Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about teacher's behaviour

665 replies

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 14:52

Last night after tea, DD (6) said to younger DD (2) 'Don't you dare do that' (touch her food) in a menacing voice.It isn't something we would say, as I think it's a nasty way to speak to someone, so i asked her where she got it from, to which she replied that her teacher had shouted at a boy in her class (year 1) 'don't you dare interuppt me when I'm talking' and re-inacted it in a thunderous sort of voice.

If she was telling me the teacher was saying such things to her I would be in no doubt to complain, as its clearly threatening behaviour, but as it wasn't at her (and she confirms she has never shouted at her) I'm on the fence whether to say anything or not about it .I've re-iterated to DD not to speak to her little sister like that, explaining that even if the teacher did it, it is still wrong.She told me when I asked that it doesn't scare her when the teacher shouts (she has very sensitive hearing and is often scared if we shout at home) but i'm not really liking that she is seeing someone who should be a professional and a role model behaving in that way towards any child.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 19/11/2023 10:33

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

It's not bullying to tell the OP she's wrong and why she's wrong.

It's not bullying to point out her hypocrisy in wanting to complain about something her child was not involved in, without context - that wasn't actually anything to complain about in any case.

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 10:32

You might not have any evidence of it. It doesn't mean it isn't a contributory factor.

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 10:15

How is it bullying to point out that complaints such as this are contributing to experienced and capable teachers wanting to leave teaching?

EstEstEst · 19/11/2023 10:04

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 09:59

Here are just some of the negative comments from just the last two pages of the thread. These comments seek to belittle to OP, to make her doubt herself, to make her feel stupid for raising her concern. They in no way seek to support or help the OP. Imagine having to read page after page of this. This is bullying and everyone know it is, to say otherwise is disingenuous.

Your behaviour is bullying and harassment
I pity the teacher for having you as a parent
Kids are arseholes
You fucking try it
I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone with such a lack of any type of self reflection?
Absence of emotional maturity
You want forgiveness for your bad choices OP?
You are not only being unreasonable but veering into the territory of irrational
You sound absolutely clueless!
Parents like you are why there there is so many leaving the profession
Do better for your child.
Get a grip.
OP is part of what makes this country so shit at the moment.
Good bit of DARVO on your part
Give your head a wobble, don't be so ridiculous
The OP has made a big song and dance
The OP wants to complain rather than parent.
Being THAT parent
You have failed as a parent
OP’s position is utterly astounding
We await your superior understanding
What an awful person you are
OP is an example of one of the reasons experienced and capable teachers are walking away from the job
Sort yourself out
Irrational and unreasonable

You missed out the OPs animal abuse. Given you’ve omitted it from your post I guess it’s not important to you.

There are hundreds of studies out there on the links with animal and child abuse. The OP openly admitted to animal abuse and shouting at a child so much the child was scared of them yet they wanted to complain about a teacher saying “don't you dare”? The comment hadn’t even been made to the OP’s child for goodness sake.

Lavinia56 · 19/11/2023 10:00

This thread reminds me of a story my dad used to tell about marching soldiers.

One of them complained, "Sarge, they're all out of step except me."

Spidersfreakmeout · 19/11/2023 10:00

I’m not just a teacher. I think the posters supporting the OP need to understand that many of us ‘teachers’ are mothers too!

To be honest, as a mum I’m truly concerned about what is happening in schools with this complaint culture on top of everything else landed on teachers.

I have friends at our local secondary schools and what they describe is carnage and the role of complaining parents who do not support schools with behaviour of their children is a HUGE part of that. Frank in reception being disciplined which causes mummy to storm in like mumma bear and shout at the teacher after being egged on by parents on the playground, suddenly turns into Frank in year 11 who is abusive to all staff and often very VERY difficult at home and mum is begging for support. It’s so utterly UTTERLY predictable.

I don’t want my daughters in a classroom with several Franks. I want my daughters to have an education because ultimately that’s what school is for!

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 09:59

Here are just some of the negative comments from just the last two pages of the thread. These comments seek to belittle to OP, to make her doubt herself, to make her feel stupid for raising her concern. They in no way seek to support or help the OP. Imagine having to read page after page of this. This is bullying and everyone know it is, to say otherwise is disingenuous.

