Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL has told me I can't give my baby a certain name because I "didn't try" for my baby and she has been trying for years

214 replies

Dramatic · 18/11/2023 21:22

So me and SIL are both pregnant. She is due around a month after me. I have two daughters already and she has a 4 year old son.

She has been trying for a baby since her son was about a year old, she's had two miscarriages (I had a miscarriage between my two daughters so I understand how painful it can be and I've always been very supportive with her)

When I fell pregnant this time we hadn't been trying and it was a bit of an "accident" for want of a better word. We found out at a similar time but it turns out I'm further along than I thought, she became instantly frosty towards me and outright told me I'd "stolen her limelight" because I'd got pregnant just before her. I tried to just ignore this and put it down to her still being upset about the previous miscarriages etc.

However, we were discussing names recently and I said I was thinking of calling my baby a name and she straight away said "no you can't do that because I'm calling mine X" she then followed up by saying I should let her have first choice because she tried so hard for her baby and I didn't try at all. For context the names are very similar , think Georgie and Georgia (not the actual names)

AIBU to be really annoyed about what she's insinuating here, almost like my baby isn't wanted so I should give up the name I love?

OP posts:
Redburnett · 19/11/2023 09:30

Jealousy or envy from women who have struggled to get pregnant, when you have become pregnant easily, is not uncommon. I was very surprised when I experienced it. I think, in the interests of family harmony, you might reconsider the name you were thinking of, to avoid years of resentment from SIL.

gannett · 19/11/2023 09:23

This is a batshit thing for your SIL to request.

The thing with people who make batshit requests is that placating them and giving into them is a mug's game. Because even if you call your child something else, the nature of batshit people is that there'll be another batshit thing they take offence at coming down the pipeline soon. And before you know it you're twisting yourself into a pretzel trying to keep them happy.

Call your child what you want. If she gets in a huff about it, it doesn't matter, because she will get in a huff with you at some point whatever you do. You will certainly be better off with a bit of distance from her anyway.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 19/11/2023 09:15

Absolutely agree with everything @billy1966 has put above especially Worst thing you could do is allow her to think you will tolerate her telling you what you can and cannot do. she is batshit.
And I can't believe all the posts telling you to acquiesce to her demands and 'think of her' especially when she's not thinking at all of the op and is being rather a bitch!
@nibblessquibbles If you've swooped in suddenly with a baby that is going to arrive before hers and with the same name, I can understand she may feel disappointed.
So you think that the op and her dh have purposely planned the conception by swooping in before the demanding sister's due date to steal the name?

electriclight · 19/11/2023 09:14

I daresay she has had this name in mind for the past three years, since she started ttc when her son was one, and through both miscarriages.

And now, so close to the finish line as it were, she hears that you might use the name first, when you can't possibly have planned to use it until you found out about your unexpected pregnancy about 7 months ago, and only get first dibs due to the fact that your 'happy accident' is due four weeks before hers.

I think she worded it badly and unkindly and everyone is right - she can't claim a name, and you can call your baby any name you want.

But it does sometimes help in family disagreements to see the other person's perspective a bit, and I think I can understand why she was shocked and insensitive.

If there were other names on my list, I'd use one of them.

If this was the only name I loved, I'd use it but would take the time to talk it through. If she's still annoyed after that, that's her problem to deal with imo.

Drfosters · 19/11/2023 09:07

She can’t tell you not to give a baby a certain name but if it had special significance to her i would definitely have changed my name but if that was not the case here then you don’t have to. But, just the same if you name your child you can’t expect that she won’t use the similar name And you might feel aggrieved they sound similar. Up to you how strongly you feel about it.

Hibiscrubbed · 19/11/2023 09:03

Asformending · 19/11/2023 03:27

I'd go with something different and just say you found one you both much preferred. I would have been put off straight away if anyone in the family was intending calling their baby by a similar name. All 5 of my children have unusual and therefore memorable names. Along the lines of Paloma, Fenella, Celandine, Primrose, Angelica, Octavia. If the name was ever in the top 100, I avoided it like the plague.

Poor little Celandine. 😬

billy1966 · 19/11/2023 08:56

She sounds batshit and there are always going to be issues with her.

Worst thing you could do is allow her to think you will tolerate her telling you what you can and cannot do.

Accept the children will not be close because she is batshit and everything else will be a bonus.

She will likely weaponise the children.

You were so foolish mentioning names with her when you know what she's like, but at least learn from it.

Use the name if you like but far more important IMO is that you really get how controlling and batshit she is, and give her a wide berth going forward.

Stylishnewmama · 19/11/2023 08:54

@MeMySonAnd1 Jesus! So what if they get the same name? Half of my cousins have my grandmother’s name and all the boys on the other side of the family have the same name or close variations of my grandfather’s name. I can assure you we never get confused about who is who.

Unless you only have 2 girl cousins with the same first name and only a couple of male relatives with the same first name, how is this not confusing?

OP, use the name you love. Your child will be born first anyway. Also, how are you stealing attention? Neither of you are pregnant with your first born.

