Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a prenup?

133 replies

Deedee37 · 18/11/2023 21:20

I have assets (property) which I own together with my parents and siblings, and the flat we live in is mine. He doesn’t have any assets. Our income is similar. I asked him if we can do a prenup but he said that if I don’t trust him, I shouldn’t marry him.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 20:46

@RachelFuchsalot

How is he trying to pressurise the OP into marrying him? This is what she says:

he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions

But the OP said originally: he said that if I don’t trust him, I shouldn’t marry him.

That's him trying to guilt her out of a prenup.

At any rate it doesn't really matter: the bottom line is that on no account should the OP marry him. A prenup might help a bit but it's not a silver bullet. The only way to guarantee the assets is to stay unmarried.

RachelFuchsalot · 19/11/2023 20:43

@Thepeopleversuswork

How is he trying to pressurise the OP into marrying him? This is what she says:

he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 20:43

I want to get married for love. I know IABU for this, but for me it’s about deciding to make a commitment to each other, and to have this day and the vows you made to look back on when more difficult times come.

But that's not what marriage is about. Marriage is a legal contract that underpins the sharing of financial assets between two people. It's designed essentially to protect the financially weaker partner in the relationship which, traditionally, was usually a woman when she was bearing and raising children.

That model works beautifully in that situation, which is why any woman who is considering being a SAHM or stopping work for any length of time is strongly advised to get married. It doesn't work as well in a scenario like yours, where you have brought all the assets to the table: in this case it's basically a meal ticket for him and you stand to lose everything you've built for yourself.

Being married to someone doesn't guarantee commitment. It simply buttresses the financial security of someone who isn't able to generate money on their own. This is not the case in your situation: you already have financial assets and you would simply be handing them over to them by doing this.

If you want to move him in and believe you have a future with him by all means do that but protect yourself legally: a) by not getting married and b) by making sure that if his name goes on any deeds relating to your house you get a trust deed drawn up to make clear where the asset split is.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 20:37

Don't marry him.

a) Because you stand to lose a lot if you split up. If you've brought the assets to the table and you marry him the starting point in a divorce would be that he could take half of the assets (it's not a given that he would but you'd have to make the case as to why not).

b) Because he's pressuring you to marry him (probably for exactly this reason).

I'm moving in with my long term partner in similar circumstances to you (ie I have far greater assets than he does). For that reason I'm a) not ever going to marry him and b) I'm having legal documents drawn up to make clear what the asset split would be in the event of a separation.

My partner is completely fine with this because he accepts that its fair and equitable that my assets are legally protected. Yours isn't, and is trying to bully you into getting married. This is a huge red flag.

If you're going to stay with him (and I don't think you should) whatever you do don't get married.

RachelFuchsalot · 19/11/2023 20:34

I get the ceremony, special day and commitment I want

Only you don't, and that's what's bothering you. Like many people, you have a romanticised view of what marriage is - but you're still hard-headed enough not to want to marry a man who won't sign a pre-nup (leaving aside whether they have any legal validity or not).

The only way you can square this circle is by marrying a man who has at least as many assets as you do. Otherwise you're going to keep coming up against this problem.

Marriage means legally sharing absolutely everything. If you want to get married, you can't really say "I want to share absolutely everything with you, except for X, Y, and Z", because a potential spouse won't on the whole want to go down that route.

If you don't want to hand over your legal entitlement to your own money and your own assets, you can't get married.

CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 20:31

I think unfortunately your choices are either to accept the marital sharing of assets or stay unmarried.

Starseeking · 19/11/2023 20:28

If you want to get married, you can't marry him, so if that's what you want, you need to move on.

Deedee37 · 19/11/2023 20:16

To answer some questions….

I want to get married for love. I know IABU for this, but for me it’s about deciding to make a commitment to each other, and to have this day and the vows you made to look back on when more difficult times come.

He lives in my flat, on my invitation to do so. I’m not asking him to contribute to my mortgage and I don’t want him to pay rent. I also pay for furniture and household items. We share the bills, that’s enough for me. I’m in the lucky position to have some assets from family and inheritance, and I’m more than happy for him to be able to save some money so that he can make his own (or we can make joint) investments further down the line.

Obviously I wouldn’t put him on the street if we separated and I would be happy to support him financially and otherwise to find his own place, but I wouldn’t really feel comfortable with giving him half of this flat because it’s been paid for 100% by me. And for family assets, these were established long before meeting him and I have obligations towards my family so I want to protect these.