Your behaviour is bullying and harassment
I pity the teacher for having you as a parent
Kids are arseholes
You fucking try it
I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone with such a lack of any type of self reflection?
Absence of emotional maturity
You want forgiveness for your bad choices OP?
You are not only being unreasonable but veering into the territory of irrational
You sound absolutely clueless!
Parents like you are why there there is so many leaving the profession
Do better for your child.
Get a grip.
OP is part of what makes this country so shit at the moment.
Good bit of DARVO on your part
Give your head a wobble, don't be so ridiculous
The OP has made a big song and dance
The OP wants to complain rather than parent.
Being THAT parent
You have failed as a parent
OP’s position is utterly astounding
We await your superior understanding
What an awful person you are
OP is an example of one of the reasons experienced and capable teachers are walking away from the job
Sort yourself out
Irrational and unreasonable

electriclight · 19/11/2023 09:50

To anyone who has ever watched a documentary about a hellish sink school and marvelled that it exists : that is the direction of travel for most secondary schools now.

Certainly when I talk to colleagues from education all over the country. We endlessly ask why. Covid, social media, decades of telling kids about their rights and importance, erosion of sanctions as parents complain about bloody everything, government closing special schools whilst simultaneously making it impossible to permanently exclude kids unsuited to mainstream education. No idea.

But in my school, it's the parents. And teaching staff without the time or will to stand up to them. Give in to their demands or deal with ten more increasingly unhinged emails, social media posts, threats to go to the press, threats to get their lawyer involved.

RosaGallica · 19/11/2023 09:42

Just before you go, op, I’ll ask again because I dont think you answered.

A bunch of 30 kids, with an LO for the lesson to achieve and individual targets for all 30. Some of those withSEN, some just being kids and wanting to play and talk, the odd one being violent. That one perhaps getting annoyed and wound up, perhaps already throwing something, and about to kick and punch the teacher or another classmate.

What would you have done?

Volpini · 19/11/2023 09:40

MrsMurphyIWish · 19/11/2023 09:13

OP, be glad your child’s teacher tries to discipline their class. I’m a secondary teacher and we are constantly told to be “mindful” of our language. We are not allowed to raise our voice and must remind students of code of conduct. Seems reasonable to us adults - teenagers take the piss. Students at my school know they hold the power. I spend so much time reminding students to be quiet to allow their peers to learn. I’m just glad my own children go to schools where their teachers can be firm so they can learn.

One of my closest friends gave up her very successful teaching career on this issue. She was going into class daily terrified for her own safety and that of her class because of the inability of her SLT to deal with the behaviour. A year after she left, the school was threatened with Special Measures by OFSTED. The reason? Pupil behaviour and the ineffectiveness of SLT. Exactly why she left.
I don’t live in an inner city. This school was considered one of the best secondary schools in our semi rural area. A tragedy and a scandal that she was put in that position where pupils had all the power no matter what they did. If someone complained about her, she and her peers had no support at all.
So many critics of teachers perceive teachers to have all this power and in reality, they are in a horribly complex and vulnerable relationship of gvt, parents, SLT and pupils. I think this is why many of these posts are so protective of the teacher who is in OP‘s crosshairs.

OooohAhhhh · 19/11/2023 09:34
Hmm
ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 09:31

So the OP is going to deregister and get the thread deleted. I'm surprised that took so long.

There have been plenty of measured, constructive responses. She just didn't want to hear them.

Badaba · 19/11/2023 09:22

This is not about 'picking battles', you're just wanting to fight for no good reason.

MrsMurphyIWish · 19/11/2023 09:13

OP, be glad your child’s teacher tries to discipline their class. I’m a secondary teacher and we are constantly told to be “mindful” of our language. We are not allowed to raise our voice and must remind students of code of conduct. Seems reasonable to us adults - teenagers take the piss. Students at my school know they hold the power. I spend so much time reminding students to be quiet to allow their peers to learn. I’m just glad my own children go to schools where their teachers can be firm so they can learn.

RedToothBrush · 19/11/2023 09:08

My son's class is a car crash. Last year I spent about a dozen or so half days with them - and I've done the same since reception (COVID notwithstanding). They are nice kids generally but omg they are hard work and they have soooo many issues between them. There isn't another class in the school like them.

I've had to complain - for safeguarding and bullying reasons. I absolutely hate doing it. I always end up apologising for it. I know I'm not alone in what I've complained about but it doesn't make it any easier. It makes me really uncomfortable to complain.

We've made a point of saying this is what we are complaining about and this is what we would like to achieve from the complain. We have not blamed anyone and we've even stated it's clear that one of the children who is a problem really needs more help and support than he's getting because this, this and this are happening.

I have been very aware that it's difficult to complain on the basis of what your child says. So a lot has been on the basis of what I've seen and making a point that we think this is happening and we are trying to get our son to talk to an adult in school when incidents have occurred rather than coming home telling us and then us having to come in about it.

How you construct a complaint and how you understand the limits of the 'he said she said' stuff really matters. If you go in with the mindset that you are trying to work WITH the teachers to achieve a goal rather than attacking them, you are going to get a much more positive outcome for all concerned. The teachers need to feel you are on the same side.

I've seen other parents kicking off in various ways. It doesn't help anyone. It takes up more of the teachers time and effort for starters. One of my friends is a teacher and by Friday she's had enough - and it's always about the parents not the kids.

Don't be part of the problem. A complaint can be part of a solution, but ultimately you need the teacher onside for that.

Castleview6 · 19/11/2023 09:05

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:59

Thanks @Repurposing for all the support...I have said all i can to defend myself and explain, but even though i'm not in denial about my own mistakes and flaws, some people will clearly never be convinced that I am not all the awful things I've been called on this thread, and like you say it's only going to make me feel worse and worse reading it all, plus the more I respond the more active this thread will remain.

Time to all move on to bullying the next unsuspecting poster now please!!

I am leaving this thread and deleting my account now, to escape the unnecessary nastiness which seems so rife on here, and focus on parenting my lovely children in the real world, which most of the time I do pretty bloody well.
I don't need an online forum trying to tell me otherwise.

People telling you you’re wrong isn’t being bullied.

Your behaviour towards this teacher is as best harrassment and at worst bullying.

your constant need to say what a great parent you are and need for validation on online platforms suggests that you aren’t.

Castleview6 · 19/11/2023 08:57

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:38

@Volpini yes I have made mistakes.Yes I have previously shared them on here, (which i now really fucking regret tbh, and WILL not be doing again) i was at the time hoping for support with my mistakes, yet here they are all being thrown back in my face years later (even though I HAVE self reflected and learnt from them.....DH and I have worked on our relationship, I no longer harm any animals, and I am in the ongoing process of bettering myself as a parent)

I hold myself to account for shouting at my child and expect my husband to do so aswell.And so I expect the teacher to do the same.
Neither she nor I should be speaking to children in an aggressive or unkind way.
If my DD had gone into school and told the teacher I had done so with her at home, I would expect them to be having a word with me about that too.
I appreciate it works both ways.

I might spend alot of time complaining, I might be 'that' parent, but I'm not fussed about being in the teachers pockets, popular or liked by them, I'm only fussed that their behaviour is professional and caring towards my little girl.

However, I also understand that there is an element of 'needing to pick battles' in some instances, and as this was not something said directly to my child, that's why I came here asking for seemingly simple advice around whether this was a battle to 'pick or not to pick' (boy do I regret it now!)

I won't agree that the teacher was not wrong in doing what she did, but that was not what the post was asking, it was asking if I should complain about it, to which I have been told loud and clear I should not, which is fine, but the unkindness laced through the replies is not.

I’ll say it again … YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT THE TEACHER SAID OR HOW THEY SAID IT BECAUSE YIU ERENT IN THE CLASSROOM.

You are making your own interpretation and judgement of something you sensative, anxious 6 year old has told you. You are saying a teacher was aggressive and unprofessional when you don’t know this. You are saying you’ll choose not to complain about this behaviour that you don’t even know happened - as if the teacher should be grateful you’ve decided not to ‘pick this battle.’

being a parent isn’t about ‘being in the pockets of teachers’ … it’s about respecting what they do and supporting them and working in partnership. You sound like a nightmare. I’d suggest you homeschooling to protect staff at your children’s school but I’d be concerned about the welfare and wellbeing of your children.

but we do know that you abuse animals, shout regularly at your children so that they are scared (which is not normal) and get to the ‘end of your tether with them. It is you who needs to be reported not this poor teacher who I pity for having to have you as a parent. I am beyond concerned that you used to (hopefully no more) worked in a nursery and were responsible for children’s well-being.

Fairospop22 · 19/11/2023 08:56

If she was effing and blinding of course speak to the head….. but she wasn’t.

Kids are arseholes sometimes and need a firm word.

how would you have worded it?

duvetdayy · 19/11/2023 08:50

Also, OP, if you’re still on the thread, if I had my current class where sadly at the moment it is a battle to get them to do anything quietly and a parent complained about me raising my voice one one occasion, I honestly think that might be the thing to tip me over into leaving teaching.

Honestly, you fucking try it.

Volpini · 19/11/2023 08:48

„yes I have made mistakes.Yes I have previously shared them on here, (which i now really fucking regret tbh, and WILL not be doing again) i was at the time hoping for support with my mistakes, „

my reply to you above was supportive. I have not thrown what you said back in your face. I don’t even reference what you have said or what those mistakes have been. Nor have I gone back and read any old posts by you. I mention them only because you have talked about those things so much across this thread.

„yet here they are all being thrown back in my face years later (even though I HAVE self reflected and learnt from them.....“

i meant specifically in relation to this thread and how you hold others to account. Sorry if that was not clear, but again, I am not responsible for what others have said only what I have said and what I have ACTUALLY said and I have very specifically attempted to do what you asked and giving you my take.

I hold myself to account for shouting at my child …And so I expect the teacher to do the same.
Neither she nor I should be speaking to children in an aggressive or unkind way.

sighs. But the point is that you do not know that she did any of that or that she was aggressive. This is coming from no place other than your imagination. And simply put, teachers are allowed to shout, whether you like it or not.

doing what she did, but that was not what the post was asking, it was asking if I should complain about it, to which I have been told loud and clear I should not, which is fine, but the unkindness laced through the replies is not.

My replies are not unkind. Many many other replies to you are not unkind. Some people have written things I would not have, myself. But for the most part you are mistaking frankness in many replies for unkindness and the tone of many of yours in response to people’s replies to you at the beginning, though, are telling. What is unkind is to ask for advice and to be graceless when it is given because you don’t like what’s said.

What is also unkind, that you cannot or will not see, is to be so determined that someone has definitely done something wrong when you did not witness any of it for yourself. Astonishing.

21 pages of people mostly trying to guide you to the realisation you‘re the one in the hole.
I’m out.

duvetdayy · 19/11/2023 08:46

This thread is utterly insane. I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone with such a lack of any type of self reflection? Like, when presented with things they’ve done wrong there’s a million excuses and cries about how it doesn’t make them a bad person but absolutely zero ability to apply that to the teacher. I can’t believe people make it to adulthood with this absence of emotional maturity.

RedToothBrush · 19/11/2023 08:41

A really important factor in the question of 'should I complain?' is 'what do I hope to achieve if I complain?' or simply what is the goal of the complaint and how likely is it to be successful and how important is the complaint?

I really can't get past the fact that the OP simply doesn't like the teacher and she saw it as an opportunity to put the boot in. It's pretty obvious it wasn't that important and it's fairly unlikely to succeed.

It is so depressing.

Learning when to complain and when not to complain is really important.

AnneValentine · 19/11/2023 08:36

nikkiandham · 19/11/2023 07:34

If it routine and trivial the teachers boss will recognise it as such - where’s the bullying?

They will yes but do you know how soul destroying it is for teachers to receive unfounded complaints?

AnneValentine · 19/11/2023 08:35

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:17

Read the posts please ...nowhere have I said its 'perfectly fine' for me to shout at her.Because it isn't! But then neither should the teacher! But apparently that's ok?!

The teacher didn’t shout at her though did she. She said “don’t you dare” to another a child. A child you don’t know. You’ve assumed she shouted. You’ve assumed the context was threatening. Has it occurred to you it was said in jest?

You have leaped to massive conclusions based on the context of you as a parent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread