Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about teacher's behaviour

665 replies

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 14:52

Last night after tea, DD (6) said to younger DD (2) 'Don't you dare do that' (touch her food) in a menacing voice.It isn't something we would say, as I think it's a nasty way to speak to someone, so i asked her where she got it from, to which she replied that her teacher had shouted at a boy in her class (year 1) 'don't you dare interuppt me when I'm talking' and re-inacted it in a thunderous sort of voice.

If she was telling me the teacher was saying such things to her I would be in no doubt to complain, as its clearly threatening behaviour, but as it wasn't at her (and she confirms she has never shouted at her) I'm on the fence whether to say anything or not about it .I've re-iterated to DD not to speak to her little sister like that, explaining that even if the teacher did it, it is still wrong.She told me when I asked that it doesn't scare her when the teacher shouts (she has very sensitive hearing and is often scared if we shout at home) but i'm not really liking that she is seeing someone who should be a professional and a role model behaving in that way towards any child.

OP posts:
Violinist64 · 19/11/2023 08:33

electriclight · 19/11/2023 07:20

If my child came home saying their teacher had shouted 'don't you dare interrupt me' I would tell them off all over again - 'quite right, you mustn't interrupt your teacher.'

I wouldn't be complaining to the head about the word choice, hoping to get her into trouble, thrilled that she'd be second-guessing everything she says from now on, showing my child that the teacher was wrong.

Behaviour in schools is a hundred times worse than it has ever been, and this nonsense is the reason why - kids who think they are untouchable, who laugh at the idea of being on the receiving end of any sort of sanction, who don't respect teachers because their parents don't either.

The voice of sanity. I have a friend who retired as a reception class teacher a few years ago. Her first few years of teaching were on her own in the classroom with no TAs, as was usual until the late nineties. She once told me that she would rather have a class of thirty five children with no TA from thirty years ago than a class of thirty of today’s children with at least one TA as the behaviour of many children has deteriorated so much in that time.

Sirzy · 19/11/2023 08:30

nikkiandham · 19/11/2023 07:34

If it routine and trivial the teachers boss will recognise it as such - where’s the bullying?

You really think someone who will complain about something this petty will stop and one complaint though? She even implies as much in her posts. That constant picking can soon fall into the bullying and harrassment bracket.

nikkiandham · 19/11/2023 07:34

electriclight · 19/11/2023 07:14

OP, don't you see how hypocritical it is to talk of feeling bullied and being treated unkindly, when that is exactly how the teacher will feel if you complain to her boss for something so incredibly routine and trivial?

If it routine and trivial the teachers boss will recognise it as such - where’s the bullying?

Lateliein · 19/11/2023 07:28

Would love to see op banging on about professionalism after a few years of managing thirty six year olds.. Guaranteed a quarter of them are feral, pushing boundaries, answering back, interrupting and talking to others, not listening, disrupting teaching and learning. Some of them will, at times, no doubt physically hurt others, disobey rules, throw objects, run out the room.

But teachers can't raise their voice because.. Professionalism 🙄

Wtf.

greengreengrass25 · 19/11/2023 07:27

electriclight · 19/11/2023 07:20

If my child came home saying their teacher had shouted 'don't you dare interrupt me' I would tell them off all over again - 'quite right, you mustn't interrupt your teacher.'

I wouldn't be complaining to the head about the word choice, hoping to get her into trouble, thrilled that she'd be second-guessing everything she says from now on, showing my child that the teacher was wrong.

Behaviour in schools is a hundred times worse than it has ever been, and this nonsense is the reason why - kids who think they are untouchable, who laugh at the idea of being on the receiving end of any sort of sanction, who don't respect teachers because their parents don't either.

Have to agree with you

electriclight · 19/11/2023 07:20

If my child came home saying their teacher had shouted 'don't you dare interrupt me' I would tell them off all over again - 'quite right, you mustn't interrupt your teacher.'

I wouldn't be complaining to the head about the word choice, hoping to get her into trouble, thrilled that she'd be second-guessing everything she says from now on, showing my child that the teacher was wrong.