He is a great partner and he agrees that he has no claim on any of my assets. This was never the issue, he says he doesn’t feel comfortable with getting a solicitor and negotiating a prenup because it’s thinking about divorce when you’re supposed to be sure that it will be forever (why marry otherwise), and he also feels that it is a lack of trust. I fully understand and respect his opinion.

We are engaged and have already started planning the wedding. I’m gutted by the thought of not going through with it. He has offered to make it a commitment ceremony instead and run the day exactly as we planned, just with a celebrant instead of the registrar.
I know that this should be a really good solution - my assets are being protected, I get the ceremony, special day and commitment I want, and he doesn’t have to do a prenup he’s not comfortable with. Feeling a bit gutted though about not being able to call the love of my life my husband, particularly after our engagement and wedding plans.

OP posts:
SkyFullofStars1975 · 19/11/2023 19:46

Out of interest, OP, how did you come to live together? Did he ask or you offer?

CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 19:39

The other way around the man would be seen as tight/untrustworthy.

CharlotteRose90 · 19/11/2023 18:54

I won’t be getting married without protecting my assets somehow. Me and my family have worked Damn hard to have a little weasel try and take half.

Baffledandalarmed · 19/11/2023 18:49

Deedee37 · 19/11/2023 12:42

If anyone wants an update / still reads: we talked again this morning and he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions. Red flag or green flag?

Red and Green.

Green = He might genuinely love you and all will be sunshine and daisies and you'll still be together when you're 90 in a nursing home poking fun at other residents etc.

Red = he could just be saying it to draw you in. Ultimately, if he lives in your house and contributes to any of the maintenance and fixing up, he could have some sort of claim.

But, for what it's worth, I think you'd be insane to marry someone who brings so little financially when you bring so much.

Example: Best friend from school married a guy she met at uni. She inherited £800K when her dad died (3rd year of uni, age 21). He proposed when they were 22 (they had been together four years by that point). Everyone in our friendship group told her not to marry him...she ignored us. Aged 25 he asked for a divorce and, as they were married, laid claim to half of her estate. Even if somehow she manages to keep more than half, she'll have spent tens of thousands on solicitor fees.

Don't do it.

Paperbagsaremine · 19/11/2023 18:28

OP, if you talk us through why you are considering marriage with him, we may be able to advise.

RachelFuchsalot · 19/11/2023 18:22

Christmaste · 18/11/2023 22:34

I don’t know, it does kind of kill the romance doesn’t it for both of. If he loved you and doesn’t need you to support him he should be happy to sign a prenup.

Marriage isn't about romance. It's a hard-headed legal (and financial) decision.

namestevalian · 19/11/2023 18:15

They aren't legally enforceable but courts do take notice of them

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 19/11/2023 18:13

Deedee37 · 19/11/2023 12:42

If anyone wants an update / still reads: we talked again this morning and he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions. Red flag or green flag?

This is fair. He’s respectful of your position and protecting his.

I still think you have polar opposite views on crucial things for a successful relationship.

Have you discussed if and how things might change if you have children, and all the things that entails?

Aprilx · 19/11/2023 16:46

Cookerhood · 18/11/2023 22:07

We've helped our DD & her DH with the deposit for their house & have insisted on a pre nup as part of that. It took the onus off her. We have seen a friend get into a terrible mess after an 18 month marriage. He will lose his house & half his pension.

You do not lose your house and half your pension after a 18 month marriage so that is just rubbish. After a short marriage both parties are returned to the financial state they were in prior to marriage.

I brought a lot more money into our marriage than my now husband did. I didn’t protect it because I knew the above and figured that as the marriage continued things would have equalled out anyway.

Densol57 · 19/11/2023 16:20

A pre nup that ( for example ) stopped a woman, who then became a mother to his children and she stopped work to look after children so husband could further career and increase his pension etc, and a lengthy marriage holds little/ no weight in the uk.

Two people - no children, very dissimilar assets, entering into a pre nup with eyes wide open that fairly discusses assets etc and with legal advice etc. Court WOULD take that into account.

AcrossthePond55 · 19/11/2023 16:08

Deedee37 · 19/11/2023 12:42

If anyone wants an update / still reads: we talked again this morning and he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions. Red flag or green flag?

Well, I guess that depends on what you want and how satisfied with the relationship you are.

Do you feel a 'need' to be married? Will you be happy without it?

Do you want children? Would you be happy to have them unmarried? Do you understand that being a SAHM would probably be out of the question as you'd never want to make yourself financially vulnerable. Are you financially stable enough to raise them on your own if 'the worst' happened?

Does he treat you well and with love and respect? Will he let the issue lie forever or will he throw it up to you during disagreements or keep trying to convince you to change your mind.

Are you financial 'equals' (meaning equal contributors to the household and have equal spending money)?

Do you feel he's he speaking from a place of true honesty or is do you think he's trying a bit of 'blackmail'.

And one final thought. IF the time came you wanted or needed to move and you looked to sell your flat to buy a new place how do you see that working? Would you want the new place in your name or any lump sum from your flat to be ring-fenced? Would you want proportional ownership based on who put in how much or would you be happy with 50/50? And do you think he'd agree with what you wanted?

bluegreygreen · 19/11/2023 15:02

Agree with @Ffsnotaconference in that he is being entirely consistent.

I wouldn't marry anyone who asked me for a prenup. Not for silly 'romantic' ideas but due to my personal views on marriage.

Ffsnotaconference · 19/11/2023 13:44

NorthernSpirit · 19/11/2023 13:28

Are you a family law solicitor?

Are you?

I am guessing not.

I had had several different consults with several different firms. As I have far more in assets than Dp. I spent a lot of time deciding what the best position for me was.

Why so snarky? I simply pointed out what you actually said. ‘it should be upheld’. Should be upheld means nothing and it’s no guarantee. Should is the correct word and the word you used.

If you don’t want to share assets a prenup doesn’t guarantee it.

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 13:32

yes that was my understanding.

you SHOULD be okay with a properly done pre-nup and assuming no changes along the way after marriage (both parties still work and earn reasonable amounts to support lifestyle, no one stops working due to sickness or having kids).

But its that SHOULD - there is no guarantee the courts won't ignore it if they think its unfair. So safest not to marry (unless you have done specific trust type things when you don't actually own your own assets then anyway, but thats for the super rich - my assets are my house and pension so not much i can do witth them if i want to enjoy using them (bar not marrying)

NorthernSpirit · 19/11/2023 13:28

Are you a family law solicitor?

Ffsnotaconference · 19/11/2023 13:19

NorthernSpirit · 19/11/2023 13:15

I have a pre nup and am UK based.

I bought considerable property BTL assets, plus pensions, savings and investments into the marriage which I wanted to protect. Should the marriage fail - I don’t want to hand over 50% of those assets that I have worked my arse off to gain.

All those saying pre nips aren’t legal in the UK are incorrect. Speak to a solicitor. UK law has a complex approach to prenups, but as long as you’ve taken steps to ensure your prenup is legally-sound and was drawn up fairly, it should be upheld by a court.

Being married also prevents your FH having to pay inheritance tax on your death. If for example you have £1m worth of assets - he would have to pay 40% inheritance tax (£400k in this example) in a very short period of time. Most people wouldn’t be able to find those funds.

Marriage, protecting your assets therefore makes sense.

Edited

The operative word is ‘should’.

You can’t guarantee it. And, quite frankly, it’s silly to bet so much money on ‘should’ when you clearly don’t want to share your assets.

The longer the marriage the less likely it is to be enforced. If you don’t want to share, it’s far easier to just not get married. A short marriage wouldn’t get 50% in most cases anyway.

NorthernSpirit · 19/11/2023 13:15

I have a pre nup and am UK based.

I bought considerable property BTL assets, plus pensions, savings and investments into the marriage which I wanted to protect. Should the marriage fail - I don’t want to hand over 50% of those assets that I have worked my arse off to gain.

All those saying pre nips aren’t legal in the UK are incorrect. Speak to a solicitor. UK law has a complex approach to prenups, but as long as you’ve taken steps to ensure your prenup is legally-sound and was drawn up fairly, it should be upheld by a court.

Being married also prevents your FH having to pay inheritance tax on your death. If for example you have £1m worth of assets - he would have to pay 40% inheritance tax (£400k in this example) in a very short period of time. Most people wouldn’t be able to find those funds.

Marriage, protecting your assets therefore makes sense.