Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a prenup?

133 replies

Deedee37 · 18/11/2023 21:20

I have assets (property) which I own together with my parents and siblings, and the flat we live in is mine. He doesn’t have any assets. Our income is similar. I asked him if we can do a prenup but he said that if I don’t trust him, I shouldn’t marry him.

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 23:19

I'd say that staying permanently part time once the kids are grown is a privilege, not oppression.

CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 23:17

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 22:30

@DisquietintheRanks

And yet when a woman meets a man with more assets the reverse doesn't apply. Strange huh?

I've explained this upthread but it's completely different. A woman who has children typically sees her financial potential hugely diminished by childbearing and rearing and time that she spends either not working or downgrading work. Men very rarely find themselves in this position - they can put their feet to the floor and concentrate on earning money unhindered by the concerns of childcare etc (unless they are stay at home dads, of which there are a very small number).

Marriage is designed to protect women from losing out financially as a result of this.

People always parrot back that a man should be as entitled to his wife's assets as a woman should be to her husband's but unless they are a child-free couple and plan to remain child-free the man and the woman are not at parity.

Looking after children and the home is what really fucks women financially. This is what they are rightly compensated for through marriage. No such equivalent applies for men.

Why should an able bodied young man earning money be handed money he hasn't worked for as a result of a canny marriage? A woman who has children should have entitlement to this precisely because she is likely to spend several years unable to earn money. No man will find himself in this position.

If the OP's husband plans to stop working and look after children then I'll completely revise my view but I'd bet good money this isn't the case.

But why do so many women choose not to ever return to full time career jobs? I think there's more to the debate and for many it's a lifestyle choice.

caringcarer · 19/11/2023 22:59

coldcallerbaiter · 19/11/2023 21:18

Is this a viable option? Do you know anyone that has done this? interesting idea.

I've got 6 of btl properties in a limited company. It's best for tax too as you can deduct the mortgage interest and write it off against tax. Obviously the profit sits in the limited company and you can pay yourself dividends then you pay tax on those. I've got 4 other btl properties in my own name. Because I've had those for about 18 years they have gone up in value a lot and if I wanted to put them into limited company I'd have to sell them and pay more stamp duty and CGT too.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 22:30

@DisquietintheRanks

And yet when a woman meets a man with more assets the reverse doesn't apply. Strange huh?

I've explained this upthread but it's completely different. A woman who has children typically sees her financial potential hugely diminished by childbearing and rearing and time that she spends either not working or downgrading work. Men very rarely find themselves in this position - they can put their feet to the floor and concentrate on earning money unhindered by the concerns of childcare etc (unless they are stay at home dads, of which there are a very small number).

Marriage is designed to protect women from losing out financially as a result of this.

People always parrot back that a man should be as entitled to his wife's assets as a woman should be to her husband's but unless they are a child-free couple and plan to remain child-free the man and the woman are not at parity.

Looking after children and the home is what really fucks women financially. This is what they are rightly compensated for through marriage. No such equivalent applies for men.

Why should an able bodied young man earning money be handed money he hasn't worked for as a result of a canny marriage? A woman who has children should have entitlement to this precisely because she is likely to spend several years unable to earn money. No man will find himself in this position.

If the OP's husband plans to stop working and look after children then I'll completely revise my view but I'd bet good money this isn't the case.

DisquietintheRanks · 19/11/2023 22:21

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 21:01

@EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness

I agree. If he was trying to bully her into marriage without a prenup he'd be saying we get married without a prenup or we split up. He wanted a marriage too, but he views it in a certain way which is incompatible with what OP wants, so remaining unmarried and OP having her assets protected is a compromise for both. Someone not wanting to sign a prenup doesn't make them a gold digger.

I don't know... Call me cynical but I think if an able bodied man marries a woman with far more assets than he does he'd have to have been living under a rock to not realise his luck was in big time. If he had any real respect and love for the OP he would understand that she was putting herself in a precarious position and support her desire to protect herself. Frankly if he really loved her he wouldn't be supporting the marriage plan at all: it's a suicidally bad idea for the OP to get married. My partner totally understands that marriage would be an insanely bad idea for me.

Marriage is not designed as a meal ticket for men who want to coast off women: its designed to protect women raising children. It has no relevance in this situation.