Behaviour in schools is a hundred times worse than it has ever been, and this nonsense is the reason why - kids who think they are untouchable, who laugh at the idea of being on the receiving end of any sort of sanction, who don't respect teachers because their parents don't either.

electriclight · 19/11/2023 07:14

OP, don't you see how hypocritical it is to talk of feeling bullied and being treated unkindly, when that is exactly how the teacher will feel if you complain to her boss for something so incredibly routine and trivial?

Jifmicroliquid · 19/11/2023 07:02

Those who say that people are bullying the OP need to look up what bullying is.

Pointing out a differing opinion to the OP is not bullying. People are getting heated because of his ludicrous it is. The OP wants forgiveness for hitting her cat, she admits she shouts and scares her child and has made bad decisions because she is human… yet she is unable to consider that perhaps this teacher, on this occasion, spoke more harshly than normal because said child had pushed her buttons one too many times.

If the OPs DD commented on this being out of character for the teacher, or at least she’s never mentioned it before, then why can’t the OP use a bit of common sense and think that perhaps the teacher has had a spectacularly stressful day.
No children were harmed, nor did she swear.

You want forgiveness for your bad choices OP? How about showing a bit of compassion to the teacher, who is human too.

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:59

Repurposing · 18/11/2023 23:26

You may want to consider leaving the thread, OP. This level of bullying will not be good for your mental health. Education is in flux right now and the old styles of teaching are changing, and that is naturally difficult for people. What is seen as acceptable by the profession now, won't be in the future, just as what was acceptable 20 years ago is not now. Sounds like you are a lovely parent who does their best, and who cares not only about their own child, but other children too. Ignore the mean girl comments, they are just hurt human beings trying to hurt others as a way to feel better about themselves.

Thanks @Repurposing for all the support...I have said all i can to defend myself and explain, but even though i'm not in denial about my own mistakes and flaws, some people will clearly never be convinced that I am not all the awful things I've been called on this thread, and like you say it's only going to make me feel worse and worse reading it all, plus the more I respond the more active this thread will remain.

Time to all move on to bullying the next unsuspecting poster now please!!

I am leaving this thread and deleting my account now, to escape the unnecessary nastiness which seems so rife on here, and focus on parenting my lovely children in the real world, which most of the time I do pretty bloody well.
I don't need an online forum trying to tell me otherwise.

OP posts:
Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:38

@Volpini yes I have made mistakes.Yes I have previously shared them on here, (which i now really fucking regret tbh, and WILL not be doing again) i was at the time hoping for support with my mistakes, yet here they are all being thrown back in my face years later (even though I HAVE self reflected and learnt from them.....DH and I have worked on our relationship, I no longer harm any animals, and I am in the ongoing process of bettering myself as a parent)

I hold myself to account for shouting at my child and expect my husband to do so aswell.And so I expect the teacher to do the same.
Neither she nor I should be speaking to children in an aggressive or unkind way.
If my DD had gone into school and told the teacher I had done so with her at home, I would expect them to be having a word with me about that too.
I appreciate it works both ways.

I might spend alot of time complaining, I might be 'that' parent, but I'm not fussed about being in the teachers pockets, popular or liked by them, I'm only fussed that their behaviour is professional and caring towards my little girl.

However, I also understand that there is an element of 'needing to pick battles' in some instances, and as this was not something said directly to my child, that's why I came here asking for seemingly simple advice around whether this was a battle to 'pick or not to pick' (boy do I regret it now!)

I won't agree that the teacher was not wrong in doing what she did, but that was not what the post was asking, it was asking if I should complain about it, to which I have been told loud and clear I should not, which is fine, but the unkindness laced through the replies is not.

OP posts:
Ellie1015 · 19/11/2023 06:33

It isnt ideal to shout at your kids but it is fine.

It is also fine for a teacher to say or even shout "dont you dare" It really isn't a big deal at all. If is even ok for your dd1 to say this to dd2 about touching her food if she was a little older than 2.

You have blown the meaning of those words out of all proportion.

