unless that's the only name you want I would choose a different one. It's very different having one miscarriage to having more than one and struggling to get pregnant (she's obviously struggled when you look at the age gap). She will mentally be in a very difficult place and full of anxiety, just let her have the name she wants.

This^
very wise approach. I wouldn’t share any plans about baby with her e.g name, layout of your nursery, potential godparents, choice of toys etc etc,
It’s nothing about your child being unloved and everything about your SIL being mentally unstable because of her difficulties.

Isittimeformynapyet · 19/11/2023 01:08

SiousieSoo · 18/11/2023 22:19

Is it really necessary to go in 'all guns blazing'? Sounds a bit overbearing and confrontational to me. You just say that you have thought about it and will be keeping the name you originally chose and which was discussed during your conversation.

OP clearly said she doesn't want DH to go in all guns blazing. It sounds like you're ticking her off.

Fionaville · 19/11/2023 01:08

I hate the whole 'My baby is more loved/special than yours because of previous suffering/waiting' game. It benefits nobody.
Personally, I'd keep the name you love. Any further communication on it, I'd say "We are waiting until the baby arrives to see what name they suit" then call them whatever you want!

Snugglemonkey · 19/11/2023 00:57

HeavenCANTwait · 18/11/2023 21:59

Well Georgie and Georgia are not the same name

Neither is Ellie and Ella - totally different

So use what you want

They are not totally different 🤣

Coulditreallybe · 19/11/2023 00:48

Are you both definitely having girls @Dramatic ?

im guessing Lily and Lila or something like that Grin

CheekyHobson · 19/11/2023 00:29

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 22:12

He's ready to go in all guns blazing and tell her where to go. I'd really rather he doesn't do this as I'd love for our kids to have a good relationship growing up, we don't have a lot of family close by and I feel like it would be a real shame for this relationship to be ruined. But then I am reluctant to just roll over and give up the name we love. Completely in two minds

It doesn't have to be either/or. There's a perfectly reasonable middle road where you politely tell your SIL that you've talked about it and you understand where she's coming from, but you've had this name in mind for some time and you're going to stick with it. If she wants to stick with her name too, you think it's quite possible the cousins will grow up loving the similarity.

If she wants to let that 'ruin the relationship', that's her choice; a ridiculous, sad and selfish outcome (and by no means necessary – she could grow up and take a positive view of the situation too) but not one that you should try to avoid by appeasing her over-entitled and frankly insulting demand.

The fact is that given you're dealing with someone who sees pregnancies in terms of 'limelight' and baby name priority as something to be 'earned' through tragedy. She's irrational, self-centred and unreasonable. You're likely to have years of drama with her in your future regardless of what you do about this name. So just do what you want to, but be dignified about it.

JANEY205 · 19/11/2023 00:11

DragonFly98 · 18/11/2023 23:46

You already have two daughters so it's clearly not your favourite name or even your second favourite, for her it is.

This is INSANE. The name picked out for my baby by my husband and I is the name WE have picked out as being our top choice for our next child. My other children’s names don’t mean my next child’s name isn’t as important or that I don’t like it as much. What a pathetic and childish view! This being OPs 3rd baby does NOT make this child any less loved or wanted.

I would not change the name we have picked out for my Feb baby if my SIL asked me to. If they are that bothered then they can can change their name choice cant they. Because trust me, if they liked a name enough they wouldn’t care what other people were calling their child!

My baby has had their name chosen since I was 12 weeks and I would NOT be having anyone telling me to change it now.

Annahh · 19/11/2023 00:07

You must use the name you want to.

I've seen so many stories like this where the woman in your position doesn't use the name they really want as it was 'someone else's' name then the someone else doesn't even use the name but had lots of control over what the first baby was named.

Then woman in your position is really angry and annoyed they chose a name they didn't really want or was second choice.

sprigatito · 19/11/2023 00:06

She needs to grow up. I wouldn't entertain this nonsense at all, I would tell her that choosing a baby name is private and you won't be discussing it with her.

Call your baby the name you love, don't feel guilty and practise your grey rock technique.

SwordToFlamethrower · 19/11/2023 00:06

We have two Charlie's in our family and no one cares because what we name our children is our business.

Name your child whatever you want to.

Jewelspun · 19/11/2023 00:03

Call your baby what you want.

JudgeJ · 19/11/2023 00:00

Inthebleakmidwinter2 · 18/11/2023 22:15

I'm guessing she means that even though your baby is coming first, she's been planning for a baby for longer and thinking of names for longer. Rather than your child being less loved in any way.

I'd tell her that the name belongs to your baby already because you've chosen it early on in the pregnancy, and you didn't realise that she had a similar name in mind but it really feels like your baby's name now. And say that you'd have no problem with two cousins Georgia and Georgie, leaving the choice up to her.

A name can't belong to a baby any more than you can let someone have a name, can't believe the nonsense some people live with.by

MaidOfSteel · 18/11/2023 23:59

No matter what she's been through, your sister in law is absolutely wrong to be so dismissive of you & your pregnancy. And she has no right to dictate to you either. She has been incredibly rude.

If this is the name you and your husband have been decided on for months, go ahead and use it.

Best wishes! X

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 18/11/2023 23:56

Use the name you each choose. The dc won't mind.