At any rate this is all somewhat irrelevant: it's clearly the OP who is driving the desire to get married and not him and its the OP who needs talking out of it, pronto.

And yet when a woman meets a man with more assets the reverse doesn't apply. Strange huh?

CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 22:17

There was a thread a while back where the husband was a much higher earner and had not only singlehandedly paid the mortage but had also supported OP whilst she studied.

She didn't want any part of his house upon divorcing but everyone on here was telling her to 'take what she could' as she was entitled to her marital assets.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 19/11/2023 22:15

but I wouldn’t really feel comfortable with giving him half of this flat because it’s been paid for 100% by me. And for family assets, these were established long before meeting him and I have obligations towards my family so I want to protect these

What belongs to your family, you can put a prenup in place for. It was there before you and should be there after you.

Whatever is yours, through your earnings and hard work, you don’t. Consider it matrimonial property. You work for both of you, make sacrifices for both of you and the family unit. Rich/poor, sickness/health etc.

He’s being totally reasonable and very fair. You’re being very cautious - that’s okay. There’s a middle ground here, given your new info.

CaramacFiend · 19/11/2023 22:11

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 19/11/2023 21:39

Nah, toss this fishy back into the sea. Thieve issues are absolutely fundamental to the basis of a relationship.

If you want the "living together" relationship to be equal you should rent out your property and rent or buy something different together, each paying 50%. Let's see how interested he'll be when living together suddenly becomes far more expensive for him?

But usually the higher earner is expected to put in more. Whenever we see a thread where the husband earns more but wants equal contribution from the OP we're told it's financial abuse. Usually the goal is for each partner to have the same disposable income.

GreatGateauxsby · 19/11/2023 21:43

Totaly · 18/11/2023 21:23

You can protect your assets in other ways - speak to a solicitor and ring fence properties.

You could also set up trust funds.

This is sensible and probably more effective than a prenup truth be told.

i was advised prenups become “less valid” post children.

Maelil01 · 19/11/2023 21:40

Littleredcorvettepurplerain · 18/11/2023 21:21

Pre-nups aren’t legal in the UK if that’s where you are…

Not true.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 19/11/2023 21:39

Nah, toss this fishy back into the sea. Thieve issues are absolutely fundamental to the basis of a relationship.

If you want the "living together" relationship to be equal you should rent out your property and rent or buy something different together, each paying 50%. Let's see how interested he'll be when living together suddenly becomes far more expensive for him?

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 21:19

AnneLovesGilbert · 19/11/2023 21:12

Such very different answers to past threads when it’s been a man wanting one.

You should have discussed this before getting engaged and starting to plan the wedding.

Have a commitment ceremony if you want to but don’t pretend it’s a legal wedding, don’t pretend he’s your husband. You don’t want to fully commit by joining your assets because he won’t agree to the half commitment your now offering so you don’t get to be married to him.

I wouldn’t marry you either.

People always bring this up, though, but it's not a comparable situation.

It's entirely legitimate for a woman who is planning to be raising children and scaling back her career to want to marry a man and share half his assets: she knows her earning power is going to be significantly limited by the need to care for children and that marriage is legal protection.

A man marrying a wealthier woman has no such limiting factors in his way. He will never be expected to stop work or downgrade work in order to bear and raise children. In that situation the marriage is pure financial upside with no requirement to meet the same threshold of contribution.

Marriage is not about love and commitment. It's about money and financial protection. Failing to understand that leaves so many woman up shit creek financially: we need to stop pretending that its the same situation on both sides of the coin. It's not.

Siamesecatlover · 19/11/2023 21:19

You sound like someone who is either naive, greedy or both

coldcallerbaiter · 19/11/2023 21:18

caringcarer · 19/11/2023 21:02

Could you put your property into a limited company then you won't own it because a limited company is an entity in its own right. You would own shares or you could put them I to your Mum's name.

Is this a viable option? Do you know anyone that has done this? interesting idea.

AnneLovesGilbert · 19/11/2023 21:12

Such very different answers to past threads when it’s been a man wanting one.

You should have discussed this before getting engaged and starting to plan the wedding.

Have a commitment ceremony if you want to but don’t pretend it’s a legal wedding, don’t pretend he’s your husband. You don’t want to fully commit by joining your assets because he won’t agree to the half commitment your now offering so you don’t get to be married to him.