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:17

MercyIsEliminated · 19/11/2023 00:04

You are being beyond unreasonable. You think it’s perfectly fine to shout at home in a way that frightens your child because you’re a parent “at the end of your tether”? And your anger issues have included hitting a defenseless animal. That’s a truly appalling thing to do, far worse than using the phrase “don’t you dare.” But you’re judging a teacher for using this expression that you don’t like? You didn’t even witness the interaction, it would be absurd for you to complain about it. Motes and beams come to mind.

In other words, focus on your own anger issues.

Read the posts please ...nowhere have I said its 'perfectly fine' for me to shout at her.Because it isn't! But then neither should the teacher! But apparently that's ok?!

OP posts:
Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:14

Once again, just because 'statistics show its more likely that someone who harms animals harms children' does not mean EVERY person who hurts an animal would hurt a child.Please try and get that into your head!

Same as statistics show that those who were sexually abused as child are more likely to sexually abuse children themselves, or those who grew up in homes with DV are more likely to be perpetrators of it....but OF COURSE many won't be either!!

Not saying that animals deserve to be abused OF COURSE they don't! But you cannot compare it to child abuse, hence why the law is different in responding to each circumstance.

And to try and say I've failed as a parent because of it is below the belt and probably the cruelest comment on this whole thread (which is pretty full of them)...I have not failed at it whatsoever.....I am a wonderful parent in many ways.
Yes I get annoyed at my child sometimes and raise my voice (never knew that would be classed as such a heinous crime!) many other parents on this thread post every day about similar struggles with that.

I can only assume that your vitriol towards my parenting comes from your mis-assumption that all animal abusers are child abusers, and your dislike of me wanting to complain about a teacher.

I am genuinely an incredibly invested, loving, devoted, responsive parent 99.9% of the time, and everyone who actually KNOWS me IRL would say that too (yes, even the school!)

I am working on my faults and flaws and trying to find ways to manage my anger issues (which are related mainly to hormonal problems)

I would love to be like the posters who have never shouted at their children, can easily remain calm etc....maybe one day I'll be more like them, but whilst i am not there yet, I am certainly not a failure as a parent either.

OP posts:
Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 05:47

The OP has made a big song and dance about how she is a great parent

Errm, not really?! I've just defended myself to those who are trying to make me sound like a bad one!

parents who don't want to parent and think its all the schools job and then seek to blame the school when their child doesn't behave correctly.

None of this is related to my child not behaving 'correctly" at school.

The reality here is that kids copy how others behavior whether that be other kids misbehaving or how adults behave. They have to learn what is acceptable and appropriate and what is not

Yes exactly, she was copying the teachers aggressive behaviours,which were not appropriate.Just the same as if she copied mine.

So, you see, you can put me and the teacher in the same bracket 'bad teacher/bad parent' for that, but can't say that me shouting isn't OK yet of course its fine for the teacher to do so. * *