Bearbookagainandagain · 19/11/2023 08:53

You are not unreasonable but if you don't care that much about the name you should try to change.
Or discuss it further with her with an open mind. It does look like she is projecting her years of anxiety and stress on the name, maybe she had picked it years ago etc. She is unreasonable and the names aren't the same, but if you do get along otherwise it would a shame to ruin your relationship over this.

TeeBee · 19/11/2023 08:49

Just don't discuss it with her further and call your baby whatever you want. She can call hers whatever she wants. It's all bonkers, just ignore and carry on.

Imagwine · 19/11/2023 08:41

I think if she’s had this name in her mind for all the years she’s been trying, I can sort of see how she feels if suddenly she can’t use it because you were lucky enough to get pregnant so quickly and get in first.

Thats not your fault and you are perfectly entitled to use it yourself, but I can understand where she is coming from if that’s the name she’s been dreaming of for years.

If you like your sil, I’d choose another name because I would feel sorry for her. Ditto if I wouldn’t want the cousins to have similar names. But yanbu to use the name if you want to.

clarepetal · 19/11/2023 08:41

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 18/11/2023 21:27

Do not entertain her utter nonsense..

This. The woman is behaving like a prick.

Anonymouslyposting · 19/11/2023 08:40

My sister called her baby boy the name my DH and I had always wanted for ours. It was the only name we loved, our DS now has a name we like but honestly I’m still a bit sad about it.

But that’s my problem, I didn’t own that name and your SIL doesn’t own any names. The first baby gets first pick of the names. It can be annoying for other people but it just is how it is.

TheNinny · 19/11/2023 08:33

I think she’s just being deliberately difficult. If you don’t use the name you want I would bet she then decides to not use it either but is not going to tell you. If you do use the name, she will still go in a huff. She probably would have done this with whatever name you said to make you feel guilty.

Don’t share details and i would step way back.

ElevenSeven · 19/11/2023 08:30

Still needs ignored, regardless

Theres no miscarriage top trumps either, to the person who said two is much worse, if that cancels OP’s experience out.

LAMPS1 · 19/11/2023 08:27

Now that you are at this impasse, I would encourage your DH to have a decent conversation with his sister where he really listens to her reasons and gets a chance to tell her what he thinks too (without losing his temper)
Or it may be better that all four parents can sensibly talk together about it given that both mums are upset about it. Maybe SIL hasn't even discussed it with her partner, maybe he isn’t even that fond of the name.

A conversation might reveal an easy solution which is satisfactory to you all.
Eg, If the two names are spelled and pronounced slightly differently anyway, the emerging two very different baby characters will somehow give credence to that little bit of individuality in their names, highlighting them as very different in others’ minds within a short time after birth.

I really wouldn’t want to easily roll over and give up on the name that myself and my DH were set on throughout my pregnancy. But I do understand your discomfort especially if the two little cousins will be close.

Your SIL is very unreasonable to have the righteous expectation you will give way and conform to her wishes, especially as she is basing her reasoning on the fact she’s had more miscarriages than you and you didn’t have to ‘try’ which is nonsense ….each of the babies is a blessing.
I really hope you can resolve this quickly at what should be a happy time of looking forward.

Roselilly36 · 19/11/2023 08:25

Just ridiculous, no one owns the name. I wouldn’t have any further discussion re names.

ACynicalDad · 19/11/2023 08:21

Do you live really close, how much will the kids see each other, we see our cousins 3 times a year max, it really wouldn’t matter if the names were the same, so if they are a bit different who cares? Call out what you want and she can too. More consequential if kids in your kids class share a name and they cope.

user1471538283 · 19/11/2023 08:19

Use the name you want!

I've got a distant cousin with the same name as me that was deliberately chosen because they loved my name. It's never been a problem.

If she's so precious now about the name she's in for a shock at school when she finds out there are at least two others with the same name!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 19/11/2023 08:14

wokbun · 18/11/2023 21:23

Never discuss baby names

Wise advice!

Thingamebobwotsit · 19/11/2023 08:09

@Dramatic do you have more than one name on your list? If so, then I would put this to one side and make a final decision when your beautiful baby arrives. Once you have seen your baby you will know what the right name is for them. We had three on the list for each of ours (we were very indecisive in our household) and the babies ultimately "chose their own" - some names just didn't seem to suit them once they were out, so to speak. No idea why. Might just have been the hormones on my part but it worked well as a method for us 😁

Passepartoute · 19/11/2023 07:59

Presumably it isn't a name you love that much, though, otherwise you'd have used it for one of your older daughters?

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 19/11/2023 07:42

wokbun · 18/11/2023 21:23

Never discuss baby names

This ^

No good comes of it

kittyycatt · 19/11/2023 07:30

With my eldest, I was discussing names with my not pregnant sister and she said we can't use X because she wanted it. Stupidly I said okay, we'll find something else. Guess who then didn't use or consider the name when they had a child 4 years later!
I would use the name.

FreyaW · 19/11/2023 07:27

Oh I don't know.
Do what you and your partner want..it's not a subject for anyone else to have a say.
But I will say, had names picked for my 3 and ended up giving all 3 of them different names because when I saw the babies, the names just didn't seem to suit. 🤷‍♀️