I wouldn’t marry you either.

caringcarer · 19/11/2023 21:02

Could you put your property into a limited company then you won't own it because a limited company is an entity in its own right. You would own shares or you could put them I to your Mum's name.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 21:01

@EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness

I agree. If he was trying to bully her into marriage without a prenup he'd be saying we get married without a prenup or we split up. He wanted a marriage too, but he views it in a certain way which is incompatible with what OP wants, so remaining unmarried and OP having her assets protected is a compromise for both. Someone not wanting to sign a prenup doesn't make them a gold digger.

I don't know... Call me cynical but I think if an able bodied man marries a woman with far more assets than he does he'd have to have been living under a rock to not realise his luck was in big time. If he had any real respect and love for the OP he would understand that she was putting herself in a precarious position and support her desire to protect herself. Frankly if he really loved her he wouldn't be supporting the marriage plan at all: it's a suicidally bad idea for the OP to get married. My partner totally understands that marriage would be an insanely bad idea for me.

Marriage is not designed as a meal ticket for men who want to coast off women: its designed to protect women raising children. It has no relevance in this situation.

At any rate this is all somewhat irrelevant: it's clearly the OP who is driving the desire to get married and not him and its the OP who needs talking out of it, pronto.

NovemberName · 19/11/2023 21:01

Someone not wanting to sign a prenup doesn't make them a gold digger.

I agree but I do think it makes them naive. "The divorce rate in the United Kingdom is estimated at 42 per cent"

He's already living there rent free. He's in a win-win situation . The OP ... not so much.

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 21:00

I do think you will split over this

He doesn't think you love him enough to marry without a pre nup. He may always think that. So sensibly he's probably one day want to marry someone and therefore to leave.
It will always be there at the back of his mind. And yours.

caringcarer · 19/11/2023 20:59

Deedee37 · 18/11/2023 21:22

Yes I’m in the UK.
Do you mean I shouldn’t marry him because I should protect my assets or because I’m unfair in asking for a prenup?

To protect your assets.

Siamesecatlover · 19/11/2023 20:58

Sorry but that's absolutely ridiculous. Any spouse who cares an ounce about their other half would be rational enough to understand why a prenup is fair and reasonable to protect pre marital assets to which they have no right to. Why should I be entitled to half of what my husband earned before we got married- if he worked hard to buy a house of his own before marriage for example and then sold it after we got married and then we got divorced 5 years later why TF should I be entitled to 50% of that money. If you're not willing to accept a prenup you're showing your true colours and confirming you don't think logically and are probably an entitled greedy person.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 19/11/2023 20:54

RachelFuchsalot · 19/11/2023 20:43

@Thepeopleversuswork

How is he trying to pressurise the OP into marrying him? This is what she says:

he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions

I agree. If he was trying to bully her into marriage without a prenup he'd be saying we get married without a prenup or we split up. He wanted a marriage too, but he views it in a certain way which is incompatible with what OP wants, so remaining unmarried and OP having her assets protected is a compromise for both. Someone not wanting to sign a prenup doesn't make them a gold digger.

perpetuallytired99 · 19/11/2023 20:54

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2023 20:46

@RachelFuchsalot

How is he trying to pressurise the OP into marrying him? This is what she says:

he said that his decision not so sign a prenup is final, but that he would like to continue our relationship as before as unmarried couple to respect both our interests/opinions

But the OP said originally: he said that if I don’t trust him, I shouldn’t marry him.

That's him trying to guilt her out of a prenup.

At any rate it doesn't really matter: the bottom line is that on no account should the OP marry him. A prenup might help a bit but it's not a silver bullet. The only way to guarantee the assets is to stay unmarried.

That's ridiculous.

In no way is him saying he does not want to sign a PN indicate he's pressuring her. He's entitled to not want to sign a PN and doing so shouldn't have an automatic negative interpretation applied

RachelFuchsalot · 19/11/2023 20:49

The only way to guarantee the assets is to stay unmarried

Absolutely! @Thepeopleversuswork

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 20:48

Definitely don't have a fake commitment ceremony. You'd have to explain to everyone it wasn't real and why it wasn't real and that would be super awkward for guests.

It is annoying that you can't get married "for love" if you have assets whereas anyone asset free can do it with zero risk.