OP posts:
Volpini · 19/11/2023 04:43

As an entirely casual onlooker, I noticed comments earlier that “hurt people are just trying to hurt people to make themselves feel better”. Yet, this is exactly what some of these exasperated posters are trying to say to OP, pointing out - in their opinion - that the OP is projecting/ employing double standards. But apparently the feedback is the problem…
And when teachers are trying to provide perspective by telling stories on this thread of the damage done to their mental health over the endless casual or unproven complaints they endure, the same people complaining about meanness have made pointed, spiteful and generalised comments in return towards teachers about their capacity, ability and motivation. Did irony just come here and straight up die?
And no, I am not a school teacher, never have been, never aspired to be, never gonna be. The principal reason because I am not a masochist. Having spent time I will not get back around some awful parents on the school run, I wish to limit my dealings with people who think they understand teaching merely because they once went to school. You see the evidence in WhatsApp groups and at pickup time that some parents appear to have never left, psychologically. It’s not fair to punish teachers teaching your kids now for whoever hurt you 20 years ago.
Have I had cause to speak to school about a concern, ever? Yes. Did I need to seek others’ opinion on it to decide if my concern was valid? No. If things are not right or problematic in a school or classroom, it’s apparent pretty clearly and quickly. if something is important enough to be raised, you know without running a poll past strangers. Equally, not every little thing that pisses you off about a school community of 100s of people needs to become a report or complain about it. Honestly, you’ll never get anything done. Before I go stir a hornets nest, how certain am I? Did I see it for myself? If I didn’t, where’s my evidence? If I don’t have any, how big of an issue could this be? Is there a law or a policy to give me some guidance? Your post does not come anywhere close to meeting my criteria on any of those grounds. There are so few things in life that don’t live in the grey, OP, but this really is one of them.
OP, you seem a bit lost. You have shared some things on here that must make you feel very vulnerable. You’ve made some mistakes youre ashamed of, that you are courageous enough to have owned and you will doubtless make many more in your life. What I would have expected to see on that basis is some self reflection and a coming to realisation of what many people on here have tried to reflect back to you, I think you've become entrenched in your position and lost the most important thing about owning mistakes - the ability to learn from them and gain some perspective. There’s also no point in asking for other people‘s opinion if you aren’t willing to truly look at a problem from another position.
You are not only being unreasonable but veering into the territory of irrational. I’d put this down and put some gentle effort into figuring out what’s going on with you.

slore · 19/11/2023 03:43

Wow.

There are no excuses: hitting a cat - a creature the size of a newborn baby - is horrific. You are an animal abuserand the fact you ever thought it acceptable to hit such a small creature shows how unreasonable and irrational you are.

Just as irrational and unreasonable is your desire to police the language style of a teacher, based on a second-hand account of a six year old of a conversation she wasn't involved in.

Volpini · 19/11/2023 02:52

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 00:00

See, it's this kind of mean girl comment, Volpini, that is just unpleasant and seeks to be hurtful. The OP asked a question, but what she is getting are not thoughtful and helpful replies, what she is getting is bullied. You must be able to see that? You must all be able to see that?

@Repurposing
not sure what I have to do with this post.
As if to illustrate the point many are trying to make on this thread, if you’re going to complain, facts matter.

Volpini · 19/11/2023 02:42

@Repurposing
You tagged me in reply to a comment that was not mine.
When making complaints accuracy matters.

CherryMyBrandy · 19/11/2023 02:34

Repurposing · 18/11/2023 23:26

You may want to consider leaving the thread, OP. This level of bullying will not be good for your mental health. Education is in flux right now and the old styles of teaching are changing, and that is naturally difficult for people. What is seen as acceptable by the profession now, won't be in the future, just as what was acceptable 20 years ago is not now. Sounds like you are a lovely parent who does their best, and who cares not only about their own child, but other children too. Ignore the mean girl comments, they are just hurt human beings trying to hurt others as a way to feel better about themselves.

ODFOD. How sanctimonious of you! I have been bullied. This isn't bullying by any stretch.

CherryMyBrandy · 19/11/2023 02:28

Saying "don't you dare do that" is not threatening speech ffs. Sort yourself out. And leave the teacher alone. He/she is trying to control 30 plus kids. Sometimes they need to use their "Mum Voice".

CatMandarin · 19/11/2023 01:04

Why start a poll if you are going to be convinced the 6% who agree with you are right and the 94% who don't are wrong?

Icopewhenihope · 19/11/2023 00:48

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 00:00

See, it's this kind of mean girl comment, Volpini, that is just unpleasant and seeks to be hurtful. The OP asked a question, but what she is getting are not thoughtful and helpful replies, what she is getting is bullied. You must be able to see that? You must all be able to see that?

The only thing bullied on this thread was the poor cat!

Volpini · 19/11/2023 00:47

Came here to post this. My kids, (14 and 9) for the most part, have had fantastic teachers. Some tougher than others but all of the engaged, brilliant in their own ways and extremely committed humans.
The weakest of these great people was my daughter’s then year 6 teacher (and he is now my son’s year 4 teacher.) Lovely guy. However, from what my dd recounted and my own limited observations, his boundaries and authority need work. He gets great outcomes from some kids, but unfortunately my dd’s y6 had some right characters in it and she would come home frustrated at the class disruption whilst teacher was turning a blind eye. Her previous teachers had been less popular with the kids, but more appropriately authoritative and with better boundaries and outcomes, in my unqualified opinion. She was relieved to get to secondary where within weeks she couldn’t believe the difference in behaviour and how much easier it was to work in a classroom not constantly disrupted because the teachers won’t stand for it.

In addition, OP:

  1. I have found it is more productive in life to work from the position that - generally - professionals tend to be the experts in their field and to work with them as a partner. Of course, there are always outliers, but when something seems off to me I seek first to understand rather than assume that the other person is unfit to be in post.
  2. I work from a position that teachers and SLT are humans and are not yet pre programmed automatons. Therefore I try not to hold them to a higher standard than I am capable of myself. If I expect forgiveness for my weaknesses, I try very hard to extend that same courtesy otherwise that would be a double standard, no? We are all learning and growing to do better together as pupils, parents and as teachers, no?
  3. context is key. Is this teacher leaping out of bed in the morning in their eagerness to be mean to little kids or was this a one off? Given your kid isn’t frightened of her, which she absolute would be if she was hollering morning til night, I think you are safe to assume that probably one child got on her last nerve on one day. she probably felt horrible about it, even though the kid needed the boundary. (See point 2.) Chatty kid is now very clear on where the line is and has crystal clear expectations. Chatty kid unlikely to keep getting into trouble for the same behaviour. Win.
  4. most importantly. I know that when I get disproportionately out of shape about something, that the thing that has triggered me is actually not about the other person or teacher, but actually something in me. For instance, I used to get very uncomfortable around anger/ raised voices or being/ feeling angry and had beliefs about anger that I was fortunate to be able to work through with someone. Anger is not rage or violence per se. It does not automatically mean that someone is unkind/ threatening/ abusive or out of control. It is merely a signpost that someone or something has crossed a boundary or line you hold. It is a sign you value and respect yourself when you feel angry. What you do with that is a different matter. Responding appropriately to and respecting anger is a part of a healthy functioning person and society. I feel you would be well served to sit with your beliefs about anger and what you perceive to be this teacher’s response. I suspect these beliefs are more likely the source of your (in my opinion) disproportionate reaction, not whatever is actually going on in the classroom with this teacher. When I learned to do this it was honestly transformative.
RedToothBrush · 19/11/2023 00:45

Picking up on the OPs hypocrisy isn't bullying.
Picking up on the OPs gross hyperbolic comparison between this situation and an abusive husband isn't bullying.
Picking up on the OPs continued attack on this teacher and how if she can't do things the way the OP likes then she shouldnt be a teacher isn't bullying.
Picking up on the OP unwillingness to understand the concept of context and that her daughter might not be explaining the whole situation isn't bullying.
Picking up on the OP STILL persisting that the teacher was 'threatening' and saying that she wasn't saying the right thing despite so many posters saying it's fine and has it's place isn't bullying.
Picking up on the OP blaming the school for a situation which should be a parenting one isn't bullying.

Saying someone is wrong and is being totally unreasonable isn't bullying.

People have said constructive things - they said the way you interact with the school matters, they've taken about how the OP has anger issues of her own (which is contributing to her reaction to this thread) and they've said they've that the OP need ls to take some parental responsibility.

They've done that robustly because the of the OPs attitude that she's STILL right no matter what. It's the tone deafness that making the responses (that are invited by creating a thread) strong.

The OP doesn't want to listen because she's right and everyone one else is wrong. And it's got backs up.

And she still doesn't get this is what would happen if she complained to school. The OP is alienating people by not listening and demanding.

That's a lesson that she'd be wise to learn, because beyond this thread, she's going to continue to have issues because she is so tone deaf and her expectations are so off.

But she won't. Because it's easier to hide behind the accusations that everyone is 'bullying' her. Because that's the pattern of not taking responsibility and not listening...

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 00:16

I still think the OP is being utterly unreasonable. The remark wasn't addressed to her child. She wasn't present and knows nothing about the context.

I don't think it's bullying to say that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread